Over 50 years of New York style pies comes through in every bite at Picnic Pizza, with dough made fresh daily, in-house meatballs and sub…
84 Canal St (Big Flats)
“Over 50 years of New York style pies comes through in every bite at Picnic Pizza, with dough made fresh daily, in-house meatballs and sub sauce, and plenty of weeknight saviors like stromboli, calzones, wings and a surprisingly addictive chicken wing pizza.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 8, 2026
Giuseppe's keeps Horseheads fed with authentic New York pizza, hearty Sicilian pizza, and pasta swimming in Giuseppe's Famous Sauce. When…
1020 S Center St (Horseheads)
“Giuseppe's keeps Horseheads fed with authentic New York pizza, hearty Sicilian pizza, and pasta swimming in Giuseppe's Famous Sauce. When you want more than pizza, there are strombolis, hoagies, wings, and a legit Friday fish fry that tastes like a hometown tradition.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 25, 2026
Louies Hanover Square turns out crisp, legit pies from fresh daily dough and premium ingredients, plus Italian go-tos like garlic ties,…
102 S Main St (Horseheads)
“Louies Hanover Square turns out crisp, legit pies from fresh daily dough and premium ingredients, plus Italian go-tos like garlic ties, greens & beans, meatballs with sausage, and fried calamari. Easy pick when Horseheads cravings hit... classic comfort with a little heat if you want it.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 18, 2026
Picnic Pizza has been tossing New York style pies around here for over 50 years, with daily hand-stretched dough, in-house meatballs and…
2898 Westinghouse Rd Ste 516 (Horseheads)
“Picnic Pizza has been tossing New York style pies around here for over 50 years, with daily hand-stretched dough, in-house meatballs and sub sauce, and plenty of fresh veggies. Go for a classic slice, wings, or a hefty stromboli... and yes, their Sicilian squares have a cult following.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 11, 2026
Opened in 1985, Rico's Pizza & Subs brings classic NY style pies, hefty subs, salads and calzones to Corning, Horseheads and beyond, with…
2162 Grand Central Ave (Horseheads)
“Opened in 1985, Rico's Pizza & Subs brings classic NY style pies, hefty subs, salads and calzones to Corning, Horseheads and beyond, with fun spins like chicken wing and white broccoli garlic slices. A reliable, family-run go to when you want crowd-pleasing comfort without overthinking dinner.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 2, 2026
On a Roll has been a Horseheads tradition since 1986, turning out no-frills counter service sandwiches in Hanover Square that just plain…
6 Hanover Square (Horseheads)
“On a Roll has been a Horseheads tradition since 1986, turning out no-frills counter service sandwiches in Hanover Square that just plain hit right. Think stacked subs and hoagies, burgers, quesadillas, plus soups and salads when you want solid, local comfort without the fuss.”
From the Finger Lakes newsletter, September 20, 2026
When you want real-deal barbecue without the wait, Fat City BBQ in Horseheads keeps it simple with homemade, quick-service BBQ that hits…
939 Hulett St (Horseheads)
“When you want real-deal barbecue without the wait, Fat City BBQ in Horseheads keeps it simple with homemade, quick-service BBQ that hits the spot. Perfect for busy days or feeding a crew, they handle catering and large groups, and they’re happy to chat about dietary questions or special requests.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 20, 2026
Pudgies Pizza keeps it classic with crowd-pleasing pies, plus subs and wings when you’re feeding more than just a craving. If it’s Friday,…
134 W Franklin St (Horseheads)
“Pudgies Pizza keeps it classic with crowd-pleasing pies, plus subs and wings when you’re feeding more than just a craving. If it’s Friday, the fish fry is the move, a simple comfort that hits right after work and before a low-key Horseheads night.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 15, 2026
Thai Asian 119 keeps Horseheads happily fed with fresh, modern takes on Thai and Chinese favorites plus a surprisingly hefty sushi lineup.…
119 W Franklin St (Horseheads)
“Thai Asian 119 keeps Horseheads happily fed with fresh, modern takes on Thai and Chinese favorites plus a surprisingly hefty sushi lineup. It’s casual, clean, and family-friendly, with friendly service and easy takeout or delivery when dinner at home suddenly sounds like a better idea.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, September 13, 2026
The Starlite Room nails that sweet spot where pizza, crisp wings, cold beer and even gluten-free picks share space with the occasional…
3018 Lake Rd (Elmira)
“The Starlite Room nails that sweet spot where pizza, crisp wings, cold beer and even gluten-free picks share space with the occasional lobster craving. Bring a friend, catch a band, and call it the Chemung County evening you actually look forward to.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 8, 2026
Whether your mood is thin Neapolitan or thick Sicilian, Vincenzo's nails it with specialty pies like The Sinatra, Leonardo D'Vinci, Prima…
303 N Main St (Elmira)
“Whether your mood is thin Neapolitan or thick Sicilian, Vincenzo's nails it with specialty pies like The Sinatra, Leonardo D'Vinci, Prima Vera, and Caesar's, plus wings, hoagies, calzones, stromboli, and garlic knots. Locally owned by Vinnie and Dominic since 1999, it's Elmira comfort that never lets you down.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 6, 2026
Maple Lawn Dairy has been keeping Elmira happily full for over 35 years with daily homemade specials, hearty wraps and burgers, crispy…
3162 Lower Maple Ave (Elmira)
“Maple Lawn Dairy has been keeping Elmira happily full for over 35 years with daily homemade specials, hearty wraps and burgers, crispy wings, a classic fish fry, and their famous homemade ice cream.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 7, 2026
Craving something fresh this week without the fuss? Tossed lets you build the salad of your dreams with 30+ toppings and add-ons, or go for…
120 N Main St (Elmira)
“Craving something fresh this week without the fuss? Tossed lets you build the salad of your dreams with 30+ toppings and add-ons, or go for wraps, Buddha bowls, gyros, hummus and falafel, even a cheeseburger bowl. Local ingredients, big flavors, and options for vegans to carnivores.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 3, 2026
Master K's BBQ is bringing the good kind of smoke to your week with juicy brisket, fall-off-the-bone ribs, and all the saucy staples, plus…
511 Broadway St (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 21
“Master K's BBQ is bringing the good kind of smoke to your week with juicy brisket, fall-off-the-bone ribs, and all the saucy staples, plus a cold beer to back it up. When you need comfort with char close to home, this is the no-fuss, big-flavor move.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 30, 2026
Saucy, cheesy, and proudly “The People’s Pizzeria,” Sauce Boss Pizza & Pasta Co. keeps it local with pies, pastas, and community vibes that…
1335 College Ave (Elmira)
“Saucy, cheesy, and proudly “The People’s Pizzeria,” Sauce Boss Pizza & Pasta Co. keeps it local with pies, pastas, and community vibes that hit just right. Five-time Community Choice winner, built by Elmira and powered by Sauce Bossians...”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 20, 2026
Beijing Garden is the dependable move when you want Chinese comfort that actually hits. Think General Tao's Chicken in their own secret…
145 W Gray St (Elmira)
“Beijing Garden is the dependable move when you want Chinese comfort that actually hits. Think General Tao's Chicken in their own secret sauce, Tangerine Beef, Roast Duck with Beijing Sauce, and Shanghai Pan Fried Noodle... perfect for those nights you want big flavor without overthinking dinner.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 14, 2026
1157 North, in the former Palms Restaurant space, keeps it classic with homemade pasta, Italian-American comfort plates, and steaks, then…
1157 N Main St #1446 (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 20
“1157 North, in the former Palms Restaurant space, keeps it classic with homemade pasta, Italian-American comfort plates, and steaks, then reels you in with a Friday fish fry and Saturday prime rib. Save room for scratch desserts like peanut butter pie or crème brûlée you’ll think about all week.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 29, 2026
Yes, you’ve seen that hillside a thousand times, but it still hits different at Hill Top Inn, where dinners come with the Chemung Valley…
171 Jerusalem Hill Rd (Elmira)
“Yes, you’ve seen that hillside a thousand times, but it still hits different at Hill Top Inn, where dinners come with the Chemung Valley spread out below, a side of local lore, and the view that inspired Mark Twain.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 13, 2026
Whether it's a classic slice, your own topping-packed creation, or a giant sheet that feeds the whole crew, Pudgie's Pizza, Pasta & Subs -…
350 S Main St (Elmira)
“Whether it's a classic slice, your own topping-packed creation, or a giant sheet that feeds the whole crew, Pudgie's Pizza, Pasta & Subs - Elmira has you covered with wings, subs, calzones, strombolis, pasta, and even a gluten-free 12" option. A hometown staple since 1963.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 17, 2026
When the schedule’s stacked and you just want easy wins, Roundin Third keeps the sports on plenty of screens, cold beer and cocktails…
255 W Water St (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 20
“When the schedule’s stacked and you just want easy wins, Roundin Third keeps the sports on plenty of screens, cold beer and cocktails within reach, and the classics covered... pizza, wings, and the kind of relaxed vibe Chemung County weekends deserve.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 27, 2026
Whether you’re rolling in early or sneaking in for a no-fuss dinner, Anne’s Pancakes keeps it classic with fluffy stacks, hearty diner…
114 S Main St (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 21
“Whether you’re rolling in early or sneaking in for a no-fuss dinner, Anne’s Pancakes keeps it classic with fluffy stacks, hearty diner plates, and the kind of comfort that makes Tuesday feel like Sunday morning. Consider this your reminder to treat yourself to a short stack this week.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 30, 2026
Ma's Cheesy Dreams & Other Things turns cravings into events with 200-plus cheesecake flavors, thick milkshakes, and a quarter-pound hot…
228B Oakwood Ave (Elmira Heights) · ✓ checked Aug 20
“Ma's Cheesy Dreams & Other Things turns cravings into events with 200-plus cheesecake flavors, thick milkshakes, and a quarter-pound hot dog riding shotgun under Ma’s homemade meat sauce. Add home-cut or sweet potato fries with that honey-with-a-kick, check it this week and consider morale restored.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 30, 2026
Los Panchos Mexican Restaurant keeps it classic with authentic Mexican dishes made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Think sizzling…
250 W Water St (Elmira)
“Los Panchos Mexican Restaurant keeps it classic with authentic Mexican dishes made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Think sizzling fajitas, crispy chimichangas, and a margarita that hits the spot, perfect for an easy weeknight takeout or a low-key night out with your Elmira crew.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 19, 2026
Family-run for over 69 years, Lib's Supper Club turns Old World Italian recipes, fresh hand-cut aged steaks, and seafood into the kind of…
106 W 5th St (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 4
“Family-run for over 69 years, Lib's Supper Club turns Old World Italian recipes, fresh hand-cut aged steaks, and seafood into the kind of generous plates that make leftovers a certainty. Perfect for date night or gathering the whole crew, with banquet chops to match your appetite.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 15, 2026
Whether you swear by classic cheese or chase the Sweet N Spicy Pepperoni with Mike’s Hot Honey, Pasquale's Pizzeria is your go-to for New…
411 S Main St (Elmira)
“Whether you swear by classic cheese or chase the Sweet N Spicy Pepperoni with Mike’s Hot Honey, Pasquale's Pizzeria is your go-to for New York-style thin crust, grabby-by-the-slice goodness. This week, round it out with char wings, a calzone or that wildly comforting creamy pomodoro soup.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 12, 2026
Centertown Social is Elmira’s new go-to for elevated bites, craft beverages, and a slick indoor/outdoor scene that works for date night or…
8 Clemens Square (Elmira)
“Centertown Social is Elmira’s new go-to for elevated bites, craft beverages, and a slick indoor/outdoor scene that works for date night or the group chat. Hit the mezzanine lounge, the game room, and brand-new duckpin bowling, then let the night casually drift into one more round.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 19, 2026
When you want that classic Elmira comfort fix, Elbow Room nails it with crisp, saucy wings from honey-garlic to ghost pepper, stacked…
1057 Walnut St (Elmira)
“When you want that classic Elmira comfort fix, Elbow Room nails it with crisp, saucy wings from honey-garlic to ghost pepper, stacked burgers, and proper roast beef sandwiches, plus rotating craft beers and legit cocktails. Catch the game, linger for live tunes, and call it a week well spent.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 20, 2026
All day breakfast and lunch in a fully restored Silk City dining car, The Diner nails the craveables like pancakes, burgers, and rotating…
59 Old Ithaca Rd (Horseheads)
“All day breakfast and lunch in a fully restored Silk City dining car, The Diner nails the craveables like pancakes, burgers, and rotating chef specials, with that cozy small town feel. When you want a quick escape to 1941 vibes and a plate that actually fills you up, this is it.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 18, 2026
When you need a dependable weeknight win, Taste of Asia nails it with fresh sushi and maki from the bar, sizzling hibachi favorites, and…
2088 College Ave (Elmira Heights)
“When you need a dependable weeknight win, Taste of Asia nails it with fresh sushi and maki from the bar, sizzling hibachi favorites, and Chinese classics like General Tso's Chicken that actually crunches; tasty comfort, zero fuss, and flavors you can happily put on repeat.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 19, 2026
Barb's Soup's On Cafe keeps it simple and delicious with homemade soups, fresh sandwiches, wraps, and crisp salads that taste like someone…
311 College Ave (Elmira)
“Barb's Soup's On Cafe keeps it simple and delicious with homemade soups, fresh sandwiches, wraps, and crisp salads that taste like someone actually cares. Look for the rotating Soup of the Day, then finish strong with a slice of homemade pie or cake because you earned it.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 22, 2026
Craving a sushi night that actually hits? Sushi Wa is rolling out nigiri, sashimi, and creative bites like the Godzilla, Pink Lady, and…
950 County Rd 64 Ste 800 (Elmira) · ✓ checked Aug 20
“Craving a sushi night that actually hits? Sushi Wa is rolling out nigiri, sashimi, and creative bites like the Godzilla, Pink Lady, and their namesake Sushi Wa Roll, plus the usual soups and starters. Easy win for weeknights when the fridge inspiration is at zero.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 27, 2026
Elmira’s Siam Elephants Thai Restaurant does authentic Thai with a lively exhibition kitchen, fresh-as-it-gets ingredients, and a crew that…
200 W Water St (Elmira)
“Elmira’s Siam Elephants Thai Restaurant does authentic Thai with a lively exhibition kitchen, fresh-as-it-gets ingredients, and a crew that keeps things friendly and fast. Grab your go-to Thai favorite or try something new, then make it easy on yourself and order ahead online for a zero-fuss night.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 20, 2026
Can’t decide between a pancake stack and a bowl of stir fry? Hamlet Delights nails both, serving fluffy pancakes for the breakfast crowd…
103 Sayre St (Horseheads) · ✓ checked Aug 20
“Can’t decide between a pancake stack and a bowl of stir fry? Hamlet Delights nails both, serving fluffy pancakes for the breakfast crowd plus legit fried rice and noodle dishes when the wok mood hits, a clutch local go-to when everyone wants different comfort food.”
From the Chemung County newsletter, August 24, 2026
