The best bakeries & sweet shops in Selinsgrove

19 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

19 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Selinsgrove's page when you're in Selinsgrove's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Chillers (opens in a new tab)

134 E Independence St · Shamokin

When the ice cream craving hits, Chillers in Shamokin is worth a stop for a scoop or sundae. They offer plenty of flavors, and are happy to…

When the ice cream craving hits, Chillers in Shamokin is worth a stop for a scoop or sundae. They offer plenty of flavors, and are happy to mix things up, because sometimes choosing just one is asking too much.

From the Northumberland County newsletter, November 17, 2026

Simply Bowls (opens in a new tab)

209 W Pine St

Simply Bowls pairs açaí and smoothie bases with fresh local and tropical fruits in healthy, delicious combinations. It’s a woman-owned…

Simply Bowls pairs açaí and smoothie bases with fresh local and tropical fruits in healthy, delicious combinations. It’s a woman-owned small business with both a mobile setup and an indoor café in Selinsgrove, serving up a colorful change of pace from the usual snack routine.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, November 12, 2026

Auntie Anne's (opens in a new tab)

One Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr

When the snack siren calls mid-errand, Auntie Anne's at Susquehanna Valley Mall serves fresh, butter-brushed soft pretzels, bite-size…

When the snack siren calls mid-errand, Auntie Anne's at Susquehanna Valley Mall serves fresh, butter-brushed soft pretzels, bite-size nuggets, and signature dips. Feeling extra hungry, grab Pretzel Dogs wrapped around a Nathan’s hot dog, a cold lemonade, and maybe pretzel buckets or party trays for game night.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, October 20, 2026

Dough C Dough (opens in a new tab)

6 W Sherman St

Dough C Dough is a family-run bakery and small event caterer turning out preservative-free, from-scratch goodies and homemade dishes by…

Dough C Dough is a family-run bakery and small event caterer turning out preservative-free, from-scratch goodies and homemade dishes by pre-order. Planning a birthday spread or office nibble lineup? Give them 48 hours, and they’ll deliver freshness, friendly service, and even to Susquehanna University if you need it.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, November 4, 2026

Our Best Friends Bakery (opens in a new tab)

8693 Old Turnpike Rd · Mifflinburg

From generous, flavor-packed bagels, cookies, and cupcakes to custom cakes that actually taste as good as they look, Our Best Friends…

From generous, flavor-packed bagels, cookies, and cupcakes to custom cakes that actually taste as good as they look, Our Best Friends Bakery leans on quality ingredients and lots of heart. Perfect for birthdays, weddings, or a Tuesday pick-me-up, this crew makes Mifflinburg days sweeter.

From the Mifflinburg newsletter, October 5, 2026

Southern BBQ and Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

1051 S Front St · Sunbury

When you want smoky comfort food followed by a legit scoop, Southern BBQ and Ice Cream nails both halves of the craving. Easy dinners, ice…

Checked Oct 2

When you want smoky comfort food followed by a legit scoop, Southern BBQ and Ice Cream nails both halves of the craving. Easy dinners, ice cream runs, and those nights when you can't decide between savory and sweet... this spot has your back.

From the Northumberland newsletter, October 7, 2026

Gable House Bakery (opens in a new tab)

441 Chestnut St · Mifflinburg

When you need a perfect birthday showpiece or just a pastry pick-me-up, Gable House Bakery nails it with custom wedding cakes, dessert…

When you need a perfect birthday showpiece or just a pastry pick-me-up, Gable House Bakery nails it with custom wedding cakes, dessert table packages, party cakes, and a menu of desserts and pastries. Keep an eye out for their gingerbread kits, Gingerbread House Lab, and Helix Hall tearoom experiences.

From the Mifflinburg newsletter, October 22, 2026

Sweet Chaos (formerly Hurr’s Dairy) (opens in a new tab)

901 Market St · Sunbury

Once known as Hurr’s Dairy, Sweet Chaos is the Sunbury go-to when you want fresh cut fries, ribeye cheesesteaks, wings, and those…

Once known as Hurr’s Dairy, Sweet Chaos is the Sunbury go-to when you want fresh cut fries, ribeye cheesesteaks, wings, and those Pittsburgh-style salads with fries and a pickled egg. It’s casual, quick, and perfect when you crave real-deal comfort food, then maybe an ice cream victory lap.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, October 19, 2026

Once Upon A Whisk (opens in a new tab)

54 S Front St · Milton

Once Upon A Whisk is the kind of sweet spot Milton quietly brags about, baking fresh daily and decorating every cupcake by hand. Expect…

Once Upon A Whisk is the kind of sweet spot Milton quietly brags about, baking fresh daily and decorating every cupcake by hand. Expect playful flavors like Apple Pie, Maple Bacon, and Cookie Butter, plus custom cakes for birthdays and weddings when you need something delightfully over the top.

From the Lewisburg newsletter, October 17, 2026

Jenn's Sugar Shack (opens in a new tab)

603 Mill St · Danville

When your sweet tooth wants something wild, Jenn's Sugar Shack turns crazy cake dreams, over-the-top cupcakes, and even dramatic burn cakes…

When your sweet tooth wants something wild, Jenn's Sugar Shack turns crazy cake dreams, over-the-top cupcakes, and even dramatic burn cakes into the kind of treats that make group chats go quiet. Danville-born Jenn builds custom breads, pies, macarons, and more, and yes, they deliver within 5 miles with a $25 minimum.

From the Danville newsletter, November 7, 2026

Sunbury CSG Bakery (opens in a new tab)

330 B N 2nd St · Sunbury

Sunbury CSG Bakery is a local spot with a bigger purpose, part of Community Services Group, which provides intellectual and developmental…

Sunbury CSG Bakery is a local spot with a bigger purpose, part of Community Services Group, which provides intellectual and developmental disability and mental health services to help folks live more independent, healthier lives, so your bakery run doubles as support for a mission that’s rooted right here.

From the Selinsgrove newsletter, October 26, 2026

Becky's Soft-Serve (opens in a new tab)

7880 PA-405 · Milton

Becky's Soft-Serve nails the no-fuss, classic soft-serve cone that tastes like summer. Easy-going, reliably good, and perfect when you need…

Becky's Soft-Serve nails the no-fuss, classic soft-serve cone that tastes like summer. Easy-going, reliably good, and perfect when you need a sweet detour after errands or baseball practice, this spot keeps dessert simple and exactly how you remembered.

From the Milton newsletter, September 21, 2026

Paris Bakery & Café (opens in a new tab)

335 Market St · Lewisburg

Paris Bakery & Café nails the essentials with buttery croissants, colorful macarons, and a pastry case that dares you to “just pick one.”…

” Beyond grab-and-go, they do custom cakes, catering, and even have space for birthday bashes or work shindigs, so keep them on speed dial.

From the Mifflinburg newsletter, October 16, 2026

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)

1568 N Susquehanna Trail

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

Cinnabon (opens in a new tab)

1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr

Counter-serve chain serving cinnamon rolls plus other baked goods & specialty frozen beverages.

Counter-serve chain serving cinnamon rolls plus other baked goods & specialty frozen beverages.

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

600 N Derr Dr · Lewisburg

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

1183 N 4th St · Sunbury

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (opens in a new tab)

105 Northumberland St · Danville

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

Italian ices & frozen custards star at this counter-serve chain with a range of other cold treats.

Sweet Frog (opens in a new tab)

330 Market St · Lewisburg

National chain with dozens of flavor combinations of soft-serve frozen yogurt, plus sorbet.

National chain with dozens of flavor combinations of soft-serve frozen yogurt, plus sorbet.