The best cafes in St. Marys

Whether you’re chasing a cozy pick‑me‑up or a last‑minute gift, Mad Hatter Tea Shop is the kind of local boutique that makes browsing actually relaxing. Pop in when your week needs a reset and leave with something delightful for you or a neighbor.

From the St. Marys newsletter, October 14, 2026

Drive-thru chain doling out coffee & espresso drinks along with breakfast sandwiches & baked goods.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Drive-thru chain doling out coffee & espresso drinks along with breakfast sandwiches & baked goods.

Hola Cuban Cafe keeps Nassau County happily caffeinated with café con leche, cortaditos, and pressed Cuban sandwiches, plus fresh pastries made daily. Swing by downtown Fernandina Beach for slow-simmered black bean soup, lentil stew with chorizo, and a relaxed, dog-friendly patio locals treat like a second living room.

From the Nassau County newsletter, October 9, 2026

Kraken Coffee & Kitchen Co. is that reliable downtown spot for handcrafted coffee made with ethically sourced beans and fresh pastries baked daily. Think flaky croissants, sweet kolaches, and a cozy vibe that works for quick caffeine runs, lingering chats, or a pre-ferry pick‑me‑up.

From the St. Marys newsletter, October 22, 2026

Nom Nom Boba Tea and More nails the balance of fresh-brewed tea, fruit and house-made syrups, then tops it with their secret-recipe boba for that perfect creamy chew. It’s a cozy, modern hangout for study sessions or catch-ups, with fun flavors, dairy-free options, and even a sweet dessert lineup.

From the Jacksonville newsletter, October 29, 2026

Pura Bean Coffee Company is a true local roaster, turning out single origin beans and signature blends on a traditional drum roaster in their Jacksonville shop. Grab a bag of Bourbon Street, Los Volcanes, Mojo or Tico Time, then slow down, sip, and actually enjoy your morning.

From the Jacksonville newsletter, October 14, 2026

Setlan Coffee Co. inside MOCA Jacksonville pours Good Citizen Coffee Co. roasts and leans hard into community, joy, and genuinely kind service.

From the Palm Coast newsletter, September 12, 2026

Need a dependable caffeine fix that actually tastes like it cares this week? Amelia Island Coffee pours locally roasted Yulee beans into classic espresso and fun specialty sips, with a linger-friendly vibe that’s been a community meet-up spot since 1995, so you can pop in, catch up, or grab a to-go pick-me-up.

From the Nassau County newsletter, October 16, 2026

904 Purr & Pour Lounge is building a purr-poseful hangout where you can sip coffee, craft beer, or wine while chilling with adoptable cats in a thoughtfully designed lounge. Keep this on your radar this week, follow their journey, and get ready for a cozy community spot that creates joy and second chances.

From the Jacksonville newsletter, August 13, 2026