The best bakeries & sweet shops in Jeffersonville

“Longtime ice cream parlor chain serving small-batch scoops, plus signature sundaes & frozen drinks.”

“Longtime chain serving a variety of donut flavors & shapes, plus coffee & frozen drinks.”

“Whether your night calls for a slice or a scoop, The Pie Kitchen is the reliable local sugar fix with housemade pies, custom cakes, and classic ice cream. Pro tip, snag their signature Cheesecake 'N' A Cup or call in a birthday cake when celebrations sneak up.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 15, 2026

“Uncommon Cups and Cones is that cozy, antique-filled spot doing super-premium hand-dipped ice cream in charming teacups or classic cones, with playful picks like Exhausted Parent and Zanzibar Chocolate, plus flights, ice cream nachos, and dairy-free vegan options when your crew can’t agree.”

From the New Albany newsletter, September 4, 2026

“Legacy Pizza & Bakery turns out hand-tossed pies, real East Coast stromboli, calzones, subs, and fresh-baked breads and sweets, all made in Uptown New Albany since 2020. When you want crust with character and a loaf that disappears before dinner, this neighborhood spot is an easy yes.”

From the New Albany newsletter, September 15, 2026

“Rookies Cookies has been baking in New Albany since 1939, and their melt-in-your-mouth Rookie’s Cookies butter wafers are the kind of tradition locals quietly hoard, while the custom wedding and birthday cakes are baked fresh to order, designed to match your vibe.”

From the New Albany newsletter, September 28, 2026

“Family-owned since 1986, Sweet Stuff Bakery is the place locals call when birthday, shower, or wedding plans require a showstopper, from custom cakes that match your napkins to trays of cookies, donuts, pies, and cheesecakes. Go for the design skills, stay for the legitimately delicious butter-and-sugar payoff.”

From the New Albany newsletter, September 22, 2026

“Bakery specializing in gluten-free French macarons in unique flavors such as Earl Grey, pistachio, and caramel.”

“Adrienne and Company is that reliable Jeffersonville go-to when you need fresh donuts in the morning, a sneaky noon cupcake, or a showstopper custom cake. Family craft shows up in everything from maple bacon fritters to the Monster Cake, and yes, they’ve got wedding cakes worth bragging about.”

From the New Albany newsletter, September 8, 2026

“From birthday flex to just-because sugar rush, Sweets by Morgan turns your ideas into custom cakes, cupcakes, and cookies that taste as good as they look. Perfect for weeknight office heroics or the kiddo’s big day, with designs that make your table look instantly more fun.”

From the Jeffersonville newsletter, September 23, 2026

“Louisville Cream churns small-batch scoops with local JD Country Milk, house-made jams and mix-ins, and a rotating cast of creative, sometimes vegan, seasonal flavors. It’s the kind of spot you hit after dinner in NuLu or when you need a pint from local groceries to survive Sunday chores.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 3, 2026

“Bakery offering Scandinavian-style breads, pastries, and other baked goods, plus a gift shop.”

“Ice-cream shop in a charming Victorian building offering sundaes, light snacks & bicycle rentals.”

“Craving the real deal? Ehrler's Ice Cream has been a Louisville tradition since 1867 and still nails the classics while sneaking in joys like rich fudgy brownies, bourbon balls, super-sized ice cream sandwiches, and ice cream cakes, plus easy catering if you’re plotting a backyard sundae takeover.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 12, 2026

“Quick-serve joint dishing up ice cream such as sundaes and milkshakes, plus chili dogs.”

“Chillers keeps it simple in the best way, slinging cones, sundaes, shakes, and even hot dogs from a low-key take-out window right here in Jeffersonville. When the Strawberry Shortcake Sundae shows up for warm weather, just go... then decide whether you're a spoon, straw, or tongue person.”

From the Jeffersonville newsletter, September 26, 2026

“Art Eatables is a family-owned chocolatier turning Kentucky’s favorite pour into small-batch magic. Their bourbon-infused and bourbon-themed candies and truffles hit that sweet spot between local pride and real flavor, perfect for a midweek pick-me-up or a gift that says I actually thought about this.”

From the Louisville newsletter, August 7, 2026

“From donuts and Danish to kuchen and coffee cakes, Plehn's Bakery has been keeping Louisville happily sugared since 1924. This week, grab a birthday hero or a simple Friday pick-me-up... custom cakes, seasonal iced cookies, fresh breads, and a legit deli with homemade ice cream.”

From the Louisville newsletter, August 3, 2026

“Secret Recipe is the grab-and-go bakery for when you need a quick macaron fix or a slice of decadent cheesecake, and if you catch the hint of footprints, follow them to Sole, the tucked-away 1920s-inspired speakeasy where craft cocktails meet thoughtfully paired desserts.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 28, 2026

“Whether you’re craving banana pudding vibes, a brownie-bottom situation, or that Strawberry Crunch nostalgia, Big Nita’s Cheesecakes keeps the slices wild and the cheesecake-stuffed cookies dangerously snackable.”

From the Louisville newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Since 1891, Schimpff's Confectionery has been cranking out Cinnamon Red Hots, hand-dipped chocolates, and caramel-kissed Modjeskas, plus a 50s soda fountain and a candy museum packed with nostalgia. Pop in this week to watch live candy making on century-old gear and leave grinning like a kid.”

From the Jeffersonville newsletter, September 16, 2026

“Whether your week needs flaky croissants, jewel-box tarts, or a macaron mood reset, La Pâtisserie Française delivers true French pastry plus legit sandwiches, quiche, and weekend brunch. Bonus temptation, their chocolate counter and daily breads make it dangerously easy to upgrade breakfast, lunch, or that 3 pm slump.”

From the Louisville newsletter, August 17, 2026

“Sweets by Millie is the compact Louisville bakeshop locals lean on for made-to-order cakes, cupcakes, and cookies, from elegant wedding tiers to quirky specialty designs. Order ahead when the calendar fills up and let them handle the delicious part of your birthday, shower, or office celebration.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 9, 2026

“Retailer offering housemade fudge, plus pralines, caramel apples & other sweet treats.”

“Chic, minimalist storefront features vegan sandwiches & bowls plus baked goods & sweets.”

“The Pie Kitchen keeps it classic with pies, creamy ice cream, cakes, cookies, and that dangerously snackable Cheesecake 'n' a Cup. Swing by for a slice now, stash a Grab 'N Go treat for later, and keep their catering in mind when dessert duty calls.”

From the Louisville newsletter, August 12, 2026

“Shelves of colorful treats including chocolates and sodas plus a friendly staff.”

“Corner bakeshop crafting made-to-order wedding cakes, donuts & other confections in snug confines.”

“Your reliable spot when you want something genuinely good, Wiltshire Pantry Bakery and Café - Highlands turns out baked goods and café bites, and their catering arm makes hosting painless with sample menus spanning appetizers, salads and sides, entrees, box lunches, bar services and even venue options.”

From the Louisville newsletter, September 5, 2026