The best bakeries & sweet shops in Yuma

7 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

7 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Yuma's page when you're in Yuma's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Big Boy Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

800 S 1st Ave

Big Boy Ice Cream has spent generations supplying ice cream, candy, snacks, snow-cone syrup, and more, with brands from Blue Bunny to…

Big Boy Ice Cream has spent generations supplying ice cream, candy, snacks, snow-cone syrup, and more, with brands from Blue Bunny to Takis. Whether you’re planning a party or just want to browse the kind of treats that make a grocery run more interesting, it’s a handy local name to know.

From the Yuma newsletter, November 3, 2026

The Rustic Pantry (opens in a new tab)

10110 N Frontage Rd

Small-batch sourdough, chewy bagels, and from-scratch sweets are the whole vibe at The Rustic Pantry, a local cottage bakery from Devoe…

Small-batch sourdough, chewy bagels, and from-scratch sweets are the whole vibe at The Rustic Pantry, a local cottage bakery from Devoe Ranch Delicacies. Order ahead this week for English muffins that toast up just right, plus cookies that somehow disappear by Tuesday.

From the Yuma newsletter, August 7, 2026

Amour Latin Cafe (opens in a new tab)

2241 S Avenue A Ste 5

Amour Latin Cafe brings together comforting coffee and jewelry, so you can pick up a cozy sip and an accessory in one stop. It’s a sweet…

Amour Latin Cafe brings together comforting coffee and jewelry, so you can pick up a cozy sip and an accessory in one stop. It’s a sweet local find when your coffee run could use a little extra personality.

From the Yuma newsletter, November 12, 2026

Catherine's Cupcakery (opens in a new tab)

6369 E 41st St

When you need treats for more than just a couple coworkers, Catherine's Cupcakery is a local wholesale bakery turning out reliably fresh…

Checked Aug 26

When you need treats for more than just a couple coworkers, Catherine's Cupcakery is a local wholesale bakery turning out reliably fresh cupcakes by the dozen around Yuma. Perfect for cafés, office events, teams, and anyone who swears morale rises with frosting.

From the Yuma newsletter, September 4, 2026

Mooo's Creamery (opens in a new tab)

1400 S 4th Ave

When the desert heat wins, Mooo's Creamery brings the cool with scoops that hit the spot, plus ice cream cakes and community events. It’s…

When the desert heat wins, Mooo's Creamery brings the cool with scoops that hit the spot, plus ice cream cakes and community events. It’s the kind of happy place you pop into and accidentally start planning a photoshoot.

From the Yuma newsletter, November 19, 2026

Teezy's Culinary Creations (opens in a new tab)

1700 S 1st Ave #304

From pistachio perfection to wild, creative spins you didn’t know cheesecake could pull off, Teezy's Culinary Creations is turning out…

Checked Sep 14

From pistachio perfection to wild, creative spins you didn’t know cheesecake could pull off, Teezy's Culinary Creations is turning out slices that make dessert feel like an occasion. Keep them on your Yuma shortlist when celebrations pop up... or when a Tuesday needs rescuing.

From the Yuma newsletter, September 26, 2026

Jay’s Party Shop – Balloon Store & Party Supplies in Yuma, Arizona (opens in a new tab)

1221 W 16th St b2

Jay’s Party Shop has latex and foil balloons, custom bouquets, columns and garlands, plus personalized decorations for celebrations big and…

Jay’s Party Shop has latex and foil balloons, custom bouquets, columns and garlands, plus personalized decorations for celebrations big and small. You can also find piñatas, candy and party supplies, or rent tables, chairs and other event essentials, making it a handy one-stop stop for getting the party off the ground.

From the Yuma newsletter, November 15, 2026