The best restaurants in Yarmouth

42 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Yarmouth’s best · Arts & Culture · Entertainment · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Nightlife · Home & Garden · Shopping · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage

Pinned in Yarmouth today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Yarmouth — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 42 places · showing the latest additions first

Cape Cod go-to for New Haven-style thin-crust pies & slices, plus sandwiches, subs & burritos.

461 Station Ave (South Yarmouth)

Cape Cod go-to for New Haven-style thin-crust pies & slices, plus sandwiches, subs & burritos.

Website ↗

99 Restaurants

Restaurants

Kid-friendly pub chain offering classic fare like burgers, wings & salads in informal surrounds.

14 Berry Ave (West Yarmouth)

Kid-friendly pub chain offering classic fare like burgers, wings & salads in informal surrounds.

Website ↗

Toly's Pizza

Restaurants

Long-standing family-run counter-serve for Greek-style pizza & sandwiches, plus takeout delivery.

1020 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Long-standing family-run counter-serve for Greek-style pizza & sandwiches, plus takeout delivery.

Website ↗

Fast-food eatery featuring a menu of pizza, pasta, rice plates & more, plus a drive-thru window.

459 MA-28 (West Yarmouth)

Fast-food eatery featuring a menu of pizza, pasta, rice plates & more, plus a drive-thru window.

Website ↗
Run a Yarmouth business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Comfortable diner & bar serving up classic Mediterranean eats, pizzas, calzones & pastas.

715 MA-6A (Yarmouth Port)

Comfortable diner & bar serving up classic Mediterranean eats, pizzas, calzones & pastas.

Website ↗

Branch of a sandwich shop chain offering subs, wraps & salads, plus rice & grain bowls.

485 MA-134 (South Dennis)

Branch of a sandwich shop chain offering subs, wraps & salads, plus rice & grain bowls.

Website ↗

New England fare with an Italian bent is served in a comfy indoor/outdoor space.

3176 Main St (Barnstable)

New England fare with an Italian bent is served in a comfy indoor/outdoor space.

Website ↗

Papa Gino's

Restaurants

Down-to-earth, family-oriented chain doling out hand-stretched pizzas, plus pasta & subs.

940 Main St (South Yarmouth)

Down-to-earth, family-oriented chain doling out hand-stretched pizzas, plus pasta & subs.

Website ↗

Long-running local chain serving New American & classic New England dishes in a rustic setting.

1196 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Long-running local chain serving New American & classic New England dishes in a rustic setting.

Website ↗

Captain Frosty's

Restaurants

Down-home seafood shack famed for lobster rolls & fried clams, plus burgers & soft-serve ice cream.

219 Main St (Dennis)

Down-home seafood shack famed for lobster rolls & fried clams, plus burgers & soft-serve ice cream.

Website ↗

Homestyle American plates whipped up in a down-to-earth setting with booths & outdoor seating.

194 Main St (West Yarmouth)

Homestyle American plates whipped up in a down-to-earth setting with booths & outdoor seating.

Website ↗

Pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a relaxed environment with a cozy bar.

1077 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a relaxed environment with a cozy bar.

Website ↗

The Pancake Man

Restaurants

Family-friendly daytime eatery serving up its namesake dish, plus eggs, waffles & burgers.

952 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Family-friendly daytime eatery serving up its namesake dish, plus eggs, waffles & burgers.

Website ↗

Summer Shanty

Restaurants

Seasonal, waterfront restaurant with a patio, offering seafood & cocktails, plus regular live music.

140 Main St (West Dennis)

Seasonal, waterfront restaurant with a patio, offering seafood & cocktails, plus regular live music.

Website ↗

Longfellow's Pub

Restaurants

Circa-1980 pub with paneled walls & an intimate bar, serving prime rib & other casual American fare.

182 Old Town House Rd (South Yarmouth)

Circa-1980 pub with paneled walls & an intimate bar, serving prime rib & other casual American fare.

