The best restaurants in Santa Maria

50 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Santa Maria’s best · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Beauty · Nightlife · Bakeries & Sweets · Entertainment · Home & Garden · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Shopping · Pets

Pinned in Santa Maria today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Santa Maria — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 50 places · showing the latest additions first

Great Scotts Pizza is the reliable, no-nonsense pie play when you want a proper weeknight win in Santa Maria. Classic, comforting pizza…

1437 S Broadway

Great Scotts Pizza is the reliable, no-nonsense pie play when you want a proper weeknight win in Santa Maria. Classic, comforting pizza made the way locals love it, perfect for movie night, kids’ sports debriefs, or those evenings you’re allergic to dishes.

From the Santa Maria newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Taqueria Charly Food Truck #1 is slinging street-style birria tacos and low-and-slow barbacoa for when the craving hits this week. Go for…

804 N Broadway

Taqueria Charly Food Truck #1 is slinging street-style birria tacos and low-and-slow barbacoa for when the craving hits this week. Go for the crispy-oozy quesabirria with a dunk of consommé, or rotate through burritos, tortas, sopes, huaraches, and seafood broths.

From the Santa Maria newsletter, August 7, 2026

Website ↗

SB Restaurant

Restaurants

Family-run eatery dishing burgers and breakfast items along with family-style dining.

2508 S Broadway

Family-run eatery dishing burgers and breakfast items along with family-style dining.

Website ↗

No-frills spot in a shopping plaza whipping up pizzas with various toppings, plus wings & subs.

1772 S Broadway

No-frills spot in a shopping plaza whipping up pizzas with various toppings, plus wings & subs.

Website ↗
Run a Santa Maria business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Warm, laid-back eatery for traditional American cuisine with a Cajun-Creole twist, plus vegan options.

135 E Foster Rd (Orcutt)

Warm, laid-back eatery for traditional American cuisine with a Cajun-Creole twist, plus vegan options.

Website ↗

Sake Sushi

Restaurants

Mall eatery featuring a variety of sushi, as well as poke bowls, bento boxes, and ramen.

194 Town Center E

Mall eatery featuring a variety of sushi, as well as poke bowls, bento boxes, and ramen.

Website ↗

Old-school chophouse with an open kitchen serving BBQ, steak & seafood, plus cocktails.

714 S Broadway

Old-school chophouse with an open kitchen serving BBQ, steak & seafood, plus cocktails.

Website ↗

Family-friendly buffet chain featuring all-you-can-eat American fare, plus salad & dessert bars.

2104 S Bradley Rd A-1

Family-friendly buffet chain featuring all-you-can-eat American fare, plus salad & dessert bars.

Website ↗

BBQ Land

Restaurants

Low-key BBQ eatery serving sandwiches & plates, plus seafood, tacos & Korean dishes.

1975 S Broadway A

Low-key BBQ eatery serving sandwiches & plates, plus seafood, tacos & Korean dishes.

Website ↗

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

795 Betteravia Rd

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

Website ↗

Relaxed, family-owned Italian-style restaurant offering pizzas and other dishes, along with beer and wine.

119 E Clark Ave (Orcutt)

Relaxed, family-owned Italian-style restaurant offering pizzas and other dishes, along with beer and wine.

Website ↗

Jim’s Burgers

Restaurants

Hamburger spot serving a variety of burgers and other classic American staples, like pastrami and fish ’n' chips.

729 S Broadway

Hamburger spot serving a variety of burgers and other classic American staples, like pastrami and fish ’n' chips.

Website ↗

Viet Kitchen

Restaurants

Vermicelli bowls and other familiar Vietnamese fare round out the menu at this casual eatery.

3558 Skyway Dr

Vermicelli bowls and other familiar Vietnamese fare round out the menu at this casual eatery.

Website ↗

Fine eatery with views that's popular for breakfast, lunch and dinner menus of fish and chips, hamburgers and eggs benedict.

925 Airport Dr (San Luis Obispo)

Fine eatery with views that's popular for breakfast, lunch and dinner menus of fish and chips, hamburgers and eggs benedict.

Website ↗

Old West-style eatery known for its huge top sirloin & other meats cooked over an oak-pit BBQ.

1760 El Camino Real (Grover Beach)

Old West-style eatery known for its huge top sirloin & other meats cooked over an oak-pit BBQ.

Website ↗

Fast-food chain specializing in fried chicken fingers, crinkle-cut fries & Texas toast.

485 Betteravia Rd

Fast-food chain specializing in fried chicken fingers, crinkle-cut fries & Texas toast.

Website ↗

Orcutt Burgers

Restaurants

Fast-food joint offering a wide burger selection, along with sandwiches, fried fish & breakfast.

1099 E Clark Ave

Fast-food joint offering a wide burger selection, along with sandwiches, fried fish & breakfast.

Website ↗

Hot or cold submarine sandwiches, pizza bread & other provisions served in an unfussy diner.

325 Betteravia Rd # B9

Hot or cold submarine sandwiches, pizza bread & other provisions served in an unfussy diner.

Website ↗

Casual, clean spot for sushi rolls and ramen, plus boba drinks and tea.

1551 Stowell, C St, Santa Maria, CA 93458

Casual, clean spot for sushi rolls and ramen, plus boba drinks and tea.

Website ↗

Wienerschnitzel

Restaurants

Fast-food chain featuring a variety of hot dogs, plus chili burgers & sandwiches.

500 E Main St

Fast-food chain featuring a variety of hot dogs, plus chili burgers & sandwiches.

Website ↗

Casual, family-friendly eatery for breakfast, lunch and dinner offerings like omelets, sandwiches and pies.

156 S Broadway (Orcutt)

Casual, family-friendly eatery for breakfast, lunch and dinner offerings like omelets, sandwiches and pies.

Website ↗

Klondike Pizza

Restaurants

Relaxed eatery serving pizza, burgers & reindeer sausages in a funky, Alaskan-themed setting.

2059 S Broadway

Relaxed eatery serving pizza, burgers & reindeer sausages in a funky, Alaskan-themed setting.

Website ↗

Basic, narrow counter serve serving familiar Mexican eats, such as burritos, huaraches & tacos.

923 N Broadway

Basic, narrow counter serve serving familiar Mexican eats, such as burritos, huaraches & tacos.

Website ↗

Popular joint serving chicken sandwiches, sliders, and fries in a casual space.

232 Betteravia Rd

Popular joint serving chicken sandwiches, sliders, and fries in a casual space.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

1848 N Broadway

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

560 Betteravia Rd d

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Santa Maria-style BBQ & other regional specialties served in an upscale setting with a mahogany bar.

300 E Clark Ave (Orcutt)

Santa Maria-style BBQ & other regional specialties served in an upscale setting with a mahogany bar.

Website ↗

Casual establishment serving up Mediterranean fare such as gyros and falafel in a liquor store setting.

750 E Main St

Casual establishment serving up Mediterranean fare such as gyros and falafel in a liquor store setting.

Website ↗

No-frills counter serve supplying hearty portions of Hawaiian-style BBQ & other classic specialties.

1836 N Broadway

No-frills counter serve supplying hearty portions of Hawaiian-style BBQ & other classic specialties.

Website ↗

SizzlinGogi

Restaurants

Polished Korean barbecue eatery where diners cook their own food on tabletop grills.

1841 S Broadway

Polished Korean barbecue eatery where diners cook their own food on tabletop grills.

Website ↗

Unfussy counter-serve venue with regular live music offering Hawaiian-style meat plates & burgers.

2880 Santa Maria Way

Unfussy counter-serve venue with regular live music offering Hawaiian-style meat plates & burgers.

Website ↗

In-N-Out Burger

Restaurants

Classic burger chain serving customizable burgers, hand-cut fries & shakes.

1330 S Bradley Rd

Classic burger chain serving customizable burgers, hand-cut fries & shakes.

Website ↗

The Pantry

Restaurants

Warm, laid-back outpost serving classic American comfort grub including breakfast & coffee drinks.

726 S Broadway

Warm, laid-back outpost serving classic American comfort grub including breakfast & coffee drinks.

Website ↗

Creative rolls & other Japanese fare served at a sushi bar or at tables in the intimate dining room.

209 Town Center E W

Creative rolls & other Japanese fare served at a sushi bar or at tables in the intimate dining room.

