The best bakeries & sweet shops in Corry

“Till Top Creamery bottles non-homogenized, creamline milk straight from their family dairy in Corry, with minimal processing that actually tastes like milk should. Chocolate and strawberry whole milk, too. Pro tip, give it a good shake before sipping and support a place built around community.”

“When the craving hits, KC’s Xpress is the kind of no-fuss, always-pleasant ice cream spot that turns weekday errands into little victories. Expect classic scoops and fun frozen treats, friendly faces, and the sort of hometown vibe that makes a quick stop feel like a tradition.”

“Colquhoun’s Ice Cream & Subs turns customer what-ifs into over 300 inventive, small-batch flavors, with Gene tinkering on scoops while Tammy builds hearty subs, salads, soups, and wraps. It’s the kind of community hangout where you stop for lunch, then somehow leave debating your next wild flavor idea.”

From the Corry newsletter, October 14, 2026

“When the sweet tooth hits, Ice Cream Shack is that easy Lakewood go-to with generous portions, plenty of flavors, and milkshakes, too. Quick stop after a ballgame or a backyard mow, and you’re instantly the neighborhood hero.”

From the Lakewood newsletter, October 6, 2026

“Counter-serve bakery/cafe chain serving sandwiches, salads & more, known for its bread & free WiFi.”

“Peterson's Candies is the spot when you need legit handmade treats without leaving the county.”

From the Chautauqua County newsletter, October 15, 2026