The best bakeries & sweet shops in Bay County

Whether it’s a weeknight couch snack or a just-because treat, Fat & Weird Cookie has mega cookies stuffed with decadent cores, poppable Lil Weirdos, and frozen cookie dough bites. Build your own box or snag a Best Sellers pack, then share with the neighborhood... or not.

From the Lynn Haven newsletter, October 15, 2026

Whether it's a last-minute office celebration or a just-because pastry craving, Mandy's Bakery turns out custom cakes that match your vibe and fresh pastries made with premium ingredients. Their handcrafted desserts look legit, taste better, and make even Tuesday feel like a milestone.

From the Panama City newsletter, August 5, 2026

Mason’s Coffee House & Bakery pairs handcrafted drinks with house-made cookies and other freshly baked treats, making it an easy local pick-me-up when your day could use a little caffeine and a little something sweet.

From the Panama City newsletter, October 28, 2026

Cozy shop specializing in made-to-order doughnuts crafted from pastry-style dough such as croissant, plus coffee, breakfast sandwiches and treats like acai bowls.

Need a gorgeous cake that doesn’t taste like cardboard? Sugar Art By Angela does custom cakes and sweet treats dialed to your style, so your Panama City wedding, shower, or birthday looks polished and tastes unforgettable. Consider this your permission slip to start picking flavors this week.

From the Lynn Haven newsletter, October 10, 2026

Candy shop with a large selection, gifts, and ice cream.

Family owned and serving breakfast and lunch all day, Sunrise Cafe & Bakery is the move this week if you want fresh donuts made every morning and coffee that hits right. Keep an eye on their rotating European menu... manty, samsa, borscht, and other specialties you don't see every day, plus custom cakes.

From the Panama City newsletter, August 28, 2026

Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.

Andy's Flour Power Cafe and Bakery is the kind of spot locals keep in their back pocket. They don't do fancy, they do fresh, from real-deal strawberries crowning the French toast to marinated veggies tucked into a frittata, so make it your brunch move this week.

From the Panama City newsletter, October 22, 2026

Traditional store selling chocolates, confections & fudge, as well as original recipe ice cream.

Bright ice cream parlor serving frozen treats & coffee drinks in a casual space with an ocean motif.

Skip the bland stuff and hit Candymaker Ice Cream Shop at the Panama City Beach store for soft serve with all the toppings plus the house-made classics they’re known for. Think fresh salt water taffy, pralines, fudge, and pecan logs, made all day so your sugar rush is the good kind.

From the Panama City newsletter, September 2, 2026