The best bakeries & sweet shops in Sayreville
39 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.
Your business could be here.
Be at the top of Sayreville's page when you're in Sayreville's newsletter.
Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
4500 Bordentown Ave
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
285 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
256 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
680 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)
802 S Orange Ave · Newark
Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
1513-1515 John F. Kennedy Blvd · Jersey City
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
Twin City Shop/Cent, 2 Garfield Ave · Jersey City
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
1379 St Georges Ave · Colonia
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Nasto's Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
992 St Georges Ave · Avenel
Family owned since 1939, Nasto's Ice Cream turns out old-world treats that actually taste like someone still reads the recipe in Italian,…
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
3830 Broadway · New York
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
880 Mt Prospect Ave · Newark
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Carrot Top Pastries (opens in a new tab)
3931 Broadway · New York
Carrot Top Pastries has been baking on premises since 1979, and their carrot cake and carrot muffins are the headliners. Expect…
King Softee Ice Cream Truck (opens in a new tab)
35 Pershing Ave · Newark
Whether it's a backyard birthday, school celebration, or a last minute treat run, King Softee Ice Cream Truck rolls up with creamy soft…
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)
3310 Washington Rd · Parlin
Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.
Untamed Grain (opens in a new tab)
683 Georges Rd · North Brunswick Township
Whether your week needs a chewy, tangy reset or a little something sweet, Untamed Grain is a local microbakery turning out handmade…
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)
Midstate Mall, 314 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.
Carvalho’s Bakery (opens in a new tab)
148 Whitehead Ave · South River
Carvalho’s Bakery brings Portuguese baked favorites and sweet treats together with lunch, pizza, chicken, coffee, and breakfast platters.…
pinas locas quetzaly (opens in a new tab)
58 Obert St · South River
Pinas Locas Quetzaly nails that sweet-heat fix with over-the-top piñas and sandías loaded with chamoy and tajin, plus raspados, fresas con…
Scoop to My Lou (opens in a new tab)
59 Main St · East Brunswick
Made onsite and ridiculously tasty, Scoop to My Lou churns out classic scoops and playful new-age flavors alongside cones, cups, sundaes…
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)
1901 Park Ave · South Plainfield
Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.
Uncle Louie G (opens in a new tab)
479 New Brunswick Ave · Perth Amboy
This week, when the humidity wins, Uncle Louie G serves up authentic Italian ices, creamy ice cream, and specialty hits like milkshakes,…
Industry Squares and Bread Co. (opens in a new tab)
20 Campus Dr · Edison
Industry Squares and Bread Co. keeps Middlesex folks fed from breakfast to dinner with hearty pies, stacked sandwiches, wraps, and…
Cones & Crepes (opens in a new tab)
1020 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Craving something beyond the usual cone? Cones & Crepes lets you build your own crepe or waffle, dunk fruit under a molten milk chocolate…
Magnifico's Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
500 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Whether it’s a Tuesday treat or birthday emergency, Magnifico's Ice Cream keeps East Brunswick smiling with soft ice cream, playful…
AlyCakes Custom (opens in a new tab)
16 William St · South River
When you need a cake that looks as good as it tastes, AlyCakes Custom turns birthdays, weddings, and every little win into something…
Ralph's Italian Ice (opens in a new tab)
508 Main St · Spotswood
Ralph's Italian Ice is the Spotswood outpost of the Staten Island-born classic, scooping 100-plus flavors of Italian ices and ice cream…
Fajji's Homemade Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
810 Amboy Ave · Perth Amboy
At Fajji's Homemade Ice Cream the motto is simple... the answer is yes. Build-your-own sundaes, mix-and-match flavors like peanut butter…
Four Boys Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
85 Washington Ave · Milltown
Four Boys Ice Cream is the classic small-town scoop shop vibe we grew up on, and it’s right around the corner. Hit Milltown or Jamesburg…
Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)
680 NJ-18 · East Brunswick
Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.
M2ICE (opens in a new tab)
678 Mt Prospect Ave · Newark
M2ICE specializes in Colombian shaved ice, including cholados and a mango mangonada with chamoy and Tajín for a sweet, tangy, spicy kick.…
Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)
75 Main St · South River
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
Causeway Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
113 Causeway St · South River
Family owned and still rocking the beloved original recipes, Causeway Ice Cream churns 20+ homemade flavors plus classic soft serve,…
Borinquen Bakery (opens in a new tab)
406 Broadway · Newark
Borinquen Bakery is known for its soft, slightly sweet pan sobao, alongside sandwiches, breakfast options, and pastries. It’s a handy local…
L'Affaire II Bake Shoppe (opens in a new tab)
312 Rues Ln · East Brunswick
L'Affaire II Bake Shoppe makes custom cakes that bring plenty of imagination to the party, from mermaid and fairy themes to glam designs…
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)
201-205 New Brunswick Ave Unit 1 · Hopelawn
Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.
