The best restaurants in Arcata

“Small, easygoing cafe offering breakfast, brunch & lunch standards alongside coffee drinks.”

“Bar & eatery with a rotating selection of local brews on tap & pub fare, including vegetarian items.”

“Casual pizza chain featuring traditional pies, gluten-free crust & assorted appetizers.”

“Long-running chain serving pizzas with customizable toppings & sauces in a simple space.”

“Rustic cafe offering house-baked bagels, breads & pastries, along with Mexican treats.”

“Sustainable seafood & craft cocktails served in a stylish, minimalist space with blonde-wood decor.”

“Delivery, carryout & dine-in chain offering a wide range of pizzas, plus a variety of other dishes & sides.”

“Italian eatery offering specialty pies & a selection of hot & cold sandwiches, with veggie options.”

“Art lines the walls of this snug, brightly decorated cafe specializing in sweet & savory crepes.”

“Bayside Farmstead Café keeps mornings and lunch honest with from-scratch, seasonal plates and flaky artisanal pastries, all from a family-run crew that actually cares. Coffee comes from local roasters like Gold Rush Coffee and Fogline Coffee Roasters, and there’s also local wine, beer, kombucha, and ciders.”

From the Eureka newsletter, September 1, 2026