The best restaurants in Caldwell

45 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Caldwell’s best · Beauty · Shopping · Bakeries & Sweets · Nightlife · Sporting Goods · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Health & Wellness · Arts & Culture · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Home & Garden · Parks & Outdoors

Pinned in Caldwell today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Caldwell — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 45 places · showing the latest additions first

Sushi Sushi

Restaurants

In Nampa, Sushi Sushi nails the sweet spot of affordable, dependable sushi with plenty of classic and specialty rolls, hot dishes for the…

16734 N Marketplace Blvd (Nampa)

In Nampa, Sushi Sushi nails the sweet spot of affordable, dependable sushi with plenty of classic and specialty rolls, hot dishes for the non-raw crowd, and a cold beer if you want it. Friendly, attentive service and easy online ordering make it a no-brainer weeknight go-to.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Blaze Pizza

Restaurants

Hip counter-serve pizzeria dishing up crispy, thin-crust pies made with creative toppings & sauces.

16375 N Merchant Way Ste 170 (Nampa)

Hip counter-serve pizzeria dishing up crispy, thin-crust pies made with creative toppings & sauces.

Website ↗

From the pizza-making imagination station at Flying Pie Pizzaria | Nampa, you can stack a build-your-own pie or go for their Contest Combo,…

1021 12th Ave S (Nampa)

From the pizza-making imagination station at Flying Pie Pizzaria | Nampa, you can stack a build-your-own pie or go for their Contest Combo, Samoan, Denver Pie, or Pesto Primavera. They’ll even deliver beer and wine, including the exclusive Triple Pi Belgian-style Abbey Ale, right to your couch.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 4, 2026

Website ↗

Craving a simple, satisfying taco night, Taqueria La Piedad delivers tacos, asada and birria that taste like they were made by people who…

201 N 21st Ave · ✓ checked Aug 28

Craving a simple, satisfying taco night, Taqueria La Piedad delivers tacos, asada and birria that taste like they were made by people who care. Nothing fussy, just bold flavors and consistency, which is exactly what you want in a neighborhood staple.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Caldwell business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Craving something beyond pepperoni this week? Extreme Pizza | Caldwell slings inventive pies like Ghost Wave with ghost pepper cheese and…

111 S 7th Ave

Craving something beyond pepperoni this week? Extreme Pizza | Caldwell slings inventive pies like Ghost Wave with ghost pepper cheese and honey, Kickin’ Chicken with Thai peanut vibes, and Mr. Pestato Head with roasted potatoes.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

If your mornings need a nudge, Mi Pueblito | Mexican Cafe is the made-from-scratch spot locals lean on for real-deal chilaquiles, breakfast…

2621 S 10th Ave Ste 104

If your mornings need a nudge, Mi Pueblito | Mexican Cafe is the made-from-scratch spot locals lean on for real-deal chilaquiles, breakfast tacos, and huevos rancheros, plus other homey platillos. Fresh every morning, comforting without being boring, and exactly the kind of Caldwell habit you won’t regret.

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

When only melty, slow-simmered birria will do, Birria Don Jose LLC comes through with crunchy or soft tacos built for dipping, gooey…

2800 Cleveland Blvd

When only melty, slow-simmered birria will do, Birria Don Jose LLC comes through with crunchy or soft tacos built for dipping, gooey quesabirria, and even a torta baptized in rich broth. Add street tacos, mulitas, and burritos to the mix, then thank yourself all week.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 16, 2026

Website ↗

Keystone Pizza

Restaurants

Rolled-fresh dough, scratch-made sauce, and their own cheese blend keep pies classic while the famous salad bar lets you pretend it’s a…

207 S 9th Ave

Rolled-fresh dough, scratch-made sauce, and their own cheese blend keep pies classic while the famous salad bar lets you pretend it’s a balanced meal. Keystone Pizza has been a family-owned Caldwell hangout for 30+ years, with arcade games, pool tables, and a lunch buffet that feels delightfully old-school.

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

When the team’s hungry and nobody wants dishes, Idaho Pizza Company nails the combo of crowd-pleasing pies, an award winning salad bar, and…

16151 N Idaho Center Blvd (Nampa)

When the team’s hungry and nobody wants dishes, Idaho Pizza Company nails the combo of crowd-pleasing pies, an award winning salad bar, and a laid back, family friendly vibe. They’ve been serving Idaho for over 20 years, with dine-in, delivery, or carry-out keeping Caldwell well fed.

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

Craving legit Mexican that hits the spot after a long day? Aguililla Mexican Restaurant dishes street-style tacos, saucy enchiladas with a…

324 11th Ave N (Nampa) · ✓ checked Aug 20

Craving legit Mexican that hits the spot after a long day? Aguililla Mexican Restaurant dishes street-style tacos, saucy enchiladas with a proper chile relleno sidekick, rich menudo on chillier days, and house-made salsas with icy horchata... simple, craveable, and straight-up Nampa.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

Marco's Pizza

Restaurants

Counter-serve chain serving up a menu of specialty or custom pizzas for takeout or delivery.

2609 S 10th Ave Ste 105

Counter-serve chain serving up a menu of specialty or custom pizzas for takeout or delivery.

Website ↗

Casa Añejo

Restaurants

Casa Añejo brings an upscale spin to street tacos and burgers, with a full bar where artistic bartenders turn out the kind of drinks you’ll…

812 Main St

Casa Añejo brings an upscale spin to street tacos and burgers, with a full bar where artistic bartenders turn out the kind of drinks you’ll want to linger over. Trendy vibe, brunch and dinner service, and plates that feel special without being fussy make it a solid local go-to.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

Mancino's Subs & Pizza has been taking fresh flavor seriously, turning out oven-baked grinders on scratch-made bread since 1983, plus…

2412 Cleveland Blvd

Mancino's Subs & Pizza has been taking fresh flavor seriously, turning out oven-baked grinders on scratch-made bread since 1983, plus classic pizzas with generous portions.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

AMANO | Mexican

Restaurants

Amano | Mexican leans into ancestral technique with meats slow-cooked in underground barbacoa pits, hand-pressed nixtamalized tortillas,…

802 Arthur St

Amano | Mexican leans into ancestral technique with meats slow-cooked in underground barbacoa pits, hand-pressed nixtamalized tortillas, and mezcal-forward cocktails in a space that actually feels special.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

When indecision hits, Superb Sushi Thai Fusion has your back with legit sushi rolls and nigiri plus Thai comfort picks like Pad Thai,…

2306 12th Ave Rd (Nampa)

When indecision hits, Superb Sushi Thai Fusion has your back with legit sushi rolls and nigiri plus Thai comfort picks like Pad Thai, Massaman curry, pho, and crispy chicken bowls. Pro tip, try a lunch combo that pairs noodles with a roll, or add jalapeño and avocado to freestyle.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 22, 2026

Website ↗

Whether the crew needs a midweek win, Idaho Pizza Company has been serving Idaho for over 20 years with crowd-pleasing pies, an…

4816 Cleveland Blvd

Whether the crew needs a midweek win, Idaho Pizza Company has been serving Idaho for over 20 years with crowd-pleasing pies, an award-winning salad bar, and hearty sandwiches. Family friendly, easy for dine-in, delivery, or carry-out, and perfect when the Caldwell crew just wants good pizza without a debate.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Mr. V's Family Restaurant is the no-fuss spot for all-day breakfast and comfort classics that taste like somebody's grandma still runs the…

407 N 10th Ave

Mr. V's Family Restaurant is the no-fuss spot for all-day breakfast and comfort classics that taste like somebody's grandma still runs the kitchen. World-famous biscuits and gravy, charbroiled burgers, and prime rib make it the place to treat yourself this week without overthinking dinner.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 14, 2026

Website ↗

Bottega Toscana

Restaurants

Level up your weeknight cooking with Bottega Toscana, right here in Nampa, where Tuscan pecorino, extra virgin olive oils, aged balsamic,…

112 3rd St S (Nampa)

Level up your weeknight cooking with Bottega Toscana, right here in Nampa, where Tuscan pecorino, extra virgin olive oils, aged balsamic, artisanal pasta, and truffle-kissed goodies turn simple meals into flexes. Pop in this week, build a board, then watch your leftovers suddenly become brag-worthy.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

When you want big wok-kissed flavor without overthinking dinner this week, Mongolian Fire Grill BBQ hits the spot with Chinese favorites…

1220 N Jacob Alcott Way (Nampa)

When you want big wok-kissed flavor without overthinking dinner this week, Mongolian Fire Grill BBQ hits the spot with Chinese favorites like house special fried rice loaded with chicken, shrimp and steak, garlicky salt and pepper chicken, plus Peking ravioli (pork) that scratches that comfort-food itch.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Blazen Burgers

Restaurants

Blazen Burgers has been serving Nampa since 2004 with hand-ground, hand-pattied burgers, fresh ingredients, and family recipes that taste…

216 1st Ave S (Nampa)

Blazen Burgers has been serving Nampa since 2004 with hand-ground, hand-pattied burgers, fresh ingredients, and family recipes that taste like someone actually cares. Try a Bacon Blue, grab a thick shake, or go gluten free or lettuce-wrapped without losing the flavor.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

When the korma-to-fry-pan energy is low, Red Fort Cuisine of India comes through with legit tandoori sizzlers, creamy tikka masala, and…

117 12th Ave S (Nampa)

When the korma-to-fry-pan energy is low, Red Fort Cuisine of India comes through with legit tandoori sizzlers, creamy tikka masala, and naan that basically disappears on contact. Plenty of vegetarian and vegan options too, so everyone at home base gets fed and happy.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

When you want a serious burger this week, The Last Stop Kitchen is the food trailer bringing big flavor with locally sourced beef,…

525 E Karcher Rd (Nampa) · ✓ checked Aug 4

When you want a serious burger this week, The Last Stop Kitchen is the food trailer bringing big flavor with locally sourced beef, house-made sauces like OG fry sauce, and creative builds like Cowboy or Quesadilla. Not feeling a bun? Wraps, chili fries, and onion rings keep the crew happy.

