From designer handbags and polished menswear to estate-quality furnishings and smart children’s finds, the Naperville area offers curated consignment that rewards discernment. Expect elevated labels, attentive service, and prices that keep luxury feeling sensible.
Let’s get to it.
The Apartment by Costello Jewelry Co
Two former apartments reinvented as a boutique make The Apartment feel delightfully intimate. Room by room, you wander a dining space, a tiny library, a mirrored walk-in closet, even a Player’s Lounge. It all sits upstairs in downtown Naperville.
The mix is decidedly elevated. Think museum-quality accents like Lalique and Georg Jensen alongside silk textiles, luxe candles and bath goods, and handsome coffee-table books. Prices skew upper mid to luxury, so it suits anyone who prefers heirloom over disposable.
Its calling card is a tight selection of consigned designer handbags and wallets from local sellers. Expect names like Louis Vuitton, Bottega Veneta, and Gucci in excellent condition, curated rather than overflowing. The staff brings real design know-how, backed by Costello Jewelry Company’s long-standing reputation.
This is a slow-browse spot with seasonal rotations and periodic designer arrivals, so the thrill is in the find. Value here means quality, not clearance. Considering consigning a bag? Terms are shared in store, and they market pieces to get consignors a strong return.
STITCH SWITCH Men’s Consignment
Finally, a consignment boutique that understands a man’s closet. Quality over quantity, labels that hold their value, and pricing that makes designer feel sensible. STITCH SWITCH is menswear only, so the racks read like an edited wardrobe, not a rummage table.
Expect blazers, premium denim, sharp shirts, outerwear, plus shoes and accessories. Jewelry, ties, hats, and bags appear, then vanish, with prices often 60 to 80 percent below retail. Occasional vintage or new-with-tags pieces pop up too.
The edit is the story. Weekend-ready Nike and Lululemon sit alongside Brioni, Loro Piana, Gucci, and Prada. Lower-tier labels are filtered out, which keeps browsing quick.
Shopping feels boutique, not bargain bin. Clean displays, steady new arrivals, and staff who know fabrics and fits. Prefer to scout first? The online catalog and social feeds make it easy to track what just landed.
Consigning is straightforward. Up to 30 laundered pieces without an appointment, larger drops by appointment, 90-day terms, and a typical 40 to 60 percent split. They fill up at times, so plan ahead.
Always In Style
At Always In Style, boutique polish meets resale smarts. In downtown Geneva, an easy hop from Naperville, it skews fashion forward over bargain bin.
Racks are tightly edited. Staff preview consignments and only put out what makes the cut, so you see excellent-condition pieces, often with tags. Brands rotate in, from Lululemon and White House Black Market to the occasional Louis Vuitton.
Pricing sits in the mid to high-end resale pocket. You are paying for quality and curation, not a dig-through. Want well-made staples or a standout bag without retail shock? This hits the mark.
Small, bright, and organized, the boutique has real dressing rooms and helpful staff who suggest pieces that work together. New arrivals land often, so quick pop-ins pay off. Follow their social feeds if you like to claim finds fast.
Consigning is selective, so call for current guidelines. Bringing in only what they need keeps the floor sharp and the browsing simple.
STITCH SWITCH Men’s Consignment
Menswear gets its own spotlight at STITCH SWITCH, treated with the care of a good tailor. The focus is entirely on men, with designer and name-brand pieces priced roughly 60 to 80 percent below retail. Both shops sit in walkable hubs in Geneva and Wheaton, an easy run from Naperville.
Expect a tidy, boutique setup. Curated racks, not clutter. Suits, sport coats, premium denim, sneakers, and some well-chosen vintage. Fitting rooms are ready, and the small team is quick with sizing and styling tips that feel helpful, not pushy.
Quality is tight. They accept like-new, on-trend, seasonal items and favor higher-end labels. Consignment is straightforward, with a 90-day term and payouts around 40 to 60 percent. Larger closet clean-outs book an appointment, while a few pieces can be dropped in anytime. Intake can pause when the floor is full, so a quick check online helps.
Stock turns fast in store and online. New arrivals post daily, and an email sign-up keeps you in the loop. Ideal for dressing a husband, son, or self in premium brands without the sticker shock. Think treasure hunt, but edited.
Acosta’s Home – New & Consigned Furniture
Designer names without the drama. That is the draw at Acosta’s Home, where consigned pieces share the floor with brand-new overstock, so you get style without sticker shock.
With two suburban showrooms, the Wheaton location is an easy hop from Naperville. Think sofas and sectionals, dining sets and home office, plus rugs, lamps, artwork, designer handbags and jewelry, even the occasional piano or pool table.
Labels like Restoration Hardware, Pottery Barn, Arhaus, and West Elm show up often, and prices typically land 50 to 80 percent below retail.
Quality is tight. They accept only showroom-ready items rated excellent to nearly new, so you are not wading through dings or mystery odors. The floor is large and well staged, inventory turns quickly, and seasonal displays land early, which keeps the treasure-hunt energy high.
Prefer to browse first? Many finds are listed online so you can scout before driving. If you are selling, expect quick photo pre-approval, a drop-off appointment, and a 90-day consignment term after processing. A consignor portal tracks everything and offers electronic payouts.
Always Growing
Boutique polish at non-boutique prices. That is the sweet spot at Always Growing, a children’s consignment collective for infants through teens.
Racks are tidy and curated, with newborn through size 16 clothing, shoes, boots, pajamas, and accessories. Expect gently used pieces alongside the occasional brand-new-with-tags find, and look for premium kids’ labels sprinkled throughout.
Inventory flips fast, with daily restocks and seasonal refreshes, so the treasure hunt stays fun without the clutter. Their social feeds spotlight new arrivals, which makes it easy to time a visit to Naperville’s walkable core.
Sellers book appointments online. Staff handle sorting, pricing, and tagging, and consignors typically receive around 40 percent once items sell. Items that do not move can be picked up or donated per store policy.
Expect thrift-to-mid-range pricing, a boutique presentation, and friendly guidance from people who know kids’ brands. It is perfect for budget-conscious parents, thoughtful gift givers, and anyone who loves scoring high-quality kidswear without the markup. Bonus, it shares space with a women’s consignment boutique, so it is easy to make it a two-for-one stop.
The Courtyard
Step into The Courtyard, where fine home furnishings are staged like a boutique in downtown Hinsdale, an easy hop from Naperville. Think estate finds without the estate-sale chaos.
Designer furniture, artwork, lamps and chandeliers, quality rugs, plus china, crystal, and silver that make a table sing. Estate jewelry and polished accessories complete the look. Everything is clean and curated, never garage-sale leftovers. This is not a clothing stop.
Here is the differentiator. This upscale nonprofit resale shop, powered by volunteers, channels proceeds to Wellness House and has raised millions since 1991. Shopping feels indulgent, yet the mission keeps it grounded.
Prices land mid to high end, reflected in condition and labels, yet regulars still score finds. Rooms are restyled weekly, new arrivals post online, and the floor flips often, so the treasure hunt stays fresh.
Have something to consign or donate? Intake is by appointment. Pricing is set case by case, so call or check the website for current acceptance guidelines.
Best for furnishing a space with character and longevity, not fast decor. If boutique presentation, estate quality, and a solid cause resonate, put The Courtyard on your shortlist.
Jane Pabon Consignment Boutique
If luxury is your love language, Jane Pabon Consignment Boutique speaks it fluently on downtown Geneva’s Third Street. Expect a polished, high-fashion edit of designer clothing, handbags, shoes, jewelry, small leather goods, and the occasional vintage gem.
The space is intimate and calm, so browsing feels purposeful rather than overwhelming. Handbags are authenticated, pieces are handled with care, and staff offer thoughtful styling guidance instead of pushy sales talk. It has that treasure-hunt thrill, yet the racks stay tidy and selective.
Consigning here is refreshingly straightforward. Walk in with designer pieces, no appointment needed, and the team reviews items in real time. They research and price to the current market afterward. The standard term runs about 90 days, payouts are a percentage of the sale via check or store credit, and unsold items can be picked up or donated, with a 15-day hold after the contract ends. Chicagoland sellers can even request concierge pickup.
Expect frequent new arrivals, newsletter alerts, and the occasional private event. Payment is flexible with cash, cards, Zelle, Venmo, and layaway for big splurges. If polished resale and a seasoned, woman-run point of view sound right, this is a smart stop a short drive from Naperville.
