The best bakeries & sweet shops in Floyd County

4 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

4 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Floyd County's page when you're in Floyd County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Uncommon Cups and Cones (opens in a new tab)

518 Vincennes St · New Albany

Uncommon Cups and Cones is that cozy, antique-filled spot doing super-premium hand-dipped ice cream in charming teacups or classic cones,…

Uncommon Cups and Cones is that cozy, antique-filled spot doing super-premium hand-dipped ice cream in charming teacups or classic cones, with playful picks like Exhausted Parent and Zanzibar Chocolate, plus flights, ice cream nachos, and dairy-free vegan options when your crew can’t agree.

From the New Albany newsletter, October 29, 2026

Cultivated Table and Sip House (opens in a new tab)

133 E Market St · New Albany

Locally roasted coffee, from-scratch soups and sandwiches, and house sourdough make Cultivated Table and Sip House a go-to in downtown New…

Locally roasted coffee, from-scratch soups and sandwiches, and house sourdough make Cultivated Table and Sip House a go-to in downtown New Albany when you want something nourishing without the fuss. Pro tip, grab a miso-browned butter chocolate chip cookie and browse their handpicked pottery and books between bites.

From the New Albany newsletter, November 13, 2026

Rookies Cookies (opens in a new tab)

310 Pearl St · New Albany

Rookies Cookies has been baking in New Albany since 1939, and their melt-in-your-mouth Rookie’s Cookies butter wafers are the kind of…

Rookies Cookies has been baking in New Albany since 1939, and their melt-in-your-mouth Rookie’s Cookies butter wafers are the kind of tradition locals quietly hoard, while the custom wedding and birthday cakes are baked fresh to order, designed to match your vibe.

From the New Albany newsletter, October 26, 2026

Sweet Stuff Bakery (opens in a new tab)

323 E Spring St · New Albany

Family-owned since 1986, Sweet Stuff Bakery is the place locals call when birthday, shower, or wedding plans require a showstopper, from…

Family-owned since 1986, Sweet Stuff Bakery is the place locals call when birthday, shower, or wedding plans require a showstopper, from custom cakes that match your napkins to trays of cookies, donuts, pies, and cheesecakes. Go for the design skills, stay for the legitimately delicious butter-and-sugar payoff.

From the New Albany newsletter, November 18, 2026