The best restaurants in Key West

47 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Key West’s best · Arts & Culture · Nightlife · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Shopping · Entertainment · Health & Wellness · Home & Garden

Pinned in Key West today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Key West — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 47 places · showing the latest additions first

Nine One Five

Restaurants

Settle into the Victorian charm at Nine One Five and let their eclectic fusion menu do the talking, simple no-fuss dishes cooked properly…

915 Duval St #5

Settle into the Victorian charm at Nine One Five and let their eclectic fusion menu do the talking, simple no-fuss dishes cooked properly with a world-class wine list to match. Add bragging rights from two James Beard Foundation invitations since 2002 and make it your move this week.

Website ↗

If your week needs a little sunshine, Sarabeth's in Key West delivers signature brunch delights made with fresh ingredients and plenty of…

530 Simonton St

If your week needs a little sunshine, Sarabeth's in Key West delivers signature brunch delights made with fresh ingredients and plenty of Key West charm. Think vibrant plates, cozy vibes, and the kind of feel-good flavors that make Wednesdays feel like Sundays.

From the Key West newsletter, August 7, 2026

Website ↗

Whether it’s a midweek pho craving or you just want a boba-fueled cooldown, Sister Noodle House turns out fresh, flavor-packed bowls and…

2502 N Roosevelt Blvd

Whether it’s a midweek pho craving or you just want a boba-fueled cooldown, Sister Noodle House turns out fresh, flavor-packed bowls and Asian Fusion comfort that actually hits. Think steaming noodle soups, legit Vietnamese coffee, and fried rice that cures the island blahs.

From the Key West newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Upbeat watering hole with a cool vibe & comfort eats including gourmet grilled cheese.

420 Appelrouth Ln

Upbeat watering hole with a cool vibe & comfort eats including gourmet grilled cheese.

Website ↗
Run a Key West business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Tiny, husband-&-wife-run food stand serving eclectic, inventive takes on tacos, burritos & burgers.

409 Caroline St

Tiny, husband-&-wife-run food stand serving eclectic, inventive takes on tacos, burritos & burgers.

Website ↗

Traditional Cuban home cooking & housemade sangria in a casual, family-friendly setting.

900 Catherine St

Traditional Cuban home cooking & housemade sangria in a casual, family-friendly setting.

Website ↗

Airy stop for seafood & elevated comfort cuisine like crab beignets plus cocktails & water views.

7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300

Airy stop for seafood & elevated comfort cuisine like crab beignets plus cocktails & water views.

Website ↗

Polished standby for creative sushi & Thai offerings in a compact seating area with a casual vibe.

504 Southard St

Polished standby for creative sushi & Thai offerings in a compact seating area with a casual vibe.

Website ↗

Mangia Mangia

Restaurants

Eatery serving homemade pastas & other Italian classics in quarters with island-inspired decor.

900 Southard St

Eatery serving homemade pastas & other Italian classics in quarters with island-inspired decor.

Website ↗

Casual eatery (and food truck) for burgers and pizza, plus steaks and cheesesteaks.

815 Sigsbee Rd Bldg No. V-4111

Casual eatery (and food truck) for burgers and pizza, plus steaks and cheesesteaks.

Website ↗

Upscale Italian seafood restaurant with wine lists, pasta dishes and dockside views.

700 Front St

Upscale Italian seafood restaurant with wine lists, pasta dishes and dockside views.

Website ↗

Harpoon Harry's

Restaurants

Cash-only diner offering hearty American comfort food in a cheerful atmosphere with quirky accents.

832 Caroline St

Cash-only diner offering hearty American comfort food in a cheerful atmosphere with quirky accents.

Website ↗

Relaxed garden cottage offering separate menus for breakfast or lunch & dinner, as well as drinks.

823 Whitehead St

Relaxed garden cottage offering separate menus for breakfast or lunch & dinner, as well as drinks.

Website ↗

Piping-hot food truck churning out Jamaican specialties like jerk chicken, along with island favorites, tacos, and burgers.

5220 US-1 (Naval Air Station Key West)

Piping-hot food truck churning out Jamaican specialties like jerk chicken, along with island favorites, tacos, and burgers.

Website ↗

Relaxed restaurant specializing in BBQ brisket, ribs and pulled pork, served via food truck or dine-in service.

31251 Ave A (Big Pine Key)

Relaxed restaurant specializing in BBQ brisket, ribs and pulled pork, served via food truck or dine-in service.

Website ↗

Sushi, sashimi & cooked Japanese dishes, plus sake & wine, served in a chic lounge environment.

925 Duval St

Sushi, sashimi & cooked Japanese dishes, plus sake & wine, served in a chic lounge environment.

Website ↗

Kaya Island Eats

Restaurants

Outdoor outpost with counter seating dishing up island-inspired fare, including tacos & salad.

618 Duval St

Outdoor outpost with counter seating dishing up island-inspired fare, including tacos & salad.

Website ↗

Hopping hot spot with Day of the Dead decor & a menu of Mexican street food & gluten-free beers.

425 Greene St

Hopping hot spot with Day of the Dead decor & a menu of Mexican street food & gluten-free beers.

Website ↗

A limited menu of shellfish-centric classics is offered with beer & wine in a casual, coastal space.

507 South St

A limited menu of shellfish-centric classics is offered with beer & wine in a casual, coastal space.

Website ↗

Sunset Pier

Restaurants

Relaxed dockside seafood eatery at the Ocean Key Resort & Spa with water views, drinks & live music.

0 Duval St

Relaxed dockside seafood eatery at the Ocean Key Resort & Spa with water views, drinks & live music.

Website ↗

A sunny cafe serving crêpes for breakfast & lunch in cozy open-kitchen digs or on an outdoor patio.

300 Petronia St #1

A sunny cafe serving crêpes for breakfast & lunch in cozy open-kitchen digs or on an outdoor patio.

Website ↗

Veteran Cuban eatery draws crowds with rustic look, live music & Mallory Square sunset celebration.

Mallory Square, 410 Wall St

Veteran Cuban eatery draws crowds with rustic look, live music & Mallory Square sunset celebration.

Website ↗

This white-tablecloth mainstay offers Italian classics & an extensive martini menu.

3593 S Roosevelt Blvd

This white-tablecloth mainstay offers Italian classics & an extensive martini menu.

Website ↗

Mr. Z's

Restaurants

Counter-serve joint dishing thin-crust pizzas, stromboli & Philly cheesesteaks in laid-back digs.

501 Southard St

Counter-serve joint dishing thin-crust pizzas, stromboli & Philly cheesesteaks in laid-back digs.

Website ↗

Casual eatery, where the menu covers classic Italian favorites as well as Sicilian dishes.

112 Fitzpatrick St

Casual eatery, where the menu covers classic Italian favorites as well as Sicilian dishes.

Website ↗

Atlas Izakaya

Restaurants

Creative sushi and other Japanese small plates, plus beer, wine, and cocktails, in a trendy setting.

500 Truman Ave #7

Creative sushi and other Japanese small plates, plus beer, wine, and cocktails, in a trendy setting.

Website ↗

This white-tablecloth mainstay offers Italian classics & an extensive martini menu.

524 Duval St

This white-tablecloth mainstay offers Italian classics & an extensive martini menu.

Website ↗

Simple eatery with Asian decor & a covered patio dishing up classic Thai dishes as well as sushi.

513 Greene St

Simple eatery with Asian decor & a covered patio dishing up classic Thai dishes as well as sushi.

Website ↗

Blue Heaven

Restaurants

Iconic landmark for Floridian-Caribbean cuisine & key lime pie, with a funky setting.

729 Thomas St

Iconic landmark for Floridian-Caribbean cuisine & key lime pie, with a funky setting.

Website ↗

A red sauce-heavy menu & robust wine list are served at this quaint Italian eatery in a former home.

1208 Simonton St

A red sauce-heavy menu & robust wine list are served at this quaint Italian eatery in a former home.

