The best restaurants in Lima

34 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Lima’s best · Home & Garden · Arts & Culture · Pets · Entertainment · Shopping · Cafes · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Parks & Outdoors

Pinned in Lima today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Lima — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 34 places · showing the latest additions first

Rooted in its original Beer Barrel style pizza but rocking an expansive made-from-scratch menu, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill pairs signature…

1840 S Dixie Hwy

Rooted in its original Beer Barrel style pizza but rocking an expansive made-from-scratch menu, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill pairs signature apps and buttermilk-brined, hand-breaded chicken with an extensive list of classic and craft beers. Add live music and it's your weeknight no-brainer.

From the Lima newsletter, September 17, 2026

Website ↗

When the craving hits, Cancun Mexican Restaurant brings Lima legit flavor with fresh guacamole, street corn, and sizzling fajitas, plus…

2613 Elida Rd

When the craving hits, Cancun Mexican Restaurant brings Lima legit flavor with fresh guacamole, street corn, and sizzling fajitas, plus margaritas and handcrafted cocktails that actually taste like sunshine. Save room for churros or flan this week, your future self will be grateful.

From the Lima newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you’re feeling spicy Thai curry, classic Chinese takeout favorites, or a sushi roll situation, Ginger Asian Kitchen Lima keeps it…

1501 Allentown Rd

Whether you’re feeling spicy Thai curry, classic Chinese takeout favorites, or a sushi roll situation, Ginger Asian Kitchen Lima keeps it fresh and surprisingly light without skimping on flavor. Treat yourself this week and let someone else handle dinner, chopsticks and all.

From the Lima newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Old City Prime

Restaurants

Old City Prime pairs serious, perfectly seared steaks with a lively lounge vibe, where dueling pianos, jazz, and tribute bands keep the…

215 S Main St

Old City Prime pairs serious, perfectly seared steaks with a lively lounge vibe, where dueling pianos, jazz, and tribute bands keep the night rolling. It’s the kind of spot locals use for celebrations, date nights, or whenever dinner should feel like an event.

From the Lima newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Lima business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Shawnee Station

Restaurants

When a craving hits, Shawnee Station keeps it simple and stellar. Their fresh, never-frozen Station Burger checks every box, and the…

2228 Shawnee Rd

When a craving hits, Shawnee Station keeps it simple and stellar. Their fresh, never-frozen Station Burger checks every box, and the handcrafted Crimson Cup Coffee, beer and wine lineup plus salads, vegetarian bites, and smoothies make it a crowd-pleasing pick this week.

From the Lima newsletter, August 25, 2026

Website ↗

Craving quality without the fuss? The Olde Thyme Pantry is a specialty grocery and deli with bulk staples, fresh baked goods, and legit…

626 E Main St (Elida)

Craving quality without the fuss? The Olde Thyme Pantry is a specialty grocery and deli with bulk staples, fresh baked goods, and legit local products, so you can restock the pantry this week, upgrade lunch, and grab something sweet for later in one easy stop.

From the Lima newsletter, August 13, 2026

Website ↗

Milano Café

Restaurants

Family owned since 1931 and proudly Lima’s oldest family-owned restaurant, Milano Café serves old world recipes with a modern twist, from…

2383 Elida Rd · ✓ checked Sep 3

Family owned since 1931 and proudly Lima’s oldest family-owned restaurant, Milano Café serves old world recipes with a modern twist, from red-sauce favorites to cozy, celebration-worthy plates. It’s the kind of place you bring people you like, then pretend you cooked it yourself.

From the Lima newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

Fuji Hibachi Sushi & Lava Bar brings bold flavors and fresh ingredients to Lima with beautifully crafted sushi, sizzling hibachi, and a…

2809 Elida Rd

Fuji Hibachi Sushi & Lava Bar brings bold flavors and fresh ingredients to Lima with beautifully crafted sushi, sizzling hibachi, and a curated drink lineup of premium sake, imported beers, fine wines, and cocktails. Slide in this week for a laid back lunch or a lively night out, presentation here does the talking.

From the Lima newsletter, August 21, 2026

Website ↗

When dinner needs to be quick but not boring this week, Hot Head Burritos lets you build burritos, bowls or tacos exactly how you like…

2525 Elida Rd

When dinner needs to be quick but not boring this week, Hot Head Burritos lets you build burritos, bowls or tacos exactly how you like them, then finish with a lineup of sauces to match your mood. Perfect for a post-practice refuel or a no-cook night.

From the Lima newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Nonno's Cellar

Restaurants

Step down into Nonno's Cellar for brick-arch coziness, great music, and an intimate vibe that feels like you scored the best table in town.…

147 S Main St

Step down into Nonno's Cellar for brick-arch coziness, great music, and an intimate vibe that feels like you scored the best table in town. It serves Casa Lu Al favorites minus pizza and sandwiches, plus a couple cocktails you can only get downstairs... perfect for celebrations or a midweek treat.

From the Lima newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Social House

Restaurants

Social House turns a former open-air bus shelter into a bright, glass-wrapped hangout where burgers, shrimp and grits, and even beignets…

205 S Central Ave

Social House turns a former open-air bus shelter into a bright, glass-wrapped hangout where burgers, shrimp and grits, and even beignets land next to crafty cocktails and microbrews. Go for the relaxed, local energy with occasional live music and a menu that balances comfort and a little flourish.

From the Lima newsletter, September 12, 2026

Website ↗

Kid-friendly chain known for its pizzas & oversized sandwiches served in modest surroundings.

2330 Elida Rd C

Kid-friendly chain known for its pizzas & oversized sandwiches served in modest surroundings.

Website ↗

Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar is your move this week for a rotating lunch buffet packed with fresh curries, naan, and vegetarian…

3175 W Elm St

Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar is your move this week for a rotating lunch buffet packed with fresh curries, naan, and vegetarian favorites, plus go-to plates like chicken tikka masala, butter chicken, goat curry, and paneer. Dine in, grab carryout or delivery, or book catering for the next get-together.

From the Lima newsletter, September 5, 2026

Website ↗

Fat Jack's Pizza

Restaurants

When cooking sounds like a chore, Fat Jack's Pizza steps in with made-to-order pies, saucy wings, stacked sandwiches, plus BBQ dishes that…

1806 N West St

When cooking sounds like a chore, Fat Jack's Pizza steps in with made-to-order pies, saucy wings, stacked sandwiches, plus BBQ dishes that hit the spot. Family-owned since 1975 and big on fresh ingredients, it’s the reliable Lima classic your weeknight deserves.

From the Lima newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

Casa Lu Al

Restaurants

Casa Lu Al is the revival of a Lima Italian classic, turning cravings into comfort with menus for lunch, dinner, dessert, and drinks. If…

147 S Main St

Casa Lu Al is the revival of a Lima Italian classic, turning cravings into comfort with menus for lunch, dinner, dessert, and drinks. If you want a cozy hang or an easy event this week, Nonno's Cellar brings the vibe and their team handles the food and setup so you can relax.

From the Lima newsletter, September 4, 2026

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

2525 Elida Rd

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Q BBQ & Fixin's

Restaurants

Q BBQ & Fixin's is calling your name this week with smoked meats, kickin fixin's, cocktails, and a brisket trifecta smoked, corned, and…

147 S Main St

Q BBQ & Fixin's is calling your name this week with smoked meats, kickin fixin's, cocktails, and a brisket trifecta smoked, corned, and pastrami plus six sauces to mix and match. Local tip, assemble your perfect plate then argue lovingly about which sauce wins.

From the Lima newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

IHOP

Restaurants

Long-standing chain serving a wide variety of pancakes & other American breakfast & diner fare.

3289 Elida Rd

Long-standing chain serving a wide variety of pancakes & other American breakfast & diner fare.

Website ↗

Fazoli's

Restaurants

Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.

2150 Elida Rd

Fast-food chain doling out baked pastas, subs, pizza & other casual Italian fare plus custom combos.

Website ↗

Pizza Hut

Restaurants

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

1509 N Cable Rd

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

Website ↗

When tacos and a cold drink are calling, El Cazador Bar and Grill keeps it simple with authentic, affordable Mexican classics, hearty…

2323 N West St

When tacos and a cold drink are calling, El Cazador Bar and Grill keeps it simple with authentic, affordable Mexican classics, hearty specialties, and a fun, family friendly vibe. Perfect for a low-key weeknight or catching up with friends, with plates that hit the table fast and flavors that feel like a mini vacation.

From the Lima newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Locally owned and proudly Lima, Lock Sixteen Steakhouse dishes out tender steaks, familiar seafood favorites, and a menu so big choosing is…

2530 N Eastown Rd (Elida)

Locally owned and proudly Lima, Lock Sixteen Steakhouse dishes out tender steaks, familiar seafood favorites, and a menu so big choosing is the toughest part. Grab your people, lean into the indecision, and let dinner turn into an easy win this week.

From the Lima newsletter, August 24, 2026

Website ↗

Wings and Rings

Restaurants

Modern sports bar with a wide range of wing flavors, plus other pub eats & kids' deals.

1939 Roschman Ave

Modern sports bar with a wide range of wing flavors, plus other pub eats & kids' deals.

Website ↗

When the week needs a reset, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill has you covered with their original Beer Barrel style pies, made-from-scratch apps,…

2625 W Market St

When the week needs a reset, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill has you covered with their original Beer Barrel style pies, made-from-scratch apps, and an extensive beer list of classics and crafts. Grab friends for live music nights and call it a Lima win.

From the Lima newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

318 Restaurant & Bar in downtown Lima pours craft and domestic beers, shakes up proper cocktails, and builds the kind of juicy burgers that…

318 N Main St

318 Restaurant & Bar in downtown Lima pours craft and domestic beers, shakes up proper cocktails, and builds the kind of juicy burgers that disappear faster than your resolve. Swing by for karaoke or a live show, grab the patio when the weather behaves, and enjoy the friendly, low-key vibe locals keep coming back for.

From the Lima newsletter, September 14, 2026

Website ↗

Happy Daz

Restaurants

Lima legends know when you need crispy bacon bliss and a thick shake, Happy Daz delivers. The new S'mores Milkshake is pure summer…

1064 Bellefontaine Ave

Lima legends know when you need crispy bacon bliss and a thick shake, Happy Daz delivers. The new S'mores Milkshake is pure summer nostalgia, and that BLT or BBQ boneless rib sandwich hits the spot when you want simple, satisfying, hometown flavor.

From the Lima newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Built on fresh daily dough and a sauce locals swear by, Bella Notta's Pizza nails the classics and the fun stuff... think Deluxe and…

662 S Main St

Built on fresh daily dough and a sauce locals swear by, Bella Notta's Pizza nails the classics and the fun stuff... think Deluxe and Pepperoni Extreme pies, golden calzones, oven-baked wings, hearty pastas, and cookie pizza for dessert. Since 2004, Lima comfort on speed dial.

From the Lima newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Old Barn Restaurant & Event Center is teasing a return, and Lima loyalists know what that could mean. Keep an eye on their updates this…

3175 W Elm St

Old Barn Restaurant & Event Center is teasing a return, and Lima loyalists know what that could mean. Keep an eye on their updates this week, then be ready to rally the crew when the doors open again... because some places just feel like home the second you sit down.

From the Lima newsletter, September 19, 2026

Website ↗

Yamato West

Restaurants

Yamato West keeps Lima happily fed with sizzling hibachi sets that include soup, salad, fried rice, and soba, plus a deep sushi lineup from…

2315 Elida Rd

Yamato West keeps Lima happily fed with sizzling hibachi sets that include soup, salad, fried rice, and soba, plus a deep sushi lineup from classics to signatures like Buckeye and Surf n Turf. It is reliably tasty, portions are generous, and the casual vibe works just as well for family nights as friend catchups.

From the Lima newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗

La Charreada

Restaurants

La Charreada keeps it simple and satisfying with fresh, authentically made favorites that hit the spot after a long day. Voted the region’s…

1448 N Cable Rd

La Charreada keeps it simple and satisfying with fresh, authentically made favorites that hit the spot after a long day. Voted the region’s best for 14 years and counting, it’s the kind of go-to you’ll be happy to slide into your weeknight rotation.

From the Lima newsletter, August 10, 2026

Website ↗

Thai Jasmine

Restaurants

Lima’s Thai Jasmine deals in bold, made-to-order Thai, from basil-kissed gaprow and tamarind tofu to that sleeper hit, beef macadamia.…

215 S Pine St

Lima’s Thai Jasmine deals in bold, made-to-order Thai, from basil-kissed gaprow and tamarind tofu to that sleeper hit, beef macadamia. Cozy, unfussy, and reliably delicious... perfect for when you want real flavor without overthinking dinner this week.

From the Lima newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Yamato East

Restaurants

Craving a low-key roll night or hibachi without the fuss, Yamato East keeps Lima fed with fresh rolls, fried rice, and bento boxes. Order…

1507 Harding Hwy

Craving a low-key roll night or hibachi without the fuss, Yamato East keeps Lima fed with fresh rolls, fried rice, and bento boxes. Order online, eat happy, and call it a win for your midweek dinner rotation.

From the Lima newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Between thin, regular or thick crust, saucy Spaghetti Pizza, and that dangerously good Cheesy Garlic Butter Pizza, Rigali's Pizza Village…

505 W North St

Between thin, regular or thick crust, saucy Spaghetti Pizza, and that dangerously good Cheesy Garlic Butter Pizza, Rigali's Pizza Village should be your weeknight hero this week. Toss in a legit kids’ menu, pastas, Italian Wedding Soup, and the namesake Rigali Burger, and everybody’s fed.

From the Lima newsletter, August 15, 2026

Website ↗

Craving an easy win this week, Lima? Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill nails it with their original Beer Barrel style pies, made-from-scratch apps,…

2755 Harding Hwy Suite B

Craving an easy win this week, Lima? Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill nails it with their original Beer Barrel style pies, made-from-scratch apps, and an extensive beer lineup of classics and crafts. Add live music and buttermilk-brined, hand-breaded chicken with bold new flavors and you’re set.

From the Lima newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →