The best restaurants in Cape May County

35 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Cape May County’s best · Entertainment · Nightlife · Arts & Culture · Shopping · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Home & Garden

Pinned in Cape May County today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Cape May County — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 35 places · showing the latest additions first

This week, when breakfast needs to feel like a hug, Dock Mike's Pancake House Inc brings the goods with original stacks like sweet potato,…

110 Broadway (Cape May)

This week, when breakfast needs to feel like a hug, Dock Mike's Pancake House Inc brings the goods with original stacks like sweet potato, buckwheat cinnamon raisin, even piña colada smothered in crushed pineapple. Not just pancakes either...

From the Cape May County newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

A Ca Mia Ristorante, Bakery & Coffee plates modern Italian classics, from proper antipasti to twirlable pastas, then tempts you next door…

524 Washington St Mall (Cape May)

A Ca Mia Ristorante, Bakery & Coffee plates modern Italian classics, from proper antipasti to twirlable pastas, then tempts you next door with fresh-baked sweets and coffee. Set in an 1872 landmark and led by Chef Todor Videv, it’s a Cape May staple worth a repeat this week.

Website ↗

Family-run joint doling out pizza, sandwiches & Italian mains in an unfussy counter-service setting.

315 Ocean St Unit 7 (Cape May)

Family-run joint doling out pizza, sandwiches & Italian mains in an unfussy counter-service setting.

Website ↗

Panico's Bistro

Restaurants

Brick-oven pizza, classic Italian fare & BYOB are found in loud, lively surrounds of an old church.

422 Broadway (Cape May)

Brick-oven pizza, classic Italian fare & BYOB are found in loud, lively surrounds of an old church.

Website ↗
Run a Cape May County business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Blue Moon Pizza

Restaurants

Pizza joint featuring Italian and Greek staples as well as wings, cheesesteaks, stromboli and burgers.

425 Beach Ave #25 (Cape May)

Pizza joint featuring Italian and Greek staples as well as wings, cheesesteaks, stromboli and burgers.

Website ↗

Snug eatery, in business since 1968, offering American & Greek fare for breakfast, lunch & dinner.

301 Beach Ave (Cape May)

Snug eatery, in business since 1968, offering American & Greek fare for breakfast, lunch & dinner.

Website ↗

Shamone BYOB

Restaurants

Buzzy, elegant locale offering multicourse tapas & wine in a bustling mall.

315 Ocean St (Cape May)

Buzzy, elegant locale offering multicourse tapas & wine in a bustling mall.

Website ↗

Laid-back fixture featuring burgers, fish tacos and seafood dishes alongside a full bar.

411 Beach Ave (Cape May)

Laid-back fixture featuring burgers, fish tacos and seafood dishes alongside a full bar.

Website ↗

Updated American fare served on the patio or in the warm & rustic dining room of an 1800s hotel.

200 Congress Pl (Cape May)

Updated American fare served on the patio or in the warm & rustic dining room of an 1800s hotel.

Website ↗

Yozu Sushi

Restaurants

Comfortable, contemporary Japanese restaurant offering hibachi-style dining & a wide range of sushi.

3845 Bayshore Rd (North Cape May)

Comfortable, contemporary Japanese restaurant offering hibachi-style dining & a wide range of sushi.

Website ↗

Quaint locale with a garden patio featuring New American dishes, all-day breakfast & vegan fare.

406 Broadway (West Cape May)

Quaint locale with a garden patio featuring New American dishes, all-day breakfast & vegan fare.

Website ↗

Fat Racks BBQ

Restaurants

Casual restaurant serving classic BBQ fare such as ribs and brisket, plus catering.

1458 NJ-47 (Woodbine)

Casual restaurant serving classic BBQ fare such as ribs and brisket, plus catering.

Website ↗

Castaway Cafe

Restaurants

Laid-back eatery featuring early bird specials and familiar American grub such as omelets, pancakes and waffles.

301 Bayshore Rd (Villas)

Laid-back eatery featuring early bird specials and familiar American grub such as omelets, pancakes and waffles.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant offering pizzas, stromboli, and other comfort foods, using fresh ingredients.

126 Sunset Blvd (West Cape May)

Casual restaurant offering pizzas, stromboli, and other comfort foods, using fresh ingredients.

Website ↗

Pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a relaxed space with a warm atmosphere.

3704 Bayshore Rd (North Cape May)

Pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a relaxed space with a warm atmosphere.

Website ↗

Low-key, counter-service cafe offering seasonal, Italian-inspired vegan & seafood dishes.

600 Park Blvd (West Cape May)

Low-key, counter-service cafe offering seasonal, Italian-inspired vegan & seafood dishes.

Website ↗

Laid-back dining spot providing classic Italian grub, including pizza, pasta & chicken parmigiana.

1216 NJ-109 (Cape May)

Laid-back dining spot providing classic Italian grub, including pizza, pasta & chicken parmigiana.

Website ↗

Ebbitt Room

Restaurants

Well-appointed, luxe eatery & tavern offering seasonal, farm-to-table New American cuisine & drinks.

25 Jackson St (Cape May)

Well-appointed, luxe eatery & tavern offering seasonal, farm-to-table New American cuisine & drinks.

Website ↗

Cozy Sicilian eatery featuring seafood specialties, steaks, some kids' fare & an early-bird menu.

315 Ocean St #4 (Cape May)

Cozy Sicilian eatery featuring seafood specialties, steaks, some kids' fare & an early-bird menu.

Website ↗

Familiar Italian eats are offered in a casual setting with a kids' menu and gluten-free options, plus a BYOB policy.

109 Sunset Blvd (West Cape May)

Familiar Italian eats are offered in a casual setting with a kids' menu and gluten-free options, plus a BYOB policy.

Website ↗

BYOB spot by the beach serving updated American breakfast, lunch & dinner fare & local seafood.

235 Beach Ave (Cape May)

BYOB spot by the beach serving updated American breakfast, lunch & dinner fare & local seafood.

Website ↗

Buzzing breakfast-to-dinner bistro offering American fare, a bar & frequent live music in cozy digs.

19 Jackson St (Cape May)

Buzzing breakfast-to-dinner bistro offering American fare, a bar & frequent live music in cozy digs.

Website ↗

Upscale American restaurant set in a Victorian plantation house with an extensive wine list & a bar.

801 Washington St (Cape May)

Upscale American restaurant set in a Victorian plantation house with an extensive wine list & a bar.

Website ↗

Colorful modern grill specializing in seafood & cocktails, with outdoor dining & regular live music.

142 Decatur St (Cape May)

Colorful modern grill specializing in seafood & cocktails, with outdoor dining & regular live music.

Website ↗

Family-friendly outpost serves a range of seafood dishes & casual comfort eats in a polished space.

1200 NJ-109 (Cape May)

Family-friendly outpost serves a range of seafood dishes & casual comfort eats in a polished space.

Website ↗

Relaxed lunch spot for grilled-cheese sandwiches (some with lobster), burgers and fries.

315 Ocean St Unit8B (Cape May)

Relaxed lunch spot for grilled-cheese sandwiches (some with lobster), burgers and fries.

Website ↗

Quaint sit-down eatery offering a menu of New American dishes, plus sandwiches & burgers for lunch.

322 Washington St (Cape May)

Quaint sit-down eatery offering a menu of New American dishes, plus sandwiches & burgers for lunch.

Website ↗

Vintage BYOB

Restaurants

Trendy restaurant with romantic ambiance and outdoor seating, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

1048 Washington St (Cape May)

Trendy restaurant with romantic ambiance and outdoor seating, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Website ↗

Grana BYOB

Restaurants

Refined BYOB establishment using seasonal ingredients for a modern take on American cuisine.

413 S Broadway (Cape May)

Refined BYOB establishment using seasonal ingredients for a modern take on American cuisine.

Website ↗

Casual pizza parlor also featuring strombolis and calzones, as well as wings and sandwiches.

102 Sunset Blvd (West Cape May)

Casual pizza parlor also featuring strombolis and calzones, as well as wings and sandwiches.

Website ↗

Views abound at this romantic eatery serving American fare in an elegant 1907 beachfront mansion.

1301 Beach Ave (Cape May)

Views abound at this romantic eatery serving American fare in an elegant 1907 beachfront mansion.

Website ↗

Traditional Italian fare is served at this family-run, Southern Italian eatery.

412 Bank St (Cape May)

Traditional Italian fare is served at this family-run, Southern Italian eatery.

Website ↗

Wildwoods BBQ

Restaurants

Casual BBQ joint serving brisket, pulled pork and ribs, plus sandwiches and fries.

701 New Jersey Ave (North Wildwood)

Casual BBQ joint serving brisket, pulled pork and ribs, plus sandwiches and fries.

Website ↗

The Surfing Pig

Restaurants

BBQ plates, burgers, seafood & cocktails in a casual, nautical-themed setup with water views.

231 W 10th Ave Rear (North Wildwood)

BBQ plates, burgers, seafood & cocktails in a casual, nautical-themed setup with water views.

Website ↗

Rusty Nail

Restaurants

Lively hangout with a rustic bar, deck & fire pit serving American eats & clever cocktails.

205 Beach Ave (Cape May)

Lively hangout with a rustic bar, deck & fire pit serving American eats & clever cocktails.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →