The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Gettysburg

“Fly by Night Trading Company curates Native American jewelry and art, western goods, and American ephemera spanning contemporary to antique. It’s the kind of spot locals hit when the house needs character or a gift with actual history, because every piece carries a story you’ll want to retell.”

“Generations of Furniture at The Outlet Shoppes at Gettysburg is a family-run trove of well-loved pieces that get a second life, from character-rich tables to comfy chairs you actually want in your living room. Inventory moves fast, the finds feel intentional, and their mascot Barry the bear adds just enough whimsy.”

From the Gettysburg newsletter, September 26, 2026

“Whether you're hunting a just right piece of Victorian glass, flipping through records, or chasing that one postcard to complete the collection, Rebels Roost Antique Emporium brings serious treasure hunt energy.”

From the Littlestown newsletter, September 23, 2026

“Run by a reenacting family with deep local roots, S & S Sutler outfits living historians with authentic Civil War garments, gear, and knitted pieces, plus steady advice so your next event reads period-correct... and not just thrift-store blue.”

From the Gettysburg newsletter, September 22, 2026