The best restaurants in Shelton

16 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Shelton’s best · Beauty · Shopping · Health & Wellness · Nightlife · Pets · Bakeries & Sweets · Home & Garden

Pinned in Shelton today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Shelton — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 16 places · showing the latest additions first

New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.

50 Pershing Dr (Derby)

“New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.”

Website ↗

Wayback Burgers

Restaurants

Made-to-order burgers & milkshakes fill out the menu at this quick-serve chain with retro decor.

54 Pershing Dr #9 (Ansonia)

“Made-to-order burgers & milkshakes fill out the menu at this quick-serve chain with retro decor.”

Website ↗

Apollo Pizza

Restaurants

When pizza night hits, Apollo Pizza is an easy pick for Shelton folks who like straightforward, classic pies without the fuss. Think gooey…

235 Roosevelt Dr (Derby)

“When pizza night hits, Apollo Pizza is an easy pick for Shelton folks who like straightforward, classic pies without the fuss. Think gooey cheese, a sturdy crust, and enough topping combos to keep the family committee from debating all night.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 24, 2026

Website ↗

Since 2006, Amici's Restaurant Shelton CT has dialed in seasonal Northern and Southern Italian classics using fresh, locally sourced…

500 Howe Ave

“Since 2006, Amici's Restaurant Shelton CT has dialed in seasonal Northern and Southern Italian classics using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, all in a cozy brick-walled, white-tablecloth setting.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 22, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Shelton business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Roma Pizzeria

Restaurants

When the week calls for real deal blistered crust and oozy cheese, Roma Pizzeria comes through with brick-oven pies loaded how you like…

150 Wakelee Ave (Ansonia)

“When the week calls for real deal blistered crust and oozy cheese, Roma Pizzeria comes through with brick-oven pies loaded how you like them, plus the kind of comfort food standbys that calm a Tuesday.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Bartone's Apizza

Restaurants

At Bartone's Apizza, expect old school pizza with a new school twist, scratch-made dough, ripe tomato sauce, and locally sourced toppings,…

143 Main St (Derby)

“At Bartone's Apizza, expect old school pizza with a new school twist, scratch-made dough, ripe tomato sauce, and locally sourced toppings, plus vegetarian and vegan options. Cozy community vibes and friendly service make it an easy weeknight win for Shelton folks who just want great pie without the fuss.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Set in Derby’s historic Old Birmingham Bank complete with an original vault, stained glass and Victorian chandeliers, Twisted Vine…

285 Main St (Derby)

“Set in Derby’s historic Old Birmingham Bank complete with an original vault, stained glass and Victorian chandeliers, Twisted Vine Restaurant serves flavor-packed plates and stirs up fun with monthly Paranormal Dinner & Ghost Tour nights, live music and the cozy Birmingham Cellars lounge downstairs.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

Bagel Bros & Co.

Restaurants

Bagel Bros & Co. is Shelton’s go-to for fresh, doughy New York-style bagels made daily, 16 classic flavors, legit spreads, and Boar’s…

350 Howe Ave

“Bagel Bros & Co. is Shelton’s go-to for fresh, doughy New York-style bagels made daily, 16 classic flavors, legit spreads, and Boar’s Head-stacked sandwiches, all from brothers Ali and Flamur Nasufi with over 50 years of know-how, named #1 by Tasting Table and voted Best Bagel in Connecticut.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

Family-owned since 1980, Mattei's Deli And Catering is that no-fuss Italian-American spot turning out satisfying lunch staples and…

418 Roosevelt Dr (Derby)

“Family-owned since 1980, Mattei's Deli And Catering is that no-fuss Italian-American spot turning out satisfying lunch staples and big-flavor party trays for pickup. Think stuffed clams, Swedish meatballs, and classics that hit the spot for an easy weeknight win or Sunday spread... just hop over to Derby.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 17, 2026

Website ↗

Craving that perfect crunch with a little Southern swagger, Shelton? Southern Chicken and Waffle is doing crispy fried chicken, golden…

64 Division St (Derby)

“Craving that perfect crunch with a little Southern swagger, Shelton? Southern Chicken and Waffle is doing crispy fried chicken, golden waffles, fried fish, and even chicken and lamb over rice, plus homemade strawberry lemonade and cheesecake that tastes like someone's aunt brought dessert to the cookout.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 17, 2026

Website ↗

When you want something cozy without the fuss, Caloroso Eatery & Bar turns out solid pies, saucy pastas, and classic Italian entrees in a…

100 Center St

“When you want something cozy without the fuss, Caloroso Eatery & Bar turns out solid pies, saucy pastas, and classic Italian entrees in a relaxed, down-to-earth setting. On nice days, claim a table outside, catch up with friends, and let the carbs do the talking.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 23, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you grew up on bacon, egg and cheese or chase new combos, Billy D's Shelton is the longtime go-to for made-to-order breakfast…

58 Bridgeport Ave

“Whether you grew up on bacon, egg and cheese or chase new combos, Billy D's Shelton is the longtime go-to for made-to-order breakfast sandwiches, the famous Doubler and hearty lunch favorites. Family run for over 35 years, generous portions guarantee you never leave hungry.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

Tacomida

Restaurants

Shelton’s Tacomida keeps it casual with Mexican and Central American plates, tacos done right, and a variety of margaritas alongside other…

50 Bridge St

“Shelton’s Tacomida keeps it casual with Mexican and Central American plates, tacos done right, and a variety of margaritas alongside other cocktails. Easy pick when you want bold flavors, a good pour, and a no-fuss night with friends.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 29, 2026

Website ↗

When you just want a laid-back, family-friendly spot with legit pies, loaded grinders, and those calzones you tell yourself you’ll share,…

90 Pershing Dr (Derby)

“When you just want a laid-back, family-friendly spot with legit pies, loaded grinders, and those calzones you tell yourself you’ll share, Italian Pavilion - Pizza and Italian Food Restaurant in Derby hits the mark for Shelton locals craving classic Italian comfort without the fuss.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 25, 2026

Website ↗

Roseland Apizza

Restaurants

Since 1935, Roseland Apizza has been the spot for New Haven pizza, lobster ravioli, and Italian comfort in an old-school setting locals…

350 Hawthorne Ave (Derby) · ✓ checked Sep 24

“Since 1935, Roseland Apizza has been the spot for New Haven pizza, lobster ravioli, and Italian comfort in an old-school setting locals actually crave. When you want a no-nonsense classic that tastes like tradition, this is the move.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 28, 2026

Website ↗

Matto Wine Bar

Restaurants

Matto Wine Bar nails the fun, contemporary vibe, with Italian-inspired tapas, craft cocktails, and those square artisan pizzas flying out…

389 Bridgeport Ave

“Matto Wine Bar nails the fun, contemporary vibe, with Italian-inspired tapas, craft cocktails, and those square artisan pizzas flying out of a serious brick oven. It’s the spot in the heart of Shelton when you want great bites to split, a thoughtful wine list, and an easy good time.”

From the Shelton newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →