The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Selinsgrove

11 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

11 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Selinsgrove's page when you're in Selinsgrove's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

The Firehouse Marketplace (opens in a new tab)

1 S Water St

The Firehouse Marketplace packs more than 30 local vendors into a historic former firehouse, with antiques, vintage clothing, records,…

The Firehouse Marketplace packs more than 30 local vendors into a historic former firehouse, with antiques, vintage clothing, records, collectibles, home décor, and plenty of one-of-a-kind finds. Each booth has its own character, so browsing can easily turn into “I didn’t know I needed this” territory.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, November 12, 2026

The Cottage on Pine Antiques (opens in a new tab)

21 E Pine St

Right in old town Selinsgrove, The Cottage on Pine Antiques is the kind of antique shop you duck into for a quick look and end up finding a…

Right in old town Selinsgrove, The Cottage on Pine Antiques is the kind of antique shop you duck into for a quick look and end up finding a conversation piece, a little character for home, and that nice feeling of keeping your dollars with a local spot that knows its neighbors.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, November 5, 2026

American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Mifflinburg (opens in a new tab)

350 Chestnut St · Mifflinburg

When you score secondhand treasures at American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Mifflinburg, your dollars help fund hunger and homelessness…

When you score secondhand treasures at American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Mifflinburg, your dollars help fund hunger and homelessness prevention programs and services. Clean out a closet, donate a bag, then hunt for vintage surprises and everyday essentials that feel good on your budget and your conscience.

From the Mifflinburg newsletter, October 9, 2026

Joe Nevo Oriental Rugs and Furniture (opens in a new tab)

2835 N Susquehanna Trail · Shamokin Dam

Joe Nevo Oriental Rugs and Furniture is a local trove for Gustav Stickley, Limbert, and Roycroft pieces, plus hand-knotted Persian and…

Joe Nevo Oriental Rugs and Furniture is a local trove for Gustav Stickley, Limbert, and Roycroft pieces, plus hand-knotted Persian and Oriental rugs. They restore with traditional techniques, so what you bring home is period-correct, sturdy, and ready to use right away.

From the Northumberland newsletter, October 10, 2026

River Valley Vintage (opens in a new tab)

100 N 3rd St · Sunbury

River Valley Vintage is the spot for crystals, mineral specimens, fossils, jewelry, and antiques, plus framed prints of vintage…

River Valley Vintage is the spot for crystals, mineral specimens, fossils, jewelry, and antiques, plus framed prints of vintage Northumberland and Sunbury scenes.

From the Northumberland County newsletter, November 18, 2026

Lewisburg Antiques Barn (opens in a new tab)

211 Silvermoon Ln · Lewisburg

Whether you're chasing a specific collectible or just window-shopping for character, Lewisburg Antiques Barn keeps the thrill alive with…

Whether you're chasing a specific collectible or just window-shopping for character, Lewisburg Antiques Barn keeps the thrill alive with aisles of antiques, vintage finds, clothing, kitchenware, military items, pottery, toys, and the odd curiosity. Perfect for a Saturday browse when you want something with a story.

From the Milton newsletter, October 2, 2026

Sunbury Station (opens in a new tab)

100 N 3rd St · Sunbury

Sunbury Station is the spot when you want character without the yard-sale elbowing, with a changing mix of antique and vintage finds you…

Sunbury Station is the spot when you want character without the yard-sale elbowing, with a changing mix of antique and vintage finds you can browse online, then have shipped or snag in-store, which makes last-minute room refreshes and gift hunting around town way too easy.

From the Danville newsletter, November 13, 2026

Common Threads (opens in a new tab)

120 Hardwood Dr · Lewisburg

Twice a year, Common Threads turns Lewisburg and Williamsport into a treasure hunt for affordable, gently-used kids' clothes, toys, and…

Twice a year, Common Threads turns Lewisburg and Williamsport into a treasure hunt for affordable, gently-used kids' clothes, toys, and gear. Shop smart or consign your own, and if tagging isn't your thing they even offer valet help so your outgrown stuff earns cash for the next size up.

From the Mifflinburg newsletter, October 20, 2026

American Rescue Workers Donation Center & Thrift Store, Sunbury (opens in a new tab)

1159 N 4th St · Sunbury

American Rescue Workers Donation Center & Thrift Store, Sunbury is where thrifty finds meet real community good. Shop for bargains or drop…

American Rescue Workers Donation Center & Thrift Store, Sunbury is where thrifty finds meet real community good.

From the Sunbury newsletter, October 12, 2026

American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Milton (opens in a new tab)

122 Maple Ave · Milton

Whether you're chasing secondhand treasures or quirky collectibles, American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Milton keeps the finds coming...…

Whether you're chasing secondhand treasures or quirky collectibles, American Rescue Workers Thrift Store, Milton keeps the finds coming... the kind you swear you'll upcycle this weekend.

From the Lewisburg newsletter, October 17, 2026

Roller Mills Marketplace (opens in a new tab)

517 St Mary St · Lewisburg

Roller Mills Marketplace packs 400 dealers into an 1880s restored flour mill in Lewisburg, spread across three floors and over 60,000…

Roller Mills Marketplace packs 400 dealers into an 1880s restored flour mill in Lewisburg, spread across three floors and over 60,000 square feet. When you need everything from farmhouse finds to weirdly perfect gifts, it’s the kind of place you enter for 'a minute' and emerge happily two hours later.

From the Lewisburg newsletter, October 17, 2026