The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Sheboygan County

9 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

9 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Sheboygan County's page when you're in Sheboygan County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

St. Vincent de Paul PLYMOUTH (opens in a new tab)

2225 Eastern Ave · Plymouth

St. Vincent de Paul Plymouth is the spot for streetwear, work-ready pieces, kids’ stuff, home goods, and those delightfully odd 90s…

St. Vincent de Paul Plymouth is the spot for streetwear, work-ready pieces, kids’ stuff, home goods, and those delightfully odd 90s knick-knacks you swear you didn’t need. Shop in-store or peek their online picks, and feel good knowing every haul helps fund jobs, safe spaces, education, and assistance locally.

From the Plymouth newsletter, September 30, 2026

Neat Repeats (opens in a new tab)

2627 Eastern Ave · Plymouth

If you love scoring gently used clothes, books, dishes, furniture, and the occasional why-did-I-ever-live-without-this find, Neat Repeats…

If you love scoring gently used clothes, books, dishes, furniture, and the occasional why-did-I-ever-live-without-this find, Neat Repeats delivers the fun and the frugality. It’s a nonprofit resale shop where your purchases and donations help keep Sheboygan Lutheran High School tuition affordable for local families.

From the Plymouth newsletter, October 14, 2026

Nikki's Nex 2 New (opens in a new tab)

804 N 8th St · Sheboygan

Nikki's Nex 2 New brings together carefully selected women’s and children’s apparel, plus prom dresses and formalwear, in a consignment…

Nikki's Nex 2 New brings together carefully selected women’s and children’s apparel, plus prom dresses and formalwear, in a consignment shop where quality is the point. It’s a smart stop when you want something special without buying brand-new, or when the kids have outgrown perfectly good clothes again.

From the Sheboygan newsletter, November 5, 2026

The Barns at Found (opens in a new tab)

N7650 Co Rd Y · Sheboygan

The Barns at Found brings together handpicked antiques, vintage finds, primitives, handcrafted art, and home décor, from pottery and…

The Barns at Found brings together handpicked antiques, vintage finds, primitives, handcrafted art, and home décor, from pottery and jewelry to painted furniture and curiosities. It’s a fun place to browse when you want something with a little more character than the usual gift or home accent.

From the Sheboygan newsletter, November 8, 2026

St Vincent De Paul Society (opens in a new tab)

2065, 4215 WI-42 · Sheboygan

Thrift store offering a wide selection of men's, women's, and children's clothing, plus shoes and furniture.

Thrift store offering a wide selection of men's, women's, and children's clothing, plus shoes and furniture.

Hello Happiness Creativity Center (opens in a new tab)

1504 New Jersey Ave · Sheboygan

Hello Happiness Creativity Center is a nonprofit, art and craft supply thrift store that’s actually organized and super affordable, with a…

Hello Happiness Creativity Center is a nonprofit, art and craft supply thrift store that’s actually organized and super affordable, with a colorful, inspirational vibe that makes ideas pop. Restock your stash, swap tips with fellow makers, and reconnect with your creative side right here in Sheboygan.

From the Sheboygan newsletter, November 19, 2026

Superior Antiques and Gifts (opens in a new tab)

1512 N 40th St · Sheboygan

Superior Antiques and Gifts specializes in antique toys, advertising, and crocks, with furniture and other vintage finds to browse, too.…

Superior Antiques and Gifts specializes in antique toys, advertising, and crocks, with furniture and other vintage finds to browse, too. It’s a good spot to hunt for something with a little history, or to see whether an old favorite is waiting on a shelf.

From the Sheboygan newsletter, November 10, 2026

Vintage of Ada (opens in a new tab)

W4024 WI-32 · Elkhart Lake

Vintage of Ada is a charming little treasure hunt, with vintage home furnishings, Pyrex, and other finds for the house. Pop in for a browse…

Vintage of Ada is a charming little treasure hunt, with vintage home furnishings, Pyrex, and other finds for the house. Pop in for a browse and you might leave with a piece of the past you didn’t know your kitchen was missing.

From the Sheboygan County newsletter, November 14, 2026

Maggie’s Closet (opens in a new tab)

127 E Mill St · Plymouth

If your wardrobe needs a little joy, Maggie’s Closet is a boutique-style consignment gem in Plymouth with racks of the good stuff, size…

If your wardrobe needs a little joy, Maggie’s Closet is a boutique-style consignment gem in Plymouth with racks of the good stuff, size inclusive from 0 to 3X, designer purses and shoes, plus prom-to-wedding dresses and a legit men’s section, with 500 to 700 new items hitting the floor weekly.

From the Sheboygan County newsletter, November 10, 2026