The best restaurants in Youngstown

61 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Youngstown’s best · Bakeries & Sweets · Arts & Culture · Nightlife · Entertainment · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Beauty · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Sporting Goods · Parks & Outdoors · Shopping · Home & Garden

Pinned in Youngstown today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Youngstown — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 61 places · showing the latest additions first

Fiesta Vallarta

Restaurants

Casual setting offering Mexican fare such as street tacos and fajitas, plus beer and margaritas.

5221 State Rd (Cleveland)

Casual setting offering Mexican fare such as street tacos and fajitas, plus beer and margaritas.

Website ↗

Kravitz Delicatessen Inc has been the corned-beef gold standard for 80-plus years, turning out epic Reubens, breakfast favorites, and daily…

3135 Belmont Ave

Kravitz Delicatessen Inc has been the corned-beef gold standard for 80-plus years, turning out epic Reubens, breakfast favorites, and daily soups like chicken noodle aka Jewish penicillin, and wedding soup. Treat yourself or win the office with party trays, boxed lunches, and deli meats by the pound this week.

Website ↗

Opal On Pearl

Restaurants

Opal On Pearl is that relaxed, modern bar you keep meaning to try, with a tight menu of wine, thoughtful cocktails, and crispy flatbreads…

4250 Pearl Rd (Cleveland)

Opal On Pearl is that relaxed, modern bar you keep meaning to try, with a tight menu of wine, thoughtful cocktails, and crispy flatbreads that actually deliver. Grab a seat this week, swap the group chat for real conversation, and let their kitchen handle the snacking.

From the Cleveland newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Craving something a little extra this week? Michael Alberini's Restaurant nails upscale yet casual comfort with Italian heart, global…

1140 Boardman Poland Rd

Craving something a little extra this week? Michael Alberini's Restaurant nails upscale yet casual comfort with Italian heart, global flair, and a list of 600 wines you can actually uncork at the table, plus smart pairings from staff who know their stuff.

From the Youngstown newsletter, August 4, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Youngstown business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Craving legit Alabama-style barbecue without leaving CLE? Southern Bar-B-Que & Mini Mart turns out made-to-order smoked meats, stacked BBQ…

630 E 140th St (Cleveland)

Craving legit Alabama-style barbecue without leaving CLE? Southern Bar-B-Que & Mini Mart turns out made-to-order smoked meats, stacked BBQ sandwiches, and savory sides, then lets you grab snacks and drinks from the mini mart on your way out. Comfort food, zero fuss, all Southern hospitality.

From the Cleveland newsletter, August 7, 2026

Website ↗

Etna

Restaurants

Intimate spot featuring contemporary Italian dishes & daily seafood specials, plus outdoor seats.

11919 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Intimate spot featuring contemporary Italian dishes & daily seafood specials, plus outdoor seats.

Website ↗

Mad for Chicken

Restaurants

Casual stop for chicken dishes, including bulgogi bowls, plus beers and cocktails.

5851 Youngstown Warren Rd (Niles)

Casual stop for chicken dishes, including bulgogi bowls, plus beers and cocktails.

Website ↗

A menu of small & shared Asian plates with an extensive array of classic & creative sushi & rolls.

840 Boardman Poland Rd

A menu of small & shared Asian plates with an extensive array of classic & creative sushi & rolls.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant & bar with a menu of Italian faves & jars of its signature sauce & salsa for sale.

12207 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Casual restaurant & bar with a menu of Italian faves & jars of its signature sauce & salsa for sale.

Website ↗

Chain restaurant serving steaks, seafood & cocktails in an upscale lodgelike setting.

5555 Youngstown Warren Rd Unit 696 (Niles)

Chain restaurant serving steaks, seafood & cocktails in an upscale lodgelike setting.

Website ↗

Italian eatery (classic dishes and pizza) also serving up American fare (burgers & fries) and wine.

4831 Mahoning Ave

Italian eatery (classic dishes and pizza) also serving up American fare (burgers & fries) and wine.

Website ↗

Upscale, old-school standby that offers everything from subs & salads to scallopines.

12020 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Upscale, old-school standby that offers everything from subs & salads to scallopines.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

5517 Mahoning Ave

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant showcasing hibachi dishes and sushi, plus steak and shrimp.

7401 Market St #791

Casual restaurant showcasing hibachi dishes and sushi, plus steak and shrimp.

Website ↗

La Dolce Vita

Restaurants

Italian dishes & drinks are served in a humble vintage setting with some sidewalk tables.

12112 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Italian dishes & drinks are served in a humble vintage setting with some sidewalk tables.

Website ↗

MISSION BBQ

Restaurants

Casual chain featuring BBQ & classic sides, plus memorabilia honoring soldiers & first responders.

2208 Niles Cortland Rd SE (Warren)

Casual chain featuring BBQ & classic sides, plus memorabilia honoring soldiers & first responders.

Website ↗

Decorated cafe for breakfast options, pastries and more, set in a cozy space.

8480 E Market St (Warren)

Decorated cafe for breakfast options, pastries and more, set in a cozy space.

Website ↗

Uptown Pizza

Restaurants

Classic place providing casual pizzas such as pepperoni, along with salads, wings, subs and pasta.

6041 Market St

Classic place providing casual pizzas such as pepperoni, along with salads, wings, subs and pasta.

Website ↗

Texas Roadhouse

Restaurants

Lively chain steakhouse serving American fare with a Southwestern spin amid Texas-themed decor.

1221 Boardman Poland Rd

Lively chain steakhouse serving American fare with a Southwestern spin amid Texas-themed decor.

Website ↗

Pho and other Asian eats feature at this casual restaurant with a trendy atmosphere.

7377 Market St (Boardman)

Pho and other Asian eats feature at this casual restaurant with a trendy atmosphere.

Website ↗

Comfort CLE

Restaurants

Trendy restaurant offering soul food such as wings, mac 'n' cheese, and cornbread.

1400 E 105th St (Cleveland)

Trendy restaurant offering soul food such as wings, mac 'n' cheese, and cornbread.

Website ↗

Quaint fixture serving up classic Italian fare, wine & desserts in a cozy setting.

12405 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Quaint fixture serving up classic Italian fare, wine & desserts in a cozy setting.

Website ↗

Elegant eatery specializing in prime-grade steaks, lobster sausage fettuccine and salads.

9519 E Market St (Warren)

Elegant eatery specializing in prime-grade steaks, lobster sausage fettuccine and salads.

Website ↗

Casual haunt offering pizzas with various toppings, along with subs, salads and wings.

2940 Belmont Ave

Casual haunt offering pizzas with various toppings, along with subs, salads and wings.

Website ↗

Relaxed eatery featuring steaks and seafood dishes, along with a menu for kids.

10078 Market St (North Lima)

Relaxed eatery featuring steaks and seafood dishes, along with a menu for kids.

Website ↗

Relaxed eatery for Italian staples, steaks, seafood, burgers, cocktails and wines, plus a weekend brunch menu.

44 Federal Plaza E

Relaxed eatery for Italian staples, steaks, seafood, burgers, cocktails and wines, plus a weekend brunch menu.

Website ↗

Italian fare & some Mediterranean dishes are presented in a quaint, muraled space with a full bar.

12200 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Italian fare & some Mediterranean dishes are presented in a quaint, muraled space with a full bar.

Website ↗

Old-school Italian fare, like veal piccata & lasagna, in converted family home with Victorian decor.

12309 Mayfield Rd (Cleveland)

Old-school Italian fare, like veal piccata & lasagna, in converted family home with Victorian decor.

Website ↗

Vibrant, casual sports bar with famous wings & 21 signature sauces, plus other classic pub eats.

3995 Jennings Rd (Cleveland)

Vibrant, casual sports bar with famous wings & 21 signature sauces, plus other classic pub eats.

Website ↗

Lucky's Café

Restaurants

Hip daytime eatery & bakery with a local, seasonal menu of creative New American dishes.

777 Starkweather Ave (Cleveland)

Hip daytime eatery & bakery with a local, seasonal menu of creative New American dishes.

Website ↗

Upscale Italian eatery with a fireplace and patio, serving dishes such as cioppino and butter cake.

492 McClurg Rd (Boardman)

Upscale Italian eatery with a fireplace and patio, serving dishes such as cioppino and butter cake.

Website ↗

Casual-chic spot for American comfort classics, pizza and burgers, plus a bar and patio for sports-watching.

3917 Belmont Ave

Casual-chic spot for American comfort classics, pizza and burgers, plus a bar and patio for sports-watching.

Website ↗

Eclectic eatery and bar offering traditional Latin American fare, cocktails, and live music.

12718 Larchmere Blvd (Cleveland)

Eclectic eatery and bar offering traditional Latin American fare, cocktails, and live music.

Website ↗

Fast-casual eatery dishing up brisket and pulled pork, plus sides like cheesy potatoes.

7684 Market St Unit 5

Fast-casual eatery dishing up brisket and pulled pork, plus sides like cheesy potatoes.

Website ↗

Cozy eatery featuring pancakes, omelets, and burgers, plus breakfast plates.

484 Youngstown Kingsville Rd SE (Vienna)

Cozy eatery featuring pancakes, omelets, and burgers, plus breakfast plates.

Website ↗

Cozy cafe preparing healthy and homemade dishes, including gluten-free and vegetarian options.

8414 Market St (Boardman)

Cozy cafe preparing healthy and homemade dishes, including gluten-free and vegetarian options.

Website ↗

Tavern featuring locally sourced New American entrees, plus indoor & outdoor seating areas.

7463 South Ave (Boardman)

Tavern featuring locally sourced New American entrees, plus indoor & outdoor seating areas.

Website ↗

L'Albatros

Restaurants

Upscale, contemporary French destination with patio seating, cheese courses & wine.

11401 Bellflower Rd (Cleveland)

Upscale, contemporary French destination with patio seating, cheese courses & wine.

Website ↗

Neighborhood mainstay serving spaghetti & other familiar Italian fare in an unassuming setting.

4151 Market St

Neighborhood mainstay serving spaghetti & other familiar Italian fare in an unassuming setting.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant in Asian Town Center featuring Vietnamese comfort food like pho.

1541 E 38th St First Floor (Cleveland)

Casual restaurant in Asian Town Center featuring Vietnamese comfort food like pho.

Website ↗

Savannah Joe's

Restaurants

Laid-back eatery serving soul-food favorites, plus from-scratch desserts.

2915 Glenwood Ave Ste 1

Laid-back eatery serving soul-food favorites, plus from-scratch desserts.

Website ↗

Pho Saigon

Restaurants

Down-to-earth eatery serving Vietnamese noodle soups & rice dishes, plus familiar Chinese cuisine.

6532 South Ave (Boardman)

Down-to-earth eatery serving Vietnamese noodle soups & rice dishes, plus familiar Chinese cuisine.

Website ↗

Boisterous Australian-themed chain serving steaks, seafood & other hearty steakhouse fare.

1320 Boardman Poland Rd (Boardman)

Boisterous Australian-themed chain serving steaks, seafood & other hearty steakhouse fare.

Website ↗

Leo's

Restaurants

Family-run Italian fixture for pizza & traditional dishes in an unpretentious, high-ceilinged space.

7042 E Market St (Warren)

Family-run Italian fixture for pizza & traditional dishes in an unpretentious, high-ceilinged space.

Website ↗

Casual diner-style pizzeria offering classic & creative, round or sheet-pan pies.

1622 S Raccoon Rd (Austintown)

Casual diner-style pizzeria offering classic & creative, round or sheet-pan pies.

Website ↗

Casual, family-friendly Mexican restaurant offering a big menu, margaritas, and a late-night menu.

3632 Belmont Ave

Casual, family-friendly Mexican restaurant offering a big menu, margaritas, and a late-night menu.

Website ↗

Casual, welcoming eatery dishing up familiar fare along with cakes, pastries and coffee.

120 E Boardman St

Casual, welcoming eatery dishing up familiar fare along with cakes, pastries and coffee.

Website ↗

Local chain with more than a dozen branches serving pizza and Italian fare in a casual environment.

789 Wick Ave

Local chain with more than a dozen branches serving pizza and Italian fare in a casual environment.

Website ↗

Traditional and modern Japanese restaurant dishing sushi rolls and other fare in a sleek space with private booths.

60 Boardman Poland Rd

Traditional and modern Japanese restaurant dishing sushi rolls and other fare in a sleek space with private booths.

Website ↗

Cafe 422

Restaurants

Italian favorites, steaks & seafood offered in a spacious, wood-trimmed setting.

4422 Youngstown Rd SE (Warren)

Italian favorites, steaks & seafood offered in a spacious, wood-trimmed setting.

Website ↗

Casual eatery featuring pizza, pasta and Italian staples, plus an outdoor patio and a bar.

8720 E Market St (Warren)

Casual eatery featuring pizza, pasta and Italian staples, plus an outdoor patio and a bar.

Website ↗

House of Bennys

Restaurants

Cozy restaurant for omelets, pancakes, salads, waffles, eggs benedict (some vegan) and stuffed french toast.

122 S Main St (Poland)

Cozy restaurant for omelets, pancakes, salads, waffles, eggs benedict (some vegan) and stuffed french toast.

Website ↗

Trendy restaurant and bar serving small plates, burgers, pizza, and wine.

100 W Federal St

Trendy restaurant and bar serving small plates, burgers, pizza, and wine.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant for breakfast eats ranging from eggs to pancakes, as well as a lunch menu and a buffet.

109 S Meridian Rd

Casual restaurant for breakfast eats ranging from eggs to pancakes, as well as a lunch menu and a buffet.

Website ↗

Familiar classics such as steaks, burgers & seafood served in a laid-back space.

7413 Tiffany S

Familiar classics such as steaks, burgers & seafood served in a laid-back space.

Website ↗

Station Square

Restaurants

Relaxed, stylish dining room & bar serving steaks, seafood, pasta & other Italian dishes.

4250 Belmont Ave

Relaxed, stylish dining room & bar serving steaks, seafood, pasta & other Italian dishes.

Website ↗

Barry Dyngles

Restaurants

Boisterous BBQ kitchen & bar with a sideline in steaks & chicken, plus TVs & a weekly card game.

1601 S Raccoon Rd

Boisterous BBQ kitchen & bar with a sideline in steaks & chicken, plus TVs & a weekly card game.

Website ↗

Familiar Mexican eats such as burritos, fajitas and tacos, plus beer, wine and cocktails, are served in a casual venue.

5000 E Market St (Warren)

Familiar Mexican eats such as burritos, fajitas and tacos, plus beer, wine and cocktails, are served in a casual venue.

Website ↗

Deli in Cornersburg Plaza offering Italian cold cuts, cheeses, and groceries, plus baked goods and prepared foods.

3381 Canfield Rd

Deli in Cornersburg Plaza offering Italian cold cuts, cheeses, and groceries, plus baked goods and prepared foods.

Website ↗

Fortune Garden

Restaurants

Chinese eatery serving an extensive menu of classic fare in simple, no-nonsense surroundings.

4245 Belmont Ave #1003

Chinese eatery serving an extensive menu of classic fare in simple, no-nonsense surroundings.

Website ↗

Cassese's MVR

Restaurants

Upbeat haunt offering classic Italian mains & a festive bar area, plus outdoor bocce courts.

410 N Walnut St

Upbeat haunt offering classic Italian mains & a festive bar area, plus outdoor bocce courts.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →