The best bakeries & sweet shops in Sayreville

31 bakeries & sweet shops we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Sayreville’s best · Restaurants · Beauty · Shopping · Nightlife · Entertainment · Arts & Culture · Health & Wellness · Cafes · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Home & Garden · Parks & Outdoors · Services · Pets

Pinned in Sayreville today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Sayreville — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Bakeries & Sweets · 31 places · showing the latest additions first

Dunkin'

Bakeries & Sweets

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

880 Mt Prospect Ave (Newark)

“Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.”

Website ↗

Whether it's a backyard birthday, school celebration, or a last minute treat run, King Softee Ice Cream Truck rolls up with creamy soft…

35 Pershing Ave (Newark)

“Whether it's a backyard birthday, school celebration, or a last minute treat run, King Softee Ice Cream Truck rolls up with creamy soft serve, legit milkshakes, dips and waffle cones, and the kindest crew. They pop by around Elizabeth, serve fast, and somehow make grownups as happy as the kids.”

From the Irvington newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

3310 Washington Rd (Parlin)

“Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.”

Website ↗

Untamed Grain

Bakeries & Sweets

Whether your week needs a chewy, tangy reset or a little something sweet, Untamed Grain is a local microbakery turning out handmade…

683 Georges Rd (North Brunswick Township)

“Whether your week needs a chewy, tangy reset or a little something sweet, Untamed Grain is a local microbakery turning out handmade sourdough and seasonal treats with top-notch New Jersey ingredients. Pre-order online, then break into a crust that actually crackles.”

From the East Brunswick newsletter, September 24, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Sayreville business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

Midstate Mall, 314 NJ-18 (East Brunswick)

“Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.”

Website ↗

pinas locas quetzaly

Bakeries & Sweets

Pinas Locas Quetzaly nails that sweet-heat fix with over-the-top piñas and sandías loaded with chamoy and tajin, plus raspados, fresas con…

58 Obert St (South River)

“Pinas Locas Quetzaly nails that sweet-heat fix with over-the-top piñas and sandías loaded with chamoy and tajin, plus raspados, fresas con crema, churros, and actual helados and milkshakes. When a basic scoop won’t cut it, this spot turns snacking into a small celebration.”

From the East Brunswick newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

Scoop to My Lou

Bakeries & Sweets

Made onsite and ridiculously tasty, Scoop to My Lou churns out classic scoops and playful new-age flavors alongside cones, cups, sundaes…

59 Main St (East Brunswick)

“Made onsite and ridiculously tasty, Scoop to My Lou churns out classic scoops and playful new-age flavors alongside cones, cups, sundaes and shakes. Grab a take-home treat or an ice cream cake for later, then call it the smartest decision you made this week.”

From the Sayreville newsletter, September 16, 2026

Website ↗

Pizza joint offering a variety of pies, plus sandwiches, wraps, and baked goods for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

20 Campus Dr (Edison)

“Pizza joint offering a variety of pies, plus sandwiches, wraps, and baked goods for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.”

Website ↗

Cones & Crepes

Bakeries & Sweets

Craving something beyond the usual cone? Cones & Crepes lets you build your own crepe or waffle, dunk fruit under a molten milk chocolate…

1020 NJ-18 (East Brunswick)

“Craving something beyond the usual cone? Cones & Crepes lets you build your own crepe or waffle, dunk fruit under a molten milk chocolate fountain, sip whipped-cream-topped 20oz milkshakes, swirl soft serve, and even try mojitos with Red Bull or Sprite… a sweet little escape minutes from home.”

From the Sayreville newsletter, September 28, 2026

Website ↗

Magnifico's Ice Cream

Bakeries & Sweets

Whether it’s a Tuesday treat or birthday emergency, Magnifico's Ice Cream keeps East Brunswick smiling with soft ice cream, playful…

500 NJ-18 (East Brunswick)

“Whether it’s a Tuesday treat or birthday emergency, Magnifico's Ice Cream keeps East Brunswick smiling with soft ice cream, playful novelties, and ice cream cakes. Family-owned since 1981 and voted one of the best in NJ, they even deliver for parties so you can skip the melting-in-traffic drama.”

From the East Brunswick newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗

AlyCakes Custom

Bakeries & Sweets

When you need a cake that looks as good as it tastes, AlyCakes Custom turns birthdays, weddings, and every little win into something…

16 William St (South River)

“When you need a cake that looks as good as it tastes, AlyCakes Custom turns birthdays, weddings, and every little win into something personal and pretty. Share a theme or a vibe, then let them bake the centerpiece your group chat will obsess over.”

From the East Brunswick newsletter, September 9, 2026

Website ↗

Ralph's Italian Ice

Bakeries & Sweets

Ralph's Italian Ice is the Spotswood outpost of the Staten Island-born classic, scooping 100-plus flavors of Italian ices and ice cream…

508 Main St (Spotswood)

“Ralph's Italian Ice is the Spotswood outpost of the Staten Island-born classic, scooping 100-plus flavors of Italian ices and ice cream since 1928. Go for a Twister, thick milkshake, or a sundae piled ridiculously high with brownie pieces, rainbow sprinkles, hot fudge, and homemade whipped cream.”

From the Middlesex County newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

Four Boys Ice Cream

Bakeries & Sweets

Four Boys Ice Cream is the classic small-town scoop shop vibe we grew up on, and it’s right around the corner. Hit Milltown or Jamesburg…

85 Washington Ave (Milltown)

“Four Boys Ice Cream is the classic small-town scoop shop vibe we grew up on, and it’s right around the corner. Hit Milltown or Jamesburg for creamy cones, simple joys, and that “ice cream is always a good idea” feeling that turns any errand into a treat.”

From the East Brunswick newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Baskin-Robbins

Bakeries & Sweets

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

680 NJ-18 (East Brunswick)

“Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.”

Website ↗

Causeway Ice Cream

Bakeries & Sweets

Family owned and still rocking the beloved original recipes, Causeway Ice Cream churns 20+ homemade flavors plus classic soft serve,…

113 Causeway St (South River)

“Family owned and still rocking the beloved original recipes, Causeway Ice Cream churns 20+ homemade flavors plus classic soft serve, including sugar-free Vanilla, Cherry Vanilla, and even vegan vanilla. When a midweek sweet tooth hits this week, this is your no-fuss scoop fix.”

From the Sayreville newsletter, September 22, 2026

Website ↗

Kid-friendly chain known for baked goods, breakfasts & other standards in dinerlike digs.

286 NJ-18 (East Brunswick)

“Kid-friendly chain known for baked goods, breakfasts & other standards in dinerlike digs.”

Website ↗

Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream

Bakeries & Sweets

Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream churns homemade scoops with high-quality ingredients and flavors that go beyond the usual, think Black Sesame,…

2203 US-9 (Old Bridge)

“Sweet Dynasty Ice Cream churns homemade scoops with high-quality ingredients and flavors that go beyond the usual, think Black Sesame, Taro, Milk Tea and Lychee alongside the classics.”

From the Sayreville newsletter, September 8, 2026

Website ↗

Paramount Bakeries Inc

Bakeries & Sweets

Paramount Bakeries Inc has been brick-oven baking in the neighborhood since 1924, turning simple ingredients and an 18-hour cold proof into…

418 N 5th St (Newark)

“Paramount Bakeries Inc has been brick-oven baking in the neighborhood since 1924, turning simple ingredients and an 18-hour cold proof into loaves with real character, from Russian rye and borodinsky to Cuban and Italian classics, delivered fresh daily. Your East Orange sandwiches will notice.”

From the Irvington newsletter, September 5, 2026

Website ↗

Häagen-Dazs

Bakeries & Sweets

Counter-service chain offering scoops of ice cream & sorbet plus sundaes, shakes & smoothies.

30 Mall Dr W (Jersey City)

“Counter-service chain offering scoops of ice cream & sorbet plus sundaes, shakes & smoothies.”

Website ↗

Angel's Recipe Ice Cream & Crepes slings sweet crepes, rolled ice cream sundaes, and bubble tea in a bright, cheery counter-service vibe.…

312 Central Ave (Jersey City)

“Angel's Recipe Ice Cream & Crepes slings sweet crepes, rolled ice cream sundaes, and bubble tea in a bright, cheery counter-service vibe. They deliver to Hoboken too, which makes last minute dessert runs dangerously easy and perfect for couch nights, study breaks, or post-dinner sweet fixes.”

From the Hoboken newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Stack Creamery

Bakeries & Sweets

Stack Creamery is all about ice cream and cookies, the classic combo locals never tire of. Swing by for a quick treat after dinner or grab…

465 Central Ave (Jersey City)

“Stack Creamery is all about ice cream and cookies, the classic combo locals never tire of. Swing by for a quick treat after dinner or grab an ice cream cake when you need a reliable crowd-pleaser.”

From the Bayonne newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Dulce De Leche Bakery

Bakeries & Sweets

Craving something that actually tastes like a reward? Dulce De Leche Bakery turns out buttery Argentine pastries, gorgeous cakes and…

376 Central Ave (Jersey City)

“Craving something that actually tastes like a reward? Dulce De Leche Bakery turns out buttery Argentine pastries, gorgeous cakes and cookies, plus savory lunch bites, all with that rich caramel vibe they’re named for... a perfect midweek pick-me-up when you need a win.”

From the Staten Island newsletter, August 19, 2026

Website ↗

2winspastryH&A

Bakeries & Sweets

2winspastryH&A is cranking out joy by the dozen, from ice cream donuts and kolaches to custom celebration cakes that actually taste as good…

2 Treat Pl (Newark)

“2winspastryH&A is cranking out joy by the dozen, from ice cream donuts and kolaches to custom celebration cakes that actually taste as good as they look. They even do keto and gluten free treats, so everyone in the group chat can say yes this week.”

From the Newark newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

French-Asian bakery offering a range of breads, plus sweet & savory baked goods & beverages.

1761 NJ-27 (Edison)

“French-Asian bakery offering a range of breads, plus sweet & savory baked goods & beverages.”

Website ↗

Keytlym Bakery

Bakeries & Sweets

This week, when the craving hits between errands, Keytlym Bakery has you covered with from‑scratch pastries, fresh bread, and real-deal…

806 Summer Ave (Newark)

“This week, when the craving hits between errands, Keytlym Bakery has you covered with from‑scratch pastries, fresh bread, and real-deal sandwiches. Grab a donut and smoothie combo, or put in for a custom cake that actually tastes as good as it looks.”

From the Kearny newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Calandra's Bakery

Bakeries & Sweets

Since 1962, Calandra's Bakery has been cranking out 100% all natural loaves that actually taste like something, plus Italian classics like…

204 1st Ave (Newark)

“Since 1962, Calandra's Bakery has been cranking out 100% all natural loaves that actually taste like something, plus Italian classics like sfogliatelle, rainbow cookies, and cannoli cake. Need a weekend pick-me-up? Grab a semolina bastone and call it dinner, no judgment.”

From the East Orange newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Tonnie's Minis

Bakeries & Sweets

Since 1993, Tonnie's Minis has been turning out bite-size cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and nostalgic pies that taste like a warm hug from the…

228 Halsey St (Newark)

“Since 1993, Tonnie's Minis has been turning out bite-size cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and nostalgic pies that taste like a warm hug from the oven. Swing by this week when the sweet tooth hits, especially for lemon-topped minis, strawberry and red velvet, plus a sweet potato pie with buttery vibes.”

From the Newark newsletter, September 22, 2026

Website ↗

Got a birthday, baby shower, or just a Tuesday that needs frosting this week? Ashley’s Delicious Treats whips up custom cakes and cupcake…

37 Commerce St (Newark)

“Got a birthday, baby shower, or just a Tuesday that needs frosting this week? Ashley’s Delicious Treats whips up custom cakes and cupcake cakes with playful designs from Sesame Street to Spider-Man, Minnie Mouse, Cars, or mermaids, and you can order online when inspiration (or cravings) hit.”

From the Newark newsletter, September 27, 2026

Website ↗

Sunmerry Bakery Cafe

Bakeries & Sweets

Whether you're sneaking out for a midday treat or fueling a weekend errand run, Sunmerry Bakery Cafe nails the sweet-savory balance with…

561 US-1 (Edison)

“Whether you're sneaking out for a midday treat or fueling a weekend errand run, Sunmerry Bakery Cafe nails the sweet-savory balance with buttery croissants, airy cakes, and flaky pastries. Add a smoothie or bubble tea, then watch for seasonal mooncakes, roll cakes, and that dangerously good Japanese cheesecake.”

Website ↗

La Bon Bake Shoppes

Bakeries & Sweets

Family-run bakery specializing in custom cakes, cupcakes and pastries baked from high-quality ingredients.

2062 NJ-27 (Edison)

“Family-run bakery specializing in custom cakes, cupcakes and pastries baked from high-quality ingredients.”

Website ↗

Paris Baguette

Bakeries & Sweets

Korean-run bakery offering cakes, croissants, French pastries and coffee, along with sandwiches.

1739 NJ-27 (Edison)

“Korean-run bakery offering cakes, croissants, French pastries and coffee, along with sandwiches.”

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →