The best restaurants in Cape May County
35 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.
Browse another shelf: all of Cape May County’s best · Entertainment · Nightlife · Arts & Culture · Shopping · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Home & Garden
Pinned in Cape May County today
This spot is open today.
Two pinned places a day in Cape May County — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →Paid placements are always marked.
Dock Mike's Pancake House Inc
RestaurantsThis week, when breakfast needs to feel like a hug, Dock Mike's Pancake House Inc brings the goods with original stacks like sweet potato,…
Dock Mike's Pancake House Inc
RestaurantsA Ca Mia Ristorante, Bakery & Coffee
RestaurantsA Ca Mia Ristorante, Bakery & Coffee plates modern Italian classics, from proper antipasti to twirlable pastas, then tempts you next door…
A Ca Mia Ristorante, Bakery & Coffee
RestaurantsMario's Pizza And Italian Eatery
RestaurantsFamily-run joint doling out pizza, sandwiches & Italian mains in an unfussy counter-service setting.
Mario's Pizza And Italian Eatery
RestaurantsPanico's Bistro
RestaurantsBrick-oven pizza, classic Italian fare & BYOB are found in loud, lively surrounds of an old church.
Panico's Bistro
RestaurantsBlue Moon Pizza
RestaurantsPizza joint featuring Italian and Greek staples as well as wings, cheesesteaks, stromboli and burgers.
Blue Moon Pizza
RestaurantsGeorge's Place Beachfront
RestaurantsSnug eatery, in business since 1968, offering American & Greek fare for breakfast, lunch & dinner.
George's Place Beachfront
RestaurantsShamone BYOB
RestaurantsBuzzy, elegant locale offering multicourse tapas & wine in a bustling mall.
Shamone BYOB
RestaurantsCarney's Restaurant & Lounge
RestaurantsLaid-back fixture featuring burgers, fish tacos and seafood dishes alongside a full bar.
Carney's Restaurant & Lounge
RestaurantsThe Blue Pig Tavern
RestaurantsUpdated American fare served on the patio or in the warm & rustic dining room of an 1800s hotel.
The Blue Pig Tavern
RestaurantsYozu Sushi
RestaurantsComfortable, contemporary Japanese restaurant offering hibachi-style dining & a wide range of sushi.
Yozu Sushi
RestaurantsBella Vida Garden Cafe
RestaurantsQuaint locale with a garden patio featuring New American dishes, all-day breakfast & vegan fare.
Bella Vida Garden Cafe
RestaurantsFat Racks BBQ
RestaurantsCasual restaurant serving classic BBQ fare such as ribs and brisket, plus catering.
Fat Racks BBQ
RestaurantsCastaway Cafe
RestaurantsLaid-back eatery featuring early bird specials and familiar American grub such as omelets, pancakes and waffles.
Castaway Cafe
RestaurantsJake's Pizza Company
RestaurantsCasual restaurant offering pizzas, stromboli, and other comfort foods, using fresh ingredients.
Jake's Pizza Company
RestaurantsVincenzo's Little Italy 🍕🇮🇹🍝
RestaurantsPizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a relaxed space with a warm atmosphere.
Vincenzo's Little Italy 🍕🇮🇹🍝
RestaurantsGood Earth Organic Eatery
RestaurantsLow-key, counter-service cafe offering seasonal, Italian-inspired vegan & seafood dishes.
Good Earth Organic Eatery
RestaurantsTony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
RestaurantsLaid-back dining spot providing classic Italian grub, including pizza, pasta & chicken parmigiana.
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
RestaurantsEbbitt Room
RestaurantsWell-appointed, luxe eatery & tavern offering seasonal, farm-to-table New American cuisine & drinks.
Ebbitt Room
RestaurantsICCARA Italian Bistro
RestaurantsCozy Sicilian eatery featuring seafood specialties, steaks, some kids' fare & an early-bird menu.
ICCARA Italian Bistro
RestaurantsViggiano's on Sunset - Cape May
RestaurantsFamiliar Italian eats are offered in a casual setting with a kids' menu and gluten-free options, plus a BYOB policy.
Viggiano's on Sunset - Cape May
RestaurantsOceanview Restaurant
RestaurantsBYOB spot by the beach serving updated American breakfast, lunch & dinner fare & local seafood.
Oceanview Restaurant
RestaurantsThe Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar
RestaurantsBuzzing breakfast-to-dinner bistro offering American fare, a bar & frequent live music in cozy digs.
The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar
RestaurantsWashington Inn & Wine Bar
RestaurantsUpscale American restaurant set in a Victorian plantation house with an extensive wine list & a bar.
Washington Inn & Wine Bar
RestaurantsFins Bar & Grille
RestaurantsColorful modern grill specializing in seafood & cocktails, with outdoor dining & regular live music.
Fins Bar & Grille
RestaurantsLucky Bones Backwater Grille
RestaurantsFamily-friendly outpost serves a range of seafood dishes & casual comfort eats in a polished space.
Lucky Bones Backwater Grille
RestaurantsCape May Grilled Cheese Co.
RestaurantsRelaxed lunch spot for grilled-cheese sandwiches (some with lobster), burgers and fries.
Cape May Grilled Cheese Co.
RestaurantsTisha's Fine Dining
RestaurantsQuaint sit-down eatery offering a menu of New American dishes, plus sandwiches & burgers for lunch.
Tisha's Fine Dining
RestaurantsVintage BYOB
RestaurantsTrendy restaurant with romantic ambiance and outdoor seating, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Vintage BYOB
RestaurantsGrana BYOB
RestaurantsRefined BYOB establishment using seasonal ingredients for a modern take on American cuisine.
Grana BYOB
RestaurantsBrother's Pizza II Cape May
RestaurantsCasual pizza parlor also featuring strombolis and calzones, as well as wings and sandwiches.
Brother's Pizza II Cape May
RestaurantsPeter Shields Inn & Restaurant
RestaurantsViews abound at this romantic eatery serving American fare in an elegant 1907 beachfront mansion.
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
RestaurantsAndrea Trattoria Italiana
RestaurantsTraditional Italian fare is served at this family-run, Southern Italian eatery.
Andrea Trattoria Italiana
RestaurantsWildwoods BBQ
RestaurantsCasual BBQ joint serving brisket, pulled pork and ribs, plus sandwiches and fries.
Wildwoods BBQ
RestaurantsThe Surfing Pig
RestaurantsBBQ plates, burgers, seafood & cocktails in a casual, nautical-themed setup with water views.
The Surfing Pig
RestaurantsRusty Nail
RestaurantsLively hangout with a rustic bar, deck & fire pit serving American eats & clever cocktails.
Rusty Nail
RestaurantsNothing matched that. Know a spot we’re missing? Tell us →
Listed here?
You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →
New spots land in the newsletter first
Free, every morning — this list is what we've already told Cape May County about.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.