The best restaurants in Elkhart County
40 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.
Browse another shelf: all of Elkhart County’s best · Shopping · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Home & Garden · Arts & Culture · Health & Wellness · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Entertainment · Nightlife
Pinned in Elkhart County today
This spot is open today.
Two pinned places a day in Elkhart County — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →Paid placements are always marked.
Bird in the Hand
RestaurantsBird in the Hand is the no-drama dinner move, serving fried or grilled chicken sandwiches that hit the comfort-food sweet spot without…
Bird in the Hand
RestaurantsBambino's Home Pizza
RestaurantsCraving something beyond pepperoni this week? Bambino's Home Pizza stacks the menu with fun picks like the No Kiss Tonight (garlic chicken…
Bambino's Home Pizza
RestaurantsFlippin Cow
RestaurantsWhen a burger craving hits and you want the water view, Flippin Cow keeps it simple and fun with hand-crafted burgers, crispy fries, famous…
Flippin Cow
RestaurantsThe Tipsy Biscuit
RestaurantsLocals keep The Tipsy Biscuit in the rotation for that signature bacon gravy and biscuits, cozy vibes, and a drinks list that runs from…
The Tipsy Biscuit
RestaurantsSmokin Fattys BBQ
RestaurantsSmokin' Fatty's BBQ keeps things laid-back with legit brisket and ribs, crispy chicken, and even some seafood, plus a cold beer to back it…
Smokin Fattys BBQ
RestaurantsPer Bacco Ristorante Italiano
RestaurantsWith rich Italian heritage and an elegant family vibe, Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano serves real Italian food with premium quality at…
Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano
RestaurantsEssence Restaurant + Bar
RestaurantsSophisticated restaurant featuring steaks and other classic dishes at the heart of an upscale experience.
Essence Restaurant + Bar
RestaurantsToasted Turtle Tavern
RestaurantsToasted Turtle Tavern is now serving dinner, the kind of low-key neighborhood spot you keep in your back pocket. Solid, no-fuss comfort…
Toasted Turtle Tavern
RestaurantsEl Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria
RestaurantsEl Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria keeps it casual with solid Mexican staples, from saucy enchiladas to crispy tripa tacos, plus a cold beer…
El Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria
RestaurantsHot Dog Eddy's
RestaurantsHot Dog Eddy's nails that relaxed, Chicago-inspired hot dog experience locals love, with snappy dogs dressed right and a breakfast menu for…
Hot Dog Eddy's
RestaurantsWings Etc.
RestaurantsRelaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.
Wings Etc.
RestaurantsBangkok Place by Kami
RestaurantsBangkok Place by Kami keeps it simple in the best way, turning out classic Thai comfort with a low-key vibe, plenty of vegetarian options…
Bangkok Place by Kami
RestaurantsChubby Trout
RestaurantsWhen the table wants steak night and sushi in one place, Chubby Trout delivers with hearty steaks, seafood, and a legit sushi lineup, plus…
Chubby Trout
RestaurantsGoshen Noodles
RestaurantsWhether you need something quick after work or a cozy weekend treat, Goshen Noodles brings Goshen the real-deal flavors of Vietnam, with…
Goshen Noodles
RestaurantsThe Jackson Rooftop
RestaurantsWhether you're decompressing after work or plotting a breezy date night, The Jackson Rooftop delivers easygoing cocktails, beers, wine,…
The Jackson Rooftop
RestaurantsHall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs
RestaurantsHall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs is family-owned and right here in Elkhart, serving hot, garlicky breadsticks and pizzas you can customize…
Hall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs
RestaurantsWings Etc.
RestaurantsRelaxed sports bar serving wings & beer.
Wings Etc.
RestaurantsThe Corner Bar
RestaurantsDowntown feels a little better with The Corner Bar turning scratch-made comfort food into small victories, from volcano shrimp and gourmet…
The Corner Bar
Restaurants523 Tap & Grill
Restaurants523 Tap & Grill nails that polished, sophisticated vibe locals reach for when steak sounds right and seafood or pastas tempt you instead.…
523 Tap & Grill
RestaurantsOsteria Amici
RestaurantsOsteria Amici leans into comforting Italian classics with house made spaghetti, spot-on pomodoro and vodka sauces, and the kind of tiramisu…
Osteria Amici
RestaurantsThe Vine
RestaurantsWith wines from around the world and a menu shaped by Executive Chef Brian “Chef Cappy” Caplinger, The Vine nails that relaxed,…
The Vine
RestaurantsLos Cabos Mexican Grill and Bar
RestaurantsLos Cabos Mexican Grill and Bar is that reliable Elkhart spot for tasty, no-drama Mexican classics and genuinely friendly service, whether…
Los Cabos Mexican Grill and Bar
RestaurantsJade Garden
RestaurantsCraving both? Jade Garden pairs classic Chinese favorites like lo mein, fried rice, and egg foo young with fresh-made sushi rolls, all fast…
Jade Garden
RestaurantsVolcano Pizza / Poplar Court
RestaurantsSince 1957, Volcano Pizza / Poplar Court has been the dependable answer when you want no-nonsense, craveable pizza that tastes like…
Volcano Pizza / Poplar Court
RestaurantsVolcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place
RestaurantsVolcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place has been an Elkhart staple since 1957, turning out Neopolitan-style pies with that crispy-cheesy edge…
Volcano Pizza / Easy Shopping Place
RestaurantsWingstop
RestaurantsCasual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.
Wingstop
RestaurantsAfuri Ramen and Boba Tea
RestaurantsCasual restaurant serving a variety of ramen options and bubble teas.
Afuri Ramen and Boba Tea
RestaurantsMadrid&Tokio Fusion Bar
RestaurantsSpanish meets Japanese with a Venezuelan twist at Madrid & Tokio Fusion Bar, where sushi shares the spotlight with creative plates and a…
Madrid&Tokio Fusion Bar
RestaurantsTradewinds & The Galley-Elkhart LLC
RestaurantsIf your crew needs a no-fuss spot with 50 beers on tap, proper cocktails, and a menu that actually satisfies, Tradewinds & The…
Tradewinds & The Galley-Elkhart LLC
RestaurantsAntonio's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsFamily-run since 1979 and boasting a World Pizza Champion legacy, Antonio's Italian Restaurant serves Chicago-style and gourmet pies…
Antonio's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsMilano's Pizza
RestaurantsMilano's Pizza has been family owned since 1983 and still turns out homemade, made-to-order pies and comforting pasta the way your week…
Milano's Pizza
RestaurantsLA CASA DEL TAMAL
RestaurantsThis week, La Casa Del Tamal is calling your name with tamales, saucy chilaquiles, elote en vaso, and tortas that hit the spot. Feeling…
LA CASA DEL TAMAL
RestaurantsWingstop
RestaurantsCasual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.
Wingstop
RestaurantsArtisan
RestaurantsWhether it's date night or a ‘we earned this’ Tuesday, Artisan nails seasonal, local, exceptional regional American plates paired with…
Artisan
RestaurantsMichael's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsTraditional Italian meals at this homey family-owned & -operated eatery in business since 1917.
Michael's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsHeinnies
RestaurantsHeinnies is the dependable hometown spot when you want a legit cut cooked right, from juicy New York Strip and prime rib to flaky haddock…
Heinnies
RestaurantsRico's at the Bulldog
RestaurantsRico's at the Bulldog is the local go-to for delicious handhelds and entrées, especially those wildly special burgers that land with kettle…
Rico's at the Bulldog
RestaurantsCubiletes Mexican Bar and Grill
RestaurantsCraving comfort with a little sizzle, Cubiletes Mexican Bar and Grill keeps it classic with authentic street-style tacos crowned with…
Cubiletes Mexican Bar and Grill
RestaurantsSakura Japanese Steakhouse
RestaurantsNeed an easy win for dinner that entertains the crew too? Sakura Japanese Steakhouse brings the hibachi flair right to your table with…
Sakura Japanese Steakhouse
RestaurantsSimonton Lake Drive-In
RestaurantsAn old-school carhop scene with frosty mugs and homemade root beer, Simonton Lake Drive-In keeps things simple and delicious. Order a…
Simonton Lake Drive-In
RestaurantsNothing matched that. Know a spot we’re missing? Tell us →
Listed here?
You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →
New spots land in the newsletter first
Free, every morning — this list is what we've already told Elkhart County about.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.