Hunting for hidden gems, unique home finds, or stylish wardrobe staples doesn’t have to come with a hefty price tag in Carmel. From curated boutiques to community-driven spots, the area’s thrift stores offer treasures for every taste and budget.
Let’s get to it.
Hoosier Sister
At Hoosier Sister in Carmel, you’ll discover a blend of vintage charm and modern design curated by sisters Heidi Heldt and Gretchen Harter. Nestled in Suite 170 of the Clay Terrace outdoor mall, the shop feels open and inviting from the moment you step in. Seasonal vignettes rotate regularly…after October, you might spot a canoe draped in plaid, and by December, snowshoes nod to old-school winters.
Every item, from European antiques to subtly distressed furniture, is handpicked for quality and style. The in-house soy candle line changes scents each season, priced around $20 to $30 for a clean, headache-free fragrance. You’ll also find cozy throws, kitchen towels, bushel baskets, jewelry, and tableware that lean more “cool aunt” than traditional heirloom.
Inventory refreshes nearly every week, keeping the selection fresh. Prices sit in the mid-to-upper range, though holiday sales and Sip & Shop events offer chances to save. The clientele spans apartment dwellers to luxury homeowners, all seeking a statement piece. Note that the store stays closed on Mondays, but otherwise you can bring your dog, snap a selfie by the vintage Jeep Wagoneer, and even pay with Apple Pay.
Amanda’s Exchange
At Amanda’s Exchange, a relaxed indie atmosphere sets it apart from typical resale shops. Founded in 2002, this stand-alone location features a convenient parking lot and bright, organized interiors. Wide aisles and clear lighting replace the usual thrift-store chaos, making it easy to browse racks laid out like a boutique.
Sections include women’s, juniors’, kids’, and plus-size apparel, plus a dedicated room just for shoes. Behind the checkout counter, a wall of designer purses adds a touch of luxury without feeling out of reach. Everything is carefully vetted for cleanliness, brand quality, and wearability. Prices hit that sweet mid-range where impulse buys feel justified, and frequent specials, plus military discounts, sweeten the deal.
New arrivals appear daily, and quarterly “Amanda’s Market” events introduce small furniture, boutique jewelry, and other unexpected finds. Whether you’re hunting for a statement handbag or a gently used throw pillow, the ever-changing inventory makes each visit feel like a discovery.
Goodwill Store
The Goodwill Store in Carmel, Indiana manages to make bargain hunting feel surprisingly polished. Wide aisles eliminate cart traffic jams, while clear signage guides you through categories like men’s, women’s, and kids’ clothing, books, furniture, gadgets, and seasonal décor. You’ll even find a dedicated mug wall that invites a second glance.
Prices remain steady and reasonable, and occasional manager’s specials reward regular shoppers. The designer and vintage rack lives up to its reputation, and the clearance section sees brisk action. Fitting rooms are discreet but require a quick ask at customer service.
Restocking occurs every day, ensuring the selection never goes stale. Up front, a cozy book nook invites browsing before you check out. Donations are just as easy…drive up, drop off, and move on. If you need help loading a sofa or table, staff will lend a hand. Run by a nonprofit, the store operates with the efficiency of a big-box retailer but retains a relaxed, community-focused spirit.
The Velvet Plum Vintage & Consignments
Since October 2020, The Velvet Plum Vintage & Consignments on the Noblesville Square has combined family warmth with a clean, curated shopping experience. Aisles are wide and well-lit, with zones dedicated to glassware, throw pillows, furniture, and more. Displays feel intentional…no clutter or unexpected chair legs underfoot.
Pricing varies from wallet-friendly specials, like $6 store-owned pillows, to higher-end pieces such as unique antique cabinets. New arrivals show up almost every day, and staff frequently share highlights on social media. The owners often provide backstories for distinctive items, adding a genuine personal touch rather than a sales pitch.
Community engagement is part of the charm, with the store supporting local charities and offering estate cleanout services. There’s no electronics or appliance section, so shoppers stay focused on quality home goods with real character. For anyone seeking well-maintained, distinctive pieces, The Velvet Plum delivers every time.
Grace Thrift Store
Grace Thrift Store, located inside Grace Church’s Grace Care Center in Noblesville, delivers boutique-style thrift shopping without the clutter. Volunteers sort men’s, women’s, children’s, and baby clothes by size and category, plus shoes and accessories. Aisles remain tidy and easy to navigate, with home goods like wall décor, lamps, and kitchenware displayed clearly.
The shop avoids oversized furniture, keeping the floor space manageable and friendly. Prices align with classic thrift expectations, and every item is clean and in working order—no mystery stains or broken gadgets. All proceeds support the Grace Care Center and its on-site food pantry, so your purchase directly benefits the community.
You can shop most days in person or browse online. Note that the store closes Thursday through Saturday. Whether you’re outfitting a home or picking up essentials, Grace Thrift Store balances affordability, quality, and a mission-driven purpose seamlessly.
Society of St. Vincent de Paul -NobleCause
When you enter Society of St. Vincent de Paul -NobleCause in Noblesville, the first thing you notice is a bright, tidy thrift store where every rack has its place. Clothing and shoes are sorted by size and style, and a fitting room stands ready for trying on Chico’s pants or a Coldwater Creek top. Larger items like that surprise sofa rest outside the entrance, so you don’t have to search through the store to find furniture.
Inside, a well-lit children’s book nook features Scholastic titles for just twenty-five cents each. Volunteers restock daily, so the selection stays fresh, and regular discounts plus clearance sections keep prices low. All proceeds directly support the local food pantry, making every purchase count. Located on Greenfield Avenue, this independent shop isn’t part of a chain. They accept only clean, gently used donations—no mystery boxes or items in disrepair. Shoppers range from budget-wise families to thrifty treasure hunters, all finding quality items without paying full price.
Plato’s Closet
Inside Plato’s Closet, merchandise resembles a boutique more than a resale rack. Bright overhead lights illuminate color-coordinated sections filled with women’s jeans, sneakers, handbags, and athletic wear. A special rack highlights brands such as Nike, Lululemon, and Michael Kors. Racks stay neat and free of stains, so you can focus on picking out items rather than dodging spots.
New arrivals appear daily, and regular prices hover around fifty percent off original retail. Clearance areas offer even deeper discounts, and “Dollar Days” promotions make budget shopping a breeze. Although most products target teen and twenty-something women, about twenty percent of the store caters to men, featuring current trends and mall staples from the past year or two. Fitting rooms are available, and consistent store hours make planning easy. The atmosphere combines a franchise’s reliability with an independent shop’s character, providing on-trend brands without full retail price tags.
Clothes Mentor Fishers, IN
Clothes Mentor in Fishers, Indiana combines local ownership with a polished thrift experience. Rows of clothing are neatly organized by type and size, making it easy to browse petite, maternity, athletic wear, or find that perfect plus-size summer dress. Spacious racks prevent the usual hanger congestion and simplify each search.
Variety is a priority: you’ll find daily restocks of dresses, tops, and jewelry, plus a front wall showcasing designer purses from Coach and Louis Vuitton. A dedicated BOHO section features Free People styles that often attract weekend shoppers. Prices run up to seventy percent off retail, with “Sundaze” promotions and luxury bag sales adding extra savings. If you bring in like-new items, you can receive instant cash casually and benefit from free authentication on high-end pieces. The store offers ample parking, wheelchair access, and a loyalty program for regular visitors. For anyone seeking designer labels on a budget or a fresh selection each week, this shop delivers a refined secondhand shopping experience.
Wheeler Mission Donation Center
Wheeler Mission Donation Center serves as a convenient drop-off hub for items destined to support people experiencing homelessness. Clean and functional donations—ranging from gently used sofas, books, and bicycles to boxes of clothing—are accepted at the main Madison Avenue location Monday through Friday. If a longer drive isn’t possible, 24-hour drop-off barns stand ready in church parking lots from Indianapolis to Carmel.
Staff and volunteers sort through every donation to remove items that require repair or pose safety risks. Approved goods move on to the Fishers thrift store, where inventory is refreshed frequently. Furniture pick-up makes it easy to clear out larger pieces, and car donations are welcome year-round. Every sale funnels back into shelter operations, recovery programs, and community outreach efforts. This organized system ensures your unwanted items become vital resources, all while supporting Indiana’s largest network for people facing homelessness.
