The best bakeries & sweet shops in Evansville

“Bakery Feeds turns bakery and snack residuals into high-energy, bio-secure animal feed ingredients, and even provides custom equipment, 24-hour maintenance, accurate data and reliable pickups so local producers help keep waste out of rogue markets and landfills.”

From the Henderson newsletter, September 10, 2026

“From custom wedding cakes that nail your vibe to cupcakes frosted daily, fresh-baked cookies, pies, party trays, and even gluten free options, Piece of Cake makes every get together sweeter. Check them out this week for birthdays, office treats, or the midweek pick me up you absolutely deserve.”

From the Evansville newsletter, September 21, 2026

“For local groups, teams, or classrooms in Evansville, Old Fashion Candy Co. does name-brand candy and snack fundraisers with easy assortments, clear guidance, and a prize program. Since 1970, they’ve helped schools and clubs raise money the low-drama way...”

From the Evansville newsletter, September 15, 2026

“Cookie Plug slings fat, thick cookies that are part cake, part brownie, part cookie, so when the sweet tooth hits this week, you’re covered. They’ve got stuffed cookies, keto options, cookie ice cream sandwiches, and custom cookie cakes, plus catering if your crew needs a sugar rally.”

From the Evansville newsletter, August 18, 2026

“Locally owned and pickup only, Cookie Bite Pastry is the spot when you want fruit pastry bites, Bischoff cheesecake, pistachio treats, or even Dubai pastry without waiting on shipping. Pre-order online, then waltz in for cream puffs or a mega raspberry mousse cake that disappears fast.”

From the Evansville newsletter, September 2, 2026

“Stephen Libs Finer Chocolates deals in small-batch classics that actually taste homemade, from old-fashioned turtles and truffles to malted milk balls and other double-dipped indulgences, all made with creamy milk or rich dark chocolate that melts in your mouth.”

From the Evansville newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.”

“Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.”

“When the craving hits, Sweet Schmitt's Candy delivers the good stuff with pillowy gourmet marshmallows, buttery caramel treats, and crunchy nut clusters that somehow disappear faster than you planned. Swing by this week and stock up for TV nights, lunchbox bribes, or an emergency stash you swear is for guests.”

From the Evansville newsletter, August 29, 2026

“From a quick cafe bite to a cookie lineup that actually deserves its reputation, Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company delivers with classics like Chocolate Chunk Walnut and Snickerdoodle plus gift boxes that ship. They craft with Callebaut Belgian chocolate and can cater your next get-together.”

From the Evansville newsletter, August 24, 2026

“Be Happy Pie Company has been baking fresh, from-scratch pies daily since 2015, using high-quality ingredients that taste like someone’s favorite grandma actually showed up. Order online for pickup or ship one to a friend, and check out their new mobile app if you like dessert on speed dial.”

From the Evansville newsletter, August 13, 2026