If your afternoon needs a morale boost, Troyer's Home Pantry II has cream pies, fruit pies, strawberry pie that begs for seconds, and…
319 E North St
“If your afternoon needs a morale boost, Troyer's Home Pantry II has cream pies, fruit pies, strawberry pie that begs for seconds, and cinnamon rolls with fresh brewed coffee to match. Everything’s fresh, simple, and made like they actually care... perfect for Wooster folks who keep meaning to treat themselves.”
Cookie Snob turns out soft, handcrafted cookies in seasonal shapes and flavors, from football-ready batches to cozy fall pumpkins and even…
201 E Liberty St Suit 101
“Cookie Snob turns out soft, handcrafted cookies in seasonal shapes and flavors, from football-ready batches to cozy fall pumpkins and even gluten free options. Perfect for watch parties, last-minute treats, or custom orders, and cakes are available through Beyond Measure Baking Co.”
Orr Valley Creamery is your close-to-home ice cream fix with an extra local twist, featuring fresh buns crafted with Michael’s Bakery’s…
3004 Dover Rd
“Orr Valley Creamery is your close-to-home ice cream fix with an extra local twist, featuring fresh buns crafted with Michael’s Bakery’s signature sponge dough recipe. Perfect for a quick scoop after errands or when you want dessert and something satisfying in one stop.”
Auntie Anne's at the Wooster Walmart turns errand runs into snack wins with butter-brushed soft pretzels, bite-sized nuggets, and Pretzel…
3883 Burbank Rd Suite 1
“Auntie Anne's at the Wooster Walmart turns errand runs into snack wins with butter-brushed soft pretzels, bite-sized nuggets, and Pretzel Dogs wrapped around a Nathan’s hot dog. Wash it down with an iced lemonade and keep moving… happiness, handheld.”
From monthly cupcake menus and gluten free options to custom cakes for birthdays, weddings, and all the kid-to-adult milestones, The…
838 E Milltown Rd
“From monthly cupcake menus and gluten free options to custom cakes for birthdays, weddings, and all the kid-to-adult milestones, The Faithful Little Cupcake nails the sweet spot. Order online, peek their classes, and let those cut-out cookies make you the office hero.”
Butter & Fire Bakery started as Linda Yoder Pattin’s cottage kitchen project, and now turns out hand-baked cookies, scones, and “healthy…
1218 S Honeytown Rd
“Butter & Fire Bakery started as Linda Yoder Pattin’s cottage kitchen project, and now turns out hand-baked cookies, scones, and “healthy bites” with wholesome ingredients that don’t skimp on joy. Spot them at Local Roots or College of Wooster, and pounce when you see pecan cinnamon roll scones.”
Since 1933, Lerch's Donuts has been the soft cake, not-greasy donut Wooster grew up on, with a stand at the Wayne County Fair since 1934…
2312 Akron Rd
“Since 1933, Lerch's Donuts has been the soft cake, not-greasy donut Wooster grew up on, with a stand at the Wayne County Fair since 1934 and trailers popping up around town in season. Grab a warm bag, maybe a French waffle and fresh-squeezed lemonade too, then pretend you'll share.”
Whether you need a cozy spot to recharge or a sweet fix after work, Café Indigo and Ice Cream too… nails the coffee dessert combo with a…
13201 Shaker Square (Cleveland)
“Whether you need a cozy spot to recharge or a sweet fix after work, Café Indigo and Ice Cream too… nails the coffee dessert combo with a chill, community-first vibe and locally sourced quality. They also make hosting easy with online reservations, ordering, and full-on party catering.”
From the Youngstown newsletter, September 10, 2026
Family-owned since 1965, Dari-Land Ice Cream sticks to tried and true recipes and fresh ingredients made with love every day. It’s the…
306 W Liberty St
“Family-owned since 1965, Dari-Land Ice Cream sticks to tried and true recipes and fresh ingredients made with love every day. It’s the hometown scoop stop for post-game cones, little celebrations, and random Tuesday cravings, the kind of place Wooster folks grow up with then keep coming back to.”
Broken Rocks Café & Bakery is Downtown Wooster’s go-to for scratch-made everything, from cozy breakfasts to house-baked desserts that test…
123 E Liberty St
“Broken Rocks Café & Bakery is Downtown Wooster’s go-to for scratch-made everything, from cozy breakfasts to house-baked desserts that test your willpower.”
Crepe N’ Drip is where your sweet tooth meets premium Belgian chocolate, gelato and ice cream, and signature sweet crepes and…
1385 W 117th St (Cleveland)
“Crepe N’ Drip is where your sweet tooth meets premium Belgian chocolate, gelato and ice cream, and signature sweet crepes and American-style waffles finished with real pistachio and white chocolate. Add a rich espresso or a 100% natural smoothie and you’ve got dessert vibes worth a neighborhood detour.”
Serving Cleveland since 1974 and now a Parma staple, Honey Hut Ice Cream turns out homemade cones, sundaes, and milkshakes in seasonal…
6250 State Rd (Cleveland)
“Serving Cleveland since 1974 and now a Parma staple, Honey Hut Ice Cream turns out homemade cones, sundaes, and milkshakes in seasonal flavors using all natural ingredients from local farms, like raspberries from Foote’s Farm, Cleveland dairy, and honey from an Amish farm in Walnut Creek.”
Since 1974, Honey Hut Ice Cream has been the hometown go-to for fresh, seasonal scoops made with all-natural ingredients, from Foote’s Farm…
4674 State Rd (Cleveland)
“Since 1974, Honey Hut Ice Cream has been the hometown go-to for fresh, seasonal scoops made with all-natural ingredients, from Foote’s Farm raspberries to dairy from a Cleveland dairy and honey from an Ohio Amish farm. Hit Old Brooklyn, Parma, Solon, or Brecksville this week and treat yourself.”
Casa Dolce Bakery is the Mayfield Heights spot when you’re craving real-deal cannolis, tiramisu, or that famous almond cake, plus fresh…
5732 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)
“Casa Dolce Bakery is the Mayfield Heights spot when you’re craving real-deal cannolis, tiramisu, or that famous almond cake, plus fresh breads for breakfast. Skip cooking this week and raid their daily-changing prepared foods, paninis, pastas, soups, and occasional heavy hitters like osso bucco or poached salmon.”
The HoneyBirch Bakehouse in Cleveland’s Larchmere neighborhood turns out crackly loaves, flaky pastries, and legit baguette and deli…
12204 Larchmere Blvd (Cleveland)
“The HoneyBirch Bakehouse in Cleveland’s Larchmere neighborhood turns out crackly loaves, flaky pastries, and legit baguette and deli sandwiches, plus a tiny grocer’s pantry with locally sourced dairy, eggs, chocolates, and conservas… ideal for a weekend stock up when you’re already headed toward Cleveland.”
In Cleveland's Asiatown, Koko Bakery nails that sweet-savory lineup locals love, from curry and sweet cream buns to teriyaki or katsu…
3710 Payne Ave (Cleveland)
“In Cleveland's Asiatown, Koko Bakery nails that sweet-savory lineup locals love, from curry and sweet cream buns to teriyaki or katsu sandwiches that actually count as lunch. Pair it with brown sugar matcha or passion fruit milk boba, then snag a tiramisu, macaron, or Taiwanese-style custard tart for the road.”
Colossal Cupcakes was the colorful, sugar-slinging spot for specialty cupcakes, soft-serve cones, and soda floats, and yes, we’re still…
528 Euclid Ave (Cleveland)
“Colossal Cupcakes was the colorful, sugar-slinging spot for specialty cupcakes, soft-serve cones, and soda floats, and yes, we’re still thinking about them. They’ve hung up the aprons, but locals with a sweet tooth in Warren still swap stories about those playful flavors and frosting.”
Planning a birthday, shower, or just craving frosting art, CAKE drama handcrafts custom cakes in Gordon Square with mix-and-match flavors…
5409 Detroit Ave (Cleveland)
“Planning a birthday, shower, or just craving frosting art, CAKE drama handcrafts custom cakes in Gordon Square with mix-and-match flavors per tier and smart custom sizing. They also do sheet cakes and cupcakes, plus in-person or virtual design consults and tasting sample boxes, so lock in something sweet this week.”
Whether you’re hunting for retro faves, hard-to-find sweets, or party-perfect colors, All City Candy is the local hookup. Build a candy…
746 Richmond Rd (Cleveland)
“Whether you’re hunting for retro faves, hard-to-find sweets, or party-perfect colors, All City Candy is the local hookup. Build a candy buffet that matches your team or wedding palette, explore kosher, vegan, or nut-free options, and snag fudge, cookies, and chocolate treats for this week’s cravings.”
Presti's Bakery is your reliable go-to when you want pastries, cookie trays for the crew, or Italian comfort like sheet pizza, lasagna,…
12101 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)
“Presti's Bakery is your reliable go-to when you want pastries, cookie trays for the crew, or Italian comfort like sheet pizza, lasagna, eggplant parm and chicken marsala. Swing by this week for a quick bite or take-home spread that makes dinner feel like Nonna cooked.”
Aladdin's Baking Co is a Cleveland landmark turning out renowned pita, craveable made-to-order sandwiches, and a stash of Mediterranean…
1301 Carnegie Ave (Cleveland)
“Aladdin's Baking Co is a Cleveland landmark turning out renowned pita, craveable made-to-order sandwiches, and a stash of Mediterranean imports. Planning a get-together? Their catering lineup makes feeding a crowd surprisingly painless, which is exactly what your group chat needs right now.”
Whether you're into blueberry lemon, chocolate amaretto, or a classic cherry, Slices Fabulous Cakes turns out cheesecakes in all the good…
4190 Pearl Rd (Cleveland)
“Whether you're into blueberry lemon, chocolate amaretto, or a classic cherry, Slices Fabulous Cakes turns out cheesecakes in all the good flavors plus specialty cakes that taste like a celebration. Bookmark this for birthdays, random Tuesdays, and every sweet emergency... your fork will know what to do.”
Grandma Campbell's Cupcakes bakes the kind of fresh cupcakes you swear you’ll only have one of, then backs it up with Campbell’s Sweets…
1979 W 25th St Stand #A9 (Cleveland)
“Grandma Campbell's Cupcakes bakes the kind of fresh cupcakes you swear you’ll only have one of, then backs it up with Campbell’s Sweets Factory’s small-batch gourmet popcorn and hand-dipped chocolates. Perfect for Lorain weeknights, game-day spreads, or easy online gifting when you need a win in the dessert column.”
