The best bakeries & sweet shops in Sumter
31 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.
Your business could be here.
Be at the top of Sumter's page when you're in Sumter's newsletter.
Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.
Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)
1003 W Dekalb St · Camden
Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.
Marble Slab Creamery (opens in a new tab)
1230 Bower Pkwy Ste B - 1 · Columbia
Small-batch ice cream is hand-blended with loads of mix-ins at this chain.
Cake By Tina (opens in a new tab)
111 Grace St · Darlington
Whether you're plotting a wedding, a last-minute birthday, or a 'just because' sugar fix, Cake By Tina bakes everything fresh to order,…
Simply Delicious and More, LLC (opens in a new tab)
121 Pearl St · Darlington
Simply Delicious and More, LLC keeps Darlington fueled with bakery favorites and other, well, delicious creations. They handle custom…
Carasmatic Creations (opens in a new tab)
204 Lemmon St
Made-from-scratch layers, pound cakes, and cookies with four generations of know-how, Carasmatic Creations nails the classics like red…
Nibl Dessert and Cafe (opens in a new tab)
1333 Main St · Columbia
Nibl Dessert and Cafe is serving Asian-inspired treats that actually taste like joy, from burnt basque cheesecake and crepe cake to ube…
Angela's Creative Creations (opens in a new tab)
1409 W King Ave · Florence
Whether your week calls for a sweet fix or you’re plotting dessert for the crew, Angela's Creative Creations turns out handmade goodness…
Silver Spoon Bake Shop (opens in a new tab)
2507 Devine St · Columbia
Silver Spoon Bake Shop keeps the sweet tooth in check with a rotating pre-order menu and friendly porch pickup. Think buttery croissants,…
Murray's Donuts (opens in a new tab)
627 Bultman Dr
Sumter locals swear by Murray's Donuts for artisanal, gourmet donuts crafted with premium ingredients and playful flavors that satisfy both…
Baker's Sweets (opens in a new tab)
1089 Alice Dr
Baker's Sweets Bistro & Bakery is the Sumter go-to for scratch-made pastries, legit breakfast plates, and a full bistro lineup that covers…
Checked Oct 23
Insomnia Cookies (opens in a new tab)
2013 Devine St · Columbia
Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.
Five Below (opens in a new tab)
1308 Broad St
Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.
Mast General Store Columbia (opens in a new tab)
1601 Main St · Columbia
Mast General Store Columbia nails that rare combo of nostalgia and usefulness, with old-fashioned candy barrels by the pound, pantry…
Lita’s Treats (opens in a new tab)
460 Killian Rd #3 · Columbia
Treat yourself to Lita’s Treats, where handcrafted cupcakes are baked fresh daily in 30+ flavors. Think Classic Vanilla, Chocolate Fudge,…
SweetLeighs Cakes and Treats (opens in a new tab)
1456 Cherokee Rd · Florence
Florence folks, when you want a dessert that tastes like someone’s favorite aunt baked it, SweetLeighs Cakes and Treats comes through with…
Ally & Eloise Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
5209 Forest Dr · Columbia
When you’re overdue for something happy, Ally & Eloise Bakeshop has colorful cookies, special-occasion cakes, and other sweet treats that…
Chocobella (opens in a new tab)
114 N Dargan St Ste A · Florence
Chocobella is your local spot for rich chocolates made with care, perfect for a midweek pick me up, a thank you, or a little…
Main Street Bakery (opens in a new tab)
3307 N Main St · Columbia
Mom-and-daughter-run Main Street Bakery turns out custom cakes that actually taste like cake, not just pretty frosting, using…
Sweet GG's Bakery (opens in a new tab)
631 B Harden St · Columbia
Sweet GG's Bakery in Five Points has been baking with joy since 2012, turning birthdays, weddings, and just-because moments into custom…
Confectionary and Company (opens in a new tab)
10 E Hampton Ave
When your week needs a little joy, Confectionary and Company has artisan-baked pastries, a signature espresso made just how you like it,…
Sweet Success Bakery, LLC (opens in a new tab)
27 S Washington St
When the afternoon slump hits, Sweet Success Bakery, LLC has your midweek fix with custom cakes, cupcakes, brownies and mini cheesecakes…
Sour & Salt Bakery (opens in a new tab)
2761 Rosewood Dr · Columbia
Follow your nose, Columbia: Sour & Salt Bakery turns out tangy sourdoughs, chewy bagels, and a rotation of bakes that actually make…
Checked Sep 2
Ally & Eloise Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
2833 Devine St · Columbia
Ally & Eloise Bakeshop is the sweet spot when you want something actually worth the sugar tax, from homemade cakes and pies to cookies,…
Palmetto Bakeshop (opens in a new tab)
305 Rainbow Dr · Florence
Palmetto Bakeshop is the kind of spot that makes Florence mornings dangerous in the best way, turning out flaky, homemade croissants, pies,…
Sweet Tooth (opens in a new tab)
2001 Hoffmeyer Rd · Florence
Sweet Tooth of Florence is a family-run bakery and cafe for made-from-scratch cupcakes, cheesecake, brownies, banana pudding, and more,…
Nothing Bundt Cakes (opens in a new tab)
2160 W Evans St Suite 70 · Florence
Franchise bakery specializing in handcrafted bundt cakes, plus curated gifts & party supplies.
Ian's Sweet Treats Baskets and More (opens in a new tab)
1133 Colleton St · Columbia
When you need a quick pick-me-up or a gift that actually lands, Ian's Sweet Treats Baskets and More pulls together sweet treat baskets and…
Freeman's Bakery (opens in a new tab)
1307 2nd Loop Rd Ste G · Florence
Since 1964, Freeman's Bakery has been Florence’s go-to for cakes, cookies, doughnuts, pies, and the custom showstoppers that make birthdays…
Kaleen's Homemade Favorites & gifts (opens in a new tab)
812 S Cashua Dr a · Florence
For homemade cakes, jams, and other goodies, plus distinctive gifts, Kaleen's Homemade Favorites & gifts is a handy Florence spot to keep…
Bakery Thrift Store (opens in a new tab)
834 S Irby St · Florence
Bakery Thrift Store is a handy spot for discounted breads and pastries, with cakes and other sweets in the mix too. If your grocery list…
Tres Leches Bakery and Cafe (opens in a new tab)
6903 St Andrews Rd · Columbia
Tres Leches Bakery and Cafe is a friendly Columbia bakery with cakes, pastries, and confections to browse when a little treat is in order.…
Nothing here matches that.
Try a shorter word, or look through every kind of place in Sumter.
Know a great place we’re missing? Email hello@baselocal.com
The best of Sumter, every morning
New places show up in the Sumter newsletter first. It's free.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.