Website ↗

Casual eatery offering sushi, familiar Japanese dishes, lunch deals & an all-you-can-eat option.

416 E Main St

Casual eatery offering sushi, familiar Japanese dishes, lunch deals & an all-you-can-eat option.

Website ↗

PiWhole Pizza

Restaurants

Family-friendly eatery serving pizza pies, salads and calzones, plus beer and wine.

330 W Tefft St Ste C (Nipomo)

Family-friendly eatery serving pizza pies, salads and calzones, plus beer and wine.

Website ↗

Fire & Vice

Restaurants

Casual, German-inspired restaurant serving pretzels and burgers, also offering pizza and beer.

3580 Skyway Dr · ✓ checked Aug 4

Casual, German-inspired restaurant serving pretzels and burgers, also offering pizza and beer.

Website ↗

Natural Cafe

Restaurants

Fresh, local Californian fare including salads, veggie sandwiches & made-to-order smoothies.

2407 S Broadway

Fresh, local Californian fare including salads, veggie sandwiches & made-to-order smoothies.

Website ↗

Straw Hat Pizza

Restaurants

Chain serving Californian pizza, stuffed sandwiches & salads made with locally grown ingredients.

1822 N Broadway

Chain serving Californian pizza, stuffed sandwiches & salads made with locally grown ingredients.

Website ↗

Upmarket restaurant with an elegant dining room and fireplace, serving a mix of classic dishes.

Santa Maria

Upmarket restaurant with an elegant dining room and fireplace, serving a mix of classic dishes.

Website ↗

Two Guy's Pizza

Restaurants

Family-run pizzeria offering an all-you-can-eat option in casual surroundings.

898 Guadalupe St b (Guadalupe)

Family-run pizzeria offering an all-you-can-eat option in casual surroundings.

Website ↗

Haha Sushi

Restaurants

Casual restaurant in the Acorn Shopping Center dishing up sushi rolls and Japanese fare including chicken teriyaki and calamari.

4869 S Bradley Rd

Casual restaurant in the Acorn Shopping Center dishing up sushi rolls and Japanese fare including chicken teriyaki and calamari.

Website ↗

Kumi Ko

Restaurants

Casual, contemporary Japanese restaurant with a sushi bar, lunch specials & hot entrees.

3830 Broad St (San Luis Obispo)

Casual, contemporary Japanese restaurant with a sushi bar, lunch specials & hot entrees.

Website ↗

FoodTrip

Restaurants

Casual, family-run restaurant with traditional Filipino fare, including BBQ, pancit, and halo-halo.

230 Betteravia Rd Unit F

Casual, family-run restaurant with traditional Filipino fare, including BBQ, pancit, and halo-halo.

Website ↗

Swiss Restaurant

Restaurants

Venerable restaurant & bar offering prime rib, steaks, poultry & seafood cooked in a red-oak pit.

516 N Broadway

Venerable restaurant & bar offering prime rib, steaks, poultry & seafood cooked in a red-oak pit.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant serving breakfast dishes such as omelets and beignets, plus sandwiches.

335 Betteravia Rd

Casual restaurant serving breakfast dishes such as omelets and beignets, plus sandwiches.

Website ↗

Contemporary coastal cuisine & local wines in an elegant setting at Sycamore Mineral Springs Resort.

1215 Avila Beach Dr (San Luis Obispo)

Contemporary coastal cuisine & local wines in an elegant setting at Sycamore Mineral Springs Resort.

Website ↗

Locally owned American daytime diner in a charming, historic building with a quaint country vibe.

135 E Clark Ave (Orcutt)

Locally owned American daytime diner in a charming, historic building with a quaint country vibe.

Website ↗

Rustic, mission-style hangout for BBQ plates, Mexican eats & sandwiches, plus many draft beers.

108 Cuyama Ln (Nipomo)

Rustic, mission-style hangout for BBQ plates, Mexican eats & sandwiches, plus many draft beers.

Website ↗

Al Pho

Restaurants

Cozy spot for pho and other Vietnamese dishes, plus beer and wine.

1201 E Main St

Cozy spot for pho and other Vietnamese dishes, plus beer and wine.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →