The best restaurants in Jefferson County

34 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

34 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Jefferson County's page when you're in Jefferson County's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Fargo Mansion Inn (opens in a new tab)

406 Mulberry St · Lake Mills

If you’ve ever admired that grand Queen Anne in Lake Mills, consider actually staying the night. Fargo Mansion Inn is on the national and…

If you’ve ever admired that grand Queen Anne in Lake Mills, consider actually staying the night. Fargo Mansion Inn is on the national and state historic registers, with a “Honeymoon Room” featuring a hidden-bookcase bathroom, plus a formal dining room and a wraparound porch perfect for long, neighborly hangs.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 23, 2026

Doyle's Dogs "At the Stand" (opens in a new tab)

337 E Lake St · Lake Mills

Doyle's Dogs "At the Stand" is the seasonal spot locals swear by for Nathan's Famous dogs in two sizes, Johnsonville brats, and Vienna Beef…

Doyle's Dogs "At the Stand" is the seasonal spot locals swear by for Nathan's Famous dogs in two sizes, Johnsonville brats, and Vienna Beef Polish, plus veggie dogs and gluten-free buns on request. Closed for now, they’re slated to reopen April 2027, so pencil it in... the hotdog wins.

From the Lake Mills newsletter, October 18, 2026

Doyle's Dogs "Downtown on Lake" (opens in a new tab)

109 W Lake St · Lake Mills

Doyle's Dogs "Downtown on Lake" keeps it classic with Nathan's Famous hot dogs in regular or quarter-pound, plus Johnsonville Stadium brats…

Doyle's Dogs "Downtown on Lake" keeps it classic with Nathan's Famous hot dogs in regular or quarter-pound, plus Johnsonville Stadium brats and Vienna Beef natural-casing Polish.

From the Lake Mills newsletter, October 17, 2026

Pizza Pit - Lake Mills (opens in a new tab)

W7655 County Trunk V · Lake Mills

When you want fresh, fast, hot delivery, Pizza Pit - Lake Mills nails it with made-from-scratch dough and sauce, 100% Real Wisconsin…

When you want fresh, fast, hot delivery, Pizza Pit - Lake Mills nails it with made-from-scratch dough and sauce, 100% Real Wisconsin Cheeses, plus wings, hot sandwiches, and take-and-bake pies that make weeknights feel easy for locals. Each location is locally owned, so your pizza habit supports neighbors too.

From the Lake Mills newsletter, October 12, 2026

LA PIAZZA PIZZERIA (opens in a new tab)

162 W Main St Ste h · Whitewater

La Piazza Pizzeria nails the local fix with fresh-ingredient pies, signature-style wings, and even a solid burger lineup, all crafted for…

La Piazza Pizzeria nails the local fix with fresh-ingredient pies, signature-style wings, and even a solid burger lineup, all crafted for bold flavor. When you want something dependable yet craveable on a weeknight, this spot hits the comfort-food sweet spot without trying too hard.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 6, 2026

Cozumel Mexican Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

1139 W Main St · Whitewater

Cozumel Mexican Restaurant keeps Whitewater well fed with a full menu you can order online, then get back to game night without dishes.…

Cozumel Mexican Restaurant keeps Whitewater well fed with a full menu you can order online, then get back to game night without dishes. They’ve got sister spots in Janesville and Oak Creek, but this location is the clutch move when you want straightforward, satisfying Mexican in town.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 8, 2026

Subway (opens in a new tab)

811 N Main St · Lake Mills

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Fanatico (opens in a new tab)

162 W Main St · Whitewater

Family owned since 2015, Fanatico serves the kind of comforting, classic Italian plates locals actually crave, with a cozy vibe and a…

Family owned since 2015, Fanatico serves the kind of comforting, classic Italian plates locals actually crave, with a cozy vibe and a lineup of craft brews. Reserve your table online, or let them make life easier by catering your next get-together or hosting the whole crew in their private-party space.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 3, 2026

Second Salem Brewing Co. (opens in a new tab)

111 W Whitewater St · Whitewater

Second Salem Brewing Co. sits on Cravath Lake in historic downtown Whitewater, pouring house-brewed beers and seltzers with nods to the…

Second Salem Brewing Co. sits on Cravath Lake in historic downtown Whitewater, pouring house-brewed beers and seltzers with nods to the town’s 'Second Salem' lore. Easy pick when you want local flavor with a side of stories, plus a solid food menu for friends who came hungry.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 2, 2026

Taco Fresco (opens in a new tab)

175 W Main St · Whitewater

Taco Fresco does the classics with clever upgrades, from Asada Fries and Steak Taco Salad to an Asian Bowl and shrimp-stuffed burritos,…

Taco Fresco does the classics with clever upgrades, from Asada Fries and Steak Taco Salad to an Asian Bowl and shrimp-stuffed burritos, plus a Veggie Taco Salad. Order online for carryout or delivery and save dinner from the usual rut... Whitewater weeknights, upgraded.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 1, 2026

Tienda Y Taqueria La Preferida (opens in a new tab)

132 W Main St · Whitewater

Skip the cooking and let Tienda Y Taqueria La Preferida handle dinner with gourmet tacos, bright fresh salsas, and high-quality ingredients…

Skip the cooking and let Tienda Y Taqueria La Preferida handle dinner with gourmet tacos, bright fresh salsas, and high-quality ingredients that actually taste like they should. Authentic flavors with a modern twist, friendly service, and a warm, bring-the-crew atmosphere make it an easy pick any night.

From the Whitewater newsletter, September 22, 2026

Jessica's Family Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

140 W Main St · Whitewater

If you’re craving pancakes at noon or a skillet before class, Jessica's Family Restaurant nails the hometown comfort thing with generous…

If you’re craving pancakes at noon or a skillet before class, Jessica's Family Restaurant nails the hometown comfort thing with generous portions, all-day breakfast, and a Friday Fish Fry that begs for a table of friends. Burgers, wraps, and omelettes keep lunch easy too.

From the Whitewater newsletter, September 26, 2026

Gus' Pizza Palace (opens in a new tab)

139 W Main St · Whitewater

Locally owned since 1962, Gus' Pizza Palace is the move when you want unapologetically greasy pizza, broasted chicken, traditional gyros,…

Locally owned since 1962, Gus' Pizza Palace is the move when you want unapologetically greasy pizza, broasted chicken, traditional gyros, and cheese sticks, with Sprecher's Root Beer to wash it down. Easy night in, order for carryout or delivery and call it a win.

From the Whitewater newsletter, September 25, 2026

Toppers Pizza (opens in a new tab)

325 W Center St · Whitewater

Pizzeria chain making pies with unusual toppings (wings too), offered at counter or via delivery.

Pizzeria chain making pies with unusual toppings (wings too), offered at counter or via delivery.

Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta (opens in a new tab)

1210 W Main St · Whitewater

No-frills, counter-serve chain featuring square, pan-style pies & slices, plus pasta & breadsticks.

No-frills, counter-serve chain featuring square, pan-style pies & slices, plus pasta & breadsticks.

Domino's Pizza (opens in a new tab)

1139 W Main St · Whitewater

Delivery, carryout & dine-in chain offering a wide range of pizzas, plus a variety of other dishes & sides.

Delivery, carryout & dine-in chain offering a wide range of pizzas, plus a variety of other dishes & sides.

Culver’s (opens in a new tab)

1414 W Main St · Whitewater

Fast-food chain specializing in frozen custard & signature burgers made with Midwest beef & dairy.

Fast-food chain specializing in frozen custard & signature burgers made with Midwest beef & dairy.

QDOBA Mexican Eats (opens in a new tab)

1114 W Main St · Whitewater

A menu of customizable Mexican food served in a modern restaurant, plus takeout & catering.

A menu of customizable Mexican food served in a modern restaurant, plus takeout & catering.

Taco Bell (opens in a new tab)

1535 W Main St · Whitewater

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

Subway (opens in a new tab)

1170 W Main St · Whitewater

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Jersey Mike's Subs (opens in a new tab)

1116 W Main St · Whitewater

New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.

New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.

Pizza Ranch (opens in a new tab)

1726 S Church St · Watertown

Buffet chain offering pizza, fried chicken & classic American sides in an Old West-themed setting.

Buffet chain offering pizza, fried chicken & classic American sides in an Old West-themed setting.

Sake House | Sushi & Hibachi (opens in a new tab)

1506 S Church St · Watertown

Sake House | Sushi & Hibachi keeps weeknights interesting with creative sushi, sizzling hibachi, and comfort favorites like udon, yaki…

Sake House | Sushi & Hibachi keeps weeknights interesting with creative sushi, sizzling hibachi, and comfort favorites like udon, yaki soba, and bento boxes. Fresh, flavorful dishes and easy online carryout ordering make it a reliable Watertown go-to when you want dinner to basically order itself.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 5, 2026

Jordy's Bar & Steakhouse (opens in a new tab)

1632 S Church St · Watertown

Whether it's a low-key family dinner, a date that deserves real sizzle, or a small private get-together, Jordy's Bar & Steakhouse brings a…

Whether it's a low-key family dinner, a date that deserves real sizzle, or a small private get-together, Jordy's Bar & Steakhouse brings a warm Watertown vibe with mouthwatering steaks, classic American comfort plates, and a full drink menu with signature cocktails. Friendly service, zero fuss, come hungry.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 18, 2026

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza (opens in a new tab)

632 S Church St · Watertown

Chain outlet offering build-your-own takeaway pizzas, to be cooked at home.

Chain outlet offering build-your-own takeaway pizzas, to be cooked at home.

Taqueria Maria's (opens in a new tab)

311 S 1st St · Watertown

Taqueria Maria's is that laid-back spot where the salsa’s legit, the fajitas arrive sizzling, seafood stays delicate, and the margaritas…

Taqueria Maria's is that laid-back spot where the salsa’s legit, the fajitas arrive sizzling, seafood stays delicate, and the margaritas are the just-right kind that make you linger. Bonus for home cooks, the little grocery corner lets you snag ingredients to keep the flavors going after dinner.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 24, 2026

PJ's Pizza (opens in a new tab)

118 N Church St · Watertown

PJ's Pizza keeps it simple and solid with made-fresh pies, subs, wraps, wings, tacos, and desserts, all built with high-quality…

PJ's Pizza keeps it simple and solid with made-fresh pies, subs, wraps, wings, tacos, and desserts, all built with high-quality ingredients. Easy online ordering and quick delivery or carryout make it the kind of reliable local go-to you appreciate when dinner decisions stall.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 21, 2026

Little Caesars Pizza (opens in a new tab)

306 W Main St · Watertown

Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough.

Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough.

El Mariachi Mexican Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

1694 S Church St · Watertown

El Mariachi Mexican Restaurant serves a full lineup of traditional favorites plus fresh, creative ideas, and they pour some of the best…

El Mariachi Mexican Restaurant serves a full lineup of traditional favorites plus fresh, creative ideas, and they pour some of the best margaritas in town. When you want friendly, no fuss vibes and Mexican food that just hits the spot, this is an easy Watertown go-to.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 17, 2026

Hardee's (opens in a new tab)

715 E Main St · Watertown

Fast-food chain serving fried chicken, big burgers & made-from-scratch breakfast biscuits.

Fast-food chain serving fried chicken, big burgers & made-from-scratch breakfast biscuits.

El Mariachi (opens in a new tab)

102 E Madison St · Lake Mills

El Mariachi keeps Watertown fed with a big menu of comforting standbys and fun curveballs, from shrimp and scallop enchiladas to a mucho…

El Mariachi keeps Watertown fed with a big menu of comforting standbys and fun curveballs, from shrimp and scallop enchiladas to a mucho grande burrito that makes leftovers a given. Start with the complimentary chips and salsa, then say yes to a guava margarita and the warm, fast service.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 8, 2026

Culver’s (opens in a new tab)

190 Tyranena Park Rd · Lake Mills

Fast-food chain specializing in frozen custard & signature burgers made with Midwest beef & dairy.

Fast-food chain specializing in frozen custard & signature burgers made with Midwest beef & dairy.

Timber Creek Pizza Co (opens in a new tab)

134 E Lake St · Lake Mills

Timber Creek Pizza Co keeps weeknights easy with creative pies like the Doritos-topped Taco Pizza and creamy Mac and Cheese, plus a giant…

Timber Creek Pizza Co keeps weeknights easy with creative pies like the Doritos-topped Taco Pizza and creamy Mac and Cheese, plus a giant 18-inch New Yorker when the crew shows up. Grab take-and-bake or go gluten free, then finish with local Wisconsin ice cream... because balance.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 13, 2026

The Edgewater Supper Club (opens in a new tab)

3522 Co Rd K · Jefferson

The Edgewater Supper Club blends Rock River charm with a cozy, old-school vibe and a menu of steaks, seafood, and classic comforts given a…

The Edgewater Supper Club blends Rock River charm with a cozy, old-school vibe and a menu of steaks, seafood, and classic comforts given a fresh, local twist.

From the Whitewater newsletter, October 18, 2026