The best bakeries & sweet shops in Evansville

6 bakeries & sweet shops we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Evansville’s best · Restaurants · Beauty · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Arts & Culture · Nightlife · Entertainment · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Home & Garden · Health & Wellness · Shopping

Pinned in Evansville today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Evansville — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Bakeries & Sweets · 6 places · showing the latest additions first

Piece of Cake

Bakeries & Sweets

From custom wedding cakes that nail your vibe to cupcakes frosted daily, fresh-baked cookies, pies, party trays, and even gluten free…

210 Main St

“From custom wedding cakes that nail your vibe to cupcakes frosted daily, fresh-baked cookies, pies, party trays, and even gluten free options, Piece of Cake makes every get together sweeter. Check them out this week for birthdays, office treats, or the midweek pick me up you absolutely deserve.”

Website ↗

Old Fashion Candy Co.

Bakeries & Sweets

For local groups, teams, or classrooms in Evansville, Old Fashion Candy Co. does name-brand candy and snack fundraisers with easy…

2546 Eastside Park Rd

“For local groups, teams, or classrooms in Evansville, Old Fashion Candy Co. does name-brand candy and snack fundraisers with easy assortments, clear guidance, and a prize program. Since 1970, they’ve helped schools and clubs raise money the low-drama way...”

From the Evansville newsletter, August 4, 2026

Website ↗

Stephen Libs Finer Chocolates

Bakeries & Sweets

Candy shop offering an array of hand-made chocolates such as turtles, plus malted milk balls.

6225 Vogel Rd

“Candy shop offering an array of hand-made chocolates such as turtles, plus malted milk balls.”

Website ↗

Insomnia Cookies

Bakeries & Sweets

Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.

318 Main St #100

“Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.”

Website ↗

Run a Evansville business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Bakeries & Sweets

Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.

6436 E Florida St Ste 100

“Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.”

Website ↗

Sweet Schmitt's Candy

Bakeries & Sweets

Family-run shop specializing in caramels, truffles, and homemade marshmallows.

422 N Main St

“Family-run shop specializing in caramels, truffles, and homemade marshmallows.”

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →