The best bakeries & sweet shops in York

“Authentic Puerto Rican cakes made with island recipes and select ingredients, YaYa’s Cravings turns birthdays and backyard gatherings into full-on vibes this week. Think Ponque Boricua, Tres Leches, Almond Cake, and Mojadito, plus semi-custom designs that actually look good and taste better.”

From the York newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Laid-back bakery featuring cakes and cupcakes with custom designs, plus cookies and other treats.”

“Candy shop selling handmade chocolates, custom candies, and other sweet treats, plus gift baskets.”

“Keto-friendly bakery, also selling vegan and gluten-free sweets, plus pizza dough.”

“Artisan bakery in Central Market offering pastries, baked goods & gourmet breakfast & lunch plates.”

“Longtime, family-owned shop specializing in homemade chocolates, candy, and brittle.”

“Quaint ice cream shop scooping a constantly changing choice of inventive, homemade flavors.”

“Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.”

“Friendly, relaxed bakery offering coffee, sweets, pastries and weekend brunch.”