The best bars & nightlife in New Castle
33 bars & nightlife we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.
Browse another shelf: all of New Castle’s best · Restaurants · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Shopping · Entertainment · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Home & Garden · Arts & Culture · Health & Wellness · Sporting Goods · Cafes · Services · Pets
Pinned in New Castle today
This spot is open today.
Two pinned places a day in New Castle — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →Paid placements are always marked.
Chili's Grill & Bar
NightlifeFamily-friendly chain serving classic Tex-Mex & American fare in a Southwestern-style setting.
Chili's Grill & Bar
NightlifeIf your fridge selection feels stale, Shallo's Antique Restaurant & Brewhaus revives the fun with a 500-strong beer lineup, a quirky beer…
Mel's at Commission Row
NightlifeMel's at Commission Row is a cozy speakeasy where the cocktail is the main event. Sip an Upstairs Tea or the Y.G.D.R. milk punch and snack…
Mel's at Commission Row
NightlifePlat 99
NightlifeNext time you find yourself in downtown Indy, Plat 99 at The Alexander is a sleek, art-soaked lounge where mornings mean locally roasted…
Plat 99
NightlifeBall & Biscuit
NightlifeIndy’s original craft cocktail bar, Ball & Biscuit mixes classics and inventive sips with always fresh, homemade touches, then pairs them…
Ball & Biscuit
NightlifeThe Alchemist
NightlifeStart your morning with a perfectly brewed espresso and circle back after work for elevated, award-winning cocktails at The Alchemist, the…
The Alchemist
NightlifeAberdeen Social House
NightlifeAberdeen Social House mixes a curated, globe-spanning wine list with a bourbon-loving bar and a menu where American comfort gets a smart,…
Aberdeen Social House
NightlifeNicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge
NightlifeIndy’s Original Retro Bar where you can actually hear yourself, Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge nails classic cocktails, a cigar list, and…
Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge
NightlifeBooks & Brews
NightlifeBooks & Brews mixes a legit indie bookstore vibe with a rotating lineup of seasonal craft beers, so you can sip while you browse and feel…
Books & Brews
NightlifeCenterpoint Brewing Company
NightlifeIndianapolis-based Centerpoint Brewing Company leans into its engineering roots to turn out balanced, approachable beers that win over both…
Centerpoint Brewing Company
NightlifeAlmost Famous
NightlifeTrendy spot for American eats (including vegan fare), coffee, cocktails and live acts.
Almost Famous
NightlifePronto by Iozzo's
NightlifePronto by Iozzo's does the classy-but-comfortable thing right, with Italian deli-style light bites, espresso when you need a lift, and…
Pronto by Iozzo's
NightlifeBrandywine Creek Vineyards & Winery
NightlifeFamily-owned Brandywine Creek Vineyards & Winery pours Indiana-grown, farm-to-table wines in a cozy tasting room, with flights, live music,…
Brandywine Creek Vineyards & Winery
Nightlife8th Day Distillery - Bottle Shop & Cocktail Bar leans into locally sourced, handcrafted spirits with seasonal cocktails and mocktails for…
Ralston's Drafthouse
NightlifeRalston's Drafthouse is winning brunch this week with a scratch-made lineup that swings from Angel Biscuits and Gravy to decadent Elvis…
Ralston's Drafthouse
NightlifeGather 22
NightlifeGather 22 hits that sweet spot between kid-friendly and treat-yourself, pouring legit espresso in the morning and shaking crafty cocktails…
Gather 22
NightlifeSolely Wine
NightlifeSolely Wine champions small producers with a curated lineup of low-intervention bottles and by-the-glass pours that actually taste like…
Solely Wine
NightlifeMulligans Grill
NightlifeWhen you want easy comfort food and a pint without crossing town, Mulligans Grill at Crestview serves up a solid clubhouse hang with…
Mulligans Grill
NightlifeMass Ave Wine
NightlifeMass Ave Wine nails the sweet spot of curated, affordable bottles you can sip by the glass or share by the bottle, alongside charcuterie,…
Mass Ave Wine
NightlifeRo-Jac's
NightlifeRo-Jac's keeps it classic neighborhood-bar style with awesome bartenders, pool tables, and bar food that’s better than you expect. Grab a…
Ro-Jac's
NightlifeHelium Comedy Club
NightlifeFamous TV comics draw laughs at this stand-up comedy club with a variety of American eats.
Helium Comedy Club
NightlifeHouse-brewed cider & light eats in a historic building with high ceilings & rustic charm.
Teams of improvisers compete during this show for all ages, which also offers classes.
The District Tap
NightlifeCasual bar and restaurant featuring burgers, chicken wings and pizza, plus an outdoor patio.
The District Tap
NightlifeThe Vault Indy
NightlifeIf you like your cocktails with a little mystery, The Vault Indy hides behind a code in Bates-Hendricks and rewards you with classic,…
The Vault Indy
NightlifeWhite Rabbit Cabaret
NightlifeIf you're craving a night where the weirdly elegant thrive, White Rabbit Cabaret keeps Fountain Square lively with an ever-changing mix of…
White Rabbit Cabaret
NightlifeCooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant
NightlifeUpscale chain serving New American fare paired with house-label wines in a contemporary setting.
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant
NightlifeGreat Legs Wine + Spirits
NightlifeGreat Legs Wine + Spirits is the resident wine + cocktail bar at The Garage Food Hall, pouring a curated lineup that swings from familiar…
Great Legs Wine + Spirits
NightlifeThe Rejoicing Vine
NightlifeCome for guided tastings with thoughtful food pairings, stay for game nights, book swaps, and the occasional Sunshine Sangria cocktail of…
The Rejoicing Vine
NightlifeEasley Winery
NightlifeIn the mood to keep it low-key but tasty this week? Easley Winery lines up self-guided tasting flights from crisp dry picks to sweet Reggae…
Easley Winery
NightlifeWhether you want wings that mean business, burgers that actually sizzle, or a heated patio where pool, darts, and cornhole get weirdly…
Tinker Street Restaurant
NightlifeNew American outpost with a patio serving wines, brews & seasonal fare in a warm, upbeat setting.
Tinker Street Restaurant
NightlifeWiseguy Lounge - Mass Ave
NightlifeWhen you want a low-key night with serious cocktails, Wiseguy Lounge - Mass Ave delivers seasonal pours, a deep bourbon list, and that…
Wiseguy Lounge - Mass Ave
NightlifeNothing matched that. Know a spot we’re missing? Tell us →
Listed here?
You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →
New spots land in the newsletter first
Free, every morning — this list is what we've already told New Castle about.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.