Winter winds howling down from the Sawtooth Mountains can test any roof’s mettle, and the intense summer sun beating down on the foothills doesn’t offer much reprieve. Boise homeowners know their roofs work overtime year-round, making the choice of contractor absolutely critical.
How We Picked: We vetted dozens of local contractors against strict criteria: licensing transparency, BBB standings, Google ratings above 3.8 stars with 25+ reviews, warranty offerings, and proven track records in Idaho’s demanding climate.
Signature Roofing
- Founded: 1994
- 4.9/5 Google Rating
Signature Roofing stands apart as one of only a handful of contractors nationwide to achieve dual elite certifications from both GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed Master Craftsman Elite programs — distinctions earned by less than 2% of roofing companies. With over 30 years of combined experience in the Treasure Valley, they’ve established themselves as the gold standard for quality and reliability. Their warehouse facility off Franklin Road stocks premium materials and allows for quality control that smaller operations simply can’t match. One homeowner raved about their crew’s attention to detail, noting how they swept even the sidewalks after completion.
Pro Tip: Ask about their exclusive extended warranty coverage that comes with dual certification — protection unavailable from standard contractors.
Bartlett Roofing
- Founded: 1993
- 4.85/5 Google Rating
BBB A+ rated and accredited since establishment, Bartlett Roofing brings over 25 years of roofing experience with certifications from GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed. What started as Doug Bartlett’s family framing crew in the early ’90s has grown into a full-scale operation serving multiple states. Their multi-state licensing (Idaho RCE-40938, Utah, Oregon, Washington, Montana, Wyoming) demonstrates serious commitment to professional standards. Customers consistently praise their insurance advocacy, with one noting how they “fought for us all the way” and successfully handled defective shingle issues directly with manufacturers.
Pro Tip: They excel at insurance claim navigation — particularly valuable after hail storms that frequently hit the Treasure Valley.
Idaho Roofing Contractors
- Founded: 2001
- 4.7/5 Google Rating
Since 2001, this family-operated company has earned BBB A+ rating and achieved Platinum Preferred Contractor status with Owens Corning — making Idaho Roofing Contractors the Treasure Valley’s first and only to reach this elite tier. They’ve successfully served more than 11,000 satisfied customers with a focus on both residential and commercial projects. Their involvement in community volunteer efforts speaks to deep local roots. Recent projects showcase their expertise with Owens Corning Oakridge shingles, comprehensive underlayment systems, and improved ventilation solutions.
Pro Tip: Their Platinum Preferred status unlocks Owens Corning’s strongest warranty coverage — ask specifically about their System Plus Limited Warranty.
Legacy Roofing of Idaho
- Founded: 2020
- 5/5 Google Rating
Chuck Turner’s roofing journey began working with his father’s contracting company before relocating to Boise in 2012 and launching Legacy Roofing in 2020. Despite being the newest company on our list, they’ve completed over 500 roofing projects with consistently glowing reviews. Customers highlight Chuck’s no-pressure approach and responsiveness, with one noting he was “the only one that showed up” for estimates when others were a no-show. Their rapid growth and perfect rating reflect genuine commitment to customer satisfaction over volume.
Pro Tip: Ask about their architectural shingle options — Idaho restricts three-tab shingles, and Legacy specializes in dimensional alternatives that look like wood shake but won’t rot.
208 Roofing
- Founded: 2017
- 5/5 Trustpilot Rating
Wayne Brault’s Mountain Home-based company brings over 20 years of roofing experience and membership in the Idaho Home Builders Association. BBB A+ accredited since 2022, 208 Roofing maintain locations in both Mountain Home and Boise to serve Southern Idaho. Customers consistently praise Wayne’s integrity, with one noting appreciation for his honesty about a roof still having “another 5 years left in it” rather than pushing unnecessary work. Their advanced technology includes drone inspections and satellite measurements accurate to 1/8th of an inch.
Pro Tip: They offer premium “Duration” 130 MPH wind-rated shingles at the same price competitors charge for standard 30-year shingles.
Weathertight Roofing
- Founded: 2008
- 5/5 Angi Rating
With nearly 40,000 completed projects across Idaho, Weathertight has been the go-to choice for roofing solutions for 9 consecutive years. BBB accredited since 2009 and based in Caldwell, they bring significant commercial experience to residential projects. Their full general contractor licensing extends beyond roofing to include tenant improvements and remodeling. GuildQuality surveys show consistently high satisfaction rates across communication, workmanship, and professionalism metrics.
Pro Tip: Their extensive commercial background means they bring professional-grade project management to residential roof replacements.
Treasure Valley Exteriors
- Founded: 2010
- 4.3/5 Google Rating
BBB A+ accredited since 2016, this full-service exterior contractor has helped over 5,000 homeowners with Idaho contractor license RCE-32092. Treasure Valley Exteriors earned over 550 five-star reviews and 68 awards, with certified installers offering warranties up to lifetime coverage. One customer praised their comprehensive approach: “TVE did our roof, windows, and exterior paint. Each individual we worked with was friendly, helpful, and professional”. Their one-stop-shop model appeals to homeowners tackling multiple exterior projects.
Pro Tip: Ask about their “No Money Down” promotions and financing options — large companies typically offer better lending relationships.
Hawaiian Built Roofing
- Founded: 2005
- 4/5 Yelp Rating
This women-owned business has served the Treasure Valley since 2005, surviving and thriving for nearly two decades through quality workmanship. Hawaiian Built Roofing focus exclusively on CertainTeed products, making them specialists in this premium roofing system with excellent fire ratings. Their CertainTeed warranty and professional approach stand out to customers, with one noting appreciation for “the time and attention given to my questions and knowledge of details/codes”. They’ve recently added groundbreaking CertainTeed Solstice solar shingles to their offerings.
Pro Tip: Their CertainTeed specialization means deeper product knowledge and stronger manufacturer relationships than generalists.
Point Roofing & Restoration
- Founded: 2012
- BBB A+ Rating
BBB accredited since 2012, Point Roofing offers comprehensive services from residential to industrial projects. Their digital visualization tools help homeowners confidently select materials before installation begins. Owner Mike La Pointe’s background spans both residential and commercial sectors, bringing broader expertise to complex projects. Their restoration focus means they excel at reviving older Boise homes while meeting modern building codes.
Pro Tip: Ask to see their digital visualization of your roof with different material options — it eliminates guesswork on final appearance.
Treasure Valley Roofing
- Founded: 2020
- 5/5 Google Rating
BBB A+ accredited since 2021, Treasure Valley Roofing offers residential roof repair and storm damage restoration. Despite being newer, they’ve completed 250+ successful projects with 5-star Google ratings. Customers highlight their responsive emergency service, with one praising how they “were out within an hour” after a bus damaged their roof and “emptied buckets so I didn’t come home to floor damage” while waiting for materials. Their smaller size allows for personalized attention often missing from larger operations.
Pro Tip: Their emergency response capability shines during Idaho’s unpredictable weather events — keep their number handy.
–
Remember: Get at least three detailed bids, verify current licensing through Idaho’s Division of Occupational & Professional Licenses, and always pull permits for major work. The foothills winds and Treasure Valley’s temperature swings demand quality installation — your roof is only as good as the crew that installs it.
