The best bakeries & sweet shops in Erie County

Same family recipe since 1904, Brummer's Homemade Chocolates turns out truffles, buckeyes, turtles, and fudge that taste like someone actually loves you. Build your own box, raid the nostalgic candy, then grab an imported wine to pair... the perfect Erie County pick-me-up.

From the Erie County newsletter, October 18, 2026

Jolly Donut is the local move when you want fresh, no-nonsense donuts and classic breakfast staples that actually fill you up. Expect sweet treats, classic diner plates, and that laid-back, feel-good vibe that keeps folks coming back, plus easy catering when you need a dozen... or three.

From the Erie County newsletter, October 20, 2026

Christina's Creations turns out celebration-worthy cakes that look polished and taste even better. Huron is a quick hop from Norwalk, so keep this spot in your back pocket for the next time life calls for a proper cake.

From the Erie County newsletter, November 3, 2026

Craving a little sugar victory between errands? Bake Erie rolls out cookies, pretzels, cupcakes, and other grab-and-grin treats from a cute bakery with a small seating area, perfect for a quick bite, a sweet catch-up, or rewarding yourself after yet another Lake Erie weather mood swing.

From the Port Clinton newsletter, October 9, 2026

When your week needs a pick me up, Soda Pop's delivers retro candy galore, ice cold glass bottle sodas, and authentic vintage arcade games that eat quarters in the most satisfying way. Grab a scoop of locally made Toft's, or build a root beer float and toast to Sandusky memories in the making.

From the Norwalk newsletter, November 5, 2026

Whether you’re chasing tangy sourdough, flaky pastries, or a cheesecake that actually lives up to the hype, Baker on the Square delivers from a small, family-run kitchen. Pies, cupcakes, pepperoni rolls, and special-occasion cakes keep the case rotating, so pop in and follow your nose.

From the Norwalk newsletter, October 11, 2026