The best restaurants in Key West
55 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.
Your business could be here.
Be at the top of Key West's page when you're in Key West's newsletter.
Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.
Nine One Five (opens in a new tab)
915 Duval St #5
Settle into the Victorian charm at Nine One Five and let their eclectic fusion menu do the talking, simple no-fuss dishes cooked properly…
Sarabeth's in Key West (opens in a new tab)
530 Simonton St
If your week needs a little sunshine, Sarabeth's in Key West delivers signature brunch delights made with fresh ingredients and plenty of…
Sister Noodle House (opens in a new tab)
2502 N Roosevelt Blvd
Whether it’s a midweek pho craving or you just want a boba-fueled cooldown, Sister Noodle House turns out fresh, flavor-packed bowls and…
Mary Ellen's Bar & Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
420 Appelrouth Ln
Mary Ellen’s Bar & Restaurant is an upbeat neighborhood watering hole with a cool vibe and comfort eats, including gourmet grilled cheese.…
Garbo's Grill @ Hanks! (opens in a new tab)
409 Caroline St
Garbo's Grill serves inventive tacos, burritos, burgers and dogs from a tiny food stand at Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon. It’s a…
Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar (opens in a new tab)
223 Petronia St
Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar blends a coastal-forward raw bar with elevated seafood and cocktails, keeping the laid-back local feel…
El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown) (opens in a new tab)
900 Catherine St
When you're in the mood for traditional Cuban home cooking that doesn't torch your wallet, El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown) hits the spot…
Doc's on Duval (opens in a new tab)
708 Duval St
Doc's on Duval serves Southern-inspired comfort classics, BBQ, and fresh seafood, with a balcony for cocktails and Duval people-watching…
Key West Cooking Show (opens in a new tab)
291 Front St Ste 207
Skip the tourist traps and catch the Key West Cooking Show, where chefs demo Conch-inspired dishes while you eat, then cap it with a Key…
Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar (opens in a new tab)
7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300
Whether you want fresh-caught fish, coastal classics, or New American comfort with island style, Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar delivers…
Misohappy Sushi and Thai (opens in a new tab)
504 Southard St
Misohappy Sushi and Thai is that rare Key West standby that nails creative sushi with a regional Thai menu, all in a laid back, compact…
Mangia Mangia (opens in a new tab)
900 Southard St
Mangia Mangia keeps it simple in the best way, with fresh house-made pastas, herb-bright sauces, and plenty of Key West flair from conch…
CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee (opens in a new tab)
815 Sigsbee Rd Bldg No. V-4111
CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee keeps locals fed with all-day breakfast pie, legit cheesesteaks, burgers and hand-tossed pizza, plus jumbo…
Bel Mare Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
700 Front St
When pasta dreams meet the Key West Bight, Bel Mare Restaurant delivers coastal Italian fine dining with homemade pasta, beautifully fresh…
Harpoon Harry's (opens in a new tab)
832 Caroline St
Harpoon Harry's is the kind of no-nonsense spot locals keep in their back pocket, slinging breakfast favorites, stacked handhelds, and…
Moondog Cafe Key West (opens in a new tab)
823 Whitehead St
Moondog Cafe Key West serves breakfast and lunch, then shifts to dinner and drinks, with a bakery in the mix too. It’s a relaxed spot to…
Onlywood Italian Restaurant at Santa Maria Suites – Pasta , Pinsa , Pizza (opens in a new tab)
1401 Simonton St
Onlywood Italian Restaurant at Santa Maria Suites – Pasta, Pinsa, Pizza does the simple things right: handcrafted pasta, wood-fired pies,…
One Love Food Truck (opens in a new tab)
5220 US-1 · Naval Air Station Key West
One Love Food Truck is the local move for jerk chicken that actually tastes like jerk, plus Hot Tuna Tacos that snagged Best Main Dish at…
Pop's Smoke Shed - Big Pine Key (opens in a new tab)
31251 Ave A · Big Pine Key
Relaxed restaurant specializing in BBQ brisket, ribs and pulled pork, served via food truck or dine-in service.
Sushi Song - Key West (opens in a new tab)
925 Duval St
Whether you're post-shift hungry or just avoiding bedtime, Sushi Song - Key West rolls out creative hits like the Red Velvet Voodoo Roll,…
Kaya Island Eats (opens in a new tab)
618 Duval St
Kaya Island Eats keeps it lively for locals, with Ahi Pok Nachos, Jamaican Jerk Chicken, Coconut Curry Veggie Bowls, and Kahula Pork…
Amigos Tortilla Bar (opens in a new tab)
425 Greene St
Amigos Tortilla Bar brings fresh, simple Mexican food and Day of the Dead flair to the table, with gluten-free beer for a festive pairing.…
The Lobster Shack Key West (opens in a new tab)
507 South St
When you want classic, no nonsense seafood without the menu novel, The Lobster Shack Key West keeps it tight with shellfish-centric staples…
Sunset Pier (opens in a new tab)
0 Duval St
Between the waterline views, tropical libations, and nightly live music, Sunset Pier nails the laid-back Keys vibe without trying too hard.…
La Crêperie French Café Key West (opens in a new tab)
300 Petronia St #1
La Crêperie French Café Key West does breakfast and lunch the way your slow mornings deserve, with delicate crêpes, savory galettes, and a…
El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar (opens in a new tab)
Mallory Square, 410 Wall St
El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar keeps the island heartbeat going with authentic Cuban plates like lechon asado, ropa vieja and…
Key West Poké House (opens in a new tab)
500 Truman Ave Unit 1
Whether you swear by the signature "Catch em All" or like to freestyle with your own base, proteins, toppings, and unique sauces and…
La Trattoria Oceanside (opens in a new tab)
3593 S Roosevelt Blvd
Craving a grown-up pasta night with a proper martini? La Trattoria Oceanside has been doing it right since 1983 with locally caught…
Mr. Z's (opens in a new tab)
501 Southard St
Mr. Z's has been bringing the real-deal Philadelphia cheesesteak to Key West since 2002, with your choice of Whiz or sharp provolone on a…
Bruschetta Francesca (opens in a new tab)
112 Fitzpatrick St
Bruschetta Francesca nails that Palermo-to-Key West vibe with arancina, crisp calamari, and rotating family recipes from the owner’s mom…
Atlas Izakaya (opens in a new tab)
500 Truman Ave #7
Atlas Izakaya is the kind of chef-owned, family-run spot you pop into for creative sushi, shareable Japanese small plates, and a smart…
La Trattoria Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
524 Duval St
A Key West standby since 1983, La Trattoria Restaurant nails the white-tablecloth vibe without the fuss, serving real-deal Italian…
Thai Cuisine and Sushi Bar (opens in a new tab)
513 Greene St
Owners from Thailand’s Isaan region turn out truly authentic Thai, from fragrant lemongrass and galanga-laced curries to basil stir-fries,…
Eleven Eleven Food Truck (opens in a new tab)
1111 Eaton St
Eleven Eleven Food Truck nails the island-morning trifecta with strong Cuban coffee, flaky homemade empanadas, and breakfast sandwiches…
Lola's Bistro Key West (opens in a new tab)
728 Simonton St
For branzino, duck, or filet mignon in a relaxed, intimate setting, Lola’s Bistro Key West makes a lovely local pick when dinner deserves a…
Blue Heaven (opens in a new tab)
729 Thomas St
Blue Heaven does Floridian-Caribbean plates with that laid-back, slightly eccentric vibe locals actually love. Go for the locally driven,…
Abbondanza Italian Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
1208 Simonton St
Abbondanza Italian Restaurant keeps it cozy in three converted cigar-makers cottages, pouring a solid wine selection and turning out the…
Banana Cafe (opens in a new tab)
1215 Duval St
Banana Cafe keeps locals well fed with French bistro vibes, craveable crêpes, and unfussy breakfast and lunch that slides into dinner…
Smoked BBQ (opens in a new tab)
1801 N Roosevelt Blvd
Smoked BBQ is the locals' move when you want real hickory and cherry wood smoke working overtime on prime brisket, melty burnt ends, and…
Sloppy Joe's Bar (opens in a new tab)
Off, 201 Duval St
Open since 1933, Sloppy Joe's Bar delivers daily live music, a lively dance floor, and Joe's Tap Room when you want to watch the game, plus…
Sunny Eggs (opens in a new tab)
517 Fleming St
Sunny Eggs brings French-inspired breakfast to Key West, with comforting classics, on-site pastries, and options for vegan, vegetarian, and…
The Breakfast Club, Too (opens in a new tab)
610 Greene St
The Breakfast Club, Too keeps brunch interesting with creative spins on breakfast and lunch staples, plus 11 varieties of Bloody Marys that…
Checked Sep 25
Little Pearl (opens in a new tab)
632 Olivia St
Tucked in Old Town, Little Pearl is a neighborhood restaurant and wine bar dialing up fresh local catch with a tropical twist. Think a…
Key Plaza Creperie - All Day Breakfast & Lunch Key West (opens in a new tab)
1105 Key Plaza
Key Plaza Creperie - All Day Breakfast & Lunch Key West is your European-style bistro for all-day breakfast and lunch, with authentic…
Kojin Noodle Bar (opens in a new tab)
422 Eaton St
Whether you need a quick takeout slurp or a seat at the bar, Kojin Noodle Bar turns out ramen-inspired bowls with savory broths, fresh…
Frita's Cuban Burgers (opens in a new tab)
425 Southard St
Whether you're sneaking out between errands or plotting a low-key dinner, Frita's Cuban Burgers delivers the real-deal frita, a…
Caroline's Cafe (opens in a new tab)
310 Duval St
Locals know Caroline's Cafe for unfussy island charm, a friendly crew, and plates that hit the Key West sweet spot, from Caribbean Steak to…
Benihana (opens in a new tab)
3591 S Roosevelt Blvd
Sometimes you want dinner to do more than just feed you. Benihana brings the sizzle to the table with teppanyaki chefs who lean into…
Santiago's Bodega (opens in a new tab)
207 Petronia St #101
Locals keep Santiago's Bodega in the rotation for global tapas and small plates, best with a glass of their house sangria or a good wine.…
Hog's Breath Saloon (opens in a new tab)
400 Front St
Hog's Breath Saloon keeps the island soundtrack rolling with live music, cold drinks, and a better-than-it-needs-to-be raw bar. Grab a seat…
Origami Sushi Bar (opens in a new tab)
1075 Duval St Ste C3
Low-key and reliably fresh, Origami Sushi Bar has been rolling Key West since 1995 with spicy rolls, Origami special rolls, and a…
VIV Wine Bistro (opens in a new tab)
300 Petronia St
If you like your evenings French-accented and unhurried, Viv Wine Bistro lines up 20+ wines by the glass and 200+ bottles in an arty,…
Seagrass Thai & Sushi (opens in a new tab)
2802 N Roosevelt Blvd
Whether your week needs a curry kick or a maki moment, Seagrass Thai & Sushi nails both with comforting Thai favorites and signature sushi…
Square Grouper Key West (opens in a new tab)
920 Caroline St
Square Grouper Key West keeps locals happy with consistently great, fresh local seafood and creative touches like conch schnitzel, island…
Jack Flats (opens in a new tab)
509 Duval St
When you want dinner that tastes like someone cooked for you, Jack Flats nails the laid-back, local vibe with comfort classics done right.…
Nothing here matches that.
Try a shorter word, or look through every kind of place in Key West.
Know a great place we’re missing? Email hello@baselocal.com
The best of Key West, every morning
New places show up in the Key West newsletter first. It's free.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.