Website ↗

Banana Cafe

Restaurants

French bistro, popular for breakfast, serving crêpes & other easygoing fare in a low-key setting.

1215 Duval St

French bistro, popular for breakfast, serving crêpes & other easygoing fare in a low-key setting.

Website ↗

Smoked BBQ

Restaurants

Relaxed eatery focusing on grilled meats, set in a boat with old-school decor & marina views.

1801 N Roosevelt Blvd

Relaxed eatery focusing on grilled meats, set in a boat with old-school decor & marina views.

Website ↗

Sloppy Joe's Bar

Restaurants

Open since 1933, this bar offers live music & dancing plus a separate tap room for sports-watching.

Off, 201 Duval St

Open since 1933, this bar offers live music & dancing plus a separate tap room for sports-watching.

Website ↗

Relaxed hangout for creative takes on breakfast & lunch classics with 11 varieties of Bloody Marys.

610 Greene St

Relaxed hangout for creative takes on breakfast & lunch classics with 11 varieties of Bloody Marys.

Website ↗

Little Pearl

Restaurants

Small, intimate eatery with modern decor for globally inspired seafood dishes made with local catch.

632 Olivia St

Small, intimate eatery with modern decor for globally inspired seafood dishes made with local catch.

Website ↗

Daytime bistro serving sweet & savory crepes, plus panini, wraps, salads & American breakfast fare.

1105 Key Plaza

Daytime bistro serving sweet & savory crepes, plus panini, wraps, salads & American breakfast fare.

Website ↗

Kojin Noodle Bar

Restaurants

Cosy noodle outlet with a takeout window & bar whipping up house ramen dishes.

422 Eaton St

Cosy noodle outlet with a takeout window & bar whipping up house ramen dishes.

Website ↗

Quaint shack with outdoor seating doling out arepas, beef-&-pork hamburgers & other Cuban eats.

425 Southard St

Quaint shack with outdoor seating doling out arepas, beef-&-pork hamburgers & other Cuban eats.

Website ↗

Caroline's Cafe

Restaurants

American cafe serving po' boys, conch fritters & the like in a circa-1838 house with outdoor seats.

310 Duval St

American cafe serving po' boys, conch fritters & the like in a circa-1838 house with outdoor seats.

Website ↗

Benihana

Restaurants

Hibachi chain serving Japanese dishes grilled tableside by theatrical chefs.

3591 S Roosevelt Blvd

Hibachi chain serving Japanese dishes grilled tableside by theatrical chefs.

Website ↗

Charming tapas bar pairing global small plates with house-specialty sangria in a warm room.

207 Petronia St #101

Charming tapas bar pairing global small plates with house-specialty sangria in a warm room.

Website ↗

Popular pub providing bar food on a covered outdoor patio plus live music & dancing.

400 Front St

Popular pub providing bar food on a covered outdoor patio plus live music & dancing.

Website ↗

Basic Japanese bistro & sushi bar with unpretentious atmosphere & a quaint garden patio.

1075 Duval St Ste C3

Basic Japanese bistro & sushi bar with unpretentious atmosphere & a quaint garden patio.

Website ↗

VIV Wine Bistro

Restaurants

Popular, arty wine bar with 20+ wines by the glass & 200+ bottles, plus cheeses & charcuterie.

300 Petronia St

Popular, arty wine bar with 20+ wines by the glass & 200+ bottles, plus cheeses & charcuterie.

Website ↗

Classic Thai dishes, sashimi & creative maki served in a laid-back setting with bright, arty murals.

2802 N Roosevelt Blvd

Classic Thai dishes, sashimi & creative maki served in a laid-back setting with bright, arty murals.

Website ↗

Upscale island eatery serving dishes including fish and shellfish in a laid-back setting.

920 Caroline St

Upscale island eatery serving dishes including fish and shellfish in a laid-back setting.

Website ↗

Jack Flats

Restaurants

Laid-back venue with a long bar & booths offering home-style surf 'n' turf plus sports on TV.

509 Duval St

Laid-back venue with a long bar & booths offering home-style surf 'n' turf plus sports on TV.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →