The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Baraboo

“Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store keeps locals hunting for deals on clothing, home goods, shoes, and pet supplies, with a cozy cat adoption space that may just pick you.”

From the Madison newsletter, September 16, 2026

“Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store has an East Side spot, double the size of the West, with more than 20,000 items on the floor. Swing through this week to snag clothes, décor, games, or pet gear, and every score helps fund animal care and wildlife rehab.”

From the Madison newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Madison Paperbacks is a used-book goldmine with shelves of fiction, sci fi, fantasy, speculative, poetry, horror, detectives and mysteries, plus pulp, sleaze, early paperbacks. Go lose an afternoon this week treasure hunting and come home with something you didn't know you needed.”

From the Waukesha newsletter, August 21, 2026

“Boomerangs Resale Store keeps things clean and easy to browse, with donated furniture and useful finds that actually feel like upgrades. Swing through this week for a low-key treasure hunt... rotating pieces, solid basics, and the kind of gently loved stuff that makes your place feel more you.”

From the Madison newsletter, August 6, 2026

“Store featuring antiques and vintage items from furniture to jewelry, plus gifts.”

“Trendy clothing chain stocking hip new, used, vintage & one-of-a-kind pieces for men & women.”

“Upscale thrift shop for clothing, books, housewares, decor and donated furniture and jewelry.”

“Stony Hill Antiques and Books curates global folk art and deep-dive reads, from Guatemalan Maya huipiles and embroidery to Cuban posters, American Indian pottery, African carvings, and Inca textiles. Wander a bit this week, learn a lot, and snag something with real history for your home.”

From the Janesville newsletter, August 30, 2026

“Vintage clothing shop stocking a large selection of men's and women's apparel.”

“Agrace Thrift Store | Madison East keeps thrifting fun with quality furniture, home décor, clothes, books and more, all priced to actually feel thrifty. Shop or donate knowing proceeds support Agrace’s compassionate care across southern Wisconsin, including palliative, dementia support, hospice care and grief support.”

From the Madison newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Upshift Swap and Thrift turns thrifting into a choose-your-own-adventure... swap a bag for a flat $20 cover, do a $30 fill-a-bag, or pick $5 singles, with a curated Fresh Finds rack for the gems. Friendly folks, occasional wine and music, and plenty of style.”

From the Madison newsletter, September 1, 2026

“Antiques including furniture, china, glass and jewelry, as well as friendly dogs.”

“Popular thrift store featuring second-hand clothing, toys and furniture.”

“Antiques Mall of Madison has been Madison’s longest operating antique mall since 1982, filling 18,000 square feet with finds from 120+ independent dealers.”

From the Madison newsletter, August 19, 2026

“Stillgood's buys gently worn designer, contemporary, and vintage pieces, selecting by style, season, condition, and current stock. Drop off quality items, then choose 30% cash or 50% store credit on the spot, so you can swap last year's impulse buys for this week's new favorites.”

From the Sun Prairie newsletter, September 2, 2026

“LA Moda Marie brings curated, Asian-inspired pieces and handcrafted accessories to your closet, with personal styling and private shopping if you want the VIP vibes. Great for refreshing weekday fits or finding that one wow piece you’ll actually wear.”

From the Madison newsletter, August 11, 2026

“Dig & Save is St. Vinny’s only pay-by-the-pound outlet where you literally dig through daily-rotating bins, weigh your finds, and save big. Stock moves fast, new stuff lands daily, and your haul helps keep hundreds of thousands of pounds of textiles out of local landfills every month… thrifting that does real good.”

From the Fitchburg newsletter, September 11, 2026