The best restaurants in Lancaster

52 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Lancaster’s best · Entertainment · Nightlife · Shopping · Beauty · Arts & Culture · Bakeries & Sweets · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Home & Garden · Cafes · Health & Wellness · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Pets · Sporting Goods

Pinned in Lancaster today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Lancaster — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 52 places · showing the latest additions first

Sushi Heaven

Restaurants

Whether you're craving a maki marathon or hibachi comfort, Sushi Heaven does all-you-can-eat made fresh to order, with a full Japanese menu…

35 S Willowdale Dr #801

Whether you're craving a maki marathon or hibachi comfort, Sushi Heaven does all-you-can-eat made fresh to order, with a full Japanese menu that keeps everyone happy. Bring the fam, bring your appetite, or grab takeout when the couch is calling, and let weeknight decision fatigue melt away.

From the Lancaster newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

This family-owned restaurant has been serving Southern Italian specialties like lasagna since 1946.

216 Harrisburg Ave

This family-owned restaurant has been serving Southern Italian specialties like lasagna since 1946.

Website ↗

551 West

Restaurants

Sizable bar & eatery with a homey, wood-walled setting serving new American pub grub & craft beer.

551 W King St

Sizable bar & eatery with a homey, wood-walled setting serving new American pub grub & craft beer.

Website ↗

Seasonal New American fare in a homey, Victorian space with a patio & an upstairs jazz lounge.

402 N Queen St

Seasonal New American fare in a homey, Victorian space with a patio & an upstairs jazz lounge.

Website ↗
Run a Lancaster business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Relaxed eatery with a diverse American menu & wine list plus Sunday brunch & frequent live music.

595 Greenfield Rd

Relaxed eatery with a diverse American menu & wine list plus Sunday brunch & frequent live music.

Website ↗

LUCA

Restaurants

Trendy, bustling venue for modern Italian dinners, plus beer, wine & cocktails.

436 W James St #101

Trendy, bustling venue for modern Italian dinners, plus beer, wine & cocktails.

Website ↗

Casual family-run pizza joint with a menu of subs, lasagna, hoagies and strombolis.

486 Royer Dr #102

Casual family-run pizza joint with a menu of subs, lasagna, hoagies and strombolis.

Website ↗

Eatery located in the Cork Factory Hotel serving seafood, upscale American comfort food & drinks.

480 New Holland Ave #3000

Eatery located in the Cork Factory Hotel serving seafood, upscale American comfort food & drinks.

Website ↗

Casual eatery with an under-the-sea vibe offering Pan-Asian fare, including rolls from a sushi bar.

1500 Oregon Pike

Casual eatery with an under-the-sea vibe offering Pan-Asian fare, including rolls from a sushi bar.

Website ↗

Family-owned eatery known for pizza (including by-the-slice options), as well as sandwiches and strombolis.

3079 Columbia Ave

Family-owned eatery known for pizza (including by-the-slice options), as well as sandwiches and strombolis.

Website ↗

Chain eatery & bar serving a diverse menu of classic Italian fare in a family-friendly setting.

100 N Pointe Blvd

Chain eatery & bar serving a diverse menu of classic Italian fare in a family-friendly setting.

Website ↗

Pho Lotus

Restaurants

Simple Vietnamese dishes such as fried rice, Pho and spring rolls in a casual venue.

1223 Lancaster Rd Ste 107 (Manheim)

Simple Vietnamese dishes such as fried rice, Pho and spring rolls in a casual venue.

Website ↗

Hibachi eatery with teppanyaki-style cooking and sushi dishes.

680 Park City Center

Hibachi eatery with teppanyaki-style cooking and sushi dishes.

Website ↗

House of Pizza

Restaurants

Long-running (since 1986) eatery in a historic cast-iron storefront, serving pies, subs & beers.

23 W Chestnut St

Long-running (since 1986) eatery in a historic cast-iron storefront, serving pies, subs & beers.

Website ↗

Dibbs BBQ

Restaurants

Casual, kid-friendly restaurant offering BBQ classics such as brisket and ribs, plus mac and cheese.

5617 Lancaster Ave (Philadelphia)

Casual, kid-friendly restaurant offering BBQ classics such as brisket and ribs, plus mac and cheese.

Website ↗

Shot & Bottle

Restaurants

Easygoing restaurant prepping brunch dishes, handhelds & hearty mains, plus cocktails & draft beers.

