Whether you love the thrill of the hunt or just want to score a stylish sofa on a budget, thrift shopping in Naples offers something for everyone. From luxurious consignment boutiques to laid-back charity shops, these local favorites deliver wallet-friendly finds and community impact in equal measure.
Let’s get to it.
St. Matthew’s House Naples Thrift Store
At St. Matthew’s House Naples Thrift Store, thrift shopping gets a boutique upgrade. Instead of random piles, items are arranged in showroom-style vignettes that highlight home décor, clothing, and accessories. Name-brand apparel for men, women, and children sits alongside small appliances, full furniture displays, and racks of designer accessories. Housewares and kitchen gadgets fill neatly labeled aisles.
Prices stay wallet-friendly, with color-tag deals and seasonal sales often slashing half the store’s price. Daily restocks keep the selection fresh, and thorough quality checks mean broken zippers and wobbly legs are rare.
The retail area feels spacious, with clean floors, modern fixtures, and clearly marked sections. Fitting rooms invite easy clothing trials, and wide aisles make browsing comfortable. All proceeds support local homelessness and recovery programs. Shoppers can score satisfying décor finds, quality clothing, and furniture, while contributing to community services. The combination of practical pricing, organized layout, and mission-driven purpose makes this thrift store a standout in Naples.
Audrey’s Of Naples
Stepping into Audrey’s Of Naples feels more like entering a gallery than a thrift store. This family-owned consignment boutique spans 5,000 square feet with sunlit spaces, wide aisles, and a dedicated vintage room showcasing mid-century fashion. Designer labels such as Gucci and Chanel share space with estate jewelry, shoes, and handbags.
Prices typically range 50 to 70 percent off retail, with extra local discounts or promotional events reducing costs even further. Fresh consignment items arrive regularly, encouraging repeat visits. The historic downtown location offers free parking, wheelchair accessibility, and a cozy tea and coffee station for customers who want to linger.
Audrey’s curates only gently worn, high-quality pieces under strict acceptance criteria. The spacious layout hosts charity galas one evening and VIP shopping nights the next, maintaining an upscale atmosphere. With estate jewelry corners, rotating seasonal displays, and dedicated staff ensuring quality, Audrey’s Of Naples stands out as a destination for discerning shoppers seeking authentic designer finds at a fraction of retail prices.
Avow Treasures Resale Shop
At Avow Treasures Resale Shop you’ll discover a tidy, well-organized thrift store that benefits Avow Hospice. Shopping here funds palliative care, children’s programs, and bereavement support. The store has clear sections for housewares, books, furniture, clothing, and a dedicated designer/vintage nook for standout pieces.
Aisles remain clutter-free and the shelves are neatly stocked, so you’ll never trample mystery boxes. Staff quality-check new donations daily, ensuring items are in good condition. Prices stay firmly in thrift territory, and special promotions like half-off color tags or flash sales add extra savings.
An appealing jewelry display features necklaces, bracelets, and rings. Regular half-off days draw deal seekers, and pop-up flash sale events reward frequent visitors. The space feels more generous than a strip-mall box, yet remains easy to navigate without a map.
Shoppers range from local families to vintage enthusiasts, all enjoying the wide aisles and fresh inventory. If you have large items to donate, the shop offers free pickup. By rehoming that couch or those unused dishes you help a vital local service. Every purchase combines bargain hunting with community support.
Twice As Nice Consignment Shop- Downtown
In the Naples Design District, Twice As Nice Consignment Shop-Downtown combines upscale fashion with meticulous organization. Owned by Lorna McCluskey, this female-owned boutique offers street parking and wheelchair accessibility in a historic downtown setting.
Inside, clean racks divide women’s and teen girls’ apparel into three sections, sizes 0 to 3X. Cruise-ready cocktail dresses, casual tanks, and seasonal pieces sit alongside shoes, handbags, fine and costume jewelry, and stylish hats. Staff curate only items in like-new condition, so pet hair and musty odors are not an issue.
New arrivals appear daily, and markdowns follow a predictable schedule—20 percent off every 15 days, with designer pieces on a slightly longer rotation. Punch cards, weekly promotions, and lively Facebook Live sales add excitement for regular shoppers. Extended hours cater to customers with unconventional schedules.
Consignors appreciate straightforward terms, while customers enjoy a polished boutique vibe. With every purchase, quality fashion comes at reduced prices and unsold items can be donated to support local charities like St. Matthew’s House.
St Vincent De Paul Society
In Naples, the Society of St. Vincent de Paul District Council shops offer a clean, organized thrift experience. Trained Vincentian volunteers sort merchandise, keeping aisles well-lit and clearly labeled so items are easy to find.
Racks of men’s, women’s, and kids’ apparel cover every size, while furniture options range from classic sofas to student desks. Kitchenware, linens, and small appliances fill the shelves, and a rotating vintage corner features designer pieces. Seasonal displays burst with Halloween and Christmas décor.
Prices remain budget-friendly, and color-tag promotions cut an extra 25 to 50 percent off low prices. Frequent deliveries keep the stock fresh, so each visit uncovers new deals. Fitting rooms stay tidy, and volunteers will even assist with large-item delivery.
Proceeds fund local assistance programs for families in need. With reliable pricing, quality control, and a mission-driven approach, these shops deliver value and community support without the typical thrift-store effort.
True Fashionistas
Visiting True Fashionistas offers the experience of Florida’s largest lifestyle consignment store. Founded by Jennifer and Brad Johnson in 2011, this 13,000-square-foot shop in Galleria Shoppes feels more like a luxury department store than a resale boutique.
A couture section showcases gowns and eveningwear, while separate areas display shoes, handbags sorted by color, and high-end furniture staged in living room vignettes. Men’s, women’s, and kids’ clothing fill neatly arranged racks. New arrivals appear daily, and seasonal décor items take center stage during holiday periods.
All merchandise undergoes authentication and quality checks, so only “like new” pieces remain on the floor. Pricing stays competitive, with regular markdowns and straightforward consignment terms. Sellers can choose to donate unsold items, directly supporting local charities.
Beyond shopping, True Fashionistas hosts events like mani-pedi days, makeup tutorials, career workshops, and fast-paced Facebook Live sales. Monthly donations from sales benefit community programs. With wide aisles, attentive staff, and a focus on sustainability, this consignment hub offers an organized, stylish alternative to a typical thrift experience.
The Shelter Options Shoppe
Walking into The Shelter Options Shoppe feels like entering a well-curated thrift environment. Operated by The Shelter for Abused Women & Children, this shop features epoxy floors, clear aisles, and separate rooms for clothing, housewares, and furniture. Daily donations keep racks and shelves updated, including a Designer Boutique section for label aficionados. Clothing racks display casual wear and formal outfits, while housewares include dinnerware, glassware, and small appliances. You can find bedroom sets, accent chairs, and occasional home decor pieces alongside vintage treasures.
Frequent promotions offer up to 75 percent off on jewelry and handbags, while storewide sales reach 60 percent off. Furniture pieces appear in showroom condition, ready to furnish any room. Donations drop off easily at the front or via the warehouse doors in back, and staff accept only items in solid condition.
Every item passes a quality check, with some pieces used to furnish transitional housing cottages for survivors. Shoppers appreciate the no-nonsense layout, rotating inventory, and bargain prices that range across all categories. By buying here, you support programs that shelter and empower women and children.
Habitat Collier ReStore — North Naples
At Habitat Collier ReStore — North Naples you’ll find a bright, spacious store that combines bargain hunting with local impact. Since moving into the larger Carillon Place location, the aisles are roomy and well lit. Every day brings new donations from gently used furniture to brand-new overstock items.
Customers browse full-size couches, washers, bath vanities, and more all neatly arranged by category. Furniture selections range from modern styles to classic wood pieces. You’ll also find doors, shelving, and building materials, so homeowners and contractors can pick up supplies in one stop. A separate section highlights new or overstock merchandise, while volunteers keep everything clean and organized. Prices range from 50 to 90 percent off typical retail cost, making quality appliances and mattress sets surprisingly affordable.
Shoppers arrive with paint swatches in hand, ready to update their homes on a tight budget. Staff test each item to ensure it works properly, so there are no mystery microwaves. Best of all, proceeds go directly toward building affordable local homes. Whether you leave with a chandelier or a dining set, you’re supporting Habitat’s mission with every purchase.
Up for Grabs Consignment
When you step into Up for Grabs Consignment in Naples, the difference from a typical secondhand store is immediate. This owner-operated boutique reflects its founder’s background in interior design. Every shelf and corner is neatly arranged with decorative vignettes that give each lamp, chair, or accessory a magazine-ready look.
The showroom spans roughly 10,000 square feet, complete with wide aisles to keep fragile items safe. Nothing feels random or overcrowded; a small in-house design team carefully curates furniture, décor, and artwork. New pieces arrive regularly, so you’ll find everything from dining tables and area rugs to elegant china sets.
Prices here reflect the upscale consignment market in Naples, but you do get quality and uniqueness in return. Designer and vintage sections showcase special finds, and a rotating art wall highlights fresh work. Every item passes a strict vetting process—no unwanted castoffs or donation overflow. Ample parking out front ensures you won’t circle the lot hunting for a spot, which in this town is a welcome bonus.
Treasure Island Antiques
Treasure Island Antiques in downtown Naples offers 12,000 square feet of dealer booths filled with antiques and vintage finds. Wide aisles create a comfortable browsing experience, unlike cramped flea markets. Each booth features curated collections, so you can compare Asian bronzes, Bakelite jewelry, mid-century furniture, and French armoires in one visit.
The jewelry selection ranges from 1920s Trifari and Chanel costume pieces to estate gold and precious stones. Furniture spans mid-century modern items by Vladimir Kagan and George Nelson, plus modern Italian and Danish designs priced below typical Naples values. Art includes pieces by Matisse and Dali alongside local artists, blending high-end works with regional talent.
Prices are set by individual dealers, and haggling is welcome on older stock. Collectors, interior designers, and casual shoppers all come through regularly. Dogs are allowed, adding to the relaxed atmosphere. Located near other downtown shops, it’s a convenient stop in any Naples outing. Open every day, Treasure Island Antiques keeps inventory rotating to reward each visit with something new.
Posh Plum Furniture Consignment
Posh Plum Furniture Consignment stands out among typical consignment stores with its curated selection of designer furniture, chic rugs, and art pieces. Floor space includes dedicated sections for lighting, tabletop decor, and accent pillows. The showroom layout allows ample room between items, making it easy to browse without bumping into lamps or pictures. Each piece arrives cleaned and inspected; stains and odors disqualify any sofa or chair.
New arrivals appear on social media so design-conscious shoppers can snag fresh pieces fast. Consignors benefit from a straightforward 50/50 split and a 90-day contract. The staff offers gentle guidance on pricing, helping consignors set competitive rates while maintaining quality standards. Prices drop at 30-day intervals to spur sales, creating deeper discounts over time. An online portal lets sellers track activity and view offers on their items.
Unsold furniture moves on to partner organizations like Habitat for Humanity and the American Cancer Society, preventing stock from gathering dust. Whether you’re hunting for a mid-century coffee table or a contemporary sideboard, the polished atmosphere and transparent process make Posh Plum a reliable source for upscale secondhand decor.
Goodwill Retail & Donation Center
At the Goodwill Retail & Donation Center, spaciousness and brightness replace the usual thrift-store clutter. Located in a busy strip mall, the center offers plenty of parking so you won’t waste time hunting for a spot.
Inside, wide aisles guide you through well-organized sections. Clothing racks for men, women, children, plus sizes, and vintage or designer labels keep everything logically placed. Nearby, furniture pieces stand ready for easy browsing. Housewares fill long shelves, and a media nook stocks books, DVDs, and games. Staff and volunteers constantly straighten displays and restock donated items, so shelves rarely look bare.
Prices stay low thanks to a color-tag system that halves the price of one tag each week. Extra manager specials, senior discounts, and theme days like Bag Day deliver even bigger markdowns. A drive-through donation dock simplifies drop-offs, and a clearance area by the checkout counter highlights fresh bargains. Fitting rooms are available, making try-ons quick and private. Overall, this Goodwill location keeps quality high and the shopping experience smooth for treasure hunters.
