The best restaurants in Holyoke

10 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Holyoke’s best · Beauty · Nightlife · Home & Garden · Shopping

Pinned in Holyoke today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Holyoke — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 10 places · showing the latest additions first

Nick's Nest in Holyoke

Restaurants

Casual, 1927 place boasting a menu focused on hot dogs, along with milkshakes, desserts, baked beans and fries.

1597 Northampton St #2

“Casual, 1927 place boasting a menu focused on hot dogs, along with milkshakes, desserts, baked beans and fries.”

Website ↗

El Guanaco

Restaurants

Casual eatery offering burritos and tacos for dine-in or takeout, plus margaritas.

50 Lamb St (South Hadley)

“Casual eatery offering burritos and tacos for dine-in or takeout, plus margaritas.”

Website ↗

Amedeo's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Restaurants

Italian & American dishes, such as pizza, pasta & grinders, served in a comfy space or for takeout.

8 N Bridge St

“Italian & American dishes, such as pizza, pasta & grinders, served in a comfy space or for takeout.”

Website ↗

Holyoke Pizza

Restaurants

Pizzeria dishing up comfort food, including halal options, in a relaxed setting.

213 South St

“Pizzeria dishing up comfort food, including halal options, in a relaxed setting.”

Website ↗

Run a Holyoke business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Capri Pizza

Restaurants

Unpretentious brick-lined joint dishes up thin-crust pies, grinders & other pizzeria staples.

18 Cabot St

“Unpretentious brick-lined joint dishes up thin-crust pies, grinders & other pizzeria staples.”

Website ↗

Mitchell's Public House

Restaurants

Casual, counter-service restaurant offering breakfast, quick bites, beer, and cocktails.

490 Pleasant St

“Casual, counter-service restaurant offering breakfast, quick bites, beer, and cocktails.”

Website ↗

Al's Diner

Restaurants

Nostalgic cash-only breakfast joint serving eggs, pancakes & meat pies in a familiar atmosphere.

14 Yelle St (Chicopee)

“Nostalgic cash-only breakfast joint serving eggs, pancakes & meat pies in a familiar atmosphere.”

Website ↗

El Paraiso Colombiano | Restaurant and Bar

Restaurants

Casual, family-owned, Colombian eatery serving plantains, arepas, empanadas, steaks and platters.

351 High St

“Casual, family-owned, Colombian eatery serving plantains, arepas, empanadas, steaks and platters.”

Website ↗

D'Angelo Grilled Sandwiches

Restaurants

Branch of a sandwich shop chain offering subs, wraps & salads, plus rice & grain bowls.

2175 Northampton St

“Branch of a sandwich shop chain offering subs, wraps & salads, plus rice & grain bowls.”

Website ↗

Pic’s Pub and Pizzeria

Restaurants

Casual bar, eatery and beer garden featuring pizzas, wings, burgers, haddock and steaks.

910 Hampden St

“Casual bar, eatery and beer garden featuring pizzas, wings, burgers, haddock and steaks.”

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →