The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in West Lafayette

“Home improvement thrift store benefitting Habitat for Humanity with new and used items.”

“Uptown Cheapskate NE Indianapolis kicked off its Denim Drop on August 1, plus the racks are full of on-trend resale from Levi's, Lululemon, Nike, and Madewell. Clean out your closet, they review while you browse and pay cash or store credit for the pieces they love.”

From the Indianapolis newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Millie's Thrift Store has been a Greater Lafayette staple for 40+ years, with three tidy, volunteer-powered shops full of legit finds. Go poke around this week, score something with a story, and feel good knowing each purchase helps local families and keeps the impact right here in Lafayette.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Golden Avenue Vintage keeps the hunt fun with a rotating mix of handpicked clothing and accessories from indie sellers, and they host lively pop-up markets that bring a bunch of resellers together on Wabash Avenue. If you’re chasing one-of-a-kind fits and community energy, start here.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, September 17, 2026

“Two of a Kind Antiques is the mother-daughter duo locals trust for Fire-King and Jadeite, with decades of know-how and a knack for uncovering Anchor Hocking, Heisey, Fostoria, and depression glass.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, September 21, 2026

“Thrift shop chain benefitting an addiction treatment program with clothing, furniture, and other secondhand items.”

“Lost Then Found is a local nonprofit thrift store with finds from vintage clothing to everyday housewares, and every purchase supports Trinity Life Ministry. This week, clean out a closet, drop off gently used items, then snag a few secondhand gems that actually feel first-rate.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Naptown Thrift is Indy’s nostalgia tap, packed with handpicked vintage tees, windbreakers, jerseys and more from the ’90s and early 2000s that actually slap. Swing by this week for the full dig, then peep their Instagram Story @NAPTOWNTHRIFT for new arrivals every day so you never miss a gem.”

From the Lawrence newsletter, August 19, 2026

“Since 1986, The Toggery Resale Boutique has been a go-to for upscale consignment, with fresh pieces hitting the floor daily and deals on designer looks for men and women, plus handbags and jewelry. They even went bagless to keep it green, so BYO tote.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, September 11, 2026

“Broad Ripple Vintage has served the Indianapolis area since 1998 with authentic men’s and women’s pieces from the 1940s through the 1980s, plus upcycled looks from artists around the world.”

From the Westfield newsletter, September 3, 2026

“Whether your living room needs a quirky lamp or your closet needs a humble refresh, Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store is the thrift stop that gives back. Hunt for secondhand gems this week, then feel good knowing every purchase supports a 12-month, faith-based recovery program for local men.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 10, 2026

“Consigned by Design is where Indy folks score quality pre-owned and new furniture without the cookie-cutter vibe. Think sofas, dining sets, mirrors, lamps, wall art, rugs, and even jewelry and designer handbags, all curated so you can refresh a room and still brag about the deal.”

“Leaping Leopard Antiques packs 13,500 square feet with curated finds from local dealers, spanning traditional pieces, mid-century modern, primitives, junky to funky, and farmhouse finds, plus vintage jewelry, coins, Fire King, cast iron, glassware, art, and unique furniture.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 30, 2026

“Nuova Vita Vintage specializes in classic, work-ready finds that actually fit into real life, think blazers, dresses, crisp separates, and thoughtful accessories. It’s a sweet spot for Kokomo locals who want sustainable style with some history, curated tastefully so you leave feeling polished, not costumed.”

From the Lawrence newsletter, September 5, 2026

“Locally known for standout antique architectural salvage, Architectural Antiques of Indianapolis is where you score statement lighting, solid doors, mantels, hardware, windows, and even wrought iron gates.”

From the Indianapolis newsletter, August 18, 2026

“Newman & Co. is the rare consignment spot where you can score sharp suits, sportcoats, tuxes, and dress shirts right alongside vintage Ralph Lauren ties, Gucci loafers, and everyday basics, plus they’re now taking furniture and home decor... which means your closet, and your living room, level up.”

From the Lawrence newsletter, August 27, 2026

“Sell It Here is Lafayette's largest antique and resale mall with thousands of antiques and collectibles, all presented in what they call an upscale resale mall with a clean, climate-controlled space. Pop in this week to browse everything from practical finds to elegant pieces and see what treasure claims you.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 20, 2026

“Millie's Thrift Store has been a Greater Lafayette staple for 40+ years, with super clean aisles, friendly volunteers, and an always-changing mix of clothing for all ages, furniture, and household finds. Prices feel like a neighborly nod, and every purchase keeps support right here in Lafayette.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, September 1, 2026

“If your closet needs a personality bump this week, The Ollie Closet serves up curated vintage and secondhand pieces that feel like you raided the coolest cousin’s wardrobe. They even team up with Flourish Studio for a Thrift + Tie Dye night, so you can turn a thrifted tee into something totally yours.”

From the West Lafayette newsletter, August 14, 2026