If you value well made pieces, gracious service, and prices that reward patience, Traverse City is rich with consignment and resale gems. From polished boutiques with cashmere and leather to lively vendor markets and seasonal pop ups, these spots make it easy to refresh a wardrobe, finish a room, or outfit visiting grandkids without the retail premium.
Let’s get to it.
penny lane
Fresh finds land every Saturday. That’s the rhythm at Penny Lane, where booths turn over weekly and the treasure hunt stays lively. Downtown across from The Little Fleet, it feels equal parts boutique and community bulletin board.
The model keeps it interesting. Sellers rent a booth for a week, set their own prices, and the shop handles the counter. That means prices skew budget to mid range, with a surprise vintage jacket or designer bag popping up when a consignor brings the goods.
Browsing is easy. Each stall reads like a mini shop, with postcard notes, tidy racks, and shelves lined with women’s, men’s, and kids’ clothing, shoes, accessories, small toys, and décor. Items are clean, sized to fit the booth, and refresh often.
It suits eco-minded shoppers and anyone who loves variety. If you came for sofas, electronics, or bulk furniture, this is not your stop. For casual consignors, the control is appealing, since you set the tags and typically keep about 65 percent.
Staff keeps the vibe friendly and highlights new booths online, so timing a visit is easy. Hit Saturday for the reset, then swing back midweek for restocks.
EB2 Vintage
The fun of EB2 Vintage is how finished everything feels. Refurbished dressers, upcycled tables, and vintage art are staged in tidy little vignettes, so decisions come easy. It reads more boutique than barn.
A curated mix of vendor booths and consignors keeps quality high. Solid furniture, re-loved decor, useful dishes, and art that feels current without chasing trends. Prices sit mid-range, and there’s locally made jewelry, handmade candles, small gifts, plus a clothing nook with new women’s pieces and some men’s vintage.
Fresh finds roll in often, with seasonal markets that keep the floor changing. The European-style Christmas market is a favorite, and the North Boardman Lake District setting puts it in a creative little shopping corridor.
Downsizing? The “Sort, Save, Sell” service can move pieces along, and vendor spots pop up; ask for terms. Staff earns high marks for kindness, and yes, the small shop dog has fans. Best for finishing a room or grabbing a thoughtful gift without designer prices.
Zany Consignment West
Silk, cashmere, and leather rule the racks at Zany Consignment West, the Slabtown sister of this upscale resale duo. It reads boutique first, consignment second.
Curated racks, sizes grouped, outfits styled, so browsing stays easy. Expect women’s clothing, shoes, handbags, jewelry, plus a sprinkling of home-y gifts. Fitting rooms available. Staff are friendly and frank about fit and fabric.
Prices land in that sweet spot, higher than thrifting but far gentler than buying new retail. Designer denim, cashmere, and good leather appear often, which keeps the value strong. If fabric and construction matter, this is your lane.
Quality control is tight. It is a classic consignment model with a limited selling window. Sellers usually earn 40 percent, which keeps standards high.
Inventory turns quickly with the season, so the fun is in regular check-ins. Slabtown’s historic vibe suits shoppers who want well-made pieces that feel current without the department-store markup.
Zany Consignment Boutique East
At the Acme outpost, linen and cashmere win over fast fashion, and the price tags reflect it. This East Bay location pairs boutique polish with secondhand smarts, and its Slabtown sister keeps the hunt going across town.
Expect women’s clothing and shoes, handbags, jewelry, and select home décor, all curated to boutique standards. Racks are tidy, sections are labeled, and fitting rooms make trying on easy. It feels like a gallery, not a garage sale.
Prices tend to land around 30 percent of original retail, so the value is in quality, not rock-bottom steals. New arrivals roll in frequently, with fresh pieces rotated up front and seasonal edits throughout. Designer labels do pop up, vintage leather sneaks in, and there is a clearance section for periodic markdowns.
Staff are friendly and informed, which helps with sizing, fabrics, and styling. Consignors see a typical 60 to 40 split, items stay on the floor about 60 days, and balances can be checked online or taken as store credit. Ideal for shoppers who care about materials and fit, want a calm, curated shop, and prefer value over volume.
Evergreen Consignment
Clean racks, bright floors, and tags that read like a who’s who of wearable classics. Evergreen Consignment keeps Traverse City and Lake Leelanau dressed smartly without the sticker shock.
Think curated, not cluttered. Men’s and women’s clothing and accessories mingle with select baby gear, jewelry, home decor, housewares, and small furniture, with vintage and designer pieces sprinkled in as seasons change. Racks are organized, fitting rooms are easy to find, and there is a dedicated sale corner that rewards patience.
It is true consignment at work. Staff screens and prices, consignors typically take about 40 percent, and store credit bumps that by roughly ten. After a holding window of about 60 days, unclaimed items head to donation, and intake rules are posted to keep the process orderly.
Prices land mid to higher for resale, which suits the quality. New arrivals roll in often, and the team is active on social, so a quick call can place a hold. Add a friendly loyalty program and a small reusable bag perk, plus staff who actually help. A strong pick for a calm, well-edited treasure hunt, less so if you want bulk-thrift pricing.
Just Between Friends Traverse City – Fall Sale October 10-12, 2025 (Presale Oct 9 & 10)
Coats, boots, and books under one roof, priced for growth spurts. That is the Just Between Friends Traverse City Fall Sale, a once-a-season pop-up happening October 10 to 12, with presale access October 9 and 10. Not a store, a well-run event.
Expect rows sorted by size and category, from infant through teen. You will see name-brand clothing, shoes, toys, strollers, nursery gear, maternity pieces, and car seats that have been safety checked. Fall leads the way here, so think jackets, snow pants, and sturdy boots. The pace is lively, volunteers know their stuff, and there is a hold area so you can keep hands free. Bring a wagon or stroller if you plan to stock up.
Pricing lands around 50 to 90 percent off retail, and quality control is real. Stained or damaged items do not make the cut, and baby gear must meet strict guidelines. Selling is just as practical: consignors earn a solid percentage, can volunteer for more, and valet tagging is available if you want hands-off help.
Savvy shoppers spring for presale or prime time tickets for first pick, then circle back for the final half off day to scoop extras. Ideal for budget-focused families, grandparents on kid duty, and parents-to-be who want value without the chaos. Check the local JBF site for tickets and specifics.