Levain Bakery (opens in a new tab)
2167 Frederick Douglass Blvd · New York
Tiny bakery serving up signature oversized chocolate chip cookies, plus brioche, scones & more.
Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)
2203 US-9 · Old Bridge
Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream churns homemade scoops with high-quality ingredients and flavors that go beyond the usual, think Black Sesame,…
Breads Bakery (opens in a new tab)
1294 3rd Ave · New York
Breads Bakery is a neighborhood favorite for artisan breads, pastries, sandwiches, salads, and coffee, with its award-winning chocolate…
Aubi & Ramsa (opens in a new tab)
1165 Broadway · New York
Dessert shop offering ice cream infused with spirits, including champagne sorbet and espresso martini flavors.
Anita La Mamma del Gelato (opens in a new tab)
1561 2nd Ave · New York
Handmade scoops, signature jams, and toppings stacked with zero chill, Anita La Mamma del Gelato makes dessert feel like an event. Expect a…
Sugar Hill Creamery (opens in a new tab)
184 Malcolm X Blvd · New York
Sugar Hill Creamery, a Black-owned, woman-led shop, churns handmade, small-batch flavors inspired by Caribbean and Midwestern roots, with…
Levain Bakery (opens in a new tab)
1484 3rd Ave · New York
Outpost of a popular NYC bakery offering its famous assortment of cookies.
Carvel (opens in a new tab)
318 Jerusalem Ave · Hempstead
Circa-1934 chain known for its soft-serve ice cream & custom cakes, mainly for take-out.
Silver Moon Bakery (opens in a new tab)
2664 Broadway · New York
Silver Moon Bakery turns out slow-risen artisanal breads, flaky French pastries, elegant cakes and tarts, all from a traditional bread oven…
Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)
380 Peninsula Blvd · Hempstead
Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.
Anita La Mamma del Gelato (opens in a new tab)
1141 Broadway · New York
Anita La Mamma del Gelato serves handmade gelato in a wide-ranging lineup, from rich chocolate and pistachio to vegan cookie and cream. The…
Amorino (opens in a new tab)
414 Amsterdam Ave · New York
Chains of Italian ice cream parlors serving gelato, sorbet and creamy hot chocolate.
Bayside Creamery (opens in a new tab)
273 Front St #4416 · Perth Amboy
Bayside Creamery deals in generous portions, 40+ flavors, and milkshakes you can customize into oblivion, with waffle cones and bowls,…
The Hungarian Pastry Shop (opens in a new tab)
1030 Amsterdam Ave · New York
At The Hungarian Pastry Shop, strudel, cakes, and flaky Danish pair with bottomless coffee and a vibe that actively invites you to linger,…
Paramount Bakeries Inc (opens in a new tab)
418 N 5th St · Newark
Paramount Bakeries Inc has been brick-oven baking in the neighborhood since 1924, turning simple ingredients and an 18-hour cold proof into…
Speak Freezy (opens in a new tab)
428 New Brunswick Ave · Fords
Speak Freezy keeps things fun with homemade flavors that actually rotate, from Jersey Pothole to Dubai Chocolate, plus sundaes, bubble…
What's the Scoop (opens in a new tab)
457A Main St · Metuchen
What’s the Scoop has been Metuchen’s go-to since 2001 for small-batch, homemade ice cream, with 72+ flavors, soft serve, vegan ice cream…
Breads Bakery (opens in a new tab)
18 E 16th St · New York
Bright, high-ceilinged bakery featuring handmade breads & baked goods, plus coffee & sandwiches.
Ice Cream Monster (opens in a new tab)
347 Matawan Rd · Matawan
Craving something fun this week? Ice Cream Monster turns dessert into a little event with monster-inspired creations, plus vegan,…
Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)
247 Greenwich St · Hempstead
Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.
Sugar Hill Creamery (opens in a new tab)
1642 Lexington Ave · New York
Treat yourself this week to Sugar Hill Creamery, a Black-owned, woman-led, small-batch ice cream spot turning Harlem stories into rotating…
Gourmet Italian Delights (opens in a new tab)
Entrance around back on waterside, 29 W Front St · Keyport
Gourmet Italian Delights makes ice cream a whole experience with a playful monster theme and choices for every eater, including dairy free,…
Checked Sep 11
Insomnia Cookies (opens in a new tab)
730 Fulton Ave · Hempstead
Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.
Häagen-Dazs (opens in a new tab)
30 Mall Dr W · Jersey City
Counter-service chain offering scoops of ice cream & sorbet plus sundaes, shakes & smoothies.
Angel's Recipe Ice Cream & Crepes (opens in a new tab)
312 Central Ave · Jersey City
Angel's Recipe Ice Cream & Crepes slings sweet crepes, rolled ice cream sundaes, and bubble tea in a bright, cheery counter-service vibe.…
Stack Creamery (opens in a new tab)
465 Central Ave · Jersey City
Stack Creamery is all about ice cream and cookies, the classic combo locals never tire of. Swing by for a quick treat after dinner or grab…
Dulce De Leche Bakery (opens in a new tab)
376 Central Ave · Jersey City
Craving something that actually tastes like a reward? Dulce De Leche Bakery turns out buttery Argentine pastries, gorgeous cakes and…
Nneka's Bakery (opens in a new tab)
JCPenney Wing, Second Floor, 410 Woodbridge Center Dr Store 2086 · Woodbridge
Craving something beyond the usual supermarket sheet cake? Nneka's Bakery turns out moist celebration cakes, Strawberry Crunch Cookies,…
Main Street Donuts (opens in a new tab)
141 Main St · Matawan
Main Street Donuts nails the classics, then gets playful with cream-filled rings, bacon-topped bites, cheesecake-inspired numbers and…
Mueller Chocolate Co (opens in a new tab)
Reading Terminal Market, 51 N 12th St · Philadelphia
Since 1980, Mueller Chocolate Co has been a Reading Terminal Market favorite for hand-dipped chocolate-covered pretzels, silky truffles,…
2winspastryH&A (opens in a new tab)
2 Treat Pl · Newark
2winspastryH&A is cranking out joy by the dozen, from ice cream donuts and kolaches to custom celebration cakes that actually taste as good…
Ray's Candy Store (opens in a new tab)
113 Avenue A · New York
Funky, colorful ice cream destination since 1974 also boasts egg creams, fries & hot dogs.
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery (opens in a new tab)
997 1st Ave · New York
Relaxed bakery known for custom cakes, cupcakes and pies, plus coffee.
Levain Bakery (opens in a new tab)
2 W 18th St · New York
Bakery chain known for its signature chocolate chip cookies, which are baked fresh daily.
TOUS les JOURS Bakery Café - Edison (opens in a new tab)
1761 NJ-27 · Edison
French-Asian bakery offering a range of breads, plus sweet & savory baked goods & beverages.
Stocks Bakery (opens in a new tab)
2614 E Lehigh Ave · Philadelphia
Stock’s Bakery is famed for its pound cake, but this no-frills Philadelphia bakeshop also has cookies, donuts, pies, and other sweets for…
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge (opens in a new tab)
145 S 13th St · Philadelphia
Traditional store selling chocolates, confections & fudge, as well as original recipe ice cream.
Cake Life Bake Shop (opens in a new tab)
1306 Frankford Ave · Philadelphia
Cake Life Bake Shop is Fishtown’s sustainable, small-batch spot for celebratory cakes and daily treats, made with fresh, locally sourced…
Pi Bakerie (opens in a new tab)
512 Broome St · New York
Pi Bakerie is the kind of spot you wander into for a freddo espresso and leave plotting your next bougatsa run. Hand-rolled phyllo, savory…
Partybus Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
31 Essex St · New York
Partybus Bakeshop is turning classic breads, pies, and cookies into small-batch, naturally leavened magic with organic stone-milled flour…
Keytlym Bakery (opens in a new tab)
806 Summer Ave · Newark
This week, when the craving hits between errands, Keytlym Bakery has you covered with from‑scratch pastries, fresh bread, and real-deal…
NY Bakery and Desserts NoMad (opens in a new tab)
1204 Broadway · New York
NY Bakery and Desserts NoMad handles sugar cravings and celebrations with same-day pickup for cake slices, pastries, and macarons, plus…
Caffé Palermo (opens in a new tab)
148 Mulberry St · New York
When the sweet tooth hits, Caffè Palermo is the Little Italy classic locals still swear by, a.k.a. the Cannoli King of Mulberry Street…
BonBon - A Swedish Candy Co. (opens in a new tab)
1220 Lexington Ave · New York
Premium Swedish pick-and-mix candy store offering a large selection of chocolates, gummies, licorice, and marshmallows.
Night Kitchen Bakery & Cafe (opens in a new tab)
7723-25 Germantown Ave · Philadelphia
Night Kitchen Bakery & Cafe has been a Philly staple for 40 years, turning out moist cakes, Best of Philly brownies, sinful sticky buns,…
Levain Bakery (opens in a new tab)
351 Amsterdam Ave · New York
Outpost for fresh breads, giant cookies & other baked treats near the iconic original.
Billy's Bakery (opens in a new tab)
184 9th Ave · New York
Billy's Bakery turns out handmade cakes, cupcakes, pies, cheesecakes, cookies, and more, with favorites like banana cake and carrot cake in…
La Bon Bake Shoppes (opens in a new tab)
356 Amboy Ave · Woodbridge
Cake-shop for custom designs and traditional treats such as brownies and cannoli, plus catering.
Calandra's Bakery (opens in a new tab)
204 1st Ave · Newark
Since 1962, Calandra's Bakery has been cranking out 100% all natural loaves that actually taste like something, plus Italian classics like…
Little Cupcake Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
270 Bleecker St · New York
NYC-born Little Cupcake Bakeshop turns out cupcakes and other baked goods that hit the sweet spot between nostalgic and ridiculously good.…
La Belle Crème (opens in a new tab)
1805 Madaline Dr · Avenel
Whether you’re grabbing a pick-me-up or planning dessert that actually gets talked about, La Belle Crème delivers with elegant pastries and…
The Sweet Shop NYC (opens in a new tab)
404 E 73rd St · New York
The Sweet Shop NYC nails that retro-candy vibe with shelves of hard-to-find sweets, plus gourmet ice cream, gelato, and proper coffee or…
La Bon Bake Shoppes (opens in a new tab)
6101a Hadley Rd · South Plainfield
Family-owned shop offering a variety of baked goods, plus sandwiches and cakes for special occasions.
NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square (opens in a new tab)
1580 Broadway · New York
When the cheesecake craving hits, NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square delivers with slices from classic New York to tres leches, plus…
Schmackary's (opens in a new tab)
362 W 45th St · New York
With more than 45 varieties, including gluten-free options, Schmackary's makes choosing just one cookie an ambitious plan. The lineup…
Majdal Bakery (opens in a new tab)
618 S 5th St · Philadelphia
Majdal Bakery is the spot when you want a not boring lunch or treat, with safeha flatbreads, potato fatayer, muhamara sourdough and babka…
Fabrique Artisan Bakery (opens in a new tab)
348 W 14th St · New York
Fabrique Artisan Bakery is the NYC outpost of a Swedish bakery turning out beautiful sourdough and those cardamom and cinnamon buns that…
Dulcemania ll (opens in a new tab)
92 N Franklin St · Hempstead
Craving that tart-sweet kick without trekking far? Dulcemania II is a friendly international grocery and juice bar serving mangonadas and…
Heritage Grand Bakery (opens in a new tab)
8 W 40th St · New York
Cozy bakery and pizzeria? serving a range of pastries, along with pizza, sandwiches and salads.
Dominique Ansel Bakery (opens in a new tab)
189 Spring St · New York
Dominique Ansel Bakery is the Soho spot where the Cronut® still steals the show, alongside the DKA, playful Cookie Shots, and jewel-box…
Isgro Pastries (opens in a new tab)
1009 Christian St · Philadelphia
Isgro Pastries is the Italian Market standby locals actually brag about, with crisp-shelled, award-winning cannoli from a secret family…
Tonnie's Minis (opens in a new tab)
228 Halsey St · Newark
Since 1993, Tonnie's Minis has been turning out bite-size cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and nostalgic pies that taste like a warm hug from the…
Sweets & Treats Factory (opens in a new tab)
6706 Rising Sun Ave · Philadelphia
Need a birthday fix, a last-minute surprise, or just something delicious after work? Sweets & Treats Factory does strawberries, cupcakes,…
Economy Candy (opens in a new tab)
108 Rivington St · New York
Since 1937, Economy Candy has stacked floor-to-ceiling sweets, nuts, and dried fruit for every mood, from by-the-pound classics and retro…
Checked Sep 25
Magnolia Bakery (Bloomingdale's 3rd Ave) - New York, NY (opens in a new tab)
1000 3rd Ave 1st Floor · New York
Cheerful bakeshop serving classic homemade cupcakes, pies & other treats at the counter.
Sweet Box Bakery (opens in a new tab)
339 S 13th St · Philadelphia
Quaint, cheery bakery providing cupcakes in unique flavors, plus cookies, brownies & dessert bars.
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery (opens in a new tab)
365 Grand St · New York
Whether you need a midweek pick-me-up or a dessert plan for the whole crew, Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery delivers with classic cupcakes,…
Milk Bar (opens in a new tab)
246 Mott St · New York
Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.
Ladurée Soho (opens in a new tab)
398 W Broadway · New York
Slip into Ladurée Soho for crisp-shelled, cloud-light macarons that taste like a tiny Paris vacation, then linger over exquisite pastries…
lil sweet treat (opens in a new tab)
1527 Walnut St · Philadelphia
Lil Sweet Treat lets you build your own gummy bag or grab curated Signature Mixes, including vegan, gluten-free, gelatin-free and naturally…
Ashley’s Delicious Treats (opens in a new tab)
37 Commerce St · Newark
Ashley’s Delicious Treats specializes in cupcakes and banana pudding, with cookies and other treats for anyone whose sweet tooth refuses to…
Checked Oct 15
Whole Foods Market (opens in a new tab)
270 Greenwich St · New York
Eco-minded chain with natural & organic grocery items, housewares & other products (most sell wine).
Baked by Melissa (opens in a new tab)
110 Fulton St · New York
Craving a tiny treat that hits big? Baked by Melissa churns out inventive, one-bite cupcakes, including no-nut and gluten-free picks plus…
Flying Monkey Bakery (opens in a new tab)
1146 Arch St · Philadelphia
Whoopie pies that hit like a hug, rich brownies and bars, classic cookies, and yes, that wild cake-with-a-pie-baked-inside situation.…
Sweet as Fudge Candy Shoppe (opens in a new tab)
1136 Arch St · Philadelphia
Sweet as Fudge Candy Shoppe in Reading Terminal Market is a playground of old-fashioned, real-butter-and-cream fudge, six crispy brittles,…
Lily of the Valley Cupcakery & Cafe' (opens in a new tab)
26 Maplewood Mall · Philadelphia
Swing by this week for scratch-made cupcakes turned over-the-top treats, from any-flavor fried cupcakes with a scoop to cupcake shakes.…
Little Cupcake Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
30 Prince St · New York
Little Cupcake Bakeshop does cupcakes, puddings, pies and cakes with sustainable ingredients in an eco-friendly space. When dessert duty…
Baked Cravings (opens in a new tab)
1673 Lexington Ave · New York
Baked Cravings is a dedicated nut-free bakery turning out award-winning cupcakes, cookies, brownies, donuts and their cult-favorite Cake in…
Nothing Bundt Cakes (opens in a new tab)
4919 Stelton Rd · South Plainfield
Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.
Venchi (opens in a new tab)
861 Broadway · New York
Ice cream parlor specializing in Italian-style gelato and chocolate.
Lore's Chocolates (opens in a new tab)
34 S 7th St · Philadelphia
For locals looking for a treat, Lore's Chocolates is a Philadelphia Tradition crafting small batch, handmade sweets for 50+ years, with…
Beard Papa’s (opens in a new tab)
239 E 53rd St · New York
This bakery chain, which originated in Japan, whips up signature cream puffs in a range of flavors.
Myzel Chocolates (opens in a new tab)
140 W 55th St #1 · New York
From handmade truffles and that dangerously good Ultimate Chocolate Cookie to almond butter crunch and chocolate nut bars, Myzel Chocolates…
Levain Bakery (opens in a new tab)
340 Lafayette St · New York
Pastries, fresh bread & celebrated oversized cookies in a relaxed spot that has counter seating.
See's Candies (opens in a new tab)
60 W 8th St · New York
Candies & chocolates are sold by the piece or box at this old-school chain, in business since 1921.
Nothing here matches that.
Try a shorter word, or look through every kind of place in Sayreville.
Know a great place we’re missing? Email hello@baselocal.com
Showing the 120 most recent of 138. See what changed this month
The best of Sayreville, every morning
New places show up in the Sayreville newsletter first. It's free.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.