The best bakeries & sweet shops in Medina

“Anderson's Frozen Custard is that rare local staple serving all natural roast beef on weck alongside signature frozen custard and handmade ice cream cakes, a combo that just works. September even brings daily Pumpkin Frozen Custard plus rotating flavors like Latte at West Amherst, so plan your cravings accordingly.”

From the Amherst newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.”

“Family-run and made with love in Kaisertown, The Yard Ice Cream keeps things delightfully simple with creamy soft serve, classic hand-scooped flavors, legit banana splits, and chocolate-dipped cones. A low-key spot that feels like summer, and yes, the kids somehow always know the way.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 7, 2026

“Skip the flavor-of-the-week roulette and hit Pam's Custard Corner, where more than 31 flavors of soft, creamy custard are always on deck, plus towering sundaes, thick milkshakes, Arctic Swirls, floats, slushes, and homemade lemon ice. Family-owned, friendly vibes, and exactly the cool-down you need this week.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Whether you're hunting down celebratory treats or need a midweek morale boost, Sugar Rush Bakery turns out fresh-baked goodness that tastes homemade in the best way. Keep them on your radar when dessert should feel special, not store-bought, especially if you're team "just one more"... which we all are.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 14, 2026

“White Rabbit Dessert Experience churns handcrafted ice cream fresh daily, then pairs it with warm, made-to-order creations that are as pretty as they are indulgent. If you crave premium ingredients, fun presentation, and a spot that feels like, well, an experience, consider this your new dessert routine.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 4, 2026

“Counter-serve chain serving cinnamon rolls plus other baked goods & specialty frozen beverages.”

“Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery turns out artisan-crafted cake pops, cookies, and fully customizable desserts, plus hands-on decorating classes if you want to level up your piping game. Perfect for birthdays, office treats, or just making Tuesday less Tuesday this week, and yes, everything is proudly made in the 716.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Buke Baking builds desserts and drinks around real tea, fresh fruit, and premium milk, delivering balanced, not-too-sweet bites that actually taste like the ingredients. Swing by this week for a tea-kissed dessert or line up a custom cake for your next get-together, and thank us later.”

From the Amherst newsletter, August 21, 2026

“Bakery specializing in huge, hot cookies in a variety of flavors, including vegan and gluten-free options.”

“Moist bakery known for a variety of cupcake flavors such as red velvet and cookies-and-cream.”

“Muscoreils Fine Desserts is that humble counter where showstopper cakes actually taste as good as they look. Think ornate, custom designs for birthdays, showers, and weddings, plus a case of fresh baked goodies when you just need a sugar win after yet another Tonawanda weather surprise.”

From the North Tonawanda newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Whether you’re plotting a birthday ambush, tying the knot, or just craving a buttercream fix, Cakes By Katya turns ideas into gorgeous, made-from-scratch cakes. This week, treat yourself to artisan designs, cupcakes, cutout cookies, and the occasional croissant cameo that makes weekday coffee feel fancy.”

From the Niagara Falls newsletter, August 18, 2026

“Whether you’re craving that legendary sponge candy or a box of artisan truffles, Alethea's Chocolates keeps it FRESH with sweets handcrafted in their own facility. Bonus points for the ice cream parlor, because sometimes Western New York pride tastes best as a sundae topped with chocolate.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 3, 2026

“Whether you’re celebrating or craving something sweet, Fig Tree Patisserie turns out custom cakes, hand-piped cookies, and what many call the best macarons in WNY. The pastry case changes daily, with French and Sicilian classics, legit vegan, gluten-free, and keto treats, plus a new macaron flavor every month.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 22, 2026

“Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.”

“Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.”

“The women-owned French-style patisserie Butter Block on Buffalo’s West Side keeps locals spoiled with croissants, cookies, and playful European-inspired pastries that change with the seasons.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 1, 2026

“Parkside Candy has been crafting Buffalo's signature Sponge Candy since 1927, along with homemade chocolates, old-fashioned lollipops, and an ice cream parlor that feels like stepping back in time. Treat yourself this week... grab a box for the house, a couple for gifts, and maybe a sundae because why not.”

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, August 29, 2026

“Since 1985, Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream has made fresh, small-batch scoops and handmade chocolates right inside the historic 1811 Williamsville Mill, often the same day you buy them.”

From the Amherst newsletter, September 4, 2026

“Ohlson's Bakery & Cafe turns out daily Wisconsin Kringles with flaky, layered dough and fillings like cherry, almond, or raspberry, alongside gourmet cupcakes, cheesecakes, and coffee cakes. Whether you need a celebration centerpiece or a pick-me-up, their custom cakes and pastry case deliver serious wow.”

From the Amherst newsletter, September 15, 2026

“Between bubble waffles piled high, the viral Dubai Chocolate Strawberry cup with pistachio sauce and kanafa, Nutella-loaded crepes, and that Lotus Milkshake that tastes like Biscoff daydreams, Golden Waffles is your excuse to skip dinner and go straight to dessert this week.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 24, 2026

“Housemade bagels, pretzels & breads, plus gourmet cafe eats, in a cozy space with a patio.”

“Spacious shop for handmade candies, including sponges, truffles and other varieties, plus ice cream.”

“Whether you’re after hearty whole-grain loaves, flaky pastries, or an espresso that actually wakes you up, Five Points Bakery bakes with locally sourced ingredients and a lot of care. It’s the kind of neighborly spot you detour for, with a cafe vibe and even beer, wine, and a few grocery staples.”

From the Amherst newsletter, September 5, 2026

“This week, treat yourself to Parkside Candy, a Buffalo original since 1927 known for its signature Sponge Candy, homemade chocolates, and an old-fashioned ice cream parlor where sundaes taste like childhood. Perfect for gifting, or for keeping a suspiciously small box all to yourself.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 18, 2026

“Manchester Place Baking Co. cranks out oversized cookies with a rotating lineup that actually rotates… think Ultimate Ube, peanut butter Butterfinger, rainbow confetti, classic whoopie pies, and chewy blondie bars. Treat yourself this week, hide them from your roommates, and pretend portion control is a suggestion.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 10, 2026

“Frost Artisan Bakery takes those grandma-kitchen classics and gives them a polished, modern glow. Drop in for tarts, cannoli, cream puffs, and the Cupcake Bar, or plan a custom cake for your next milestone... Buffalo-tested way to sweeten any get-together.”

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 13, 2026

“Since 1950, The Chocolate Shop & More has been crafting Buffalo-made chocolates that locals actually brag about. From boxed assortments and Easter bunnies to logo-stamped bars, corporate gifts, and custom molds, they even run fundraising programs, so your kid’s team can sell something people fight over.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 6, 2026

“Artigiana is that rare bakery where every loaf feels hand-signed... classic sourdough, hearty whole grains, fruit-and-nut beauties, even seeded baguettes and focaccia, all built on great ingredients.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 10, 2026

“Whether you need celebratory cake magic, hand-decorated cupcakes, or a box of nostalgic cookies that taste like home, Fairy Cakes Bakeshop bakes everything in-house with fresh ingredients. Swing by this week for custom designs or even a full dessert table, plus they’ve been featured on Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats.”

From the West Seneca newsletter, August 29, 2026

“Buffalo-based shop carrying sponge candy as well as chocolates, ice cream and other treats.”