The best cafes in Johnson County

7 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

7 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Johnson County's page when you're in Johnson County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Sassafras Lunch & Tea Room (opens in a new tab)

229 N Madison Ave · Greenwood

Sassafras Lunch & Tea Room makes an ordinary lunch feel delightfully fancy, with English tea service, scones, finger sandwiches, and…

Sassafras Lunch & Tea Room makes an ordinary lunch feel delightfully fancy, with English tea service, scones, finger sandwiches, and treats, alongside soups, salads, and café favorites. A cozy spot to slow down and sip from a proper teacup, because your mug at home just doesn’t have the same dramatic flair.

From the Greenwood newsletter, November 18, 2026

BIGGBY COFFEE (opens in a new tab)

156 S Marlin Dr · Greenwood

BIGGBY COFFEE serves a wide-ranging lineup, from lattes and sweet-foam cold brew to tea lattes, smoothies, and hot chocolate, plus muffins…

BIGGBY COFFEE serves a wide-ranging lineup, from lattes and sweet-foam cold brew to tea lattes, smoothies, and hot chocolate, plus muffins and Bragels for a snack. It’s a handy Greenwood pick when your coffee order needs a little fun, or you want something tasty to go with it.

From the Greenwood newsletter, November 12, 2026

The Local Grind (opens in a new tab)

25 N Main St · Franklin

The Local Grind brings a pop up coffee shop to your event, proudly serving Indiana so your team, club, or neighborhood can skip the coffee…

The Local Grind brings a pop up coffee shop to your event, proudly serving Indiana so your team, club, or neighborhood can skip the coffee run and still get the good stuff, right here in Columbus when you need an easy caffeine win.

From the Columbus newsletter, October 21, 2026

1823 Bakehouse (opens in a new tab)

25 E Court St Ste a · Franklin

1823 Bakehouse is a 100% gluten-free cafe with a full breakfast and lunch menu plus made-from-scratch desserts that don’t taste like a…

1823 Bakehouse is a 100% gluten-free cafe with a full breakfast and lunch menu plus made-from-scratch desserts that don’t taste like a compromise. Order online for quick delivery, or let them cater your next get-together... because everyone deserves dessert.

From the Johnson County newsletter, November 10, 2026

Coffeehouse Five (opens in a new tab)

41 W Monroe St · Franklin

Coffeehouse Five brews the good stuff and backs it up with a For-Benefit mission that funds free premarital and marriage counseling,…

Coffeehouse Five brews the good stuff and backs it up with a For-Benefit mission that funds free premarital and marriage counseling, addiction recovery, mentor training, and broader mental health support.

From the Johnson County newsletter, November 19, 2026

Strange Brew (opens in a new tab)

4800 Smith Valley Rd · Greenwood

Since 2004, Strange Brew has been Greenwood’s cozy go-to for properly pulled espresso, iced lattes that actually taste like coffee, and…

Since 2004, Strange Brew has been Greenwood’s cozy go-to for properly pulled espresso, iced lattes that actually taste like coffee, and fresh-roasted beans you can take home. Swing by this week for a mood lift, then snag a bag and keep the good vibes brewing.

From the Greenwood newsletter, October 29, 2026

Coffeehouse Five (opens in a new tab)

10 Plummer Ave · Bargersville

Need a pick-me-up with purpose? Coffeehouse Five pours seriously good coffee and food, and as a for-benefit coffeehouse their profits fuel…

Need a pick-me-up with purpose? Coffeehouse Five pours seriously good coffee and food, and as a for-benefit coffeehouse their profits fuel free counseling, recovery programs, and mentor training. Sign up for a Latte Art or Roasting Room experience this week, then bring those skills to your home brews.

From the Bloomington newsletter, August 21, 2026