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 15, 2026

Website ↗

Right here in Caldwell, Indian Creek Steakhouse delivers the classic combo of steaks, seafood, and live country music on weekends, which is…

711 Main St · ✓ checked Aug 13

Right here in Caldwell, Indian Creek Steakhouse delivers the classic combo of steaks, seafood, and live country music on weekends, which is basically the local cure for decision fatigue. Grab a table, let the guitars twang, and treat yourself to something that actually tastes like Friday.

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 20, 2026

Website ↗

L&L Hawaiian BBQ

Restaurants

Whether the week’s getting wild or you just want something that hits right, L&L Hawaiian BBQ does Hawaii’s beloved plate lunches with…

140 Caldwell Blvd (Nampa)

Whether the week’s getting wild or you just want something that hits right, L&L Hawaiian BBQ does Hawaii’s beloved plate lunches with hearty portions and craveable barbecue flavors. Easy, fast, and seriously satisfying, it’s the local move when you need comfort food that actually delivers.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 23, 2026

Website ↗

In-N-Out Burger

Restaurants

Classic burger chain serving customizable burgers, hand-cut fries & shakes.

16225 N Marketplace Blvd (Nampa)

Classic burger chain serving customizable burgers, hand-cut fries & shakes.

Website ↗

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

2101 N Cassia St #2111 (Nampa)

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

Website ↗

Pub and Putt

Restaurants

Pub and Putt brings 9 creative indoor mini golf holes, rotating regional taps, craft cocktails, and legit pub eats under one roof in…

1215 2nd St S (Nampa)

Pub and Putt brings 9 creative indoor mini golf holes, rotating regional taps, craft cocktails, and legit pub eats under one roof in downtown Nampa. Rally the crew for laughs, friendly trash talk, and a rematch... then celebrate with pizza or a sandwich while you plot your comeback.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

1459 Caldwell Blvd (Nampa)

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Wheeler's Handout turns out juicy, hand-pattied burgers with fresh toppings, plus Idaho-approved fingersteaks, onion rings, and tacos…

215 Caldwell Blvd (Nampa)

Wheeler's Handout turns out juicy, hand-pattied burgers with fresh toppings, plus Idaho-approved fingersteaks, onion rings, and tacos wrapped in cheddar cheese shells with cilantro lime or jalapeño ranch. Hit the Wheeler Dealer or the ham-happy Wheeler Squealer and call it a weeknight win.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Holy Cow Idaho!

Restaurants

Whether you're craving a legit craft burger and a cold beer, Holy Cow Idaho! keeps it simple and stellar with locally sourced proteins,…

1226 1st St S (Nampa)

Whether you're craving a legit craft burger and a cold beer, Holy Cow Idaho! keeps it simple and stellar with locally sourced proteins, fresh seasonal produce, and brioche buns that mean business. Keep an eye out for rotating daily and beverage specials, then bring an appetite and a friend.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 4, 2026

Website ↗

Zullee | Mediterranean Grill is an easy Nampa win this week, with bold Mediterranean flavor in their Zullee Bowls, make-any-sandwich-a-wrap…

16383 N Marketplace Blvd (Nampa)

Zullee | Mediterranean Grill is an easy Nampa win this week, with bold Mediterranean flavor in their Zullee Bowls, make-any-sandwich-a-wrap freedom, and fresh, healthy dishes that actually taste fun.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 12, 2026

Website ↗

Brick 29

Restaurants

Brick 29 turns locally-grown ingredients into American comfort classics you actually brag about, served in an industrial-chic space that…

320 11th Ave S Suite#300 (Nampa)

Brick 29 turns locally-grown ingredients into American comfort classics you actually brag about, served in an industrial-chic space that feels like Nampa’s living room.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

2025 12th Ave Rd Ste 140 (Nampa)

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Casual, modern eatery serving spicy chicken tenders and sandwiches as well as mac 'n' cheese.

16365 N Marketplace Blvd (Nampa)

Casual, modern eatery serving spicy chicken tenders and sandwiches as well as mac 'n' cheese.

Website ↗

For nights when tacos are the only plan, Birreria El Semaforo nails meaty birria tacos, quesabirria, and birria pizza, all in a laid-back…

5830 E Franklin Rd (Nampa)

For nights when tacos are the only plan, Birreria El Semaforo nails meaty birria tacos, quesabirria, and birria pizza, all in a laid-back spot with a full bar. Easy local move when you want flavor that hits like a green light.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Roadhouse-style chain serving wings, burgers & hearty comfort-food plates, plus craft beers.

16250 N Marketplace Blvd (Nampa)

Roadhouse-style chain serving wings, burgers & hearty comfort-food plates, plus craft beers.

Website ↗

Mongolian BBQ

Restaurants

Load up a Little Kahn, Mighty Kahn, or Barbarian bowl at Mongolian BBQ, pack it with fresh-cut veggies, meats, and original sauces, then…

1123 Caldwell Blvd (Nampa)

Load up a Little Kahn, Mighty Kahn, or Barbarian bowl at Mongolian BBQ, pack it with fresh-cut veggies, meats, and original sauces, then watch it sizzle on the giant iron griddle. All you can eat, gluten free options, and perfect for post-commute hunger.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Italian To Go

Restaurants

Whether you're on a couch night or catching up with friends, Italian To Go nails the Nampa comfort-food itch with hot pizzas, saucy…

122 12th Ave S (Nampa) · ✓ checked Aug 20

Whether you're on a couch night or catching up with friends, Italian To Go nails the Nampa comfort-food itch with hot pizzas, saucy classics, and big cheesy energy. Order in when you don't want dishes, or pop in for a laid-back bite that tastes like a weeknight win.

From the Nampa newsletter, August 24, 2026

Website ↗

Craving something cozy and Idaho-grown? The Orchard House Restaurant folds Sunnyslope seasonality into hearty breakfasts and lunches, then…

14949 Sunny Slope Rd · ✓ checked Aug 4

Craving something cozy and Idaho-grown?

From the Caldwell newsletter, August 11, 2026

Website ↗

Burger Theory

Restaurants

Casual restaurant for burgers with a create-your-own option, plus wings, salads and beer.

16245 N Merchant Way (Nampa)

Casual restaurant for burgers with a create-your-own option, plus wings, salads and beer.

Website ↗

From half-pound burgers to pan-seared salmon and hand-cut finger steaks, JaK*s Place Neighborhood Grill goes big on from-scratch comfort.…

6026 Birch Ln (Nampa)

From half-pound burgers to pan-seared salmon and hand-cut finger steaks, JaK*s Place Neighborhood Grill goes big on from-scratch comfort. Think crispy onion rings, fried pickles and zucchini fries, then seal the deal with a beer, wine or cocktail this week.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

H&M BBQ

Restaurants

Since 1963, H&M BBQ has served Treasure Valley folks old-fashioned ribs, brisket, pulled pork, and chicken, all fueled by their in-house…

Entrance through the parking lot on 3rd st & 14th ave, 215 14th Ave S (Nampa)

Since 1963, H&M BBQ has served Treasure Valley folks old-fashioned ribs, brisket, pulled pork, and chicken, all fueled by their in-house meat shop for that extra legit flavor. Hosting a backyard hang this week, they’ll roll up with the mobile pit and make you look like a genius.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗

The Tower Grill

Restaurants

The Tower Grill is that easy weekend go to at Nampa Municipal Airport where mimosas meet propellers. Grab Huckleberry Crunch French Toast…

105 Municipal Dr (Nampa)

The Tower Grill is that easy weekend go to at Nampa Municipal Airport where mimosas meet propellers. Grab Huckleberry Crunch French Toast or tackle a burger named for a WWII icon while the kids watch takeoffs from the patio, all with genuinely friendly service and simple, local food.

From the Caldwell newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗

CHICKENBALL

Restaurants

If your meal routine needs a plot twist this week, Chickenball rolls out Asian-fusion balls of goodness like grilled or black spicy…

172 E Maine Ave (Nampa)

If your meal routine needs a plot twist this week, Chickenball rolls out Asian-fusion balls of goodness like grilled or black spicy chicken, tempura apple chicken, and tempura cod, all served with steamed rice and veggies. Add pot stickers or spring rolls and a mango or taro bubble tea, call it a day.

From the Nampa newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Soup Kettle Grille In Nampa keeps things cozy this week with scratch-made soups, seven bread-bowl options, and hearty grilled or crisp cold…

9809 W Sand Hill Dr #140 (Nampa)

Soup Kettle Grille In Nampa keeps things cozy this week with scratch-made soups, seven bread-bowl options, and hearty grilled or crisp cold sandwiches. They’ve also got espressos, boba milk tea, and a lineup of gluten-free, dairy-free, vegetarian and vegan eats...

From the Nampa newsletter, September 19, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →