The best restaurants in Elkhart County

40 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Elkhart County’s best · Shopping · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Home & Garden · Arts & Culture · Health & Wellness · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Entertainment · Nightlife

Pinned in Elkhart County today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Elkhart County — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 40 places · showing the latest additions first

Bird in the Hand

Restaurants

Bird in the Hand is the no-drama dinner move, serving fried or grilled chicken sandwiches that hit the comfort-food sweet spot without…

210 E Jackson Blvd (Elkhart)

Bird in the Hand is the no-drama dinner move, serving fried or grilled chicken sandwiches that hit the comfort-food sweet spot without slowing you down. Swing by this week when you want something crispy or flame-kissed, plus the kind of chill vibe that makes a quick meal feel like a win.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Craving something beyond pepperoni this week? Bambino's Home Pizza stacks the menu with fun picks like the No Kiss Tonight (garlic chicken…

1832 Cassopolis St Suite B (Elkhart)

Craving something beyond pepperoni this week? Bambino's Home Pizza stacks the menu with fun picks like the No Kiss Tonight (garlic chicken on alfredo), Spicy Italian loaded with heat, and a Mediterranean pie with lemon-garlic chicken and kalamata olives, plus wings, calzones, baked pastas and gluten-free pies.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Flippin Cow

Restaurants

When a burger craving hits and you want the water view, Flippin Cow keeps it simple and fun with hand-crafted burgers, crispy fries, famous…

51330 IN-19 (Elkhart)

When a burger craving hits and you want the water view, Flippin Cow keeps it simple and fun with hand-crafted burgers, crispy fries, famous milkshakes, and a solid craft beer lineup featuring their own Fat Hop on tap, perfect for low-key Elkhart nights.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗

Locals keep The Tipsy Biscuit in the rotation for that signature bacon gravy and biscuits, cozy vibes, and a drinks list that runs from…

103 N 5th St (Goshen)

Locals keep The Tipsy Biscuit in the rotation for that signature bacon gravy and biscuits, cozy vibes, and a drinks list that runs from mimosas to spiked coffees. They also cover your crew with vegan, keto, and gluten-free options, plus hearty sandwiches when breakfast becomes lunch.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Elkhart County business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Smokin' Fatty's BBQ keeps things laid-back with legit brisket and ribs, crispy chicken, and even some seafood, plus a cold beer to back it…

3241 Interchange Dr (Elkhart)

Smokin' Fatty's BBQ keeps things laid-back with legit brisket and ribs, crispy chicken, and even some seafood, plus a cold beer to back it up. Easy online ordering, catering, and reservations for big groups make it a handy go-to when your crew in Elkhart wants smoke-kissed comfort.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 17, 2026

Website ↗

With rich Italian heritage and an elegant family vibe, Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano serves real Italian food with premium quality at…

28046 Co Rd 16 (Elkhart)

With rich Italian heritage and an elegant family vibe, Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano serves real Italian food with premium quality at prices that feel friendly. Planning a midweek hangout or family celebration in Elkhart? They also do catering, so you can bring that taste of Italy to your crew.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 20, 2026

Website ↗

Sophisticated restaurant featuring steaks and other classic dishes at the heart of an upscale experience.

333 Nibco Pkwy (Elkhart)

Sophisticated restaurant featuring steaks and other classic dishes at the heart of an upscale experience.

Website ↗

Toasted Turtle Tavern is now serving dinner, the kind of low-key neighborhood spot you keep in your back pocket. Solid, no-fuss comfort…

51425 IN-19 (Elkhart)

Toasted Turtle Tavern is now serving dinner, the kind of low-key neighborhood spot you keep in your back pocket. Solid, no-fuss comfort food vibes and easy carryout when you’re not in the mood to cook... it’s got “regulars welcome” written all over it.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

El Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria keeps it casual with solid Mexican staples, from saucy enchiladas to crispy tripa tacos, plus a cold beer…

1832 Cassopolis St (Elkhart)

El Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria keeps it casual with solid Mexican staples, from saucy enchiladas to crispy tripa tacos, plus a cold beer to seal the deal. Great for weeknight cravings or a low-key meet-up when you want big flavor without the fuss.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

Hot Dog Eddy's

Restaurants

Hot Dog Eddy's nails that relaxed, Chicago-inspired hot dog experience locals love, with snappy dogs dressed right and a breakfast menu for…

606 S Main St (Elkhart) · ✓ checked Aug 27

Hot Dog Eddy's nails that relaxed, Chicago-inspired hot dog experience locals love, with snappy dogs dressed right and a breakfast menu for early appetites. It’s the kind of easy, no-fuss spot you swing by when you want flavor without overthinking it.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

Wings Etc.

Restaurants

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

105 County Rd 6 W (Elkhart)

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

Website ↗

Bangkok Place by Kami keeps it simple in the best way, turning out classic Thai comfort with a low-key vibe, plenty of vegetarian options…

705 Co Rd 6 (Elkhart)

Bangkok Place by Kami keeps it simple in the best way, turning out classic Thai comfort with a low-key vibe, plenty of vegetarian options and zero fuss. When a noodle craving hits, their shrimp rolls and mango sticky rice seal the deal, and online ordering makes weeknights wonderfully easy.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Chubby Trout

Restaurants

When the table wants steak night and sushi in one place, Chubby Trout delivers with hearty steaks, seafood, and a legit sushi lineup, plus…

3421 Plaza Ct (Elkhart)

When the table wants steak night and sushi in one place, Chubby Trout delivers with hearty steaks, seafood, and a legit sushi lineup, plus craft beers and mixed drinks. Easygoing local hang that works for weeknights, group dinners, or those order online nights.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Goshen Noodles

Restaurants

Whether you need something quick after work or a cozy weekend treat, Goshen Noodles brings Goshen the real-deal flavors of Vietnam, with…

1303 College Ave (Goshen)

Whether you need something quick after work or a cozy weekend treat, Goshen Noodles brings Goshen the real-deal flavors of Vietnam, with slurp-friendly bowls and bright, clean tastes that wake up your palate without weighing you down. Add it to your go-to list this week.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 15, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you're decompressing after work or plotting a breezy date night, The Jackson Rooftop delivers easygoing cocktails, beers, wine,…

240 E Jackson Blvd 4th floor (Elkhart)

Whether you're decompressing after work or plotting a breezy date night, The Jackson Rooftop delivers easygoing cocktails, beers, wine, shareable snacks, and the kind of rooftop views that make Elkhart evenings feel special. Casual, stylish, and reliably fun, it's an easy go-to for low-key hangs with a little sparkle.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 14, 2026

Website ↗

Hall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs is family-owned and right here in Elkhart, serving hot, garlicky breadsticks and pizzas you can customize…

2930 S Nappanee St (Elkhart)

Hall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs is family-owned and right here in Elkhart, serving hot, garlicky breadsticks and pizzas you can customize with over 50 toppings, 6 sauces, and multiple sizes. Round it out with oven-baked subs, hearty pastas, or a crisp salad, then enjoy the instant-addiction vibes.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Wings Etc.

Restaurants

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

23222 US-33 (Elkhart)

Relaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.

Website ↗

The Corner Bar

Restaurants

Downtown feels a little better with The Corner Bar turning scratch-made comfort food into small victories, from volcano shrimp and gourmet…

502 S Main St (Elkhart)

Downtown feels a little better with The Corner Bar turning scratch-made comfort food into small victories, from volcano shrimp and gourmet burgers to Irish nachos, plus seasonal frozen cocktails, wine flights, and fun trivia nights. Slide in for a craft pour and flavors that hit sweet, salty, and spicy just right.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 22, 2026

Website ↗

523 Tap & Grill

Restaurants

523 Tap & Grill nails that polished, sophisticated vibe locals reach for when steak sounds right and seafood or pastas tempt you instead.…

523 S Main St (Elkhart)

523 Tap & Grill nails that polished, sophisticated vibe locals reach for when steak sounds right and seafood or pastas tempt you instead. Add a lineup of creative martinis and it's an easy pick for birthdays, client dinners, or just proving you own something besides hoodies.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Osteria Amici

Restaurants

Osteria Amici leans into comforting Italian classics with house made spaghetti, spot-on pomodoro and vodka sauces, and the kind of tiramisu…

240 E Jackson Blvd (Elkhart)

Osteria Amici leans into comforting Italian classics with house made spaghetti, spot-on pomodoro and vodka sauces, and the kind of tiramisu you pretend to split but don’t. If pasta isn’t calling, there are pizzas, steaks, and seafood, plus kid-friendly plates for those high-stakes family negotiations.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 12, 2026

Website ↗

The Vine

Restaurants

With wines from around the world and a menu shaped by Executive Chef Brian “Chef Cappy” Caplinger, The Vine nails that relaxed,…

214 S Main St (Elkhart)

With wines from around the world and a menu shaped by Executive Chef Brian “Chef Cappy” Caplinger, The Vine nails that relaxed, contemporary bistro vibe in downtown Elkhart. Think craveable steaks, pizzas, and plates that feel special without the fuss, whether you're sliding in at lunch or settling into an easy dinner.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

Los Cabos Mexican Grill and Bar is that reliable Elkhart spot for tasty, no-drama Mexican classics and genuinely friendly service, whether…

3011 Belvedere Rd Ste 101 (Elkhart)

Los Cabos Mexican Grill and Bar is that reliable Elkhart spot for tasty, no-drama Mexican classics and genuinely friendly service, whether you’re grabbing quick online takeout or settling in with the crew. Zero pretension, just flavorful plates that hit the spot on busy weeknights and lazy Sundays.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Jade Garden

Restaurants

Craving both? Jade Garden pairs classic Chinese favorites like lo mein, fried rice, and egg foo young with fresh-made sushi rolls, all fast…

1308 S Nappanee St (Elkhart)

Craving both? Jade Garden pairs classic Chinese favorites like lo mein, fried rice, and egg foo young with fresh-made sushi rolls, all fast and flavorful. Great for a midweek pick-me-up or quick takeout when cooking sounds ambitious and the leftovers are giving you side-eye.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Since 1957, Volcano Pizza / Poplar Court has been the dependable answer when you want no-nonsense, craveable pizza that tastes like…

1900 Berry St Ste G (Elkhart)

Since 1957, Volcano Pizza / Poplar Court has been the dependable answer when you want no-nonsense, craveable pizza that tastes like childhood Friday nights. Cheesy, slightly addictive, and proudly Elkhart, it’s the kind of standby you keep in your back pocket for an easy win.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 21, 2026

Website ↗

Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place has been an Elkhart staple since 1957, turning out Neopolitan-style pies with that crispy-cheesy edge…

126 Easy Shopping Pl (Elkhart)

Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place has been an Elkhart staple since 1957, turning out Neopolitan-style pies with that crispy-cheesy edge plus those beloved sausage subs and other Italian standbys. Reliable, unfussy and local through and through, it’s the kind of spot you order from when everyone nods yes.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

4568-600 Elkhart Rd (Elkhart)

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant serving a variety of ramen options and bubble teas.

129 S Main St (Elkhart)

Casual restaurant serving a variety of ramen options and bubble teas.

Website ↗

Spanish meets Japanese with a Venezuelan twist at Madrid & Tokio Fusion Bar, where sushi shares the spotlight with creative plates and a…

600 S Main St (Elkhart)

Spanish meets Japanese with a Venezuelan twist at Madrid & Tokio Fusion Bar, where sushi shares the spotlight with creative plates and a lively bar vibe. Swing by for flavorful lunch or dinner, then circle back on the weekend when downtown Elkhart turns up and the place becomes a proper dancey nightlife scene.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

If your crew needs a no-fuss spot with 50 beers on tap, proper cocktails, and a menu that actually satisfies, Tradewinds & The…

3147 Northview Dr (Elkhart)

If your crew needs a no-fuss spot with 50 beers on tap, proper cocktails, and a menu that actually satisfies, Tradewinds & The Galley-Elkhart LLC has you covered. Post up this week for live music, giant screens, and a game room with darts, pool, shuffleboard, even skee ball, then call it a week well spent.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

Family-run since 1979 and boasting a World Pizza Champion legacy, Antonio's Italian Restaurant serves Chicago-style and gourmet pies…

1105 Goshen Ave (Elkhart)

Family-run since 1979 and boasting a World Pizza Champion legacy, Antonio's Italian Restaurant serves Chicago-style and gourmet pies alongside comforting Southern Italian classics.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

Milano's Pizza

Restaurants

Milano's Pizza has been family owned since 1983 and still turns out homemade, made-to-order pies and comforting pasta the way your week…

2808 S Main St (Elkhart)

Milano's Pizza has been family owned since 1983 and still turns out homemade, made-to-order pies and comforting pasta the way your week needs it. Ideal for a low-key date or gathering with the crew, it’s the kind of reliable, cozy classic Elkhart folks claim as theirs.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 19, 2026

Website ↗

This week, La Casa Del Tamal is calling your name with tamales, saucy chilaquiles, elote en vaso, and tortas that hit the spot. Feeling…

1101 W Beardsley Ave (Elkhart)

This week, La Casa Del Tamal is calling your name with tamales, saucy chilaquiles, elote en vaso, and tortas that hit the spot. Feeling adventurous, try the torta tamal or go classic with combo tacos... and yes, they even do ultras fries if you need that extra crunch.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 17, 2026

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

187 County Rd W (Elkhart)

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Artisan

Restaurants

Whether it's date night or a ‘we earned this’ Tuesday, Artisan nails seasonal, local, exceptional regional American plates paired with…

505 S Main St (Elkhart)

Whether it's date night or a ‘we earned this’ Tuesday, Artisan nails seasonal, local, exceptional regional American plates paired with wines and craft cocktails in a chic setting. There’s a light bar menu, a dedicated vegetarian and vegan lineup, and even Artisan To Go for those couch-first nights.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

Traditional Italian meals at this homey family-owned & -operated eatery in business since 1917.

528 Harrison St (Elkhart)

Traditional Italian meals at this homey family-owned & -operated eatery in business since 1917.

Website ↗

Heinnies

Restaurants

Heinnies is the dependable hometown spot when you want a legit cut cooked right, from juicy New York Strip and prime rib to flaky haddock…

1743 W Lusher Ave (Elkhart)

Heinnies is the dependable hometown spot when you want a legit cut cooked right, from juicy New York Strip and prime rib to flaky haddock and charbroiled salmon. Grab crispy potato wedges and finish with the carrot cake or those famous donuts this week.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 23, 2026

Website ↗

Rico's at the Bulldog is the local go-to for delicious handhelds and entrées, especially those wildly special burgers that land with kettle…

3763 E Jackson Blvd Unit 3 (Elkhart)

Rico's at the Bulldog is the local go-to for delicious handhelds and entrées, especially those wildly special burgers that land with kettle chips and a pickle spear. This week, pair it with a great brew or proper cocktail, then call it a business lunch or a friends’ night out, your pick.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

Craving comfort with a little sizzle, Cubiletes Mexican Bar and Grill keeps it classic with authentic street-style tacos crowned with…

4100 E Bristol St #1 (Elkhart)

Craving comfort with a little sizzle, Cubiletes Mexican Bar and Grill keeps it classic with authentic street-style tacos crowned with cilantro and onion, gooey quesadillas, flat top fajitas, and their cheesy Pollo Cubetazo. Perfect for a midweek pick-me-up when the fridge is judging you.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, August 24, 2026

Website ↗

Need an easy win for dinner that entertains the crew too? Sakura Japanese Steakhouse brings the hibachi flair right to your table with…

151 County Rd 6 W (Elkhart)

Need an easy win for dinner that entertains the crew too? Sakura Japanese Steakhouse brings the hibachi flair right to your table with chefs who make veggies fly, plus a sushi bar that hits both classic rolls and craveable specials. It’s weeknight happiness without the sink full of dishes.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

An old-school carhop scene with frosty mugs and homemade root beer, Simonton Lake Drive-In keeps things simple and delicious. Order a…

3724 Cassopolis St (Elkhart)

An old-school carhop scene with frosty mugs and homemade root beer, Simonton Lake Drive-In keeps things simple and delicious. Order a cooked-to-order burger, a giant basket of fries, then cruise in for the nostalgia... sometimes literal cruise-ins roll through.

From the Elkhart County newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →