The best bakeries & sweet shops in Fort Pierce

“This week, treat yourself to Treasure Coast Bagel Bakery, where a family crew with 30 years of New York-style bagel know-how bakes fresh daily. Pile on flavored cream cheeses, go big with a handcrafted breakfast sandwich or an authentic deli stack, then snag a pastry and a house-made salad for later.”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, September 11, 2026

“From classic Hershey Ice Cream scoops to fresh acai sorbet and fruit-packed bowls, Hershey Ice Cream & Acai Cafe nails the cool-down. Add a loaded waffle or a thick shake, and you’ve got the midweek morale boost Fort Pierce deserves.”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, August 22, 2026

“Run by a local mama as a cottage bakery, Mama J’s Bakehouse drops pre-order menus so you can snag fresh-baked treats without the sellout scramble. Perfect for Fort Pierce folks who like their sweets planned, not panicked... keep an eye on new drops via their socials.”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, August 31, 2026

“Need a little joy between errands? Batter House Bakery keeps things simple with fresh baked goods and legit Cuban coffee that hits just right. Pop in for a midweek treat, snag something sweet for later, and consider your energy restored and your sweet tooth thoroughly high-fived.”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, September 18, 2026

“Importico's Bakery Cafe Fort Pierce is worth a detour this week, turning old-world techniques into everyday treats with hand-shaped, slow-fermented breads, hearth-baked crusts, and buttery pastries inspired by classic French and Italian bakeries, all made with premium, locally sourced ingredients that taste like you…”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, August 26, 2026

“When you need a showstopper for birthdays, showers or weddings, Sweet Tiers Fort Pierce delivers custom designs that taste as good as they look, famous for light, not-too-sweet buttercream and award-winning flavors like Marble Cake with White Chocolate Liqueur and fudge filling.”

From the Fort Pierce newsletter, August 19, 2026