Website ↗

Chapin's Bayside

Restaurants

Casual restaurant serving coastal classics, pastas & grilled steaks, plus a patio & raw bar.

85 Taunton Ave (Dennis)

Casual restaurant serving coastal classics, pastas & grilled steaks, plus a patio & raw bar.

Website ↗

Fin

Restaurants

High-end eatery in an antique home features sustainable seafood dishes paired with eclectic wines.

800 Main St (Dennis)

High-end eatery in an antique home features sustainable seafood dishes paired with eclectic wines.

Website ↗

Sea Dog Brew Pub

Restaurants

Longtime haunt for American pub classics plus pizza, tacos & draft beer in a low-key space with TVs.

23 Whites Path (South Yarmouth)

Longtime haunt for American pub classics plus pizza, tacos & draft beer in a low-key space with TVs.

Website ↗

Local-seafood-heavy menu served in a marine-themed dining room & adjacent tavern with many taps.

960 Main Street, MA-6A (Yarmouth Port)

Local-seafood-heavy menu served in a marine-themed dining room & adjacent tavern with many taps.

Website ↗

Casual all-suite hotel with a pub offering Irish entertainment & a restaurant, plus 2 pools.

476 MA-28 (West Yarmouth)

Casual all-suite hotel with a pub offering Irish entertainment & a restaurant, plus 2 pools.

Website ↗

Takis Pizza

Restaurants

No-frills long-running pizza joint provides vast selections of made-to-order pies, plus subs & more.

MA-28 #547 (West Yarmouth)

No-frills long-running pizza joint provides vast selections of made-to-order pies, plus subs & more.

Website ↗

Venezia

Restaurants

Classic Italian dishes in a refined airy dining room on the water, plus related winery next door.

20 Ericsson St (Boston)

Classic Italian dishes in a refined airy dining room on the water, plus related winery next door.

Website ↗

Vintage-chic space for tacos, ceviche & other Cali-Mex fare, plus creative cocktails.

2297 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Vintage-chic space for tacos, ceviche & other Cali-Mex fare, plus creative cocktails.

Website ↗

Sweet Life

Restaurants

Airy, contemporary seat-yourself coffeehouse with light breakfast & lunch fare, baked goods & cakes.

2243 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Airy, contemporary seat-yourself coffeehouse with light breakfast & lunch fare, baked goods & cakes.

Website ↗

Italian wraps, hot & cold subs, calzones, pizza & pasta served in a basic setting.

2254 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Italian wraps, hot & cold subs, calzones, pizza & pasta served in a basic setting.

Website ↗

Chubbs Taco & Tequila Bar channels Lucha Libre vibes in Dorchester with funky, fresh plates like elote dip, three kinds of guac, and…

750 Adams St (Boston)

Chubbs Taco & Tequila Bar channels Lucha Libre vibes in Dorchester with funky, fresh plates like elote dip, three kinds of guac, and signature tacos, plus a weekend brunch featuring chilaquiles and churro pancakes. Tequila fans will love the house infusions, classic margs, and the cheeky Espress-O Yourself.

Website ↗

Eire Pub

Restaurants

Eire Pub is that classic neighborhood spot with 50-plus years of stories, a visit or two from presidents, and 11 taps pouring steady with…

795 Adams St (Boston)

Eire Pub is that classic neighborhood spot with 50-plus years of stories, a visit or two from presidents, and 11 taps pouring steady with rotating seasonals. Come for the fish and chips or Irish curry fries, stay for the easy vibe and reliable place to gather.

Website ↗

Nick's Pizza & Seafood keeps it simple and solid with handmade-to-order pies, loaded subs, juicy burgers, wings, and crispy fried seafood,…

1143 Blue Hill Ave (Boston)

Nick's Pizza & Seafood keeps it simple and solid with handmade-to-order pies, loaded subs, juicy burgers, wings, and crispy fried seafood, all hot from the oven and made with premium ingredients. Time-tested recipes, dependable turnaround, and flavors that hit when you need them most.

Website ↗

The Bowery Bar

Restaurants

Comfort food, weekend brunch & seasonal cocktails offered in a vintage-style bar that has a patio.

2261 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Comfort food, weekend brunch & seasonal cocktails offered in a vintage-style bar that has a patio.

Website ↗

The Pheasant

Restaurants

Refined American fare with French influences in a centuries-old barn with fireplace & garden.

905 MA-6A (Dennis)

Refined American fare with French influences in a centuries-old barn with fireplace & garden.

Website ↗

Long-standing hangout lures locals with hearty New England fare & clam chowder, plus a bustling bar.

668 MA-28 (West Yarmouth)

Long-standing hangout lures locals with hearty New England fare & clam chowder, plus a bustling bar.

Website ↗

Homemade classics & local seafood served up since 1696 in a homey but elegant institution.

223 MA-6A (Yarmouth Port)

Homemade classics & local seafood served up since 1696 in a homey but elegant institution.

Website ↗

Leonessa

Restaurants

Italian-inspired dishes and cocktails are served at this chic restaurant with an extensive wine list.

43 Main St (Yarmouth Port)

Italian-inspired dishes and cocktails are served at this chic restaurant with an extensive wine list.

Website ↗

Keltic Kitchen

Restaurants

Acclaimed Irish restaurant known for its traditional breakfast and corned beef hash

415 MA-28 (West Yarmouth)

Acclaimed Irish restaurant known for its traditional breakfast and corned beef hash

Website ↗

Via Cannuccia

Restaurants

Bakery, trattoria, and pizzeria whipping up Italian mains, including risotto and lasagna.

1739 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Bakery, trattoria, and pizzeria whipping up Italian mains, including risotto and lasagna.

Website ↗

Clean, cheerful, family-oriented eatery for pancakes, omelettes and traditional meals.

161 MA-6A (Yarmouth Port)

Clean, cheerful, family-oriented eatery for pancakes, omelettes and traditional meals.

Website ↗

Casual spot doling out thin-crust pizzas, subs, and burgers, plus beer and wine.

731 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Casual spot doling out thin-crust pizzas, subs, and burgers, plus beer and wine.

Website ↗

Yarmouth House

Restaurants

Yarmouth House is that dependable long-timer with the signature waterwheel, where locals still go when they want lobster done right and…

335 MA-28 (West Yarmouth) · ✓ checked Sep 3

Yarmouth House is that dependable long-timer with the signature waterwheel, where locals still go when they want lobster done right and prime rib that actually feels like a treat. Comfortable, a little nostalgic, and reliably celebratory... perfect for birthdays, promotions, or just winning Tuesday.

From the Cape Cod newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

Noodle soups & other Vietnamese dishes in a bright corner space with plants & colorful banquettes.

1356 Dorchester Ave (Boston)

Noodle soups & other Vietnamese dishes in a bright corner space with plants & colorful banquettes.

Website ↗

Homey '50s diner serving hearty traditional New England fare for breakfast & lunch. Cash only.

36 Old Bass River Rd (South Dennis)

Homey '50s diner serving hearty traditional New England fare for breakfast & lunch. Cash only.

Website ↗

Gerardi's Cafe

Restaurants

Sicilian-style cuisine & traditional Italian cocktails in a relaxed, romantic atmosphere.

902 MA-28 (South Yarmouth)

Sicilian-style cuisine & traditional Italian cocktails in a relaxed, romantic atmosphere.

Website ↗

Ann & Fran's Kitchen has been serving Cape Codders since 1975 with scratch-made comfort and playful twists, think 7-hour corned beef hash,…

4843 471 MA-28 (West Yarmouth)

Ann & Fran's Kitchen has been serving Cape Codders since 1975 with scratch-made comfort and playful twists, think 7-hour corned beef hash, blueberry ricotta pancakes, or a lobster Benny that actually earns its butter. West Yarmouth locals know it’s where brunch feels neighborly and unapologetically satisfying.

From the Cape Cod newsletter, September 4, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →