The best cafes in Brookhaven

29 cafes we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Brookhaven’s best · Restaurants · Shopping · Beauty · Nightlife · Bakeries & Sweets · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Arts & Culture · Entertainment · Home & Garden · Health & Wellness · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Parks & Outdoors · Sporting Goods · Services · Pets

Pinned in Brookhaven today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Brookhaven — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Cafes · 29 places · showing the latest additions first

Break Away Cafe pairs thoughtfully brewed coffee, fresh pastries, and house-made soups with a full-service bike shop for sales, rentals,…

71 Cabrini Blvd (New York)

Break Away Cafe pairs thoughtfully brewed coffee, fresh pastries, and house-made soups with a full-service bike shop for sales, rentals, tune-ups, and solid advice, plus weekly group rides, women’s rides, and kids programs.

From the The Bronx newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

Semicolon Cafe is the kind of relaxed spot locals use for a quick caffeine reset or an easy lunch, with well-made coffees, crisp grilled…

9 Edward M Morgan Pl (New York)

Semicolon Cafe is the kind of relaxed spot locals use for a quick caffeine reset or an easy lunch, with well-made coffees, crisp grilled sandwiches, sweet pastries, and bingsoo shaved ice that absolutely hits when the day needs a cool turn.

From the White Plains newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Buunni Coffee - Pinehurst pours Ethiopian brews from beans directly sourced from small farms, roasted weekly in NYC, and pairs them with…

213 Pinehurst Ave (New York)

Buunni Coffee - Pinehurst pours Ethiopian brews from beans directly sourced from small farms, roasted weekly in NYC, and pairs them with sweet and savory baked goods. Cozy, bohemian energy, coffee tastings, and community vibes make it a solid neighborhood habit.

From the The Bronx newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

Dunkin'

Cafes

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

4030 Broadway (New York)

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Website ↗
Run a Brookhaven business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

140 Hospital Rd (Patchogue)

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

Website ↗

Part coffee spot, part beautifully curated general store, Bellport General is where you grab a coffee, then wander through housewares,…

138 S Country Rd (Bellport)

Part coffee spot, part beautifully curated general store, Bellport General is where you grab a coffee, then wander through housewares, fashion, books, and essentials that feel anything but boring. Ideal for a caffeine top‑up, a quick host gift, or an excuse to browse longer than planned.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

3 Farber Dr (Bellport)

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

Website ↗

Southdown Coffee - Patchogue keeps it close to the source with beans roasted on a weekly schedule, so your cup tastes bright and fresh.…

16 Havens Ave (Patchogue)

Southdown Coffee - Patchogue keeps it close to the source with beans roasted on a weekly schedule, so your cup tastes bright and fresh. Order ahead for a painless pickup, grab a bag for home or a coffee subscription, and nerd out with brew gear like a Hario V60 or Chemex filters.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

Moka & Co turns your caffeine run into an experience, with a live in-house roastery, Yemeni specialties like the spiced Mufawar and a silky…

142 W 34th St. (New York)

Moka & Co turns your caffeine run into an experience, with a live in-house roastery, Yemeni specialties like the spiced Mufawar and a silky Pistachio Latte, plus savory bites, croissants, and heritage milk cakes worth lingering over. Need focus time?

From the The Bronx newsletter, August 26, 2026

Website ↗

Bird & Branch Coffee Roasters riffs on lattes with housemade almond macadamia milk and flavors like blackberry-thyme (Blackbird), Earl Grey…

359 W 45th St (New York)

Bird & Branch Coffee Roasters riffs on lattes with housemade almond macadamia milk and flavors like blackberry-thyme (Blackbird), Earl Grey espresso (Nightingale), and a cozy turmeric-ginger number (Robin). Pair it with a black sesame square or kabocha molasses loaf and make it your treat this week.

From the The Bronx newsletter, August 20, 2026

Website ↗

Cozy coffeehouse featuring Puerto Rican coffee and teas, plus quick bites such as empanadas.

310 W 14th St (New York)

Cozy coffeehouse featuring Puerto Rican coffee and teas, plus quick bites such as empanadas.

Website ↗

Craving a low-key treat this week? Bellport Apothecary pours legit lattes, iced coffee, and lavender lemonade, blends fruit smoothies, and…

151 S Country Rd (Bellport)

Craving a low-key treat this week? Bellport Apothecary pours legit lattes, iced coffee, and lavender lemonade, blends fruit smoothies, and turns out crepes and waffles... then tempts you with boutique gifts and beauty finds so you leave caffeinated and smugly stocked.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 20, 2026

Website ↗

Dutton Brew House roasts your beans only after you order, then ships the same day, so your at-home cup actually tastes fresh. From playful…

407 William Floyd Pkwy (Shirley)

Dutton Brew House roasts your beans only after you order, then ships the same day, so your at-home cup actually tastes fresh. From playful flavors like Dubai Chocolate and Cinnabun to single origins, teas, and single-serve capsules, it’s an easy Brookhaven upgrade for weekday mornings.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

2269 Sunrise Hwy (Islip)

Pit stop for snacks, drinks & daily essentials

Website ↗

Ariston Coffee Bar tucks a legit cafe inside a lush flower shop, so your latte comes with the scent of peonies and orchids. Swing by for a…

78 5th Ave (New York)

Ariston Coffee Bar tucks a legit cafe inside a lush flower shop, so your latte comes with the scent of peonies and orchids. Swing by for a mood reset, sip something smooth, then pick up a bouquet for your desk or that dinner you forgot about.

From the Manhattan newsletter, August 19, 2026

Website ↗

Grind The NYC Coffee Shop & Bagel House is your low-key MVP for weekday fuel or lazy weekend treats, turning out bagels, croissants,…

602 9th Ave (New York)

Grind The NYC Coffee Shop & Bagel House is your low-key MVP for weekday fuel or lazy weekend treats, turning out bagels, croissants, desserts, and breakfast sandwiches alongside proper coffee and fresh juices. When the day starts fast, this spot keeps it delicious, simple, and in your rotation.

From the North Bergen newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Dunkin'

Cafes

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

1 Front St (Hempstead)

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Website ↗

Cozy coffee shop specializing in espresso drinks, brewed coffee (including iced varieties) and lattes.

245 W 46th St (New York)

Cozy coffee shop specializing in espresso drinks, brewed coffee (including iced varieties) and lattes.

Website ↗

Shake up your caffeine routine this week with Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay, where the beans are roasted on a weekly schedule for peak…

49 Audrey Ave (Oyster Bay)

Shake up your caffeine routine this week with Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay, where the beans are roasted on a weekly schedule for peak freshness and the menu swings from bright Kenyan to smooth espresso blends or a cold brew blend. Order ahead, grab a cup, snag beans for home, then actually enjoy your morning.

From the Gold Coast newsletter, August 19, 2026

Website ↗

Tend Coffee is the neighborhood spot where organic beans get the star treatment on a USA-made Loring Smart Roast, so your cup actually…

924 Montauk Hwy (Shirley)

Tend Coffee is the neighborhood spot where organic beans get the star treatment on a USA-made Loring Smart Roast, so your cup actually sings. Add a dessert, with legit gluten-free picks, and you’ve got an easy Brookhaven habit worth keeping.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 22, 2026

Website ↗

CoHo Coffee House is Patchogue’s daytime coffee haven turned coffee cocktail hangout at night, pouring thoughtful espresso drinks and…

62 W Main St (Patchogue)

CoHo Coffee House is Patchogue’s daytime coffee haven turned coffee cocktail hangout at night, pouring thoughtful espresso drinks and serving paninis, wraps, cookies, and pastries that actually taste like a treat. Swing by when you need a little community hug in a cup.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 25, 2026

Website ↗

Between Italian-imported espresso, a smooth Colombian drip, and lattes that double as tiny art projects, Brewport Coffee House in Bellport…

129 S Country Rd (Bellport)

Between Italian-imported espresso, a smooth Colombian drip, and lattes that double as tiny art projects, Brewport Coffee House in Bellport Village nails the everyday cup. Their seasonal specials keep things fun, plus fresh pastries, scones, and grab-and-go salads and wraps from a popular local deli.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Boris & Horton is the rare spot where your caffeine fix comes with tail wags, thanks to a split setup that lets pups be off leash in the…

195 Avenue A (New York)

Boris & Horton is the rare spot where your caffeine fix comes with tail wags, thanks to a split setup that lets pups be off leash in the Dog Dining Room while you hang with a latte and cafe bites. Go solo, bring your mutt, either way it’s a joyful midweek reset.

From the Brooklyn newsletter, August 6, 2026

Website ↗

Koneko

Cafes

When your week needs a serotonin reset, Koneko pairs quality hang time with adoptable cats with a shop full of purr-worthy apparel,…

26 Clinton St (New York)

When your week needs a serotonin reset, Koneko pairs quality hang time with adoptable cats with a shop full of purr-worthy apparel, jewelry, and stationery. Pop in for a calm, whiskered escape, maybe meet your future roommate, then leave stocked with extremely necessary cat things.

From the Brooklyn newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Ultramodern and European at heart, Charlotte Cafe pours premium Italian espresso with the kind of crema that makes you reconsider your…

2541 Broadway (New York)

Ultramodern and European at heart, Charlotte Cafe pours premium Italian espresso with the kind of crema that makes you reconsider your priorities. Pair it with a flaky pastry and call it self-care, or a perfectly acceptable meeting, whichever gets you there sooner.

From the The Bronx newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

maman

Cafes

Branch of a French bakery and cafe serving coffee, pastries, and brunch in a cozy setting.

152 Columbus Ave (New York)

Branch of a French bakery and cafe serving coffee, pastries, and brunch in a cozy setting.

Website ↗

maman

Cafes

Relaxed eatery serving French-influenced light fare in a rustic-chic space with a patio.

375 Hudson St (New York)

Relaxed eatery serving French-influenced light fare in a rustic-chic space with a patio.

Website ↗

NYC’s first cat café since 2014, Meow Parlour lets you book time with adorable, adoptable cats, whether you’re browsing or ready to bring…

43 Essex St (New York)

NYC’s first cat café since 2014, Meow Parlour lets you book time with adorable, adoptable cats, whether you’re browsing or ready to bring one home this week. It’s run by a 501(c)(3) rescue, so your visit helps real kitties find fosters and families, which feels pretty great.

From the New York City newsletter, August 12, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you’re team latte, froyo, or craving something iced and ultra smooth, Cha Cha Matcha (NoMad) nails it with ceremonial-grade matcha…

1158 Broadway (New York)

Whether you’re team latte, froyo, or craving something iced and ultra smooth, Cha Cha Matcha (NoMad) nails it with ceremonial-grade matcha and a pink-and-green tropical vibe that brightens any day. A solid go-to when coffee fatigue hits and you want a clean, feel-good lift.

From the Freeport newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →