The best restaurants in Lima

30 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Lima’s best · Entertainment · Pets · Arts & Culture · Cafes · Home & Garden · Beauty · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Shopping

Pinned in Lima today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Lima — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 30 places · showing the latest additions first

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

Restaurants

Rooted in its original Beer Barrel style pizza but rocking an expansive made-from-scratch menu, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill pairs signature…

1840 S Dixie Hwy

“Rooted in its original Beer Barrel style pizza but rocking an expansive made-from-scratch menu, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill pairs signature apps and buttermilk-brined, hand-breaded chicken with an extensive list of classic and craft beers. Add live music and it's your weeknight no-brainer.”

From the Lima newsletter, August 4, 2026

Cancun Mexican restaurant Lima

Restaurants

When the craving hits, Cancun Mexican Restaurant brings Lima legit flavor with fresh guacamole, street corn, and sizzling fajitas, plus…

2613 Elida Rd

“When the craving hits, Cancun Mexican Restaurant brings Lima legit flavor with fresh guacamole, street corn, and sizzling fajitas, plus margaritas and handcrafted cocktails that actually taste like sunshine. Save room for churros or flan this week, your future self will be grateful.”

Ginger Asian Kitchen Lima

Restaurants

Relaxed venue turning out Chinese and Thai classics, plus sushi.

1501 Allentown Rd

“Relaxed venue turning out Chinese and Thai classics, plus sushi.”

Old City Prime

Restaurants

American restaurant & lounge with live entertainment including dueling pianos, jazz & tribute bands.

215 S Main St

“American restaurant & lounge with live entertainment including dueling pianos, jazz & tribute bands.”

Run a Lima business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Shawnee Station

Restaurants

Cozy place providing breakfast, burgers, and other comfort eats, plus beer and wine.

2228 Shawnee Rd

“Cozy place providing breakfast, burgers, and other comfort eats, plus beer and wine.”

Milano Café

Restaurants

Long-standing trattoria offering a variety of old-fashioned Italian dishes in a comfortable setting.

2383 Elida Rd

“Long-standing trattoria offering a variety of old-fashioned Italian dishes in a comfortable setting.”

Hot Head Burritos

Restaurants

Mexican chain serving customizable dishes, such as burrito bowls, over the counter.

2525 Elida Rd

“Mexican chain serving customizable dishes, such as burrito bowls, over the counter.”

Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders

Restaurants

Kid-friendly chain known for its pizzas & oversized sandwiches served in modest surroundings.

2330 Elida Rd C

“Kid-friendly chain known for its pizzas & oversized sandwiches served in modest surroundings.”

Fat Jack's Pizza

Restaurants

Local pizzeria chain serving pies, sandwiches & wings, plus BBQ ribs & chicken, in a casual space.

1806 N West St

“Local pizzeria chain serving pies, sandwiches & wings, plus BBQ ribs & chicken, in a casual space.”

Casa Lu Al

Restaurants

Classic Italian dishes are served in a casual restaurant or a cozy cellar-style space.

147 S Main St

“Classic Italian dishes are served in a casual restaurant or a cozy cellar-style space.”

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

2525 Elida Rd

“Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.”

Q BBQ & Fixin's

Restaurants

Upscale options for tacos, tequila and margaritas in a lively setting with a rooftop terrace.

147 S Main St

“Upscale options for tacos, tequila and margaritas in a lively setting with a rooftop terrace.”

IHOP

Restaurants

Long-standing chain serving a wide variety of pancakes & other American breakfast & diner fare.

3289 Elida Rd

“Long-standing chain serving a wide variety of pancakes & other American breakfast & diner fare.”

Fazoli's

Restaurants

Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.

2150 Elida Rd

“Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.”

Pizza Hut

Restaurants

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

1509 N Cable Rd

“Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.”

El Cazador Bar and Grill 1

Restaurants

Traditional family recipes for Mexican meals and margaritas in a kid-friendly setting.

2323 N West St

“Traditional family recipes for Mexican meals and margaritas in a kid-friendly setting.”

Lock Sixteen Steakhouse

Restaurants

Laid-back American bar/eatery with casual steak & seafood meals, plus weekly specials & happy hours.

2530 N Eastown Rd (Elida)

“Laid-back American bar/eatery with casual steak & seafood meals, plus weekly specials & happy hours.”

Wings and Rings

Restaurants

Modern sports bar with a wide range of wing flavors, plus other pub eats & kids' deals.

1939 Roschman Ave

“Modern sports bar with a wide range of wing flavors, plus other pub eats & kids' deals.”

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

Restaurants

Popular outpost featuring draft microbrews, hearty pizzas, burgers & other eats, plus patio seating.

2625 W Market St

“Popular outpost featuring draft microbrews, hearty pizzas, burgers & other eats, plus patio seating.”

318 Restaurant & Bar

Restaurants

Trendy, informal eatery and bar featuring burgers and other casual fare, plus a patio and karaoke.

318 N Main St

“Trendy, informal eatery and bar featuring burgers and other casual fare, plus a patio and karaoke.”

Happy Daz

Restaurants

Familiar diner fare such as steaks, hamburgers and shakes, plus some salads and wraps.

1064 Bellefontaine Ave

“Familiar diner fare such as steaks, hamburgers and shakes, plus some salads and wraps.”

Bella Notta's Pizza

Restaurants

Relaxed eatery known for 2-for-1 deals and offering pizza, salads, subs and wings.

662 S Main St

“Relaxed eatery known for 2-for-1 deals and offering pizza, salads, subs and wings.”

Old Barn Restaurant & Event Center

Restaurants

Laid-back place offering a breakfast and dinner buffet, alongside menu items.

3175 W Elm St

“Laid-back place offering a breakfast and dinner buffet, alongside menu items.”

Yamato West

Restaurants

Japanese restaurant featuring hibachi-grilled fare, sushi, and other specialties in a casual atmosphere.

2315 Elida Rd

“Japanese restaurant featuring hibachi-grilled fare, sushi, and other specialties in a casual atmosphere.”

La Charreada

Restaurants

Traditional Mexican fare with full bar served in a colorfully painted setting filled with art.

1448 N Cable Rd

“Traditional Mexican fare with full bar served in a colorfully painted setting filled with art.”

Thai Jasmine

Restaurants

Relaxed, long-standing eatery presenting made-to-order Thai dishes in warm, intimate environs.

215 S Pine St

“Relaxed, long-standing eatery presenting made-to-order Thai dishes in warm, intimate environs.”

Yamato East

Restaurants

Casual sushi restaurant serving Japanese cuisine including fried rice, hibachi, and bento boxes.

1507 Harding Hwy

“Casual sushi restaurant serving Japanese cuisine including fried rice, hibachi, and bento boxes.”

Rigali's Pizza Village

Restaurants

Local joint serving pizza and other staples in a laid-back space with a kids' menu.

505 W North St

“Local joint serving pizza and other staples in a laid-back space with a kids' menu.”

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

Restaurants

Chain restaurant with a wood-burning fireplace serving specialty pizzas, plus beer, wine, and cocktails.

2755 Harding Hwy Suite B

“Chain restaurant with a wood-burning fireplace serving specialty pizzas, plus beer, wine, and cocktails.”

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →