The best bakeries & sweet shops in Batavia

11 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

11 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Batavia's page when you're in Batavia's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Hans’s Bakery On Main (opens in a new tab)

439 Main St · Medina

Hans’s Bakery On Main turns out artisanal pastries, breads, bagels, cookies, and specialty cakes, all made fresh daily. Whether you’re…

Hans’s Bakery On Main turns out artisanal pastries, breads, bagels, cookies, and specialty cakes, all made fresh daily. Whether you’re after a good bagel or something sweet to make an ordinary day feel less ordinary, it’s a Medina bakery worth keeping in mind.

From the Medina newsletter, November 17, 2026

Audrey 2.o.1’s Bakery (opens in a new tab)

201 E Main St

Audrey 2.o.1’s Bakery keeps its lineup of pastries and breads changing, alongside sandwiches, coffee, and tea. Pick up a fresh-baked treat,…

1’s Bakery keeps its lineup of pastries and breads changing, alongside sandwiches, coffee, and tea. Pick up a fresh-baked treat, or make a little outing of browsing the galleries and creative spaces at GO ART! while you enjoy it.

From the Batavia newsletter, November 12, 2026

Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)

829 Dick Rd · Buffalo

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)

3470 Main St · Buffalo

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Double Dips (opens in a new tab)

1418 S Main St · Medina

Whether the craving hits after work or right after mowing, Double Dips serves up Perry’s hard ice cream, silky custard, and sundaes, plus…

Checked Oct 10

Whether the craving hits after work or right after mowing, Double Dips serves up Perry’s hard ice cream, silky custard, and sundaes, plus mini ice cream cakes when you want to be the hero at home. A Medina standby locals rely on when only a real-deal cone will do.

From the Medina newsletter, November 8, 2026

Deb's Bakery (opens in a new tab)

5282 Clinton Street Rd

Deb's Bakery turns out scratch-baked pies, cookies, tarts, and wedding, shower, and other celebration cakes daily from its spot inside…

Deb's Bakery turns out scratch-baked pies, cookies, tarts, and wedding, shower, and other celebration cakes daily from its spot inside Harrington's Produce/Cafe. Planning a wedding or shower, they even rent cake and cupcake stands, and the farm market tie-in means you can grab specialty goodies while you’re at it.

From the Batavia newsletter, October 28, 2026

Dave's Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

3872 W Main Street Rd

When the ice cream mood hits, Dave's Ice Cream nails it with scoops and ice cream cakes, plus catering and a truck you can book for…

When the ice cream mood hits, Dave's Ice Cream nails it with scoops and ice cream cakes, plus catering and a truck you can book for neighborhood shindigs. Perfect for post-game stops, birthday missions, or just that "I earned this" Tuesday.

From the Batavia newsletter, October 30, 2026

Nola's (opens in a new tab)

525 Main St · Medina

Nola's is the kind of Medina coffee spot you end up claiming as your own, with well-made cups, friendly faces, and a cozy, linger-a-minute…

Checked Sep 30

Nola's is the kind of Medina coffee spot you end up claiming as your own, with well-made cups, friendly faces, and a cozy, linger-a-minute vibe. Perfect for a midweek pick-me-up or quick neighborly catch-up before tackling the next errand.

From the Medina newsletter, October 9, 2026

KMC Custom Cakes (opens in a new tab)

9015 Alexander Rd

KMC Custom Cakes brings home-baked goodness and creative ingenuity to custom cakes and cupcakes, with themes tailored to the people and…

Checked Oct 16

KMC Custom Cakes brings home-baked goodness and creative ingenuity to custom cakes and cupcakes, with themes tailored to the people and occasions they celebrate. If you’re planning a wedding, birthday, or baby shower in Batavia, this is a local baker who knows how to make the dessert feel like part of the story.

From the Batavia newsletter, October 20, 2026

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

405 W Main St

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

136 W Main St

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)

20 Main St

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

The Yard Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

33 Spann St · Buffalo

Family-run and made with love in Kaisertown, The Yard Ice Cream keeps things delightfully simple with creamy soft serve, classic…

Family-run and made with love in Kaisertown, The Yard Ice Cream keeps things delightfully simple with creamy soft serve, classic hand-scooped flavors, legit banana splits, and chocolate-dipped cones. A low-key spot that feels like summer, and yes, the kids somehow always know the way.

From the Niagara Falls newsletter, November 5, 2026

Pam's Custard Corner (opens in a new tab)

2190 South Park Ave · Buffalo

Skip the flavor-of-the-week roulette and hit Pam's Custard Corner, where more than 31 flavors of soft, creamy custard are always on deck,…

Skip the flavor-of-the-week roulette and hit Pam's Custard Corner, where more than 31 flavors of soft, creamy custard are always on deck, plus towering sundaes, thick milkshakes, Arctic Swirls, floats, slushes, and homemade lemon ice. Family-owned, friendly vibes, and exactly the cool-down you need this week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, October 18, 2026

Sugar Rush Bakery (opens in a new tab)

Buffalo St · Buffalo

When a homemade-tasting treat is calling your name, Sugar Rush Bakery is a sweet local pick for a celebratory bite or a small dessert-time…

Checked Sep 9

When a homemade-tasting treat is calling your name, Sugar Rush Bakery is a sweet local pick for a celebratory bite or a small dessert-time morale boost. Because sometimes “just one” is more of a hopeful suggestion.

From the Niagara Falls newsletter, November 17, 2026

White Rabbit Dessert Experience (opens in a new tab)

2130 Walden Ave · Buffalo

White Rabbit Dessert Experience churns handcrafted ice cream fresh daily, then pairs it with warm, made-to-order creations that are as…

White Rabbit Dessert Experience churns handcrafted ice cream fresh daily, then pairs it with warm, made-to-order creations that are as pretty as they are indulgent. If you crave premium ingredients, fun presentation, and a spot that feels like, well, an experience, consider this your new dessert routine.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, October 17, 2026

Cinnabon (opens in a new tab)

1 Walden Galleria · Buffalo

Counter-serve chain serving cinnamon rolls plus other baked goods & specialty frozen beverages.

Counter-serve chain serving cinnamon rolls plus other baked goods & specialty frozen beverages.

Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery (opens in a new tab)

27 Chandler St #214a · Buffalo

Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery turns out artisan-crafted cake pops, cookies, and fully customizable desserts, plus hands-on decorating classes if…

Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery turns out artisan-crafted cake pops, cookies, and fully customizable desserts, plus hands-on decorating classes if you want to level up your piping game. Perfect for birthdays, office treats, or just making Tuesday less Tuesday this week, and yes, everything is proudly made in the 716.

From the Buffalo newsletter, October 5, 2026

Bee Sweet Cakery (opens in a new tab)

1006 Grant St · Buffalo

Bee Sweet Cakery brings homemade goodness to Buffalo, with cakes, cupcakes, cookies, breads, old-school treats, and more. There are also…

Bee Sweet Cakery brings homemade goodness to Buffalo, with cakes, cupcakes, cookies, breads, old-school treats, and more. There are also savory bites, pies, puddings, cobblers, and gluten-free goodies, so it’s a sweet spot to remember when the dessert craving refuses to be ignored.

From the Buffalo newsletter, November 19, 2026

Alethea's Chocolates (opens in a new tab)

8301 Main St · Buffalo

Whether you’re craving that legendary sponge candy or a box of artisan truffles, Alethea's Chocolates keeps it FRESH with sweets…

Whether you’re craving that legendary sponge candy or a box of artisan truffles, Alethea's Chocolates keeps it FRESH with sweets handcrafted in their own facility. Bonus points for the ice cream parlor, because sometimes Western New York pride tastes best as a sundae topped with chocolate.

From the Buffalo newsletter, November 1, 2026

Kupkates Llc (opens in a new tab)

956 Abbott Rd Apt 1 · Buffalo

Need cupcakes, cookies, or a small cake for a celebration? KupKates Llc is a neighborhood specialty bakery known for custom orders for…

Need cupcakes, cookies, or a small cake for a celebration? KupKates Llc is a neighborhood specialty bakery known for custom orders for weddings, showers, and other events, with plenty of sweet treats to make bringing dessert the easy part.

From the Erie County newsletter, November 9, 2026

Fig Tree Patisserie (opens in a new tab)

3062 Delaware Ave · Buffalo

Whether you’re celebrating or craving something sweet, Fig Tree Patisserie turns out custom cakes, hand-piped cookies, and what many call…

Whether you’re celebrating or craving something sweet, Fig Tree Patisserie turns out custom cakes, hand-piped cookies, and what many call the best macarons in WNY. The pastry case changes daily, with French and Sicilian classics, legit vegan, gluten-free, and keto treats, plus a new macaron flavor every month.

From the Buffalo newsletter, October 19, 2026

Five Below (opens in a new tab)

3540 McKinley Pkwy Suite 10 · Buffalo

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

Five Below (opens in a new tab)

2141 Elmwood Ave Ste 800 · Buffalo

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

Butter Block (opens in a new tab)

426 Rhode Island St · Buffalo

The women-owned French-style patisserie Butter Block on Buffalo’s West Side keeps locals spoiled with croissants, cookies, and playful…

The women-owned French-style patisserie Butter Block on Buffalo’s West Side keeps locals spoiled with croissants, cookies, and playful European-inspired pastries that change with the seasons.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 1, 2026

Parkside Candy (opens in a new tab)

1 Walden Galleria · Buffalo

Parkside Candy has been crafting Buffalo's signature Sponge Candy since 1927, along with homemade chocolates, old-fashioned lollipops, and…

Parkside Candy has been crafting Buffalo's signature Sponge Candy since 1927, along with homemade chocolates, old-fashioned lollipops, and an ice cream parlor that feels like stepping back in time. Treat yourself this week... grab a box for the house, a couple for gifts, and maybe a sundae because why not.

From the Buffalo newsletter, November 2, 2026

Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

56 E Spring St · Buffalo

Since 1985, Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream has made fresh, small-batch scoops and handmade chocolates right inside the historic 1811…

Since 1985, Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream has made fresh, small-batch scoops and handmade chocolates right inside the historic 1811 Williamsville Mill, often the same day you buy them.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, October 13, 2026

Golden Waffles (opens in a new tab)

3500 Main St Ste 120 · Buffalo

Between bubble waffles piled high, the viral Dubai Chocolate Strawberry cup with pistachio sauce and kanafa, Nutella-loaded crepes, and…

Between bubble waffles piled high, the viral Dubai Chocolate Strawberry cup with pistachio sauce and kanafa, Nutella-loaded crepes, and that Lotus Milkshake that tastes like Biscoff daydreams, Golden Waffles is your excuse to skip dinner and go straight to dessert this week.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, September 29, 2026

BreadHive Bakery & Cafe (opens in a new tab)

402 Connecticut St · Buffalo

BreadHive Bakery & Cafe is the kind of spot you detour for from West Seneca, with fresh bagels and pretzels hitting early and loaves…

BreadHive Bakery & Cafe is the kind of spot you detour for from West Seneca, with fresh bagels and pretzels hitting early and loaves rolling out mid-morning, plus thoughtful cafe bites. It’s worker-owned, ten years strong in Buffalo, and it tastes like people who care made it.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 29, 2026

Half Baked Cookies (opens in a new tab)

451 Elmwood Ave · Buffalo

Half Baked Cookies churns out rotating weekly flavors alongside classics, plus vegan/gluten-free options, all available for local delivery…

Checked Sep 16

Half Baked Cookies churns out rotating weekly flavors alongside classics, plus vegan/gluten-free options, all available for local delivery or easy pre-order pickup.

From the Erie County newsletter, October 26, 2026

Oliver's Candies (opens in a new tab)

211 W Main St

Oliver's Candies has been handcrafting small-batch chocolates since 1932, and you can taste the tradition in their melt-in-your-mouth…

Oliver's Candies has been handcrafting small-batch chocolates since 1932, and you can taste the tradition in their melt-in-your-mouth sponge candy, French Cremes and Ameri-Mints. Swing in for a scoop, snag a gift box for later, and pretend it’s all for “guests” if that helps.

From the Medina newsletter, November 22, 2026

Five Points Bakery (opens in a new tab)

44 Brayton St · Buffalo

Whether you’re after hearty whole-grain loaves, flaky pastries, or an espresso that actually wakes you up, Five Points Bakery bakes with…

Whether you’re after hearty whole-grain loaves, flaky pastries, or an espresso that actually wakes you up, Five Points Bakery bakes with locally sourced ingredients and a lot of care. It’s the kind of neighborly spot you detour for, with a cafe vibe and even beer, wine, and a few grocery staples.

From the Buffalo newsletter, November 6, 2026

Parkside Candy (opens in a new tab)

3208 Main St · Buffalo

Parkside Candy has been part of Buffalo since 1927, serving homemade chocolates, old-fashioned lollipops, its signature Sponge Candy, and…

Parkside Candy has been part of Buffalo since 1927, serving homemade chocolates, old-fashioned lollipops, its signature Sponge Candy, and ice cream parlor creations.

From the West Seneca newsletter, November 8, 2026

Dipped & Designed by Mallory (opens in a new tab)

73 Glenwood Ave · Buffalo

Dipped & Designed by Mallory turns fruit and chocolate into custom treats, with themed birthday creations that make a party feel extra…

Dipped & Designed by Mallory turns fruit and chocolate into custom treats, with themed birthday creations that make a party feel extra thoughtful. If your sweet tooth likes a little flair, this Buffalo shop is worth a peek.

From the West Seneca newsletter, November 22, 2026

Manchester Place Baking Co. (opens in a new tab)

64 Manchester Pl · Buffalo

Manchester Place Baking Co. cranks out oversized cookies with a rotating lineup that actually rotates… think Ultimate Ube, peanut butter…

Manchester Place Baking Co. cranks out oversized cookies with a rotating lineup that actually rotates… think Ultimate Ube, peanut butter Butterfinger, rainbow confetti, classic whoopie pies, and chewy blondie bars. Treat yourself this week, hide them from your roommates, and pretend portion control is a suggestion.

From the Buffalo newsletter, October 12, 2026

Frost Artisan Bakery (opens in a new tab)

1197 Niagara St · Buffalo

Frost Artisan Bakery takes those grandma-kitchen classics and gives them a polished, modern glow. Drop in for tarts, cannoli, cream puffs,…

Frost Artisan Bakery takes those grandma-kitchen classics and gives them a polished, modern glow. Drop in for tarts, cannoli, cream puffs, and the Cupcake Bar, or plan a custom cake for your next milestone... Buffalo-tested way to sweeten any get-together.

From the West Seneca newsletter, November 2, 2026

The Chocolate Shop & More (opens in a new tab)

871 Niagara St · Buffalo

Since 1950, The Chocolate Shop & More has been crafting Buffalo-made chocolates that locals actually brag about. From boxed assortments and…

Since 1950, The Chocolate Shop & More has been crafting Buffalo-made chocolates that locals actually brag about. From boxed assortments and Easter bunnies to logo-stamped bars, corporate gifts, and custom molds, they even run fundraising programs, so your kid’s team can sell something people fight over.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, November 6, 2026

Artigiana (opens in a new tab)

935 Seneca St · Buffalo

Artigiana is that rare bakery where every loaf feels hand-signed... classic sourdough, hearty whole grains, fruit-and-nut beauties, even…

Checked Oct 17

Artigiana is that rare bakery where every loaf feels hand-signed... classic sourdough, hearty whole grains, fruit-and-nut beauties, even seeded baguettes and focaccia, all built on great ingredients.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, October 24, 2026

Fairy Cakes Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)

289 Parkside Ave · Buffalo

Whether you need celebratory cake magic, hand-decorated cupcakes, or a box of nostalgic cookies that taste like home, Fairy Cakes Bakeshop…

Whether you need celebratory cake magic, hand-decorated cupcakes, or a box of nostalgic cookies that taste like home, Fairy Cakes Bakeshop bakes everything in-house with fresh ingredients. Swing by this week for custom designs or even a full dessert table, plus they’ve been featured on Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats.

From the Buffalo newsletter, October 27, 2026

Watson's Chocolates (opens in a new tab)

738 Elmwood Ave · Buffalo

Buffalo-based shop carrying sponge candy as well as chocolates, ice cream and other treats.

Buffalo-based shop carrying sponge candy as well as chocolates, ice cream and other treats.