The best bakeries & sweet shops in Sidney

“Ulbrich's Hometown Bakery nails that Sidney sweet spot between tradition and creativity, turning quality ingredients into gourmet pastries and custom cakes that look great and actually deliver flavor.”

“Baken Me Happy nails the hometown sweet tooth with 5 oz bakery style cookies chilled 24 hours for a perfect chewy bite, from Cookies & Cream to S’mores and Cookie Butter. Add banana pudding, parfait cups, brownies, or a cookie cake, then order online for easy pickup... some items need a little notice.”

“Chilly Jilly's is that low-key Sidney staple when your sweet tooth clock strikes now, serving creamy soft-serve twists, hot fudge milkshakes, and cyclone-style candy mix-ups that hit the nostalgia button. Perfect for post-practice bribes, weeknight pick-me-ups, or anytime you need a quick smile in cone form.”

“Susie's Big Dipper churns every scoop on-site in small batches with premium ingredients, and the aroma of freshly made waffle cones seals the deal. Expect 50+ flavors plus melts, soups, salads, and hot topped waffles, and yes, their bright yellow ice cream truck can roll up to your event.”

“Family-owned Dulce Vida Ice Cream - Paleteria & Heladeria turns hot afternoons into small celebrations with artisan Mexican ice cream and paletas in 40+ flavors, plus craveable snacks. When a plain vanilla mood hits, try something bolder... fruity, creamy, or unexpected, and discover a go-to treat spot.”

From the Gahanna newsletter, September 3, 2026

“Mardi Gras Homemade Ice Cream brings serious flavor adventure with a Flavors of India lineup and more than 50 scoops, from Kesar Pista and Malai Kulfee to tropical Jamun, Chikoo, and Sitafal, plus thick milkshakes and celebration-ready cakes. Treat yourself this week, no passport needed.”

From the Dublin newsletter, August 25, 2026