The best cafes in Plymouth

Cafe Monte Alto roasts single origin, direct trade, shade grown, hand picked 100% Peruvian coffees, from the San Crispin espresso blend out of Villa Rica to limited-release Geisha and Peaberry. It's a reliable Plymouth pick for a smooth cup that tastes like someone actually cared.

From the Plymouth newsletter, October 13, 2026

Family owned and operated, Water Street Cafe keeps Laconia fueled with rotating weekly specials, fresh-ground coffee, and craveable staples like bennies (yes, even lobster), chicken and waffles, and heftier burgers for the late risers. If the coffee needs backup, their Bloody Marys and mimosas happily report for duty.

From the Tilton newsletter, October 14, 2026

Pure & Brave Coffee keeps things cozy with a lineup that ranges from bold Venezuela and Catatumbo to a Mexico Decaf that won’t keep you up. Tea fans aren’t left out either, and you can snag bags for home so tomorrow’s cup doesn’t depend on luck.

From the Plymouth newsletter, October 7, 2026

When you want something bright, filling, and fresh, The Natural Pickle turns out organic salads, hearty wraps, comforting soups, and plenty of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Feels like you cooked at home, only quicker, and easy on the wallet.

From the Tilton newsletter, October 5, 2026

Locally owned Verdi Caffetteria is pouring fresh, flavorful coffee, rich chocolate, bright teas and natural fruit juices, with Italian and Latin American ingredients showing up in the cup and on the plate.

From the Gilford newsletter, October 7, 2026

Gusto Italian Café in nearby Center Harbor leans into its Tuscan roots with daily baked, spongy focaccia piled into authentic panini, a juice menu, and even dinner. Owners Elena and Nick met on a train in Florence while he crocheted, which tells you everything about the vibe.

From the Plymouth newsletter, October 24, 2026

Whether it's a pre-commute caffeine fix, a mid-game snack run, or a late-night dash, Cumberland Farms keeps it simple with hot and iced coffee, prepared foods, and grab-and-go that actually hits the spot. Bonus: beer in the cooler and fuel out front, plus a SmartRewards program.

From the Laconia newsletter, October 22, 2026

Wayfarer Coffee | Downtown roasts their own beans and keeps the flavor dialed, from bright single origins to a solid everyday cup, all fueled by that Coffee + Community vibe. Skip the wait with mobile ordering, then settle in and actually enjoy your Lakes Region caffeine.

From the Laconia newsletter, October 24, 2026

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.