The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Orange County

Blue Fox Books is that community spot around Montgomery where gently used finds mingle with a few new must-reads, plus stationery, journals, and bookish gifts. They’ll special order what you’ve been hunting, curate collections for your shelves, and host the kind of low-key events that actually feel neighborly.

From the Montgomery newsletter, October 9, 2026

If your closet or living room needs a refresh without punishing your wallet, ShawnKats Paddywaks is a Port Jervis, NY thrift stop where secondhand scores get a second life. Go when you’re feeling curious, you might walk out with something you didn’t know you needed.

From the Port Jervis newsletter, October 3, 2026

Family-run Retro Quest Toys & Collectibles is all about the hunt, buying, selling and trading vintage toys and action figures from the 70s, 80s and 90s, think Star Wars, GI Joe, Transformers, TMNT, Thundercats and more. Swing through Historic Downtown Port Jervis or check their eBay listings for fresh scores.

From the Port Jervis newsletter, October 20, 2026

Score upscale and designer pieces, prom dresses, suits, shoes and cozy coats at The Warwick Hope Chest, where new and gently used finds keep your closet happy and prices friendly. Every purchase fuels Warwick’s free clothing bank, which has already given over $500,000 in essentials to neighbors in need.

From the Goshen newsletter, October 3, 2026

Rabbit Hole Antiques is the kind of local spot where a quick peek turns into an hour, with fresh finds popping up on Instagram. If you love the hunt, watch their updates and pounce when something speaks to you.

From the Walden newsletter, October 22, 2026

Linda's Thrifting and Antiques keeps a regularly changing mix of vintage, antiques, collectibles, furniture, and home décor that scratches Chester’s treasure-hunting itch.

From the Goshen newsletter, October 21, 2026

Benningtons Antique Center corrals 30+ vendors under one roof, so you can bounce from vintage glass to mid-century chairs to quirky local art without leaving town. New pieces roll in constantly, which makes it dangerously easy to pop in for a look and leave with a story.

From the Walden newsletter, October 17, 2026

BP Sports Cards and Memorabilia keeps the local hobby itch satisfied with sealed baseball, football, basketball, and hockey boxes, plus Pokémon and Disney Lorcana. Grab Ultra Pro sleeves and Saftgard stands too, so you can rip, sleeve, and display your latest hits without leaving town.

From the Port Jervis newsletter, October 17, 2026

Newburgh Vintage Emporium is the kind of place you "just pop into" and emerge an hour later with a statement chair, a stack of vinyl, and a story. Since 2013, their three locations gather hundreds of vendors, local makers, and one-of-a-kind finds, with the flagship boasting over 10,000 square feet of treasure hunting.

From the Hudson Valley newsletter, September 28, 2026