Thrift shopping in Fort Myers is all about discovering the unexpected, from designer handbags tucked between the racks to vintage furniture hiding in plain sight. Whether you’re after a bargain, on the hunt for treasure, or hoping to support a community cause, the city’s selection of thrift stores offers something for everyone.
Let’s get to it.
A STEP ABOVE Consignment Shop
Located on S. Tamiami Trail, A STEP ABOVE Consignment Shop offers a clean, nonprofit-driven shopping experience. The store is part of HOPE Community Outreach, so each purchase supports foster children and struggling families. Inside, separate sections for clothing, shoes and home goods prevent clutter. Large furniture items stay in an offsite warehouse and can be delivered directly if you find a piece you love.
Quality control ensures racks hold only items that meet high standards. Kids’ clothing is priced at one dollar every day, and adult items follow standard resale rates. On Thursdays, the entire store goes on sale at fifty percent off. Military discounts apply year-round. Fresh inventory arrives weekly, and special events like Resale Trail BINGO bring the community together.
The straightforward layout makes it easy to find a handbag, coat or kitchen gadget. Shoppers and consignors appreciate the fast payout options, with cash available for items under twenty-five dollars and checks issued for higher totals. Store credit offers an extra incentive for those who prefer to shop again later.
The House of Ride Nature
In the two-story building on 2nd Street, The House of Ride Nature blends a surf shop, skate park, coffee bar and thrift boutique into one space. Downstairs shelves hold surfboards, wetsuits and branded hats alongside a thrift corner stocked with vintage clothing. Prices for new tees and hoodies range from twenty to fifty dollars, while the thrift area offers older treasures at lower rates.
A sixteen-foot-wide mini ramp sits inside near the coffee counter. Customers can order espresso and pastries while watching skaters practice tricks. Upstairs the building houses staff offices and discipleship student space for outreach and Bible study groups, though these areas are not open to casual visitors.
The store is closed on Sundays and Mondays for team meetings and outreach planning. From Tuesday through Saturday, it operates as a retail hub, community gathering point and mission center. All sales support the global skate-evangelism mission, making each purchase part of a larger outreach effort.
SuperThrift Fort Myers- South Tamiami Trail
Starting off, SuperThrift Fort Myers on South Tamiami Trail changes the thrift store experience. The store covers a large area with wide aisles and powerful air conditioning, so you stay cool while browsing furniture, housewares, electronics, décor, shoes and other secondhand items.
Rows of shoe racks stretch down the aisles, and separate sections showcase mattresses, refrigerators, microwaves and more… All items are cleaned and in good condition. Private dressing rooms let you try on clothes comfortably.
The checkout counter features a discount wheel where every customer can spin for a chance at savings. New inventory arrives daily, and regular sales mean each day can feel like a sale day. Families, students and vintage collectors find steady streams of fresh items and real bargains. The store supports Teen Challenge programs and offers retail training to people seeking job skills. Shopping here helps fund these initiatives, adding an extra layer of value to every purchase. The layout makes comparing items simple.
Puddle Jumpers Children’s Resale
Serving Fort Myers families since 2009, Puddle Jumpers Children’s Resale offers a well-organized space for affordable kids’ clothing and gear. Wide aisles accommodate strollers, and separate sections for boys’ sizes up to seven and girls’ up to twelve keep items easy to find. Racks hold like-new outfits, while shelves display baby gear, toys and bicycles. Staff enforce strict quality checks, so you won’t find stained onesies or incomplete puzzles.
Consignors receive immediate payment: cash for items under twenty-five dollars, checks for higher totals or a bonus with store credit. Car seats and sippy cups are excluded for safety, but most clothes and equipment are welcome. Prices range from five to ten dollars per item on average, making it simple to stock up without overspending.
The store includes free parking and full wheelchair accessibility. Regular arrivals of fresh inventory ensure new bargains every visit. A transparent pricing policy and straightforward layout appeal to budget-conscious parents and consignors alike.
Gannon’s Antiques and Art Center
In South Fort Myers, Gannon’s Antiques and Art Center occupies a 20,000-square-foot space with over 100 vendors. Wide aisles and bright lighting give it museum-like appeal instead of a cluttered attic. Antique furniture, silver, lamps and art glass pieces line display cases and open floor areas.
The jewelry selection ranges from fine Tiffany and Cartier pieces to chunky Mexican silver and a variety of signed costume designs. Coin and currency dealers offer Civil War bills, Morgan and Peace dollars and other collectibles. Appraisal and consignment services are available for those bringing their own treasures.
With thousands of new pieces rotating daily, each visit offers fresh discoveries. Decorators, collectors and occasional celebrity guests browse the showroom for one-of-a-kind items. Clean floors and organized booths make navigation simple. On-site staff can assist with special orders, shipping arrangements or detailed information on a vendor’s wares.
Whether you seek décor accents or high-end antiques, this center provides a well-curated, stress-free environment for serious shopping.
St. Matthew’s House Fort Myers Thrift Store
At St. Matthew’s House Fort Myers Thrift Store, shelves and racks remain clean and well-organized. The store divides merchandise into dedicated sections including fine jewelry, name-brand clothing, gently used furniture, appliances, décor, and more. The jewelry display features rings, necklaces, and bracelets under glass with clear price tags. Prices stay low throughout the store. Regular promotions include store-wide sales and military discounts. A daily rotation of donations brings fresh items to the floor each morning.
Wide aisles and clear signage guide shoppers to designer shoes, accessories, and home goods without navigating clutter. Furniture offerings range from sofas and tables to cabinets in excellent condition. Donations fund local programs for people facing homelessness and addiction, operated by St. Matthew’s House nonprofit.
Free pickup services simplify donations and delivery options handle larger purchases. Community volunteers keep the space tidy and assist customers during busy periods. The store blends practical pricing with a boutique atmosphere. St. Matthew’s House Fort Myers Thrift Store provides a clean, community-focused shopping experience that directly supports social services in the region.
Style Encore Fort Myers
At Style Encore Fort Myers, the store embraces simplicity and organization. Located in a strip mall, the interior features tidy racks sorted by size and color. Carolyn Rivera and her team inspect and display items with care. Shoppers can browse dedicated sections for brands like Coach, Louis Vuitton, Ann Taylor, Talbots, White House Black Market, and Banana Republic. Designer bags often appear at discounts of up to ninety percent.
The inventory refreshes rapidly, so the selection changes weekly. Sellers drop off items without appointments. If a piece meets the store’s standards, sellers receive cash on the spot. New arrivals are steamed and arranged neatly, keeping the floor clutter-free. This efficient process highlights sustainable shopping by extending garment life and reducing waste.
Customers appreciate the straightforward setup. There are no elaborate fixtures or marble flooring, just a focus on quality merchandise. The team’s friendly approach and clear layout make each visit productive. Style Encore Fort Myers proves that a practical environment can offer high-end finds at budget-friendly prices.
St. John XXIII Thrift Store
St. John XXIII Thrift Store is a parish-sponsored shop staffed by over 130 volunteers. Proceeds support local Catholic education and outreach programs as far away as Thailand. Unsold items are cleaned and donated to other charities, ensuring minimal waste.
The store features a medium-sized open floor plan with tidy displays and uncluttered aisles. Clothing and shoes sit beside housewares, framed art, furniture, and small appliances. A dedicated section holds religious collectibles such as rosaries and art glass pieces. Pricing remains fair and includes a tax-free benefit at checkout.
New donations arrive daily and volunteers sort, price, and display each item promptly. Wheelchair access and wide aisles make navigation straightforward. Curbside drop-off and pick-up services add convenience for donors. The environment feels welcoming and organized, reflecting the personal investment of the volunteer team.
St. John XXIII Thrift Store combines mission-focused fundraising with a clean, accessible shopping layout. Customers can expect a steady flow of fresh items and the satisfaction of supporting charitable educational programs through each purchase.
Bratz Consignment Furniture Warehouse Of Fort Myers Inc
Since 1992, Bratz Consignment Furniture Warehouse Of Fort Myers Inc has operated from a strip-mall plaza on S. Tamiami Trail. The showroom spans a generous floor plan with wide aisles and distinct areas for living room, dining room, and mattress displays. Coastal-style pieces reflect bright, relaxed Florida design. New consignments arrive regularly, keeping the selection current.
The store accepts only meticulously cleaned items from smoke-free, pet-free homes. That policy ensures each piece feels fresh, as if it arrived straight from a model home. In addition to well-maintained pre-owned furniture, the showroom carries new USA-made mattresses in various styles. Price points range from moderate to higher-end, with occasional clearance deals.
Bratz offers free local delivery and setup, saving customers the task of moving heavy items. The store allows cash or card payments and remains open seven days a week. Wheelchair access and curbside service add to the convenience. With a focus on quality control and customer service, Bratz Consignment Furniture Warehouse Of Fort Myers Inc provides a reliable source for furniture shoppers.
Fleamasters Flea Market
Fleamasters Flea Market in Fort Myers offers over nine hundred vendor booths spread across an indoor space the size of a small neighborhood. Spacious aisles follow a clear grid, allowing shoppers to move through sections dedicated to antiques and collectibles, crafts, fresh produce, vintage Hawaiian shirts, handmade jewelry, tools, and small appliances. Vendors set their own prices and often run sales, and haggling is welcomed at most stalls.
Since the entire market is indoors, visitors avoid heat or rain and can navigate wheelchair-accessible walkways. Food stands number around twenty, serving snacks and meals near seating areas. A large Music Hall hosts live performances and special weekend events.
Inventory rotates daily as vendors restock, so regular visits reveal new finds. Locals and tourists crowd the market between Friday and Sunday. Clear signage and wide walkways help manage over a million annual visitors. Fleamasters Flea Market delivers a diverse, organized shopping experience with unexpected treasures around every corner.
blue a Goodwill Boutique
Stepping into blue a Goodwill Boutique feels more like browsing a well curated urban shop than a typical thrift store. Located on First Street in historic Fort Myers, the layout is neat and organized. You can browse racks without bumping into anyone while friendly staff welcome you with a genuine smile.
Inside you will find tidy racks sorted by size and style, making it easy to spot hidden treasures. The boutique specializes in designer jeans, statement handbags, and jewelry that sparkles more than standard thrift fare. There is also a selection of Southwest Florida themed souvenirs and home décor items that highlight local flair. Premium prices on big name brands reflect the careful sorting of quality pieces. Inventory changes frequently, so shoppers who visit midweek often find fresh arrivals waiting.
The focus stays on clothing, accessories, and manageable home goods you can carry to your car. A fitting room is available with staff assistance. Donating items is simple and most proceeds support neighborhood job training programs. Every purchase helps the community and ensures a guilt free, stylish find.