The best restaurants in Delaware County

38 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

38 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Delaware County's page when you're in Delaware County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

J's Dairy Inn (opens in a new tab)

207 W Union St · Liberty

J’s Dairy Inn cooks every order to order, so your meal is made fresh rather than rushed. If you’re hungry for a classic American restaurant…

J’s Dairy Inn cooks every order to order, so your meal is made fresh rather than rushed. If you’re hungry for a classic American restaurant stop, it’s a local spot to keep in mind, just call ahead or give your order a little time.

From the Connersville newsletter, October 26, 2026

EL Reparo Mexican Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

9 N Main St · Liberty

Family-owned El Reparo Mexican Restaurant is a clutch local pick when you want easy crowd-pleasing Mexican and space to actually sit…

Family-owned El Reparo Mexican Restaurant is a clutch local pick when you want easy crowd-pleasing Mexican and space to actually sit together. They’ve got a banquet room that converts into a patio, full-menu catering, and online ordering for those nights you’d rather keep it cozy at home.

From the Connersville newsletter, October 12, 2026

Liberty Bell Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

215 S Main St · Liberty

Liberty Bell Restaurant keeps it simple and satisfying with pressure-fried chicken, chicken and dumplings, beef and noodles, pizza, and…

Liberty Bell Restaurant keeps it simple and satisfying with pressure-fried chicken, chicken and dumplings, beef and noodles, pizza, and breakfast all day. If Friday perch or a burrito mood hits, they’ve got you, and the seniors and kids menus make weeknights easy.

From the Connersville newsletter, October 23, 2026

By Hand and Fork (opens in a new tab)

1617 Wheeling Ave · Muncie

By Hand and Fork nails the breakfast-to-lunch sweet spot with perfectly crafted omelets, decadent French toast, and classic egg dishes that…

By Hand and Fork nails the breakfast-to-lunch sweet spot with perfectly crafted omelets, decadent French toast, and classic egg dishes that taste like a slow Saturday. Their Mimosa service keeps things festive, so grab a friend and make a quick, delicious escape this week.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 25, 2026

1925 PubHouse Courtyard (opens in a new tab)

625 S High St · Muncie

1925 PubHouse Courtyard turns out creative burgers, a proper breaded tenderloin, and legit steaks alongside plenty of craft beer and…

1925 PubHouse Courtyard turns out creative burgers, a proper breaded tenderloin, and legit steaks alongside plenty of craft beer and cocktails that don't phone it in. It’s the kind of reliable local hang where weeknight dinners, online orders, and even catered celebrations just... work.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 16, 2026

Steak City Fish & Chicken (opens in a new tab)

1428 S Walnut St · Muncie

Steak City Fish & Chicken serves up crispy fried fish, juicy chicken, wings, tenders, and combo meals, with generous portions that make…

Steak City Fish & Chicken serves up crispy fried fish, juicy chicken, wings, tenders, and combo meals, with generous portions that make choosing just one thing a challenge. It’s a satisfying local option when the usual fast-food routine needs a shake-up.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 6, 2026

Sunrise Breakfast (opens in a new tab)

3124 N Granville Ave · Muncie

Sunrise Breakfast is dishing out comfort classics that hit like a hug, from biscuits and gravy and Popeye omelets to hearty skillets, berry…

Sunrise Breakfast is dishing out comfort classics that hit like a hug, from biscuits and gravy and Popeye omelets to hearty skillets, berry pancakes, and their signature churro waffles. When your day needs a jumpstart this week, this is the kind of plate that makes errands feel optional.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 1, 2026

Adams Street Chophouse (opens in a new tab)

617 E Adams St · Muncie

Adams Street Chophouse serves USDA Prime steaks with wine, beer, and era-authentic cocktails in a prohibition-era setting inside the…

Adams Street Chophouse serves USDA Prime steaks with wine, beer, and era-authentic cocktails in a prohibition-era setting inside the historic Thomas S. Neely House. Grab a table in the Frank Sinatra or Rat Pack rooms, then slip into the 21+ speakeasy...

From the Muncie newsletter, November 13, 2026

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders (opens in a new tab)

4116 W Bethel Ave · Muncie

Pizza & Italian sandwiches in a laid-back, seat-yourself setting with retro signs lining the walls.

Pizza & Italian sandwiches in a laid-back, seat-yourself setting with retro signs lining the walls.

Roots Burger Bar (opens in a new tab)

1700 W University Ave · Muncie

Roots Burger Bar leans into Indiana’s thin, smashed-burger tradition with crispy-edged patties, saucy wings, and fries that don’t exactly…

Roots Burger Bar leans into Indiana’s thin, smashed-burger tradition with crispy-edged patties, saucy wings, and fries that don’t exactly practice restraint. It’s the kind of place you claim as your regular, with community vibes, easy carryout, and a kids’ menu that keeps family dinners sane.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 20, 2026

Puerto Vallarta Mexican Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

3901 N Broadway Ave · Muncie

Craving something bright and legit, Puerto Vallarta Mexican Restaurant brings the fiesta with Fajita Piña, crispy chimichangas, and tortas…

Craving something bright and legit, Puerto Vallarta Mexican Restaurant brings the fiesta with Fajita Piña, crispy chimichangas, and tortas that hit the spot, plus cantaritos and strawberry margaritas when you deserve a sip.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 30, 2026

Cheers (opens in a new tab)

3823 N Broadway Ave · Muncie

Laid-back venue for comfort eats, beer and cocktails, plus karaoke and sports TV.

Laid-back venue for comfort eats, beer and cocktails, plus karaoke and sports TV.

Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson (opens in a new tab)

508 S Tillotson Ave · Muncie

Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson brings vibrant, authentic Mexican flavors to your week, from Fajita Piña and chimichangas to a Cantarito or…

Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson brings vibrant, authentic Mexican flavors to your week, from Fajita Piña and chimichangas to a Cantarito or strawberry margarita that basically tastes like sunshine. It’s festive without the fuss, perfect when you want big flavor and zero decision fatigue.

From the Delaware County newsletter, November 22, 2026

Salsa’s Mexican Grill Express (opens in a new tab)

2421 S Madison St · Muncie

When your taco craving hits, Salsa’s Mexican Grill Express keeps it simple with tacos, burritos, and other Mexican favorites, plus…

When your taco craving hits, Salsa’s Mexican Grill Express keeps it simple with tacos, burritos, and other Mexican favorites, plus margaritas that do the job. Casual, quick, and reliably tasty, it’s an easy Muncie standby for weeknights, game nights, or whenever you forgot to defrost dinner.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 2, 2026

Cousin Vinny's Pizza (opens in a new tab)

1513 W McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Cousin Vinny’s Pizza pairs east-coast-style pies made with homemade dough, rich tomato sauce, and 100% mozzarella with gourmet toppings,…

Cousin Vinny’s Pizza pairs east-coast-style pies made with homemade dough, rich tomato sauce, and 100% mozzarella with gourmet toppings, sandwiches, pasta, calzones, wings, and more. It’s a laid-back pick for Muncie locals when a classic slice sounds good, or when the table can’t agree on just one thing.

From the Delaware County newsletter, November 16, 2026

BAYLEAF Indian Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

1529 W University Ave · Muncie

Bayleaf Indian Restaurant nails the comfort-crave sweet spot with fragrant biryanis, kathi rolls, and Indo Chinese favorites, plus solid…

Bayleaf Indian Restaurant nails the comfort-crave sweet spot with fragrant biryanis, kathi rolls, and Indo Chinese favorites, plus solid tandoor and plenty of veg or vegan options. Keep it low-key with takeaway or delivery, or call them for outdoor catering when your backyard suddenly becomes a party.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 22, 2026

Pizza King (opens in a new tab)

2905 E Jackson St · Muncie

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Honey Beez Pancake House (opens in a new tab)

700 S Tillotson Ave · Muncie

Craving something beyond the usual bacon-and-eggs routine? Honey Beez Pancake House is serving carrot waffles, cherry crepes, cinnamon…

Checked Oct 24

Craving something beyond the usual bacon-and-eggs routine? Honey Beez Pancake House is serving carrot waffles, cherry crepes, cinnamon rolls, Mediterranean skillets, stuffed French toast, even tenderloins, all with that cozy, friendly vibe you want on a slow morning... perfect for a Sunday brunch reset.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 31, 2026

Lahody Meats (opens in a new tab)

1308 Wheeling Ave · Muncie

Whether you’re grilling this week or just craving a legit deli lunch, Lahody Meats has you covered with fresh-cut steaks from folks who cut…

Whether you’re grilling this week or just craving a legit deli lunch, Lahody Meats has you covered with fresh-cut steaks from folks who cut hundreds every month, plus made-to-order sandwiches and a deli case full of party-tray favorites like stuffed mushrooms and broccoli salad. Treat yourself to the good stuff.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 29, 2026

Madison Street Cafe (opens in a new tab)

2323 S Madison St · Muncie

Family-owned and wonderfully unfussy, Madison Street Cafe serves the kind of homestyle breakfast, brunch, and lunch that feels like a…

Family-owned and wonderfully unfussy, Madison Street Cafe serves the kind of homestyle breakfast, brunch, and lunch that feels like a weekend at grandma's, minus the chore chart. Comfort classics and a welcoming vibe make it the kind of spot locals drift into once, then keep coming back.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 5, 2026

Amazing Joe's Grill (opens in a new tab)

5193 N Walnut St · Muncie

Amazing Joe's Grill is that no-pretense local standby for American comfort done right, powered by their "The answer is YES" spirit. When…

Amazing Joe's Grill is that no-pretense local standby for American comfort done right, powered by their "The answer is YES" spirit. When you want a solid, diverse menu without the fuss, this is an easy pick for weeknights, catch ups, and those I-can't-deal-with-cooking nights.

From the Delaware County newsletter, November 20, 2026

Pizza King (opens in a new tab)

109 E McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Ruby Tuesday (opens in a new tab)

1901 W McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Casual chain with American fare, featuring burgers, a salad bar, cocktails & a convivial vibe.

Casual chain with American fare, featuring burgers, a salad bar, cocktails & a convivial vibe.

Wingstop (opens in a new tab)

837 S Tillotson Ave #6 · Muncie

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

12th Street Cafe (opens in a new tab)

1900 S Mock Ave · Muncie

For eggs, biscuits, waffles, and other diner staples, 12th Street Cafe is an easy pick when you’re craving a hearty breakfast, lunch, or…

For eggs, biscuits, waffles, and other diner staples, 12th Street Cafe is an easy pick when you’re craving a hearty breakfast, lunch, or dinner. It’s the sort of place where comfort food does the talking, and nobody’s judging if you order waffles at dinnertime.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 9, 2026

Bird's Smokehouse BBQ (opens in a new tab)

9008 S Walnut St · Daleville

Bird's Smokehouse BBQ brings the kind of Southern cookin’ that makes weeknights feel like a backyard party, no cleanup required. Stick it…

Bird's Smokehouse BBQ brings the kind of Southern cookin’ that makes weeknights feel like a backyard party, no cleanup required. Stick it in your rotation for tailgates and birthdays too, with catering at the ready and legit bragging rights from Muncie Ribfest and Best of Madison County.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 7, 2026

Buffalo Wild Wings (opens in a new tab)

838 E McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

Timbers Lounge (opens in a new tab)

2770 W Kilgore Ave · Muncie

Timbers Lounge has been a Muncie staple for over 30 years for a reason. Think made-to-order breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the steak locals…

Timbers Lounge has been a Muncie staple for over 30 years for a reason. Think made-to-order breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the steak locals voted best, plus a friendly hangout vibe and a full bar, including the best mezcal selection in town. Treat yourself this week.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 19, 2026

Pizza King (opens in a new tab)

1421 W Bethel Ave · Muncie

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

Sunshine Cafe (opens in a new tab)

3113 N Oakwood Ave · Muncie

When you want a low-key spot that nails the classics, Sunshine Cafe Muncie serves breakfast all day, hearty lunches, and home-style dinners…

Checked Oct 23

When you want a low-key spot that nails the classics, Sunshine Cafe Muncie serves breakfast all day, hearty lunches, and home-style dinners that taste like your neighbor's best potluck. Watch for rotating midweek specials like ham and beans or Swiss steak... the kind of plates that make errands feel rewarded.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 26, 2026

Cammack Station (opens in a new tab)

9200 W Jackson St · Muncie

Craving a simpler-time reset? Cammack Station serves made-to-order, one-of-a-kind burgers, old-fashioned sandwiches, and the kind of creamy…

Craving a simpler-time reset? Cammack Station serves made-to-order, one-of-a-kind burgers, old-fashioned sandwiches, and the kind of creamy ice cream, milkshakes, and sundaes that make weeknights feel like summer. Go for the vintage gas-station vibe and stay for the food that actually lives up to the stories.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 21, 2026

Fuji Sushi & Hibachi (opens in a new tab)

1705 W McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Fuji Sushi & Hibachi brings hand-rolled sushi, hearty seafood soup, and crowd-pleasing hibachi dishes to Muncie, with kid-friendly options…

Fuji Sushi & Hibachi brings hand-rolled sushi, hearty seafood soup, and crowd-pleasing hibachi dishes to Muncie, with kid-friendly options and treats like mochi ice cream and crème brûlée. A handy pick when your table can’t agree on one kind of Japanese comfort food.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 15, 2026

La Glorieta (opens in a new tab)

1307 S Batavia Ave · Muncie

La Glorieta keeps it simple and tasty with pollo tacos, crispy taquitos dorados, asada burritos, a legit cabeza torta, and pozole that hits…

La Glorieta keeps it simple and tasty with pollo tacos, crispy taquitos dorados, asada burritos, a legit cabeza torta, and pozole that hits the spot. Order online when the day gets busy, then enjoy fresh, no-fuss Mexican comfort that won’t overcomplicate your evening.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 22, 2026

Wings Etc. (opens in a new tab)

1401 W McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

Fazoli's (opens in a new tab)

307 E McGalliard Rd · Muncie

Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.

Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.

Old Town Root Beer Stand (opens in a new tab)

1917 W Memorial Dr · Muncie

Old Town Root Beer Stand pairs classic American comfort food, including Nathan’s Famous hot dogs, juicy burgers and frosty root beer…

Old Town Root Beer Stand pairs classic American comfort food, including Nathan’s Famous hot dogs, juicy burgers and frosty root beer floats, with newer favorites like bubble tea and lemon shake-ups.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 8, 2026

Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co (opens in a new tab)

1231 S Walnut St · Muncie

Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co keeps it simple and right, with fresh-made sliders, crispy fries, and a special sauce that mysteriously…

Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co keeps it simple and right, with fresh-made sliders, crispy fries, and a special sauce that mysteriously disappears fast. Family-friendly, locally loved, and easy online pickup when you just need a quick win between errands or practice.

From the Muncie newsletter, October 24, 2026

Puerto Vallarta (opens in a new tab)

3505 Wheeling Ave · Muncie

If you want a laid back, time-tested spot that nails the classics, Puerto Vallarta delivers with sizzling Fajita Piña, craveworthy…

If you want a laid back, time-tested spot that nails the classics, Puerto Vallarta delivers with sizzling Fajita Piña, craveworthy chimichangas, and icy strawberry margaritas. Multiple Muncie spots make it an easy weeknight go-to, and the cantarito or classic limonada keep things bright.

From the Muncie newsletter, November 19, 2026