2 N Queen St

Easygoing restaurant prepping brunch dishes, handhelds & hearty mains, plus cocktails & draft beers.

Website ↗

Relaxed eatery turning out a variety of sushi rolls and other classic Japanese dishes including fried rice, teriyaki and tempura, plus…

1565 Manheim Pike

Relaxed eatery turning out a variety of sushi rolls and other classic Japanese dishes including fried rice, teriyaki and tempura, plus takeout options for busy days.

Website ↗

Upscale eatery specializing in farm-to-table dishes featuring local, seasonal ingredients.

1573 Fruitville Pike

Upscale eatery specializing in farm-to-table dishes featuring local, seasonal ingredients.

Website ↗

The Fridge

Restaurants

Storefront selling craft beer & doubling as a cozy cafe for sandwiches & flatbread pizzas.

534 N Mulberry St

Storefront selling craft beer & doubling as a cozy cafe for sandwiches & flatbread pizzas.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual eatery dishing up boneless and traditional wings plus fried chicken tenders, sauces and sides.

1957 Fruitville Pike

Casual eatery dishing up boneless and traditional wings plus fried chicken tenders, sauces and sides.

Website ↗

Fireside Tavern

Restaurants

Hearty American fare is served in this comfy, rambling choice, which is also a wedding/party venue.

1500 Historic Dr (Strasburg)

Hearty American fare is served in this comfy, rambling choice, which is also a wedding/party venue.

Website ↗

Hamburger food-cart operator Josh Kim has a brick-and-mortar shop to hang his hat.

2821 W Girard Ave (Philadelphia)

Hamburger food-cart operator Josh Kim has a brick-and-mortar shop to hang his hat.

Website ↗

MISSION BBQ

Restaurants

Casual chain featuring BBQ & classic sides, plus memorabilia honoring soldiers & first responders.

2002 Fruitville Pike

Casual chain featuring BBQ & classic sides, plus memorabilia honoring soldiers & first responders.

Website ↗

Bright, airy eatery for Vietnamese fare including banh mi sandwiches, spring rolls & macarons.

1238 Lititz Pike

Bright, airy eatery for Vietnamese fare including banh mi sandwiches, spring rolls & macarons.

Website ↗

Sushi One‎

Restaurants

Informal locale serving an array of sushi rolls and Japanese entrees alongside hibachi-grilled dishes, plus sake.

1961 Fruitville Pike

Informal locale serving an array of sushi rolls and Japanese entrees alongside hibachi-grilled dishes, plus sake.

Website ↗

Bad Brother

Restaurants

Lively fixture for American classics like burgers, grilled cheese & wings, plus cocktails & beer.

726 N 24th St (Philadelphia)

Lively fixture for American classics like burgers, grilled cheese & wings, plus cocktails & beer.

Website ↗

Hip, counter-serve chain for gourmet takes on fast-food classics like burgers & frozen custard.

1100 Christopher Pl Bldg. G

Hip, counter-serve chain for gourmet takes on fast-food classics like burgers & frozen custard.

Website ↗

Ginza

Restaurants

Restaurant for sushi, seafood cuisine, offering all-you-can-eat options.

565 Greenfield Rd

Restaurant for sushi, seafood cuisine, offering all-you-can-eat options.

Website ↗

Prince Of Subs

Restaurants

Informal diner dishing up fried chicken and subs in a casual setting with sports TVs, plus takeout and pickup window options.

147 S Prince St

Informal diner dishing up fried chicken and subs in a casual setting with sports TVs, plus takeout and pickup window options.

Website ↗

Pie In the Sky

Restaurants

Pizzas, cheesesteaks & other typical grub whipped up in small, low-key quarters with sidewalk seats.

Ground Floor, 105 Duncan St C

Pizzas, cheesesteaks & other typical grub whipped up in small, low-key quarters with sidewalk seats.

Website ↗

Tavern offering a diverse pub grub menu, including wings & oysters.

1081 N Plum St

Tavern offering a diverse pub grub menu, including wings & oysters.

Website ↗

Farm-to-table, seasonal fare from shrimp & grits to grass-fed beef in an elegant, comfortable space.

300 Harrisburg Ave

Farm-to-table, seasonal fare from shrimp & grits to grass-fed beef in an elegant, comfortable space.

Website ↗

Popular tavern offering artisan hamburgers, beer and hot dogs, plus fries and tots.

4421 Main St (Philadelphia)

Popular tavern offering artisan hamburgers, beer and hot dogs, plus fries and tots.

Website ↗

Casual pizzeria offering specialty pies, fried appetizers and subs.

1040 Harrisburg Pike

Casual pizzeria offering specialty pies, fried appetizers and subs.

Website ↗

Quaint, old-school American restaurant set in a historic steamboat inn with a full bar.

1 Hartman Bridge Rd

Quaint, old-school American restaurant set in a historic steamboat inn with a full bar.

Website ↗

Warm Italian bistro & bar crafting brick-oven pizzas, panini & classic fare plus homemade gelato.

605 Richmond Dr

Warm Italian bistro & bar crafting brick-oven pizzas, panini & classic fare plus homemade gelato.

Website ↗

The BBQ Barn

Restaurants

BBQ meals, housemade coleslaw & whoopie pies offered in a straightforward eatery on an Amish farm.

2395 Covered Bridge Dr

BBQ meals, housemade coleslaw & whoopie pies offered in a straightforward eatery on an Amish farm.

Website ↗

Airy, spacious eatery located in the Eden Resort & Suites serving a Sunday brunch buffet & drinks.

222 Eden Rd

Airy, spacious eatery located in the Eden Resort & Suites serving a Sunday brunch buffet & drinks.

Website ↗

Low-key pizzeria serving NY-style pies, plus pasta, subs, burgers, wings & more.

1750 Oregon Pike

Low-key pizzeria serving NY-style pies, plus pasta, subs, burgers, wings & more.

Website ↗

Pho Pasteur 3

Restaurants

Casual, warm-toned restaurant dishing up familiar Vietnamese staples from pho to vermicelli, plus beer.

2204 Columbia Ave

Casual, warm-toned restaurant dishing up familiar Vietnamese staples from pho to vermicelli, plus beer.

Website ↗

Horse Inn

Restaurants

Historic site offering refined, globally inspired pub grub, specialty cocktails & a speakeasy vibe.

540 E Fulton St

Historic site offering refined, globally inspired pub grub, specialty cocktails & a speakeasy vibe.

Website ↗

Capricio's Pizza

Restaurants

Italian eatery near Smoketown Airport serving pizza and calzones, plus cheesesteaks.

303 Airport Dr (Smoketown)

Italian eatery near Smoketown Airport serving pizza and calzones, plus cheesesteaks.

Website ↗

1950s-inspired diner offering American comfort food favorites in a relaxed space with vintage signs.

45 W Liberty St #2700

1950s-inspired diner offering American comfort food favorites in a relaxed space with vintage signs.

Website ↗

The Coffin Bar

Restaurants

Craft brewery with an offbeat vibe and coffin-shaped bar serving comfort food and cocktails.

30 W Lemon St

Craft brewery with an offbeat vibe and coffin-shaped bar serving comfort food and cocktails.

Website ↗

Double C

Restaurants

Trendy eatery offering American to South American eats, alongside drinks, and margaritas.

220 N Prince St

Trendy eatery offering American to South American eats, alongside drinks, and margaritas.

Website ↗

Unpretentious restaurant offering hibachi-style dishes, sushi & Thai fare in a low-key dining room.

12 McGovern Ave

Unpretentious restaurant offering hibachi-style dishes, sushi & Thai fare in a low-key dining room.

Website ↗

Valentino's Cafe

Restaurants

Cozy restaurant and bar known for Italian food and quick bites, plus breakfast, and happy hour drinks.

132 Rider Ave

Cozy restaurant and bar known for Italian food and quick bites, plus breakfast, and happy hour drinks.

Website ↗

Cozy pizzeria serving traditional pies along with cheesesteaks, subs, and stromboli.

678 W Chestnut St

Cozy pizzeria serving traditional pies along with cheesesteaks, subs, and stromboli.

Website ↗

Plough

Restaurants

Modern American restaurant at the Marriott offering locally sourced ingredients, beer, and wine.

25 S Queen St

Modern American restaurant at the Marriott offering locally sourced ingredients, beer, and wine.

Website ↗

Pizza Boli's

Restaurants

Down-to-earth Italian chain restaurant serving up pizzas, sandwiches, wings & salads.

24 W Clay St

Down-to-earth Italian chain restaurant serving up pizzas, sandwiches, wings & salads.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

1831 Columbia Ave

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Multi-story, mountain-themed American eatery at the Heritage Hotel serving burgers, salads & more.

500 Centerville Rd

Multi-story, mountain-themed American eatery at the Heritage Hotel serving burgers, salads & more.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →