The best bakeries & sweet shops in Pueblo County

6 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

6 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Pueblo County's page when you're in Pueblo County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Bite Me Cake Company / Flip A Coin Arcade Bar (opens in a new tab)

223 S Union Ave · Pueblo

Bite Me Cake Company / Flip A Coin Arcade Bar is that rare Pueblo combo where you can grab a killer cupcake or ice cream, then chase a high…

Bite Me Cake Company / Flip A Coin Arcade Bar is that rare Pueblo combo where you can grab a killer cupcake or ice cream, then chase a high score. Planning a birthday or tying the knot soon? Their custom cakes make celebrations taste like a win.

From the Pueblo County newsletter, November 17, 2026

Mauro Farms & Bakery (opens in a new tab)

936 36th Ln · Pueblo

When the sweet tooth hits, Mauro Farms & Bakery comes through with old-world potica in walnut, pecan, or poppy seed, Italian cookies like…

When the sweet tooth hits, Mauro Farms & Bakery comes through with old-world potica in walnut, pecan, or poppy seed, Italian cookies like pizzelles and biscotti, and small-batch candies from English toffee to brittle. Perfect for coffee breaks, porch hangs, or bribing coworkers.

From the Pueblo County newsletter, November 9, 2026

Cold Stone Creamery (opens in a new tab)

4200 N Fwy Rd Ste 110 · Pueblo

Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more.

Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more.

Eliza Jane Cakes LLC (opens in a new tab)

1411 US-50 · Pueblo

Have a celebration that deserves more than a grocery-store sheet cake? Eliza Jane Cakes LLC makes custom cakes with a focus on excellent…

Have a celebration that deserves more than a grocery-store sheet cake? Eliza Jane Cakes LLC makes custom cakes with a focus on excellent taste and show-stopping creativity, bringing your vision into the kitchen and turning it into the centerpiece everyone will want a slice of.

From the Pueblo newsletter, November 12, 2026

Goodies De Lu (opens in a new tab)

108 W D St · Pueblo

From Blue Bell ice cream and crepes to mangonadas, chamoyadas, nachos and even ceviche, Goodies De Lu’ nails the sweet-and-savory mood…

From Blue Bell ice cream and crepes to mangonadas, chamoyadas, nachos and even ceviche, Goodies De Lu’ nails the sweet-and-savory mood swings with handcrafted drinks and a cozy, downtown vibe. Bonus points for weekend Neon Nights with lasers and selfie corners that practically demand a group hang.

From the Pueblo newsletter, November 4, 2026

Zoelsmann's Bakery & Deli (opens in a new tab)

912 E Abriendo Ave · Pueblo

Since 1898, Zoelsmann's Bakery & Deli has kept Pueblo running on stone-baked Vienna and sourdough, cinnamon rolls, potica, and fresh…

Since 1898, Zoelsmann's Bakery & Deli has kept Pueblo running on stone-baked Vienna and sourdough, cinnamon rolls, potica, and fresh cannolis, plus a legit deli with capicola, artisan cheeses, and Sicilian green olives. Swing by when your week needs real bread, a sandwich, or a cookie tray.

From the Pueblo newsletter, November 17, 2026