The best bakeries & sweet shops in Jefferson County

8 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

8 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Jefferson County's page when you're in Jefferson County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

La Michoacana (opens in a new tab)

113 E Main St Ste B · Whitewater

La Michoacana is that reliable local fix when you want something cold, creamy, and cheerful. Swing by for classic scoops, fun flavors, and…

Checked Oct 2

La Michoacana is that reliable local fix when you want something cold, creamy, and cheerful. Swing by for classic scoops, fun flavors, and the kind of treat that turns a regular Whitewater afternoon into a small victory lap.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 11, 2026

Fremont Sweets (opens in a new tab)

259 N Fremont St · Whitewater

Fremont Sweets turns out pies, cakes, tarts, scones, and custom wedding cakes with quality ingredients, often local and organic, and no…

Fremont Sweets turns out pies, cakes, tarts, scones, and custom wedding cakes with quality ingredients, often local and organic, and no shortening, margarine, mixes, or pre-bought frosting.

From the Whitewater newsletter, September 24, 2026

Mullen's Dairy Bar - Watertown (opens in a new tab)

212 W Main St · Watertown

Creating smiles since 1932, Mullen's Dairy Bar - Watertown churns out small batch super premium ice cream that tastes like hometown…

Creating smiles since 1932, Mullen's Dairy Bar - Watertown churns out small batch super premium ice cream that tastes like hometown nostalgia in a cone. Swing by when you need something genuinely creamy and unfussy, the kind of scoop that keeps locals coming back between errands and little league.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 16, 2026

Sassy Sweets Bakery, LLC (opens in a new tab)

116 W Main St · Watertown

If you're plotting a wedding dessert bar or just craving something glorious on a random Tuesday, Sassy Sweets Bakery, LLC nails it with…

If you're plotting a wedding dessert bar or just craving something glorious on a random Tuesday, Sassy Sweets Bakery, LLC nails it with hand-dipped truffles, cheesecakes, cupcakes and more. Since 2015, Amber’s tastings make planning fun... pick up to three flavors and watch your vision come alive.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 19, 2026

Sweet Talkin Treats (opens in a new tab)

108 S 3rd St · Watertown

From flaky breakfast pastries to cheesecake cupcakes, pies, cookies, custom cakes, and even keto treats, Sweet Talkin Treats is the…

From flaky breakfast pastries to cheesecake cupcakes, pies, cookies, custom cakes, and even keto treats, Sweet Talkin Treats is the neighborhood go-to in Watertown when you need something sweet for your morning, your milestone, or just your Monday.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 13, 2026

Chandler House Bakery (opens in a new tab)

411 E Main St · Watertown

Chandler House Bakery is the local go-to for custom cakes that actually taste as good as they look, creamy cheesecakes, flaky pies, and…

Chandler House Bakery is the local go-to for custom cakes that actually taste as good as they look, creamy cheesecakes, flaky pies, and brunch-ready quiche, plus cookies, bars, breads and even pup treats. Baker April keeps the flavors playful, and they were voted Best Desserts in Watertown in 2022.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 25, 2026

Jerzey Junction Ice Cream & Candy Shoppe (opens in a new tab)

116 Sandy Beach Rd · Lake Mills

Whether you're chasing a double scoop, checking out bubbly sodas, or filling a bag with candy you swear you'll share, Jerzey Junction Ice…

Whether you're chasing a double scoop, checking out bubbly sodas, or filling a bag with candy you swear you'll share, Jerzey Junction Ice Cream & Candy Shoppe is a cheerful little escape. They lean into 'Selling Smiles' with fun merch and tasty surprises, perfect for a quick pick-me-up close to home.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 4, 2026

Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop (opens in a new tab)

360 Enterprise Dr · Lake Mills

Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop is a USDA-certified, from-scratch Wisconsin bakery turning out sweet and savory pies, artisan breads, homemade jams,…

Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop is a USDA-certified, from-scratch Wisconsin bakery turning out sweet and savory pies, artisan breads, homemade jams, plus an award-winning craft beverage lineup. Skip the fuss this week and snag a pie or bottled mixer at Woodman’s, then pretend you made it yourself... we won’t tell.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 7, 2026